Noor Zaman Vs The State

\'w ( JUDGMENT STIIIli'f

I)ESIIAWAIT HI GII COUR.T , Alllt o't'1'AI] AI) I}[.,NCTI .I T] DICIAL I)EI'AIi.TM IiNl' C r. M isc. l].A.N o.tt3il-A/20 I tt alongwith Cr.M No.9l 5-A/20I ti'

.TUDGMIINI'

l)rrla ol hcurin 3 26-1I-20l8

l)el il ioner (s) ln-oor Zuman) by ('htrudhury,4bdur' llntl ('hohan.,4dt,otut e......

lle .spo ndtnl (.;) il'he Stuttt et(') b.t l'LS .\urdur lvluhutnmud lsif .11(i trnd l'lus'u Khtrn, /tlt,oto/e......

SYI.,I) MI.JIIAMMAI) A]"r't0rJr,l sllAIt. .f .- Accusccl-pctitioncr, Noor /.anaq sccks his post arrcsL bail in casc Illl No.47, datcd 24.03.2018 undcr scctions 324 34 ctl- l)akistan I)cnal (]odc, l8(r0 and scctiorr 15 nn, Kl)K, rcgistcrcd al l)olicc Station Ilanna Al lai, I)istrict []altagrarr.

2 l'hc allc-qation againsl thc accuscd- pctitioncr, as rcvcals lrom thc rcport o1'Mahrj fatullah, conrplainant is l-hat hc alongwith his co-accr.rscd (jr.rl Zaman atl.cmptccl at his lilc as wcll as li[c oi'his son ( wasccnr on 2..1.03.2018 at 0it.30 houls in thcil horrsc

(: situatcd in villagc l)ashkal Nchr, within thc crin.rir.ral .iurisdiction o{' I)o1icc Statiorr IJanna Allai, l}attagram, bv ll rin s at thcm

l Argumcnts o[- thc lcarnccl counscl lbr thc partics hcald iind thc rccord pcrrrscd with thcir vaIuab]c assistancc.

1 No doubt, tl-rc prcscnt acc uscd/pctitioncr iras bccn clilcctly chargcd in thc prcscnt casc lirr [lrin!.

at l"hc complainant, howcvcr, rccord o1' thc casc lcvcals that co-accuscd (iul Zaman has bccr"r rclcascd on bail bv this Court vidc ordcr datcd 23.01 .2018 'Ihc prosccr-rlion has not cxplaincd thc clclay ol'abor-rt trvo ancl hali' hours in lodging thc l;.1.R. 'l'hc compLainant in tris rcport clcarll, mcntionccl thc narncs o1'two pcrsons i.c. thc prcscnt accusccl/pclilioncr and lris co-accusccl Oul /.atnan lirr comrnissior-r ol- o['l'cncc.

howcvcr', latcr on, hc discloscd thc narnc ol- Zaman son Nazir and chargcd hirn bcirrg co-accuscd, in his sr-rpplc nr cn tary stalcmcnt rccordcd on 05.04.20 I U, alict' tu'clvc da1,5 91'thc occurrcncc. As obscrvcd by this (loLrrt, r,r'hilc allowing bail pctition o1'co-accuscci, that statcmcnl. ol injurcd Wasccm was also rccordccl aItcr-trvclvc clays ol'thc occurrcncc, on 05.04.201tJ but no cxplanation has bccn givcn lor such dclay. It r,i,as ( lright occulrcncc and no sourcc o1 light has bccn

rrcntioncd by thc complainant. l'hc Mcdical ol'llccr also liiuncl blackcning around thc wounds, whicl-r could not bc possiblc li'om a distancc o1' 10 I-cct, as shown by thc l.O. in thc sitc plan bctwccr.t point No.1 arrd 5. l'hc ' kalashinkov' was not rccovcrccl on thc pointation ol'accusccl, rathcr it was shou'n to havc bccn rccovcrcd liorn thc housc of'accuscd/pctitioncr alicl cightccn ciays o1- occumcncc and scparatc casc rvas rcgistcrcd vidc |.1.R No.60 clatcd 10.04.2018, thus, thc cvidcntiary valuc o1' thc said rccovcry ilncl posirivc rcport o[' liircarms lixpcrt wou]d bc dctcnnincd by thc lcarncd trial Courl alicl rccording cvidcr-rcc oi' lhc plosccution. Mrlrcovcr, thc invcstigation in tl-rc casc is cornplctc and thc accuscd/pctiti<incr is no morc rcquircd to thc policc or' prosccr"rtion lbr Iurthcr invcstigation. In vicw ol' pcculiar I'acts and circumslanccs, thc casc ol thc ac cuscd/pctiLio ncr', prima .fbcie, bccomcs that o1' 'filrlher incluiry', as cnvisagcd in scction 497 (.2) (l'.1).(.

'l'i-rc obscrvations rcndcrcd hcrcinabovc.

arc tcntativc in naturc and it would nol- prcjudicc thc nrind o1' thc lrial Court in any manncr whatsocvci', during trial o1'thc casc.

I\

C (r. Oonscqucntly, this bait application as wcll as Cl.M No.9l5-Al2O15,lilcd by thc accuscd/ pctil.ioncr ibr acldition of scction l5 AA KI)K' arc acccptccl, accuscd-pctitioncr is admittcd to bail in thc

abovc ol'l'cnccs, subjcct to his turnishing bail bonds.irr lhc sutr ol'its.2.00,000/- (liupccs lrvo lacs), with two surctics cach it"t thc likc an-rount, to Lhc satisl'action o1' I I l u c1 u I l)trLy .l udi cial Magistratc, llattagram' t)r.26-l l-20llt. .r

//-/Z

i' r) (; ri

t\tJ) \1t )15 /tr.\tu] .\ltthttnDtu l )tttqtk'.\hnlt