Noor Muhammad (Appellant) VS The State (Respondent)

Eg.w-Jrn. -,\ nroF t\"t+- i Cs**.^ .,.-..,kVu\--t==1 L 12- IN THE HIGH COURT o F SIND H, RA CHI

Presanl:

Mr,lustlce Mohnnunatl lkrim l(nn Agln Mnlnstice AutJad All llolrio 'r

Spec*ial Crirninal A.T.A. No.56 of 20?2

Appellant: Raeesudclin @ Mama 5/o. Ameenuddin through Mr. Mamoon A'K, Sherwani, Advocate.

Respondent/The State: Through Mr. Muhammad Iqbal Awan, Additional Prosecutor General, Sindh and Mr. Ch. Mehmood Anwar, Special Public Prosecutor Rangers.

Date of hearing: a4.10.2023.

Date of )udgrnent: 10.10.2023.

IUDGMENT

MOHAMMAD I(ARIM KHAN AGHA, I;- The Appellant Raeesuddin @ Mama S/o. Arneenuddin has filed this appeal against the judgment passed by the Anti-Terrorism Court No.XVI, Karachi dated 26.A2-2022 in Special Case No.A-99-A of 2013 (New Special Case No.67 of 2018) arising out of F.l.R. No.143/2012 u/s. 302/324/427/34 of the Pakistan Penal Code, with section 7 of the Anti-Terrorism Act, 1997 registered at P.S' Korangi, Karachi wl'rereby the appellant was convicted and sentenced as under:-

i)'Ihe accused Raeesuddin @ Mama S/o.-Amecnudclin is hereby convicted for the offeuce u/s. 7(1) of ATA 1997 and hr,' is hcleby sentenced to rigorous inrprisonmeut for Iife and with fine of Rs.1,00,000/- ancl in case of failure to pay the fine, he slrall servc SI for six months more, The convict is also ordered to pay compensation of Its.2,00,000/- (trvo httnclretl thousands) each to the respective legal heirs of deceased u/s. 544-A Cr.P.C. and in default of such payment, he shall undergo S.I. for six months.

ii)The accused Raeesuddin @ Marna S/o. Arneenuddin is hereby convicted for'the offence u/s.7(c) of ATA 1997 and he is llereby sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for ten (1.0) years and with fine of Rs.1,00,000/- and in case of failure to pay the fine, he shall serve SI for six months lnot'e. The convict is also, tlthoruund Ari( I

L6,

or(lcrcrl lo pny cttntpcnsntittn of t1s.1,00,0001' (one huntlrt'tl tlrousnntls) ltt lht'lttjtttt'tl t'W llinz. Alrmctl u/s, 5'l'l'A Cr.l''C, nttrl ltt tlt'fatrlt'of ruclt ltnytttt'ttl, hc rhirll un(l('rri(, 5'1. frrr tix ntrutllrs.

'r ill)'l'lrc flrcttst'(l l{rtt'cstrrltllrt rttt Mntnn S/rt. Arnt'cnurltlin ir hcrcby nult'l(lt'rl [or tltc ttffcltce u/s. 302(tr) nltrl [tr: ls tonlcnced ltr rlllrrtous lnrprlsurrrrtcttl for lifa.'l'ha convlcl il alctr ordcred trr tr.llt c()tlllx'ltsnllott ol l{s.2,00,000/' (two hunttrerl thourand) t'irclt trr tlrc resl:t'ctlvc lcp,al lrcirs ol dcccascrl uf s.5,1'l'A Cr.l'.C, antl in tlcfnult of suclt paymcnt, hc shall unclerg,o 5.1. lar six rrtttntlrs.

iv)Thr-'accusetl l{accsutlrlin @ Mama S/o. Amcenutlclin is hereby convictetl for the offencc u/s.324 and he is sentenced to rignrous imprisonment for ten (10) years with fine a{ Rs.1,00,000/- arrcl in case of failure to pay the fine, he shall scrvc SI for six months morc. The convict is also orclered to pay compensation of Rs,1,00,000/- (one hundred thousands) to the injurecl PW Riaz Ahmed u/s544-A Cr.P.C. and in default of such payment, he shall undergo S.l. for six months.

v)Accused is hereby also sentenced to R.l. for ten (10) years and to pay fine of Rs.50,000/- (fifty thousand).

vi)The property of accused Raeesuddin @ Mama S/o.

Ameenuddin as defir"red in section 02 (p)(a) of ATA, 1997 are 1 also liable to be forfeited as provided under section 7 (2) of

ATA,1997.

Benefit of section 382-8 Cr.P.C. was also extended to the appellant.

2.Thc Lrrief facts of prosccution case arising out of FIR No.1{3 of 2013 of [Ii Koran11i, Karachi lotlgcd b1, complainant Riaz Alrurerl are that he rtas Perforrnirrll lris tlut1, rvith SP Shalr Mtrhattttttatl .ts tlrivt'r. LJn 2t1.05,2(ll2 SI'Shah Mulrarnrtrnrl whcn visitcrl DL. Dilshnd r\li at his clirric, l)ilshatl Mcrlical Cctllrl, lht rca[tr:r' l)r. Dilsharl Ali caurt' orrt rvitlr SP Slr.rh Mtrlt,ltllrtt,rtl nt,irr his 'lir1,1r1;1 lill(l-crttiscl ttt st't' o[[ hinr .utcl tht' roltt;llaitrnlrl/rlrivcr \v.lri (ltl tlrivinli $r,.lt \\'llL'll itt.rtrout 0'l:3() lrnr ftrtrr ttttkltuwtt rtccur.r(r(l Urtltr slrt'irl<irtli tvltcatislt cour[rlt.ritrn (Saanrvlat') rtclrirtl; p,rrtl slrirls, otrl of llrt'rn otrc rvits lalk'r, all accusctt.rgcr.l atrout l7/lti,rntl 22125 y(Llrs (',ull(, lllt'rr', rllt o[ tht'rn [irt.tl .rt thp cornpltrinant arrd three othcrs stitlterl firirtg uporr l)r. Dilsharl antl SI'Shnh Muhammatl.

ln rcsult of firirrg tlrc conrplaiuaut rcccivcrl tlnc fircarrrr iniury on his neck and tu'o injurics on lris shouklcr anrl bccanrc uncotrscittus. Latcr otr lrc Icarnt that SP Shah Mulrammad and Dr. Dilshacl rvcrc marty'rccl ou the

Lbq

Ar r olrlllrllly 'trlrlt Jrll{ tvau lrtrlllt'tl rrllairtst ,.lrrrl rlttu lo ,llrrrtr litittll rttlLtlrttvll rt( ( tl'r('(l trt'l'{(lllri.

lAllt'rrt'1',irlt,llirrttrlllltr''u*t',lllt'fir'{llttr'r'qli1"'tliottlr'ptlrlw'tr ()atlri wllo rrrhrttltlcrl rltttlct' "A" ('l,t'is. ()rr th'O(r'20lil nrcttqt'tl \yail l;'iar'

'I

\\rt\,tlf*,ttlt'rlttt'\lt'tl ltt illltttllt'f ('flq('|, tlttfilrg ittlt'fro11'tlion lflatlc rli*rloqutr, lnr tltt, il[tr!l,t! crltrtt, ntttl lctl llrr' Ptrlict' Parly to thr placc rrf ht' was irtcitlt.lt st! rllstr tlisclpsctl tllplr.s 6f lrln accrtmplices, acctrrtlinl;ly rttl t.arnba irntl Raelsutltlin trrrtrkt'tl ip llrq ntrlvc casc. l,ittr,r <tn accUsctl hsit t,, lrlattr.r \vcrL! alstt flrrcstcd irt tlris casc, who lvcrc thoroughlv irrvcstigatt'tl.

.l.Aftercorrrpletiorrofinvestigationclrargewasframedagainstthe appcllant to which he clenied the allegations and claimecl trial'

5.The prosecution in order to Prove its case examined 19 witnesses and exhibited various documents ancl other items. Tl1e statement of the appellant was recorclecl uncler Section 342Ct.P.C. However, the appellant clicl not give eviclence on oath or call any D.w. in support of his defence

case,

6.After hearing the parties ancl appreciating thc evidence on recorcl, tlre learncd trial court corrvicteci and sentencec{ tl're appellant aS set otlt earlicr ancl hencc, the appellant has filed this appeal against his conviction and scntcnce. It is to be noted that his two other co-accttst'd lverc act;uiilcd of thc chargc ancl no appcal against their actlttittal has been filerl by lhe Statc.

7, 'l'lrc fnctr of the casc ns well as ovltlencc prorlttcctl ttkrtc thc trial cnurt filrrl an clnburatc rnelttlon ln tltr. iutP1t1islq1l itttlgrilent tl.rtctl 26.02.2027;rnsserl lry the lrial court nntl, tltcre[()tr', tllr'srltll(! tll.l]'trot trc rt'Prtttttlcctl llcrr'$o ar ltt nvttltl rlttlrllcntlott iltltI ttllllt'ct'lis(lr]' r('P('titi(lll' tt. l,cartrctl cttuttsrtl fttr tltt' it1:Icl[1111 Itas ctttttctltletl tlrat thc apPcllant is curnl:letel1, innoccnt nntl ltas been falscly iruplicatctl in this (1ti1' [ry tltc poticu ancl the rangcrs or1 irccount of political victinrizntiou; thnt tlrt'sttlt' c),r. witucss against thc appallnnt cannot bc safcly lclictl uPoru that thc llInhnmnal Ar{ 3

LLS^

,rllr.1y'rl t ottlt'qrltIt hy llrr ,rp;n,llilttl lx'lrttl' lllr' frlrlrr i,ll ltr,rllittr.ll{' w.li tt-llttt'lt'rl illtrl ptt*r! ttllr't wla{' ll w,tt ,l,ll fllv{'tt volunl'rtlly alttl catttlttl ll' ufrly ftlft'rl lltn1; llurl lly-6' lc tt6 lrlly,r 1,yl1lplyr a1r4ltrrl lltl npp'lhltl ,rltrl llttlr Lu ;rll trl iltll' rrf ;f11' illrlvr trrltrrllt llrr' ,l;tlrrll'tltl tltrrulrl h' I rrrrlrtlllr.rl nI llrr rltllly'l1y h,lrryi trlrtrrll,rl lhr,]r,lrlil of lltt'tlnttlrt. ttt lrlar r.rl trllrttrr 1' 1;11 f t;r, t l\t\ qllrlrrtf I rrl ltlt r n,lllrtlhrnc lrr, tt('l'aflq l'oJvst r'.'lhr.31,1lt (ltttl"r '{ Mll t'l.l'i}, lrnllirr" nllrr'l'nf v,'lhr $lalr ancl rtlhert {}{llN t{ hll{ :lll), lh,ltrtt,rl rrllrrr l(r,ltrtt,r tll,rrlh v,'lhr )lalo (llfli !( lvll{ il1), M,rllr,rl itlliu l\.lnfrorll nttrl nlltptq v.'lltr, 1i1;1p Q"tl') 't.Mll lttl), Slralrhlr Altrnrrl v.'lht ttlrrtc (?{lll fr('Ml{ ll,l21, Kanwsr hnwaar Ali, Spt'rlitl furllclnl IVlalgl*lrnlt': lrr tlrunnlltr, of Crlmln,rl Mlrrrllaneouq A;rlrllr,rtlrrn Nu.tll3 $f zllltt ln Crtnrlnal Appc.rl No,279 ol Z$ltl (l'1.1) 2{ll9 Suprr'tttr'('(turl 4tttl) nrrtl Mlan fiohnll Ahmcrl anrt olherq v,'fhe litalc nrtrl olhcrr (2(ll9 fi("M11956),

tt. ()rt fttt, ulltcr ltntttl Mr. Muhammad ltlbal Awan, Adrlitirrn.rl Itrttsccutttr Ct'ttcrnl nrrtl Clr. Mcltmotlcl Anwilr, Special l'ublic l'rttsccutttr It.rnllers ap;rcaring on bchalf of ttre State ltavc fully supported thc irrtpul;,rrcrl jurllirncnt an(l in particular contendcd that thr.: uye rvitntss har (orrt'clly idcntified thc appcllant as murclering thc rlcccaserl by [ire arm rvtrictr is corroboralctl [ry tlre medical cvidsncc ancl his rclractetl furlicial crtnfcssirxr wlriclr could be rclicd upon a$ it was maclc voluntarily with thc 'l'hey havc obicct of tellinl; ttrc truttt anrl as sucll thc appcal be tlisntisscd. ptact,rl rcliancc on lhc cascs of Solat AIi l(han v. The State (2002 SC'[UR tl2(,), Muhnrnnracl tihsan v. Thc State (2006 SCMt{ ltl57), Khan Ivtuharnntarl nncl ollters v. Thc Stote (1999 $CMt{ ltlltl), IVluhanttrrael Arrrln v, 'I'he Slalc (l,t,D Z()()fi SC 219), Muhatttntatl fVtarrsha v. Thc !italc Qlllrt K:MI{ 199) lrrtl NInz..u<l.l)ln tntl anolhcr v.'l'he lilrte antl another (2{[ t 5( Mlt725').

l{r, Wc t1,1y1, trt,,rfrl lttr itrl,,trrtu.tlls ()[ llrr, ltttnlt'tl eotttlst'l ttrr tltt' ,t;r;x,llirnt rtt w(,tl rrr tt,iiltt,tl Atlrllllorrnl l'l'(r$r't'tll()t' (k'ttt'r.tl Sirttlh .trttl It.,rnI.rl 51r0r'lrrl t'tort't'ulrlr t{,ut11r,t'lt, 11trttt' lltrtrttlilt tttt' r'lltirt' t'vitlcll((' wltir lr lr,l,, lrtrn rt,,rrl oul iry tlrc lr,.tflturl ('rtunscl {or lltt rt[tP1r]1.1111, .tttd tltc illt;ru1;,ltrrl fttrll,rtttrtrl rvlllr tlu.lr ,ttrlt. ,trrlrt,ul('(, (uttl lt.tvt' C(ttlsirlcrt'tl llto rr.lt.r,,ull lrtrv htrluttittll lltr'( rtbu Ltlv cllt'tl ,tt lltt' tr.tr, ll. Al ltrt,uul;t,l lr,rrt,rl urr tltr,Prort,ctttlott uvirlcttcr'.ttttl itt ll.trticttlar lltr. tttt.rlit'.rl t,vitlr.rx'r', t'rtrplil'1, .urrl trlrlorl r('(ovcrt'tl itl tltr crlttttt ticcllu

Lb6

nlorrg rvitlr tlrc trtlirinl cat rvhiclr hart bullct ltoles lvt' fintl that the a tcaron.rltlt'rlotlbl lltal on 2[l'03'2012 itl Irocr"culirtrr t1,rs rfirv(t(l trty,$rrrl nlrorrl 5,1$Ittt ttttlcltlt' lllltlratl mctllrnl rftnlr(t, l('(lor 3'l/3 Korangi No'3 Krrrat-lri rr rru*trr.r (rf lx.rr(()rtq rvlth lir*rrnlq rltfltlt' nlralllht flrt'at 5['$halr t lt'arl trr lh* tlcath of htttltitttttttetl, l)r.lllltlrtrtl All alrtl l{llr Alrnrctl tvtrlc}r Slt Slr.rlr lt,tuh,rrrurrctl, l)r,l)llqlrrrrl All nrrrl (flllqt'rl qt'ritttls lnjtrrlcr lo Riar'

Alrrttt'rl lltc rlt ivt'r o( lrl'5lrnlt.

12, llrt tlrrl\'(lu(rrll()t1 lcft bclorc us tltcrr,lrtrc is whrt murtlerect thc (lc(fitscrl try' (irt'ilrlt't atttl causcd seriou.c irriury lo I{iaz' Ahmetl by [irearm ll tltt'sairl titttt', tlatc atttl location?

13.After our rc.rsscssmerrt of the evidence we fincl that the proseculion lras NOT proverl beyonr! a rcasonablc cloubt the charge against the

appullarrt for which he was convicted for the following reasons;

with

(a)The FIR was lodgecl by the complainant. Riaz .A.hmed we find pr:onrptitucle which wls five hours afte; the incident' What iome what surprising however is that as Per- the evidence of the complainant bei.g f'fu tg during the incident he sustained firearm iniur:ies on his ,-ruik, t*o on his right arm at shoulcier, one at left { ann llear shoulder, one at tl're back ind one on the lef t leg and then he fell unconscious ancl yet he was fully conscious 5 hours later to recorcl a very cletailed FiR. There was also no certificate on record from any cloctor that he was even fit to record his statement at the relevant tirne which puts us to some caution vis a vis his FIR.

(b)we fincl that tl"re prosecution's case against the appellant piimarily rests on the evidence of the eye witnesses to the inciclent and theii ability to correctly identify the appellant rvho along rvith others openecl fire on the deceasetl and the iniured eye lvitness Riaz Ahmed ancl then fled from the crime Scene whose t't'itlence rve shallconsider in cletail below;

(i)Eyc witncss PW 13 Riaz Ahtnecl. He is the compl'rinant anrl lvns tltc driver of thc policc vchicle of deceased SI' Stratr. Accorcling to his eviclence on 2S.05'2012 at Zpnr he took tlrc dcccascrl SI, Shalr to thc clinic of thc otht'r tlt'Ct-'.\scr.l Dr.Dilshatl as hr" ltacl nasal antl chcst issttes' That .rt {.lSptu Itt' wnr wnitlrrl; ln thc official vchicle u'hcll he s.llv the' dcct',tsurl ctlrttlng toguthcr totvnrtls his vchiclt', D('ct'Ascd l)ilslrntl w,rs ctttttltrg to scu off ttcct'.rst'tl S['Shalr. f ttst bt'[orc' rlt,ccnscrl 5l'lihah 11ot lrtto tltc vtrlticlt' llr,' s.ltr' -l [ro]'s conting by foot; rrttc o[ lhcnr rvls l7-ltl yunrs o[ ag,r,'ilnd thc rest o[ tlrt,nr wers irbout 2? ttr 25 ycars okl; irll thc boys tvc'rc of n(,rntll huililrl t'xceltt ouc lvlrtr wirs tirll; thcy hat{ r,vhcatish cunrplcxirrtt (ulrl wurc annc.tl, I [u was hit at first with fircarm irtjurl, tu ltis tteck irntl twu un his right arrn at sl-toulcler, one at le(t ann ncnr slroultler, one at the back arrr.l one on the left

I

Itluluwtnnd Anl 5

z0+

It'g antl lhcn lrt lcll unconscious. I le came lo hir scnscs itt lrorpltal rvlrrn hc c0nrr lo knorv that lhe tleceaserl hnd trcn killcrl itt lltt' flrinp, incfulenl. On l0.Ol.20lll hr: plckcd oul thc orrt'llnttl irl ntt Llcnlificirllrtn par,ttlt'rvilh llrc firflertll role of fitirtl', orr lhc ttn'e.tcttl anrl hlnrqtlf,

lltls r'1'c rvllrrt'qq lv,tq {r ttalurnl rvllncqq flq ht'rvar thc rlriver rrf llrt. 111.1 1.,1q1.11 Slt 3lralr ntttl wc la.tl1,v1 ltlq arrrtttnt ol the lrtt lrlt.ttl .lc il rv.ts rlny lllllrt ntlrl ht' rvar ltt ;r grrrxl potilion trr olr,i1'11'1. tltr'lttrltlcttl ntttl ltt rt's1tr,r:l rtf lltc lnrirlrnl ltag m..rtls ll(! rtrrrl(.rlill lnlltovt,nlt'nls ln hlq l:ll{ anrl *uhsmlrlrnl $.161 ('r.lr(' sltllt lll('nls.

I lt' tlitl ttttl knurv the nppcllant belore the incident. During tltt'bricf cltaotic shoot out thls cye witness woultl only have got r flcetlng glirnpsc o[ the appellant under stressful cit'cuntstances and 6s per his own cvidence he became urrconscious irnmecliately after lre was shot and even in his cvidcncc in chicf does not say that hc saw thc deceascd bcing shot but rather lre came to knorv of this rvhen he came to his senses in hospital.

ln his FIR however he gave no hulia/description of the appellant. This eye witness was a police men and knew the importance of giving a hulia/description of the assailants '-{ yet he failecl to do so. Like wise in his later Section 161 Cr.PC statements he gave no adequate hulia/description of the assailants.

Most significantly rvhen on22.A6.1.2, about four rveeks after the incident, when he was brought before the CPLC to tlrarv sketches of the assailants he wrote that he rvas unable to recognize any of them which he signerl antl hence no skctches of tlre assailants were clratvn.

It is also sigrrificant that wherr the appellant tvas allegetll,v arrcstcd at |inrrah Intcrnational airport on 26.03.2018 his fact. rv,ts flasltctl nll ovl'r the locnl nredia as il rvatltctl terrorist before thu irlcntilication paratlc \vils hr-'ltl otr 10.0{.2018 tu'o wceks nftur lrls arrcst nttrl ns such this e1'u rvittrt-ss rfottl,,l havc lrntl n clrancr: t9 seL, t[c a1'r1xrll1111 bt krrc thr' iclerrtlflcntlttn parntlc or lrc poltrtctl trttt to lrinr by tlre [0 or cvgr rlrrtrvtt lrr ltlrtt at tlrt, IS ns cl,titrtctl [r1' tltt'.rppt'llant' l)g,pltr 11ivlrr1i tyr lrrrlln/tlcsrripllgtr 6[ t[c .rPPcllatrt .ltrr.l atlrrritlinll tltat lrt'cottltl not recogrtlr.r: thc.rppt'll.rnt 4 wet'ks aflcr llrrr llrclrlt'pt Arrtl tltcrefg[(r ryrlli 111q,1[r[. ttr rlr.rrv a skt,tcl'r o[ tlrunr rltiitt: itrcrt'rlibly he rvrl$ rttrlt' to pick oul the a1>pctlatrt frottt llte itlcntificatittn par.rde 7 ycars after the incitlent rr'itlt ottly a lluttcral role.

lrllrrrnrral nrrl I

t LLg

Tlrcre nlso $ecms to bc some procctlural defccts in thc idt'ntification pnratlt'cspr.cially in terms of thc tltlmmies nol Itnt,irtg lht'ir nonlt's recortlcd antl CNIC's copicrl rvhich also llul us rttr cnuliott ns lrr lhe lelgality of the ltlenlificalion l),11',lrlt', lrr lhis rt'srt'el rt'llattctl ls placctl on Kanl.rr All's cirsc (Pl.l) 2(ll9 Sultrcrnc ('otrrl 4llll).

It ls ttrtt' tltill rvl cntt eonvlcl bnsctl on lltt: ttvitlt'nce ttf even a srrk (.1'(, rvllttcsn ltt*vcvt'r lrnsctl <tn tltc particular lacts antl cii'cuntslflnct's ttf tltls rn.se ns tllscussetl atrttvc wa fintl that (.\'r'1 if tlrt' t'ye wllrress tvas prcsent at lhc timc of the itrcltlcttt lrnscrl trn tht' rcnsons mentirrnetl atrove he would rrot hnvu trccrt nblc to corrcctly, safely antl reliably identify thu appc,llont and ns suclr lve veer on the sicle of caution in tltis casc espc.cially as thcre flPPears to be hartlly any other rcliablc corroborative or suPportive evidence and find that the eye r,vitness was not able to correctly identify the appellant especially as he gave no hulia/c'lescription at any time and statecl under his own signature that hc could not recogr"rize any of the assailants 4 weeks after the incident.

Irr this respect reliance is placed on the case of Javed Khan V State (2017 SCMR 524) concerning the necessity for an early hulia/description of an accused by an eye witness in his { 5.161 Cr.PC statement before an identification parade ancl the need to strictly follow the rules governing identification parades where it n'as held as under at P.528 to 530:

"7. We hnue lrcnrd the leanrcd corursel aurl gone tlvough llrc record. The proscctrtion cnse rests otr tlrc positiue identifcnlion proceedings and the Forcnsic Science Lnborntory reporl ulicl, stales thnt llrc bullet cnsing sent to it (rulich tt,ns slrtft'd to lmve Irecn picked up from llrc crinrc scene) was lired from tlw snnrc pistol (ruhich wns rccot,cred from Rnccs Kllnrr in anollwr cnse). We tlu,raloro yrocead to cottsider ltollt tlu'se ns;rt'r'ls o/ tlre cose. As rcgnnls llrc itlurtificntiott yrocceding,s and tlrcir coufrxf tltarc ls n loug llur of yraculeuts slolirg thot iilurtificnliorr prora*llngs nrusl be cnrcfitlltl ctttulttctul, ltt ltrrtt:rrt t, I t yr ro r (A I tl, 1 929 .cjfr , 4 9) Pe n\,ra[ lL', rrrrilirrg, fitr ll n' I u di ri il t t

('ottttttrssiouri's (otrrI (llrc yysl'11ysttr o{ lln'l'ligl (-orrrt o/Sinrllr) hrll llml, "'l'|rc reco:lttltlou al n rlrtcrtt'f rrr trfltr'r ofli'ttdtr bt1 a p(r!;ot, tplto lnrc uol yrntlonsly srol ltlttt is,l lftdrr[, ultrnn of rulilt'ttt't,, tphlrh ltns nlrutys fur Lr, trrlrclr tpltlt n colr.sirlcrrtLk' tttttottttl of rnullott, Lrrflr.sr, lttl.slrtlrc"s .rrt' (rlilr(rl/.s lrtrssible ill sudr (il6(,s" (1ut1qr' 149, cduuut 2), ltt Alim (,, SIlk, (PLD 1967 SC 3Al) Corttliut Cl.l, u,lw lmil il(lip(rt'il llu, juigtttt,ttl t{ tlis Courl, u,ith rr$nri lo llu' urulk'r of i&,lalitir'rtliort lurrndts lu'ld, llurl, "'l'lrcir f trrlfllr'sst'sf oltyorluuitlt's lor obseruntiott of the uilprit uta'rl (xtrctnclv llmlteil. Tlrcry lmi trcl'ct secn hittt, tl,,l,rrrr*rf nilf 1

b$are. Thay had ytckcd oul thr assnilnnl al tlr ldmllflcatlott pnrnies, bnt lharc ls n clmr yossibillty nrisittg tttrl ttl lhrir slatflnanls that llry t*re assislrd to do so by brlng rhott'tt llto dcrttwil t t a,, aailtaf l1arye Jl.ltl. In Lnl I ldntr*l llr pdgncnl ol lht; (l.ortrl, hclil thnl,lf n u'ltness lmi ,rrr, ,{rrrrr n ilrs",lplhtn of llrc nrqnllnnl ln hls slnlemenl lo tlw ltollrc nwl licttllflcilllutt took yla* /rnt or firc ntonllts tltr llrc nnrr,lt lt tuouli, "t(ncl ngnlnsl llrc aullre frosciltllo,t (rts{' $nga l45C). ln o nnra rcctrtl ludgttwil af lhis ( rrrrrl, lnt'm A<lrnl r'. Slnlr QAA, Sclvlll 424t, tlwh nns nnllwrtd by lltt|r.tnr Mtilnmwnd Clwrllry l, tlus Caurl hrld thnl, il ttntsl be ensur*l thnl lltc fulcntifytng witttcsses nust "rtol sec lhc ficcrtqill nfter tlrc connnisslotr of tlrc crlme ltll the idenli{icntion yarade ls hekl lmnrcdlotely nftcr the arrest ol tltc tccrtsccl persorrs as cnrly ns yosslble" $tage 485P).

8.The Coutplainnnt (I'W-S) had not urcntioned nny fenlurcs of tlrc assailants eitlrcr in tlrc FIR or h his slntement rccorelccl tutder sectiort 767, Cr.P.C. tlrcrefore there was no benclunnrk agninst uhiclt to test wlrcther tlrc appellants, tulro lrc lmd identi/ied after ouer a yeat of the crime, and tuho lrc hnd fleetingly seen, uere in fact tlrc sctunl culprits- Neitlrcr of ltrc tu,o Mngislrates hnd cerlifed tlmt in tlrc itlentifcnlion proceedings tlrc otlrcr Persotts, nntongsl tt'ltom llu { nppellnnts rrere plnced, uere of sintilar nge, lrciglrl, buill nnd colouring. The nmin object of identificntion praceedings is to enable a uitness to properly irlentify n persort inaalaed in a crime aud to exclurle the possibility of n uibrcss sinryly confinnittg a faint recollectiotr or intprcssiott, tlmt is, of an old, yourrg, tall, short, fnt, tltitt, dnrk or fair suspect..,.

9.As regnrds tlrc identifcnlion of the nypellmrts before llv lrinl court by Nnsir Melfuoab (PW-s), Stfuednr Mehnnod Alunul Klnn (PW-6) nnd ldrcss Mrilmmnmd (PW-7) that loo u,ill not nssist tlt Proscculiott becmtse lltese tt,ilttessts lmd a nuntber of oyyorlnnilics lo scrr llwm ln'fore llrcir slnknteuls ttt're rtt'ordtd. lu Sl(tr u. fnrnu! $l.D 19BS SC 1), tlrc nmjorilyjrrrlgrrt'rrt of n'Liclr wns mtlhorcrl by Ajnml Minn l, the lennrcd iudgc hni held tltnt nu lilaullflcnllou yarnilc rr,fls ,rrcessnnl u,ltttt tlle rcifuress only hrul o flttllttg .r;lirrl;rsr o/ nn nrrltsrrl tt'llo J1'n.5 ,1 slrougrr fis co,rtlrfirad lo nu rtcrltsctl tt,lto lltr lt'itttrss ltrrrl ytttlottsly ttrcl n uunilter ol tiutt's (Irtgr' ?5V). Tlrr' .srrlrc yrtrui1ilt' ttnt !illon,atl iu llu't,lrntitltlt.s irlr{glrcnl o/'tlris Corrrl, ildiu,rnl lry Nmir Aslnm ?.nhil l, itr llrr'rrtsr oJ'Mmrctr Alnutd u Slile (1998.5('Mrt 752), itt rulticlt nrst' llu' obiltu'lt't, lni runiltutl u,ilh lln, nlnhu lon fitr sotna liuw nuil (,,t sca,('r',r/ rrcr'rl.siolls lnd sent llu'ir ltnrs. ltt lltc prcscnl lypr tt/ case tlu' culprits uterc rcqulrul lo be lilenl{leil througlt yroper iilctttificntiott yrocrcdings, ltotttcuar, the ttt,t,tner iu which tlrc Itinlnnnnd lr1( I

./-\ ao

nlse sulotts lluttlficttllttu yrocettllttg's tuer( cttt"r,l,tt,c,trilol tlto l'toc6s' ''t"ott llrc rtallhllllv cotrt'l lty rlottlrl.c (n's rltrlrrl ,rl'ot'a)' eya' 'l'ltt, ltlrttlflutltott ,4 ttTtltallnt.t,ts ,,ltt onre tuouli lto rllt,rrssr,s rplut lttttl ,'i"' ttii" rttllitttts flealntgtu Ircrrrtsr'4ttet il I nl," (txrltl ntltlctl) i liuhnll Ahmed V State lll(r Stllrrttlltt"(irttt[ (t1rt' rtl Mlnn tlx''carc nntl cauli<tn which t2019 I,('tr4l{ 956) ltnq rtlso ctltPltnsizctl unknown accusr:tl lr'r crrsurlnli llral an lt"'i* irrust tre tnkcn lry tlt" caulirtn in rclyiny' itlcrrtlf ictl' ln fnct suclt cxtra care anrl is corrt'ctly r plrcn,mcna i n most .rr itrt,tif ic,r ti,,rr pnrn.i;';; ;;;;"r:tecr. - 91.ba o{ rlelibcrately or criuriunl jurisdtcrlon;'"* ii; iJ,rssitrititv an itlentification wrotlg- pcrso.n from nristrkcrrly picking ttut d to iail or in this country piltotlt' attrl st'lrrling'';ti innnttni "'nn thus' most uotr'rrtintly to tlrc gtll;;-'i;

;try''t"rt rccognizetl'ancl mandatory -tin'tit ha'e .pui in such incorrect place juristliction, 1i,',.rutriil"g'i"titititl g,uirlt'littcsto g"t'iti thc cl''anccs of irlcntification' FIe is an independent

(ii)Eye witness PW 11 Lal l(han' outside the hospital rvitness who was selling vegetables that evidence corroborates whetr the incident ottu'La' ilis he to the-irrciclent' Flowever of tlte cornplainant *'ii' regarcl from appears to be a chance i'itnt" who clisappeared giving any statement to-the Karachi for 4 r'nonths without police. FIis eye witness 5'161 Cr'PC statement was therefore is

I

recordecl at lbast 4 nronths after the incident and as such he does not give any of little legal value' In an1' event assailants but like the hulia/clescription of any of tn* one of the accusecl Syetl conrplainant was able to pick out on 26'09'2013 one year Ejaz'at an ic{entification paracle helc{ after the irrcideut.

oltt at the itlentification Althougtl tlte accusetl who he pickeel pararlc Sycci Eiaz rvas acquittecl of thc charge rvhat is alter his arrc'st significant irr this nppeal is that the appeltant to on 2(r,03.2018 u,ns noi put bcforc an iclcntification Pararlt' We J1t"tt1 16i5 to bc' scr'l[ I'W 11 l.al l(hon coultl pick him ottt' appcllant hefore an hililrly silplficnnt as tlrr.' IO liatl prtt tlrr" b1' PW 13 liiaz Ahtltr'tl i,t,'nrificnit,rtt parntlc to [rr-'Pigkl'1l orrt yct lre rlltl ntrt botltcr to ptrt tll-' nppctlant bt'forc an

Irlcrrtlflc,rtlttll P'lriltlc for l'\{ lt l'nl Kltnn to P[ck out tlr"sPitc I'l{, II l.irl l(lr,rrr ,tlt't'irtl1' haviug sttcccssIttlly itlq'11[iIisql 1rt1t'

itrcirlcrtt' I)\,V t l of lltt' ,rt'tlttilk'tl crl',lct'tlst'r'l rl )'('rl[ 'lItl'f t[tt' ltt' L,rl Klr,ur rvrrs av,rll,tlrltr [ttr ,ttt lrlt'trtiIlc,ttiott ltar'ltl0 'rs 11avt, pvirlt'ltt't' .tt lri,rl rvlticlt lrcgs tlrc tptcstiotr rvltl' this rvas rve fitrtl tlrtt tlotlt' ilt rt'rPccl ol tlte rtlrl)1'[['11117 Sttclt otrtlssiott (g) Qanoon' Itarlr lo llru .rtlvcrstl irrlcreucc rrutl.'r Artick"' 129 wns not pttt e.lifillt,rrlat Ortlitr,rtrcc l9tl4 tftnt tfic appctlattt bt,(orc .rn itletrtilicatiolt p.tratlc for ['W I I t'al Khan to pick

Itlilutnu*t.l At{ I

za\ PW 11 lal Khan oul lrt'cattsc the prost'culion kn*v thnt prcscnt at thc rvrrkl fnll r. rderitrly rhe nppellnnt as bcing tittrt' of the incldcttl' to evldence agalnsl lhe appellant since rvt, hnvt, f.urrtl tlre cyt, wltrress evldence , ldcntlflcntl,n what olher trc urrrclintrro rn rorn* or i,r, corrcct coultl lencl to ltls convlclion' is lltt'ir ngilttst ,1" n;';;itrri*lrtth nppcllant is his ev-ldcnce agalnst the

(c)l'hc otltt'r tttaitr piecc of by now that the court co'rfu"iorr' It is wetl rt'tl'.tctt'tl iutlicinl 'ot'l"ttprovicletl that (a) it has o-'oi*ttetl judicial conio"ion c.lll l't'l)'un the truth (c)

(b)with ri"Io oU;*t'of telling trct'tt rt\atle volurrtarily antl (tl) is irregularities tltctc arc orrly mlnor p'ot"A'*l other unimpeachable corroboratccl/supportcc{ by sorne irrclcPenclent ev idcnce' 'l'0 pages and 35 the appeltant is

(d)The Jucticial confession of in extreme detail the paragraphs long whereby to numerouu *f"pp"rf""iconfesses itf' f''t and other MQM accomplices "t?'tou"'i'nu' carriecloutoveranumberofyears.Wefinditimpossiblethatthe during one a detailed confession appellant could have made such any notes' I-Ie would have sitting f,.fo'u * ''tagistrate without neeclecl to have u b'-oi'"t etther like a comPuter or a photographic has himself possess' es tne appellant memory which he does not most likeiy prepared by the police

claimed the conJessiou rvas and he was simply mua" to tign it' As such we fincl ancl/oruung"tu tlrattlreritractedjudicialcorrlessionwasnotmadevoluntarilywith place no reliance on it' the object to tell the truth and

Toillustrateourpointtlrejuclicialconfessiorroftlreappellantunder S.164 Cr.PC is reproclucecl below for ease of reference'

STATEMENT UNDEII SECTION

l,ttrrrsk, tlrrlrt s;,r'rr[rlr3 l lku,rstdtlitt (,) I{rll,r,s Mtl,tu| S/0, Atttitttttllin i7" AlrtrrtrJti' lltr,lirrs ttttrtl .llt w'rtrs ll/o. ii""ti Nrr'F163' KorurrSi tii,' t t t t t 11 r iint No.'l ) ) 0 t'U !!t17'l'9' l ltrtt'r'prl's'tcrl orrl lir\ t) tlu4ottg to MQM Alltr!'tirotryrirtrt lg"i.6' lln' vt:trr 2arc' r\rtrl irr lltt' vr'rtr {rotn ktntrt,i tttti"'')iit1'4 i'i'' 20.10,?0tt MQM uy'1'''"il't':"t 11"'Irslrlrtrtl l)ttrt'ltrr lil,'("lr'lll "1t' l(X)ll lr'rtrft'r o/ rllQi\l l(Mt,' ()ttl+lt,t,r ,"lqti'lt, Krtrrlr'lti' ltt llu' t|'t.tr i'tlt't'rrr' I lttttrttml '\ir,lrr'rri' Allnl t lttttttitt, K I1:'l':i;;;;'tt' I "'t"'l (irtttilltt', luul Nulrrt, Nrrr,rrt u,,,t" ,i,uli,,,i,i,ti,,s llil,iIr pl 'tylttt.ittltl I tt'rt'' lltr'ir rrtrlt't'r' tttr rtt lrtrlutrgr ol X,""",tii 'gr'riirrr wtil 1n'r [illllr'g.rlr llu'.t1tttt ,,1,1n,,t,ttrrl ,tt l'itrlt,irl;,r,'1 Kt'rirrr.rgr Sr't',r, lrtrgt'1'r/ I lrrrrl l0l0 ttttrl 111 ,,x',,,fi':,'''"*''i""lirr;"i"''/ r'rt i{) l'rrgt'l Ar/l.'rs' tr/ ttttttlt t'tu' 1',1tlttlt *tlttr o!!ttr rts torlttn' r'l'll, u'ltt'rt' ! uti ttt\. ttt.ot,tl,!ilirt': trrrrl lrr lrrtttlg oy1'rutnt'ttt ttn'titfur'rs ttti lorlttrt llu'm' llntittg lorlrtrt,i, klk'ri ntiri lui ittltt lltt,t,tv srrr'Ar' l.lnlnnn,r,l Ati t0

La7

2)On l2ttr Mny,2007 nl Balofi Colony firiilgt', Slnhrube-l'nisillitrd ( y'r ylnu l, Mumlnz KK, Nnmr Mrftnrnm, lnunii Buldog, Ayynz l.nniltrtrt, \ilrur, Knshi.f nnl olfur 25/.10 lnrgrl killers nnneil willt KK rurrl rrl/,(','rl'rrr.c ltlttrktl lln, ntl mul killul o1rywu'ttl y'rsou+ lry nrtrsirrg./irrs.

/ .l) (),, l2,r' Mnv 2007 l, lutnil lhiilt;q rtrul lti\ ttnotilYli(n hnlkillul (),,(' ,,rr,1I,li( s |rillt Sluilii Ali nnil lnjtrntl ottr ltnlrslrinn'

1)ltt lln, vrnt"2008 I tnl tny tr t'otttylircs ttrunrlq Ayyi! Itrtyt.r, ['1r1,r'rl Itnlrnri, llnlw lttlli .froni gutrtt ltistols lmil killul llutyli Arlion (irrl|r,,illrr,.s' yrtsidanl nnutdrl Alwl l-lnssnrr nl w-22 Mntln Btts Sloy, K<trn4qi2t/t,

5)ltr tln' vanr 2010 I nlttngruillt ttty olfur nccomylircs uayely Ilrrrlsltrr/r Lnl, (rpord itlegihlc), Fnraed, Aiinz Gorcltnrti.' Wnsittt' Nrtcr'rrr, Sltnleel, Fnisnl, Pnkori nnd IA/"15 olln'rs uorkers nmde n.ct.it'ists 1pord .firittgs 'iffryi,l.trt'ottt thair raspactiT)a nrtts uyorr lmy -sinrlh kiltarl, rtliti Kntnnl nnd Inttnm Bux hacnnrc injtrerl'

6)ltt lln' ycnr 201A, il ilw snying of Hnmnd Siddiqui' Nndrem Ntrsnni nnrl coruruittec nrctibeis, i nlongoith my nccomplices Sycd A.ftnb, Akbnr Toto, Itfnn Laln mttt 10/15 nccomylices !n'y! ,,iitl, xK nnrl gttmt pistots runde firings nt offre of lNn in 7is colony, in tpltirlt tuto octiaists of ANP tuere killed nnd 4 irriured.

7)ltt tlrc yenr 20"t0 one dny in niglt nt 11:0A pm, I nlongtuilh.t.r.ty nrrr,rflirt nnnrctl lunniri fuildag, had killed one unrcolics' yeddler -t Mnlik Noor Jahan in R-Aren, Sector 32'8, Kornngi 2/l B) ln tlrc ycnr 201A, dislnrte tuo-s goitrg oucr plot n'ith 4 nttit'isls of leny Sitrdh, t nnd Jmnirl Buldng cnllcd llrcm nl Nnsir lunryt in PNT Cotonv and nturdered tlrum by friug tpith tlw lwly of onr nrcontplices.

9)ln lhe ycnr 20"10, Jcny Sindh ncfitrisls lntl ort-rtltitrl ot't'r Clitut Cutlitrg a.[ Molnliln iu Melmn Tolt'tt, Konrngi, I nnd 2Afi,3 killars ol Korruryi Seclor rtrnrlr' y'rirr.gs ttlttttt lltrttt, .lrom u'lutlt t,tttt,V rclitrisl.s ol lcny Sirrrl/r lrt'tutrtt' ittiurtl. l0)ttt l.tu,20"l'1, nflar c.rr/rnlrgirrS lrrrc/r rgrrrl.q o.f ]ttrtnid.SrrlrlrrSrtillr [)nrutslt Mmjii's y(ttlil' ltnln'flnmu nurclry A4r'lurrtrt'rl Sl,lh, tltrtr !trttriil llttklngrr,,(l N()pr Mulunnruul (D Nrrurr ,,,urd(n\ll,int l,V rur.sittg lin's'

ll)ltt llu' vrtr 2011, I ulougn,ilh nry rrt'ttuttlr/itls lulr,ill lirrl.lrr5. llusstttt l)ilnntr, Asif Knlq tlfiu Bdli uul olln'r,fl0 lru.lt'l Ail['rs ttt'ttt(tl n,i!lt u,t'ttltotts tt'r'ttl tt tj!) ltnllti, u'ln'r( tfrt'llr'rl /irrlrgs ttl,ttil tttn'toltrr lu,lllrr ilil,tfi| l\tlluttt Nir/,tr|rr/r, /l'tlrrt .srttrl /ilttt.qs Ittv otn'qyul uwt lilkl.

l))ln llu'2011 nl t):10 7t1tt I tur iulourcl uluul ft',r,'r,,S;rosft'r tr/ Allul lllnu in Kurntry,t 5r,r'fttr', nl rchidt l, Ar1t1rtz, ltnnm h'luti, Afglmu, liun,t'(t, lliklutr, Aif, lqlail, AtU dr Asi/' Mrtrt.srtrr; Nuh'rm Akltku:, lqlttil, I'trlttn, Srr.glrrrr Mtlttuttoi, lttl,ir,'l"tttt'r'tr, lunm lnnbr4 Arrf, Llumir,lutmiil liuilrrg, AshnL Shtlii L'lutllt, As{ lnnbt, Knturut, Attnir, Sulnmtt l-ttngnt, lqbil, Aryt'l,, \luluuu*l At( lt

T7>

Sln.bltir, Abdnt Flnkeettr, Sltnhid Btrgnr nnrl1Sp.0 otlrcr octitrists anitetl rrrillr KKs I ltislols orriucd nt Karrtttgi scclor. Durirtg ttltidt tpa snru yolicantur itt Mnnrnl Cottclt, nt ttlich rre opc,,el ./irirrgs uytott lltuu /rotn tlrcir rcsyeclitut tttutpot,s ft'otrt toliich 4 ;rtr/itr' ;rclsor ttnl nnd one petlts!t.iut tp?re kille rl, u,lile 26 paliccuutr & 0,,c l,&lfilriil,t ,lv,'tt ittjttrtrl, mul I nlso nmle lirings.

l.]) lrr //rr' rycrr 201"1, nl snrlittg oJ'l:nrhnu Mullnh ntul llnnmil Sidrliqui, I rr/rrrr.gruill l:nrlnrr Nlnllnlt, luttnkl Btilitr1q, Ayynz Pnptt, Noor lthiluurtnmd (0 Noorrr, lJnlu tsnli, llnml Ahdul Nnsir (9 (-tllrrrtltrltt, Al,di Ati ail B/'19 nclirtists o.[ Motnlicln nrurcd tpitlr ?r,('(tix,,,s trrlttl rrl Sltnltct'd Millnl Kornngi uul oltncd .firings frotu lln'ir respccti?a ut(filatts ttltotr ut,lticlc itt ultich uisilors u'are goittg lo A'npnl lnil. Knrnchi loi ttrceling tuith Altnb Alttned' From snid ./irings, Hnqiqi lendttr Aklttnr Httssnin, Mulmnrnmrl Slrcnib, Anuar 'nuttAbfuil 'Ktttritu rpt:re killcrl runl one ltcfuslrinn wns nlso killed'

I

14)trr ttrc ycnr 20'12 nlotrgtuitlt lihrnn md (toorrls illegihle) nrnrcd toitlt rticnltotts ttrcrtl at tanstgunrtl Clwrprnngi wlrcre ldlled ane tttrkttoun Pmjnbi.

15)ttr tlrc yenr 2012, Motnlida. htclmrge' Fnrlmn Mullnh nnrl Hntrrntnrl Siddiqtri go?e n1(, n taslc far tnrgatiug to 5P Shnlt Mtlmttrrtrul. On 2Bi' Mny 20'12 at 3:00pnr l, Ayynz Pnpu, Asif, Snjjid Nnstro,.lmaid Britrlng, Aiinz Gorchnni, lunnitl Buldng's btottrcr Arif, Zulfqnr Blutin and Bnbt Bnlli etc. nrurcd witlt 'tpanlla,ts rinchad trt Di.lsl.ir,tl Clittic. At 4:00pm u'hert SP Sluth Multntnutnd nnd Dr, Dilshnd catue out f'otrt clittic rentlrcd nenr { Iheir ue!ilcle, tlwn I nntl nry ncconrylicts openerl firings fratn their rcspcctiue lwopons mul cammitted rurrders af SP Slmlr Mrlmnrnmd tt Dr. Dilshnd,

16)ln tltc yenr 20'L2 I nlonguitlt ttry nccortrytlices librntt Fcraze lmd killerl one nnrcotics petlrller nnnrcd (illegiblc) by t:ausing frrcs frout their respactiue uenpotts irr Noornni. Bnsli Sectar 40-C.

CERTIFTCATE

It is lo certify tlnt tha statenmtt "f ncars'd ttus recordad bry nte per uerbntiru rrr/ricft rlns rtnd ot,er to ltitu, linL lrc nccttpled, Arcusad 1ut his LTI B signnture.

Ba.fore nw t6/4fi8 '17)lrt llr ymr 20'12, I nlonguith Noor Muknrnur, Wnlid Lnuiltn nnr{ 2/i'killers Nctil nl KorrutgiNo,5, nlrd kirlunlty'd orte )'nsit' Hnjnno ttltotr lmsinr; /o .girls ntul brougltl ltim nt st'r'lor o//ir'c, Lntur, lmping lorlttrc, killcd nnd llwtp limirr Kornl.qi.

ln lfu ytrr 20"13, I nlougrrilh ttty nr.cotnyli('(,s ,lrr,,,cly librm Ftrazt: nlins (tuanl illegilta) nuil fi{dnr Dnu lmrl ltilltd otu, tmrcotits ltrdrller Fozilttr lleluuut @ Mrr.slliL' br1 nmking ,fires from th,ir rc s x, t' I iot, ut( tt l,o, s il r (7 rnw tl t nl ron l, Secft u, 4 tl.

t tt t

ln llrc yenr 20'li nt 8:30pm, I nlonyuillr tuy otlu:r nccotttplices lutrnid Bultlng, Knshif nttd Shonih l-lnssut tnnn, nt Bismillnh, Muhdntund Aif

zlY llnkcnl ["-Arm, Krrrrrgr nnil hnl kllil tttr t,tlnoltts ythllrr tttttttnl Ah I lfic.ttu l,y firutgr.

I J0) ()r l\rt, Mnv 101.1, t tlnrh wm goitrg of m lrn{t $ tltQlvl I tniln Srr lrrr tailh I lnrluy ar !it'isls itr I nnilln ,\tr.6. I thwg,rillr rrrrrrlrlrlit'r Ali{, lwnil lhiing, llillhtl I l, llluul, Ktrlnf, A"ttttt t,ttrtltt, Sltdni ltlurttt, \lurlm lknft, (tilftrrt, fun'rl Anun tntl ollttr /\fi,'r t,tl,t'lrls ttttutl wtlh tutltttttt ttt'ttl tl ltuilu Ntr.(' tt,/rr'r,'l lilittlt \t.lar nruiln't'tttttunl \hilrtrl Alnvd nni l/l ulh'r' lt.(r,,,r., rttlttt.t,l fr.|4tt ftrings of nr tilrl t,tv ttt ttttslyl111< )l) lrt llrr't1t'ttr'20t'1, I Noor tvhiltnttttttili til) Nnnttr' l!rurntm lltt^rt'i' llril,u fiittllt hod killri ottt, tttt,'fitli(s lwhllrr Alt I htcctttt l,v ttt,t*,tt:!, litrt, tt, J',-(', Kttntttllt

"lrttrtttt )2) ttt lltt r|'ttr 2QlJ, t truil tttr1rr-xnryiliff lfinur it lr'ul ltlktl orr,' rr,ritrrrirc yelllcr mnicd llnzn, nl Nnsir !tttrty, Kornngi lt/t' 2.1) Irr llrr' rlcr,r 2013, I tlortgtrillt libron 6l Titrtttry utl Snfihr Dnn lmtl kitl*l inn'ttr,'rrlics p.it,tltr fuilfiqnr C0 l'nyt Knslnnin ttt st'(lor 4tl-ll, Konrtrgi 2t/2.

24)tn thr y'nr 2A13, al lfu snyiug of AtI$ tlttsstritt,..flru'unni Sniltlrri nttd Nntlutrt Nrtsrrit, I niongu'illt n.'cailryli{ts. (u'arl illtSilrle) @ Kastif, Aznrn Gnnjn, ftrord illegibla) @ Irfnl nnil Stri.,,l lnpnni tni kiltc,t Assistint Dinclor of KDA ,,1 ,1111i11 rond Kormtgi 2 by orttsittg frt nntl nlso ittiurcd ltis t'o"tl.,tt'ti("t ' { 25) lu tlu' ycnr 20'10, nt kitlittg af Motnhicln MPA Rn:;: Hnidcr, nt tln, iirictircs of Altnf Flrrs.<rrirr, Hnnnnnd Siitliqui rrrtrl Nrtr[t'ttt Nusrrnl; I alonguitlt Slmn Snbir @ Slurlttunurt:, Rrt/H't'l Lttdlu, Slu'hzotl, Snghir, Fueitd, Aiinz Gorclmni, ltttttirl Buldng, Bn|ut Bnlli, Fnn:cd Palmri, Shnlid Possporhtnln, Farlmn Almu'd SlrrrrLlr, ,:r,ul 9flA Mulnrmurtd Snfilnr, Rrrs/lid Hnqiqitualn, Itttmtr Stlrht'r rclipists of Kornngi Seclol snt Slnli Sycri's pelrol Yunt1 nnrl 30/35 z,thiclcs ott frt:.

26)tn tlu' vtnr 20"14, I nftttrgtpitlt trty ttt't'tr,,,l,licrs lil'nnt Fr'ro:c (l Titttuty lmd killtrl on.' nnrcolics ;rr'rlrl&'r tunk'i At/yrt: rr Sluniln in Krrnngi ltA.

27)ln llu y*tr 20t l, I nltwgtt,itlt ,,ty tt.'.\t,tqilrtl-r lttnttr, ltttmtt i\htttr, Afghtn,'l'nnnrr, l[tikhnr, Asif, lqbnl, Alil C] Asr/, llllrrrrt, Nrtrftt'lt Al,lrlu, lqlwl, I'trlurl, .SrrSlrrrr, Nlrlnnwd, /il'ir, (u'trrtl rlt'.r;rl,l') lntttn I ililil,il, Attl, Lluutir, lutrrtii lllrlrlgt,, Aslmn,.SJl,r/rrrl ('ltrllfu. A,tf I mulu4 l\ilt,tt'ttt,, Anntir, .Srtltltrttl , rl,,S,'rl, lrllrrrl, rLlttl. 5lrr'r, Alultrl I lthn m, 5lulil Iflrr;tr'r; .Slrrnltrltrrrl ('lutllt, .(rll'tr I)orlllrlrtlt ttttl )it/.10 m ltritlt ,r,'tu(il tpilh anlrl,(t,,\, ttuu|' /irilgr nl Qttlrltttt*tluttl l'lul, lrom n'lmlt uu, l(,,rrur rt'rrt ,tll/r'r/ rll,r/ .l rrtrr' tttltt rrl.

)lJ) lu llu' y*u )010 tl l:0ll1ttr1, ill itt(tltt,r't il I lilut,,uul \ulltrytt ttnl Nrrrlrrtl Nttrrtttl, I ilottgu,tllt lutttttil lfilrrt, Nrrrrr ltlttlmrtttttnl',t Nutnt, liltntu l.'nt:'( Qtt ltuttttrl, Khurrutn l(rr:rl ,1,) Ilillt, lvltrt:rntr I nulw, Altwu hlml uul 5/b m liotrls h*l l.rlbil .l I ltrlirli rtr'lit,irls ,,1 ,,,t, ul Allul, Itrlrol l\rnrybtl lillllg /irr.r.,

^ltlunflil,l Attl t,t

2ll)ln lltr rJrnr J0l.l, rrt lltr' sar/rt,t oI ll,nnumi \riirrlttt, r,lor,,{rt',llr lttnill lllrlrlrrg, Nwr lvhitrt,,,t,tiltl ?,' iYorrrr, lil'ttn I to:t ,t I ttrtttty, Kltrttrtrut lh't ',r) lhillt, lvldnuunl l$*lntt. ( tul hlttltttttttttnl ,, \lrlt"ttl ilttl olhrr tft' tt llr'ttl" I t,lrt,t1'1',',1 l'ry l,ttll,trl,t lo llu ir,,,ni.'ttl tnltutlt llnlnrl {' lnlut ,tt,tl l.tllnl llk',,t tlltt lotltttltg t1ti llu'u tlnru'tu'ny lltrtt thvi lwlrt ln lltniluttt { I ltltlrr t.

.tf)) ll lln, llrnr )0t 1, ttl,tttt ot ltr ol I ltttttrttrl ',titltr|tt. I rrlrtrrSrlrl/i ,,,11 ttt.tt,ttlrlkt< libmn lrto't t" lttttttrtl, llhttntnt ntil Alrd had kllcl Ail,,tir /.in tlr Acqt\tt,,,l lttrrtlor Attlr I llr'r'rrrrrllltr'ttl ttul tlxr oyanul firings ttl,,o,, lx' rilmlt al lliltr Ittttty, ft'out rdrrlt l)(' drittr il,,d Sr,,,,tt,r,r ln'ttntr initrrul' .tl)t)n 27 ivlatth 2018, rclu'tt I tu,s.'tt,,tt,,ll lntl' lo l\t|tslttt lrortt Alrllrrysirr, 1lr.sl rurltillS twl trottt Airyort lln'n |tolut o[ lt! Kontrrgt ur,r'r|r,l ,,r. Lllxrtt ttry yainlntitttt, foliu rtrotvrnl "l lurni gi,tt,, nlongu'ith luilh ls, {mw ['ullrgnlt .qr1',,,,(rr'.$, ,,u' IiK, ,t,,i' (irrrrrrrrl rpltidt tr,:rr httritd by trtt iltti,t, b rtwr ol Oy'nrliettt. On .lnl Ayril, ltytttt t,tll lroi,,liltitut, l,tsltl,rlot' Dilnrrnr Klntlll( rc(ot|r('l r1rr, KK tpith ittlltls, o,t,g mni pistol nilh bnllrls tni lmt luunt 8r1',,,r,I('s tt'itltin linils ttf PS Nrlfii Btrr.

32)I hnt! to rlryosit ,'ttltc(s otrc cro'Lt itr nmitt offrc o! Mtrln-ltitlt IrtT rlr.irirrg cxlorlio, ft'om Golobnl rrclu'ork, Shnlili'llnlls tt Mnrkal Associnliorl ln Kornngi.

33)ll,h got Rnpal5 one ntul lmf uore lln'ough Hntnnmd sidiqui tt ttifi,itrtt orrrsrolrs by occu,,tyittg lnnds uri llrrtrrrg/r Clitttr Crrllirg.s. And nlso mnde clirm r:.tltittgs of nltout 20 ylols tttt oflicinl plols, ynrks urd itt Meltrnn Toturt irt Kornrtgi rt"l.

31)Fnrooq Sntlnr lhrough lis .ft'ottt nren Hnbib Goln, Melil,ob, Knslilf, Forooq Clnlh tt Noslm nmdc China arttirtgs of 345 plols al krcrd illegible) Sclnol, Mehntn Nisn Hospilnl Ttlace situnlul alorrgside Znumn Towtr PS, hnm Bnrgnh plnce sifrlrrlt'd lrr Kornngi 6, Glrous Pnrk No.6 in Korangi 2th, Bnkri Pelrol pil,tty, F-Art't tuul Rnrgcrs Grotruds. Tlte forurcr Gotenrcr Ishtrntul llrrrrl gol rlnrlt' 50/55 ylots o/f cltina artlittg tlrough his fi'ont nmrr Slmlii Alr&rrs, Kornngi No.6, in frottl of nran of Mnnslm Cnclut rrali lrr Trr:er'rr'rrlrl. Snrfmz Merchnnl & Ahsnn @ /arrrr Mnnno gol nrmle 40fi5 chirut tulli,tg ;rlols.

15)lu tln' yrn 201,1, |r't' silttrtlitrtts r'n'rllr'rl rt/L,t' Krttur'l,i (tr'(','rll,o,t, ortlrrrtl trtr ltr.qrr lrrl, irrft'llir;r,llrr llrr'ri'tr/".r/rrrll pr1r1'11 fu yotr tnfintutltort. Ott lSlh luu,20l5 I wndwi tt'['t[ltn lrtrrrft'r lrr[' Qrrr'llrr. On lTllt luna ?015 llrtii tcttl rr rr'/rir'['(r'lrrr is s;,r1irtl rrrrlr ul lnntt lttltlligutr( tt,kl fttrl' rrrr, tttt,tnl ill lnttti lttttlh\'r',1(i' Itrulquttlrr:4t /ttltiilrut At rrigtrl litut, 1,,,(,, s(r,,,(,rr//irlr.r rr'/rrr rrtlmngnl t,tt,ttt\ t'(gtv,,lirrli stlrrrrlirl,r rr/'Nr,rilr lu. l'ltry,f{4.,{, /r(,,r, tnr illu\tl Xrrr.,urgl ('ntA llrlsr,, u\ul\ ttl' lrr ir t lttl p!' I,rll' rrrr furrllt,g \fitt,tl.U TtttLrls, utri ulto mkti lrottt,,r(,(r,t .,4r,lr./r rrl,rrrrl /)r.r/r I rutnltlttltottt tttt'lrr'rlg rtrt,r, (,,, ri.rirrl t; l./, o/ nrrrrl.s illr{rrrlrrrg \(itlrllV &11i','r't. ()l l,r,rl ,,r(r,',,i1$ nlltr brtdrfirsl lllr'sr' tr/lirlr's ,r{r,,,, I ttrttr,,, ;ltou,,tl nU lUtttil ilruwtt s/rr'k,lr, lntlk'r.:t rnnl Sol Altrli,lrrrrr, r I drtl tt

L^[

tllrf,tr,iltl lltttt tilrt"lltr. il,tv tluutgr ttt ln'*fiyuuhr 'i trrrr .tttrtl l,t'ilq,mtln l.\l ttltrnlt'i olottlptlr l,lr,gr'nl ltlt:t lnryt1n',k'.1, ilt .r{nlt 7t1t*1!1111s 11 gnnd nfiniltrttclr. ttyrl tmltti*l unl lo whith I rtttlttttti Alfi'r rlnryntt r.lttvr itty< fi ltttt,llr tttltlltlyrttt'ollilt tt lrli nt lltnl ntq il,tt,,t!(t',,,rttl ltilclw'tt ttiri,lt'tl lltilr,tt I wt: lill,*l |'ilh I lamntrrl lllntr llun|/tI(h lVlutt*tyy n'lw *lt't<t,l ,,tt' ,t,'l lo l,'lk / d'utl I rlrrr (rrlll,{r|t,t ltrr\ttllq ll;ttr l,m lldotlt, ()n ilnrlnrt rlty lo llllvu, otr tlltu'r rrc[,'rl ttt( lil till lrr* yrrlurt< $ Nilnil llrrrr' lt.f,,rt,,,,((trt,, lourr rililill*l tn I tttiln t\l uluth I ilS{fi'tl rrtrl rtrlr'rl AlQnl \ottil tv4*ltt til,tlttt,tt.tn Klnlttl Nlrlntmnl Q'il,,r1r,,t,r, h llotlilt /1,qrl: llltrrttgh ,r.lrul*trlt ltt *t'tttl frtsh Ntt'tl I r;ntrrr,,r<rrr,, Itrut', rtlrrrlfttl in I anillu. I ls v'ttl lttt lttrr* nflrr ntry rrrrrlrrg m llnl,rtt llmt I stttl <nli ltirlttrc< lltrottglt n'lutltrrylt tl lltt iqnri',, ,nttnlvr o{ lrani lntdligmr. Alltr <ettthttg I rtutwimlcly ltblrrl lln' snilu'. Afttt lottg litw, rla'trtrr il,tV t,'tt1 or 1llicttl 1ilnr drltil rrrytirtil llu'ru, llttl trtulmlrl wlh nr ttri I rr.rrl lrr fr\x'ii( lluw nlbr geltirtg ytnutssron {rom lmfur4iy. (ururls illr'.gil,[1, so,tk' Kil,l,{hi ltolkr olfirrs rtc{tl lo sttlryorl un' 'fntnlt,. A5l Asltful din'cll1l or indircthl, ()ttl of tltnrr, 5l Mrsir rlrrl rtlltr'r;rrrlirr'1rr'rsolt,kl iltlu, usfil lo yrorifu tttt' it{orumlk',rt tuttl ;lnft,r'l rrnl hoys.

Nrr11r ; fi,nr by Cod nud I nm giuittg lrtrc slrtlr.tttr'ttl st> llmt Alntigltly Altnfi ntny ynrdort t,t(. I ttttty ln' yrot'ubtl ti.t'rry ;to.ssi0lr' r'ortccssiort. I told tpltiletrr I r:',,t(ttilvrcd llml y rlutps sotrrellrirr.g ttriglrl lmt,e baeu left.

SkwtY l6.4.lli

(e)Irr adr"lition, it cloes not also appeal to logic, cortmonsense anr{ reason that the appellant lvould confess to his involvement in so many capital offences rvhen in most of the cases he confesses to there is no evidence against hinr.

(q Wittr no eye witness eviclence as to the iclentity o[ rvho carried out tltc attack the merlical evidence lrecomes incotrsequential as it can only reveal rvfiat kincl of rveapon/device rvas ttsetl antl the seat of tlre injurics of who was injuret{ or killec{. lt cannot iclentify tht' pcrson rvho inflicterl the injuries or caused the tleath.

(tl)Nn rvrt;lporl lv;rs !'ccovcrc'tl fronr the appellant rvhich lnakes tht' recovery of cnrptics irrclcvant ns tlreir reco\'ory alonc carrnot link tltr,, appcllant to thc crlnro.

(lt)'l lrr tlt,{errcr, cilss l!,n$ llut bcforl' cach u'itltr'ss in cross t'x,uttirt,lliolr ,rurl ln thu npPullartls Ii.3-12 Cr,l'C st.rtt'l't'lcllt rultl .rs ruclt r,rrltrol [x, slrtt;rl], tllscnrtlt'rl nt'rtl tttttst [rr' placcrl itr jttrt.r ;xrlitinrr rt,itlr llrt' l)r()$r,cull()n crliiu ttr sr"rc if thu Prosccrttion h.ts

I

)r'()v('(l lt r t',rrt' [rt,1,nllrl rl l t\l ri()rllt)lt' rltttt[rl.

l'1. llt,tt tlrr lrrnhr'('tlli(,ll llltl$l lrr()\'t! its c.tsr.' itl(lipst tlrt' accusctl lrr:l'txrd rl n,,rr'on(r[]lt'rlotrbl .rrrtl llr*t llrc [rtnt'[it o[ r,loutrt urust 1;o to th1 .,llrhtrlu,.l,l r(l/ l5

T)

reliance accuserl by way of right as opposc(l to c,rrccssion, In this rcspect

('1995 scMR is placcrl orr the case o[ Tariq l,crvcz v/s. Thc state thc benefit of the

15.lror t.e r.easors cliscussccl alrrvc by extenc{ing of the chargc' the impugned / rloutrt to t5e appella.t hc is acqLrittctl be and thc appellant shall iurlgurc.t is set asici*, t6c appcal is allow'et'l otlter custocly case' relerrser.l utrless watrteti irr any

thc above terms

16.The appeal starrds tlisposecl o[ in 'W,,wt.-

GE

lr,ltiltruunni Ar{ t6