Akhtar Munir VS The State

I

v JUDGMENT SHEET

IN THE PESHAWAR HIGH COURT,

MTNGORA BENCH (DAR-UL-QAZA), SWAT

(ludicial Department)

Cr.M.BA. No. 105-fu1/2018

Akhtar Munir V/S The State

Cr.M B.A. No. 106-fu1/2018

Ali Mahir V/S The State

CONSOLIDATED

JADGMENT

Date of hearing: 13.03.2018

(Akhtar Mun iil bv Farhana Naz Marwat, Advocate.

Res- ' ' "- (The Stater bv Mr. Raa ' ' Astt: Advocate General MOHAMMAD IBRAHIM KIIAN. J.. ThCSE ATE two separately filed bail petitions, Cr.M B.A.

No.105-M of 201 8 is preferred by Akhtar Munir and Cr.M B.A. No. 106-M of 2018 by Ali Mahir. Both these Petitioners are off springs of Aziz-ur-Rahman and are implicated in case FIR v2 f No. 9l dated 29.0L2018 charged under section g (c) CNSA registered at Police Station Mingora Swat.

tfrwrt (S.S.) Hon'bte Mr. Justice Mohammad Ibrahim Khan

v 2. Earlier, these Petitioners filed their separate bail applications for the similar relief (post arrest bail) before the Court of leaned Additional Sessions Judge-VI llzafi Zila Qazi Swat, which were dismissed on 09.02.2018 and 20.02.201 8 respectively.

3 Both these bail applications pertain to the same case registered against them by the local police of Police Station Mingora Swat vide FIF. ibid, therefore are disposed of through this singled-out judgment.

4.During the course of recovery of huge quantity of Chars weighing 5,255 grams from the possession of accused/Petitioner Ali Mahir, who had secretly placed the same in the motorcar bearing No. Ai-5173 and was roaming to find customers for the purpose of selling. He was chased and apprehended at a place known U4 as Haji Baba near old Kokarai 'Adda' while he f, was sitting on the driver seat. During search of the motorcar beneath the driver seat out of secret cavities the potice recovered 5 packets of Nawab (S.8.) Hon'ble Mr. Justice Mohrmmad Ibrrhim Khan

\./ Chars which were wrapped up with yellow colour plastic ((). The accused atthat time was having Rs. 25,000/- as sale proceed. Out of each packet 515 granrs were separated for chemical analysis while rest of the Chars were sealed into separate parcels. The accused Mahir Ali during the course of investigation disclosed that his brother Akhtar Munir is also co-owner of the Chars and the motorcar belong to him, thereby, the said Akhtar Munir was also arrayed as an accused in this case

t. Having heard arguments of learned counsel appearing on behalf of both of the Petitioners and learned Astt: Advocate General for the State, record with their valuable assistance gone through.

a 6. Learned counsel for the Petitioners referred to 2013 SCMR 669 * Raia t' Muhammad Younas V/S The State", 2001 SCMR 14 " The State throueh Deoutv Director Anti-Narcottc Force Karachi V/S Sved Abdul Oavum", 2077 P Cn.LJ Note 50 (Lahore Newrb (S.B.) Hon'ble Mr. Justicc Mohrmmed Ibrohim Khan

Rawaloindi Branch) " Muhammad Waoas V/S The State throush SHO PS Dhudial Chakwal", unreoorted iudsment of this Court rendered in Cr, M B.A. No. 44-P of 2017 titled

AS

a( Niamat Khan The State on

03.02.2017 His Lordshio Mr. Rooh- ul-Amin Khan at Hon'ble Princioal seat of Peshawar Hish Court Peshawar, unreoorted toffu Court in Cr.M No.

23 42-PnU7 onI 11.2017 His

Lordshi^ Mn lustice Muhammad Ghazanc ' Khan and of this Court

in Cr.M B.A. No. 42-P of 20 7on 30.01 '17 bv io Mr.

Ikramullah Khan.In the light of these dictums of the Hon'ble superior Courts prayed for the grant of bail in favour of each of the Petitioner.

Id Inversely, learned Astt: Advocate General f, - appearing on behalf of the State vehemently opposed the grant of bail in favour of the Petitioners in view of their previous involvement in offences of similar nature and Nawab (S.B.) Hon'ble Mr Justicc Mohammrd Ibrahim Khen

\./ being squarely fall within the category of habitual offenders.

7.Both these Petitioners have been assigned different roles. Amongst them, Ali Mahir was apprehended while sitting on the driver seat and beneath in the secret cavities 5 packets of Chars were wrapped in plastic yellow color (i.), which on weighment came to 5,255 grams. This is not for the first time that he is involved in this business of sale of narcotics.

There are several other ctnes registered against him. These include case FIR No. 433 under section 9 (c) CNSA pertaining to recovery of 1025 grams registered at PS Matta Swat, case FIRNo. 654 datedl8.7.2017 under section 9 (c) CNSA registered at PS Mingora Swat of recovery of 2081 grams and case FIR No' 101 dated 20.3.2012 under section % PHO registered at Police Station Abanr, wherein he ,,4 has been convicted for fine of Rs' 500/-' Therefore, the Petitioner Matrir Ali is a habitual offender in the business of selling Chars' The report of the Forensic Science Laboratory would Nawab (S.B.) Ilon'ble Mr. Justice Mohrmmad lbrrhim Khrn

further confirm of the recovery of Chars with its physical appearance of brown solid. Hence on account of his previous history and having misused the concession of bail in other cases, this time, he being apprehended with huge quantity of narcotics. He is not at all entitled to the concession of bail, so, the bail application on his behalf stands dismissed.

8.Whereas the role of Petitioner

Akhtar Munir is on different lines, he has been nominated by his brother Ali Mahir in the statement before the police but he was not apprehended on the spot. May be he has been named as the motorcar from which the recovery has been effected is his ownership' Although there are other cases registered against him yet there is no record of his conviction in all those cases. His case falls within the scope of further inquiry. Thereby he is entitled to the concession l4 of bail. Hence he is asked to furnish bail bonds t' in the sum of Rs. 200,000/- (Rupees two lacs) with two sureties each in the like amount to the satisfaction of learned Trial court, who shall Newab (S.B.) Hon'blc Mr. Justice Mobrmmed lbrahim Khrn

v ensure that the sureties are local, reliable and men of means.

9.These are the reasons of my short order of even date.

Announced { I dr Dt: 13.0i.2018. JUDGE

d(h"

w\r

Nrwrb (S.B.) Hon'ble Mr. Mobrmmad Ibrahim Khan