Mashooque (Petitioner) VS Province of Sindh & others (Respondent)

ORDER SHEET

IN THE HIGH COURT OF SINDH

CIRCUIT COURT HYDERABAD

1.C.P No.D-1065 of 2018 [Mashooque v. Province of Sindh & others] 2. C.P No.D-1075 of 2018 [Ghulam Mustafa v. Province of Sindh & others] 3. C.P No.D-1091 of 2018 [Naveed v. Province of Sindh & others] 4. C.P No.D-1097 of 2018 [Sabir v. Province of Sindh & others] 5. C.P No.D-1098 of 2018 [Mubarak v. Province of Sindh & others] 6. C.P No.D-1113 of 2018 [Nooruddin v. Province of Sindh & others] 7. C.P No.D-1121 of 2018 [Allah Wasayo v. Province of Sindh & others] 8. C.P No.D-1124 of 2018 [Zeshan v. Province of Sindh & others] 9. C.P No.D-1130 of 2018 [Muhammad Qasim v. Province of Sindh others] 10. C.P No.D-1139 of 2018 [Anwar Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 11. C.P No.D-1142 of 2018 [Abdul Majeed v. Province of Sindh & others] 12. C.P No.D-1145 of 2018 [Anwar Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 13. C.P No.D-1154 of 2018 [Shamshad Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 14. C.P No.D-1156 of 2018 [Papu v. Province of Sindh & others] 15. C.P No.D-1161 of 2018 [Kirshan v. Province of Sindh & others] 16. C.P No.D-1162 of 2018 [Muhammad Hassan v. Province of Sindh & others] 17. C.P No.D-1163 of 2018 [Abdul Razzak v. Province of Sindh & others] 18. C.P No.D-1165 of 2018 [Abdul Sattar v. Province of Sindh & others] 19. C.P No.D-1167 of 2018 [Abid Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 20. C.P No.D-1168 of 2018 [Khursheed Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others] 21. C.P No.D-1169 of 2018 [Riaz Hussain v. Province of Sindh & others] 22. C.P No.D-1174 of 2018 [Allah Dino v. Province of Sindh & others] 23. C.P No.D-1175 of 2018 [Amir Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 24. C.P No.D-1179 of 2018 [Bahadur v. Province of Sindh & others] 25. C.P No.D-1181 of 2018 [Hazar Khan v. Province of Sindh & others] 26. C.P No.D-1182 of 2018 [Hazar Khan v. Province of Sindh & others] 27. C.P No.D-1184 of 2018 [Nawab v. Province of Sindh & others] 28. C.P No.D-1185 of 2018 [Muhammad Yaseen v. Province of Sindh & others] 29. C.P No.D-1186 of 2018 [Abdul Razzak v. Province of Sindh & others] 30. C.P No.D-1187 of 2018 [Manzoor v. Province of Sindh & others] 31. C.P No.D-1189 of 2018 [Allah Rakhio v. Province of Sindh & others] 32. C.P No.D-1190 of 2018 [Gul Bahar v. Province of Sindh & others] 33. C.P No.D-1191 of 2018 [Jaffar v. Province of Sindh & others] 34. C.P No.D-1194 of 2018 [Ayoub v. Province of Sindh & others] 35. C.P No.D-1199 of 2018 [Mohammad Farooque v. Province of Sindh & others] 36. C.P No.D-1200 of 2018 [Mohammad Rafique v. Province of Sindh & others] 37. C.P No.D-1203 of 2018 [Sajid Abbasi v. Province of Sindh & others] 38. C.P No.D-1205 of 2018 [Mohammad Rafique v. Province of Sindh & others] 39. C.P No.D-1206 of 2018 [Mohammad Juman v. Province of Sindh & others] 40. C.P No.D-1208 of 2018 [Sikandar Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 41. C.P No.D-1211 of 2018 [Shakeel Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others] 42. C.P No.D-1212 of 2018 [Khaleeque Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others] 43. C.P No.D-1213 of 2018 [Ghulam Hyder v. Province of Sindh & others] 44. C.P No.D-1214 of 2018 [Soomar v. Province of Sindh & others] 45. C.P No.D-1216 of 2018 [Abdul Shakoor v. Province of Sindh & others]

46.C.P No.D-1217 of 2018 [Abdul Nasir v. Province of Sindh & others] 47. C.P No.D-1218 of 2018 [Ahmed Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 48. C.P No.D-1219 of 2018 [Abdul Hussain v. Province of Sindh & others] 49. C.P No.D-1220 of 2018 [Rashid Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 50. C.P No.D-1221 of 2018 [Rashid Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 51. C.P No.D-1228 of 2018 [Mohammad Khan v. Province of Sindh & others] 52. C.P No.D-1229 of 2018 [Sarfaraz v. Province of Sindh & others] 53. C.P No.D-1230 of 2018 [Huzoor Bux v. Province of Sindh & others] 54. C.P No.D-1231 of 2018 [Qadir Bux v. Province of Sindh & others] 55. C.P No.D-1233 of 2018 [Shahadat Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 56. C.P No.D-1234 of 2018 [Qurban Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 57. C.P No.D-1235 of 2018 [Nazar Muhammad Shah v. Province of Sindh & others] 58. C.P No.D-1236 of 2018 [Amanullah v. Province of Sindh & others] 59. C.P No.D-1237 of 2018 [Nabi Bux v. Province of Sindh & others] 60. C.P No.D-1238 of 2018 [Bahadur Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 61. C.P No.D-1239 of 2018 [Khairudin v. Province of Sindh & others] 62. C.P No.D-1243 of 2018 [Javed v. Province of Sindh & others] 63. C.P No.D-1244 of 2018 [Abid Hussain v. Province of Sindh & others] 64. C.P No.D-1245 of 2018 [Yar Muhammad v. Province of Sindh & others] 65. C.P No.D-1246 of 2018 [Ashique Hussain v. Province of Sindh & others] 66. C.P No.D-1247 of 2018 [Imtiaz Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others] 67. C.P No.D-1248 of 2018 [Imtiaz Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others] 68. C.P No.D-1249 of 2018 [Shah Zaman Shah v. Province of Sindh & others] 69. C.P No.D-1251 of 2018 [Shah Hussain v. Province of Sindh & others] 70. C.P No.D-1252 of 2018 [Saifullah v. Province of Sindh & others] 71. C.P No.D-1253 of 2018 [Alam Zaib v. Province of Sindh & others] 72. C.P No.D-1254 of 2018 [Abdur Rab v. Province of Sindh & others] 73. C.P No.D-1255 of 2018 [Arshad Javeed v. Province of Sindh & others] 74. C.P No.D-1256 of 2018 [Farman Khan v. Province of Sindh & others] 75. C.P No.D-1257 of 2018 [Habibullah Domki v. Province of Sindh & others] 76. C.P No.D-1258 of 2018 [Bilal v. Province of Sindh & others] 77. C.P No.D-1261 of 2018 [Ali Raza v. Province of Sindh & others] 78. C.P No.D-1262 of 2018 [Farooque v. Province of Sindh & others] 79. C.P No.D-1264 of 2018 [Ali Raza v. Province of Sindh & others] 80. C.P No.D-1265 of 2018 [Mukhtiar Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 81. C.P No.D-1266 of 2018 [Muhammad Rajab v. Province of Sindh & others] 82. C.P No.D-1267 of 2018 [Muhammad Ashraf v. Province of Sindh & others] 83. C.P No.D-1268 of 2018 [Aziz Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others] 84. C.P No.D-1269 of 2018 [Raheel Waheed v. Province of Sindh & others] 85. C.P No.D-1271 of 2018 [Abdul Shahid v. Province of Sindh & others] 86. C.P No.D-1272 of 2018 [Abdul Rehman v. Province of Sindh & others] 87. C.P No.D-1273 of 2018 [Mehboob Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 88. C.P No.D-1275 of 2018 [Mohammad Hashim v. Province of Sindh & others] 89. C.P No.D-1276 of 2018 [Muhammad Ameen v. Province of Sindh & others] 90. C.P No.D-1277 of 2018 [Ali Gul v. Province of Sindh & others] 91. C.P No.D-1279 of 2018 [Asghar Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 92. C.P No.D-1280 of 2018 [Baqar Khan Jokhio v. Province of Sindh & others] 93. C.P No.D-1281 of 2018 [Nouman Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 94. C.P No.D-1282 of 2018 [Jamal v. Province of Sindh & others]

95.C.P No.D-1283 of 2018 [Zaman Detho v. Province of Sindh & others] 96. C.P No.D-1284 of 2018 [Rabdino v. Province of Sindh & others] 97. C.P No.D-1285 of 2018 [Nirdosh Kumar v. Province of Sindh & others] 98. C.P No.D-1286 of 2018 [Jangshair v. Province of Sindh & others] 99. C.P No.D-1288 of 2018 [Parvez Ali v. Province of Sindh & others] 100. C.P No.D-1289 of 2018 [Muhammad Sajjad Kori v. Province of Sindh & others]

101.C.P No.D-1291 of 2018 [Wahid Bux Rind v. Province of Sindh & others]

102.C.P No.D-1292 of 2018 [Zahid Hussain v. Province of Sindh & others]

103.C.P No.D-1294 of 2018 [Rizwam Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others]

104.C.P No.D-1297 of 2018 [Latif Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others]

105.C.P No.D-1299 of 2018 [Irshad Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

106.C.P No.D-1300 of 2018 [Ayoub v. Province of Sindh & others]

107.C.P No.D-1301 of 2018 [Muhammad Mutlib v. Province of Sindh & others]

108.C.P No.D-1302 of 2018 [Shakeel Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others]

109.C.P No.D-1303 of 2018 [Umed Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

110.C.P No.D-1304 of 2018 [Mahesh Kumar v. Province of Sindh & others]

111.C.P No.D-1305 of 2018 [Muhammad Moosa v. Province of Sindh & others]

112.C.P No.D-1306 of 2018 [Abdul Razzak v. Province of Sindh & others]

113.C.P No.D-1307 of 2018 [Dayaram v. Province of Sindh & others]

114.C.P No.D-1308 of 2018 [Gotam Kumar v. Province of Sindh & others]

115.C.P No.D-1311 of 2018 [Dhani Bux v. Province of Sindh & others]

116.C.P No.D-1312 of 2018 [Muhammad Anwar v. Province of Sindh & others]

117.C.P No.D-1314 of 2018 [Shaukat Ali Kalhoro v. Province of Sindh & others]

118.C.P No.D-1315 of 2018 [Ali Gul v. Province of Sindh & others]

119.C.P No.D-1316 of 2018 [Ghulam Murtaza v. Province of Sindh & others]

120.C.P No.D-1317 of 2018 [Israr Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others]

121.C.P No.D-1318 of 2018 [Ayaz v. Province of Sindh & others]

122.C.P No.D-1319 of 2018 [Mir Hassan v. Province of Sindh & others]

123.C.P No.D-1321 of 2018 [Kashif Raza v. Province of Sindh & others]

124.C.P No.D-1322 of 2018 [Ali Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others]

125.C.P No.D-1324 of 2018 [Ghebi Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

126.C.P No.D-1325 of 2018 [Fayaz Hussain v. Province of Sindh & others]

127.C.P No.D-1326 of 2018 [Habibullah v. Province of Sindh & others]

128.C.P No.D-1327 of 2018 [Saifal Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

129.C.P No.D-1328 of 2018 [Roshan din v. Province of Sindh & others]

130.C.P No.D-1330 of 2018 [Muhammad Ayoub v. Province of Sindh & others]

131.C.P No.D-1331 of 2018 [Zanwar Muhammad Safar v. Province of Sindh & others]

132.C.P No.D-1332 of 2018 [Azizullah v. Province of Sindh & others]

133.C.P No.D-1334 of 2018 [Akber Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

134.C.P No.D-1335 of 2018 [Ghulam Akbar v. Province of Sindh & others]

135.C.P No.D-1336 of 2018 [Ali Muhammad v. Province of Sindh & others]

136.C.P No.D-1337 of 2018 [Mashooque Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

137.C.P No.D-1339 of 2018 [Mushtaque Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others]

138.C.P No.D-1340 of 2018 [Tahir Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

139.C.P No.D-1341 of 2018 [Imam Bux v. Province of Sindh & others]

140.C.P No.D-1342 of 2018 [Allah Bachayo Chandio v. Province of Sindh & others]

141.C.P No.D-1343 of 2018 [Arif Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

142.C.P No.D-1344 of 2018 [Ali Hassan v. Province of Sindh & others]

143.C.P No.D-1346 of 2018 [Atta Muhammad v. Province of Sindh & others]

144.C.P No.D-1352 of 2018 [Niaz Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

145.C.P No.D-1354 of 2018 [Rizwan v. Province of Sindh & others]

146.C.P No.D-1355 of 2018 [Pathan Korejo v. Province of Sindh & others]

147.C.P No.D-1356 of 2018 [Naik Nawaz Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

148.C.P No.D-1357 of 2018 [Rana Shahid Haleem v. Province of Sindh & others]

149.C.P No.D-1358 of 2018 [Javed Ahmed Jamali v. Province of Sindh & others]

150.C.P No.D-1359 of 2018 [Rab Dino v. Province of Sindh & others]

151.C.P No.D-1360 of 2018 [Manzoor Ahmed Laghari v. Province of Sindh & others]

152.C.P No.D-1362 of 2018 [Shabir Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others]

153.C.P No.D-1363 of 2018 [Syed Akbar Hussain Shah v. Province of Sindh & others]

154.C.P No.D-1364 of 2018 [Mudasir Manzoor v. Province of Sindh & others]

155.C.P No.D-1365 of 2018 [Muhammad Imran v. Province of Sindh & others]

156.C.P No.D-1366 of 2018 [Gul Hassan v. Province of Sindh & others]

157.C.P No.D-1367 of 2018 [Ali Asghar v. Province of Sindh & others]

158.C.P No.D-1368 of 2018 [Gulzar Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others]

159.C.P No.D-1369 of 2018 [Nimro v. Province of Sindh & others]

160.C.P No.D-1370 of 2018 [Safdar Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

161.C.P No.D-1371 of 2018 [Ali Gohar Chandio v. Province of Sindh & others]

162.C.P No.D-1372 of 2018 [Umer Gul v. Province of Sindh & others]

163.C.P No.D-1377 of 2018 [Muhammad Ramzan v. Province of Sindh & others]

164.C.P No.D-1382 of 2018 [Mazhar Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

165.C.P No.D-1383 of 2018 [Ghulam Shabir v. Province of Sindh & others]

166.C.P No.D-1384 of 2018 [Rashid Ali Kalhoro v. Province of Sindh & others]

167.C.P No.D-1385 of 2018 [Jawaid Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

168.C.P No.D-1386 of 2018 [Muhammad Aslam v. Province of Sindh & others]

169.C.P No.D-1387 of 2018 [Jalal v. Province of Sindh & others]

170.C.P No.D-1388 of 2018 [Kashif Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

171.C.P No.D-1389 of 2018 [Shahid Hussain v. Province of Sindh & others]

172.C.P No.D-1390 of 2018 [Dildar Ali Khaskheli v. Province of Sindh & others]

173.C.P No.D-1391 of 2018 [Ghulam Rasool v. Province of Sindh & others]

174.C.P No.D-1392 of 2018 [Hakim Ali Khaskheli v. Province of Sindh & others]

175.C.P No.D-1393 of 2018 [Rashid v. Province of Sindh & others]

176.C.P No.D-1394 of 2018 [Shahid Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

177.C.P No.D-1395 of 2018 [Rasool Bux Rahimo v. Province of Sindh & others]

178.C.P No.D-1396 of 2018 [Muhammad Hassan v. Province of Sindh & others]

179.C.P No.D-1397 of 2018 [Rano v. Province of Sindh & others]

180.C.P No.D-1398 of 2018 [Syed Munawar Ali Shah v. Province of Sindh & others]

181.C.P No.D-1402 of 2018 [Sadam v. Province of Sindh & others]

182.C.P No.D-1403 of 2018 [Muhammad Aslam v. Province of Sindh & others]

183.C.P No.D-1404 of 2018 [Fahmeed Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

184.C.P No.D-1405 of 2018 [Shambhoo v. Province of Sindh & others]

185.C.P No.D-1408 of 2018 [Jan Muhammad v. Province of Sindh & others]

186.C.P No.D-1409 of 2018 [Manzoor Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others]

187.C.P No.D-1410 of 2018 [Fida Hussain v. Province of Sindh & others]

188.C.P No.D-1411 of 2018 [Shabir Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others]

189.C.P No.D-1412 of 2018 [Muhammad Saleem v. Province of Sindh & others]

190.C.P No.D-1413 of 2018 [Saleem v. Province of Sindh & others]

191.C.P No.D-1414 of 2018 [Muhammad Anwar v. Province of Sindh & others]

192.C.P No.D-1415 of 2018 [Aijaz Ahmed Solangi v. Province of Sindh & others]

193.C.P No.D-1416 of 2018 [Noor Muhammad v. Province of Sindh & others]

194.C.P No.D-1417 of 2018 [Muhammad Malook v. Province of Sindh & others]

195.C.P No.D-1421 of 2018 [Muhammad Younis Detho v. Province of Sindh & others]

196.C.P No.D-1424 of 2018 [Sajjan v. Province of Sindh & others]

197.C.P No.D-1425 of 2018 [Ashiq Hussain v. Province of Sindh & others]

198.C.P No.D-1426 of 2018 [Nadeem Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others]

199.C.P No.D-1427 of 2018 [Khan Muhammad v. Province of Sindh & others]

200.C.P No.D-1428 of 2018 [Sajid Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

201.C.P No.D-1429 of 2018 [Ali Khan Junno v. Province of Sindh & others]

202.C.P No.D-1430 of 2018 [Ahmed Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

203.C.P No.D-1431 of 2018 [Daood Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

204.C.P No.D-1432 of 2018 [Abdul Sattar v. Province of Sindh & others]

205.C.P No.D-1433 of 2018 [Daood Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

206.C.P No.D-1434 of 2018 [Teja Ram v. Province of Sindh & others]

207.C.P No.D-1435 of 2018 [Haji Khan Lund v. Province of Sindh & others]

208.C.P No.D-1436 of 2018 [Ali Bux v. Province of Sindh & others]

209.C.P No.D-1437 of 2018 [Ali Bux v. Province of Sindh & others]

210.C.P No.D-1438 of 2018 [Manzoor Hussain v. Province of Sindh & others]

211.C.P No.D-1439 of 2018 [Sajjad Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

212.C.P No.D-1440 of 2018 [Sajjad Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

213.C.P No.D-1441 of 2018 [Muhammad Misri v. Province of Sindh & others]

214.C.P No.D-1442 of 2018 [Muhammad Juman v. Province of Sindh & others]

215.C.P No.D-1443 of 2018 [Bashir Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

216.C.P No.D-1444 of 2018 [Deen Muhammad v. Province of Sindh & others]

217.C.P No.D-1445 of 2018 [Nisar Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others]

218.C.P No.D-1446 of 2018 [Wali Muhammad v. Province of Sindh & others]

219.C.P No.D-1447 of 2018 [Qurban Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

220.C.P No.D-1448 of 2018 [Gul Hassan Brohi v. Province of Sindh & others]

221.C.P No.D-1449 of 2018 [Nawab v. Province of Sindh & others]

222.C.P No.D-1450 of 2018 [Sheereen Badshah v. Province of Sindh & others]

223.C.P No.D-1451 of 2018 [Majid Ali Abbasi v. Province of Sindh & others]

224.C.P No.D-1452 of 2018 [Naseem Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others]

225.C.P No.D-1453 of 2018 [Abdul Sattar Chandio v. Province of Sindh & others]

226.C.P No.D-1454 of 2018 [Mir Muhammad Khaskheli v. Province of Sindh & others]

227.C.P No.D-1455 of 2018 [Arshad Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

228.C.P No.D-1456 of 2018 [Muhammad Zaman Chandio v. Province of Sindh & others]

229.C.P No.D-1457 of 2018 [Saddam Ali Mirjat v. Province of Sindh & others]

230.C.P No.D-1458 of 2018 [Shaman Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

231.C.P No.D-1459 of 2018 [Ali Asghar Chandio v. Province of Sindh & others]

232.C.P No.D-1460 of 2018 [Ghulam Sarwar v. Province of Sindh & others]

233.C.P No.D-1461 of 2018 [Tamachi v. Province of Sindh & others]

234.C.P No.D-1462 of 2018 [Mumtaz Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

235.C.P No.D-1463 of 2018 [Syed Ali Raza Shah v. Province of Sindh & others]

236.C.P No.D-1466 of 2018 [Liaqat Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

237.C.P No.D-1471 of 2018 [Jan Muhammad v. Province of Sindh & others]

238.C.P No.D-1472 of 2018 [Allah Bux v. Province of Sindh & others]

239.C.P No.D-1473 of 2018 [Deedar Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

240.C.P No.D-1474 of 2018 [Shaukat Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

241.C.P No.D-1475 of 2018 [Shahid Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

242.C.P No.D-1476 of 2018 [Mohammad Aamir v. Province of Sindh & others]

243.C.P No.D-1477 of 2018 [Afzal Chandio v. Province of Sindh & others]

244.C.P No.D-1478 of 2018 [Shahid Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

245.C.P No.D-1479 of 2018 [Abdul Rasheed Mastoi v. Province of Sindh & others]

246.C.P No.D-1482 of 2018 [Nawab v. Province of Sindh & others]

247.C.P No.D-1483 of 2018 [Sahib Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

248.C.P No.D-1484 of 2018 [Zeeshan Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others]

249.C.P No.D-1485 of 2018 [Moor Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

250.C.P No.D-1487 of 2018 [Mirza Kashmiri v. Province of Sindh & others]

251.C.P No.D-1488 of 2018 [Abdul Razak v. Province of Sindh & others]

252.C.P No.D-1489 of 2018 [Mohammad Yousuf v. Province of Sindh & others]

253.C.P No.D-1490 of 2018 [Sain Dad v. Province of Sindh & others]

254.C.P No.D-1491 of 2018 [Mukhtiar Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

255.C.P No.D-1492 of 2018 [Ali Asghar v. Province of Sindh & others]

256.C.P No.D-1493 of 2018 [Syed Nasir Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

257.C.P No.D-1494 of 2018 [Manthar Ali Talpur v. Province of Sindh & others]

258.C.P No.D-1495 of 2018 [Ali Sher v. Province of Sindh & others]

259.C.P No.D-1496 of 2018 [Mohammad Yaseen v. Province of Sindh & others]

260.C.P No.D-1497 of 2018 [Bhoongar Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

261.C.P No.D-1498 of 2018 [Ahsan Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

262.C.P No.D-1499 of 2018 [Muhammad Amir v. Province of Sindh & others]

263.C.P No.D-1500 of 2018 [Hakim Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

264.C.P No.D-1501 of 2018 [Bilawal Soomro v. Province of Sindh & others]

265.C.P No.D-1502 of 2018 [Abdul Khalique Qureshi v. Province of Sindh & others]

266.C.P No.D-1503 of 2018 [Muhammad Ali Baloch v. Province of Sindh & others]

267.C.P No.D-1504 of 2018 [Muhammad Usman Mallah v. Province of Sindh & others]

268.C.P No.D-1505 of 2018 [Zameer Hussain v. Province of Sindh & others]

269.C.P No.D-1506 of 2018 [Abdul Rehman v. Province of Sindh & others]

270.C.P No.D-1507 of 2018 [Ayaz Ahmed v. Province of Sindh & others]

271.C.P No.D-1508 of 2018 [Ali Sher Raho v. Province of Sindh & others]

272.C.P No.D-1509 of 2018 [Naseem Akhtar Bhatti v. Province of Sindh & others]

273.C.P No.D-1510 of 2018 [Salar v. Province of Sindh & others]

274.C.P No.D-1511 of 2018 [Sikandar Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

275.C.P No.D-1512 of 2018 [Soorat Singh v. Province of Sindh & others]

276.C.P No.D-1513 of 2018 [Shakir Hassan Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

277.C.P No.D-1514 of 2018 [Waseem Keerio v. Province of Sindh & others]

278.C.P No.D-1515 of 2018 [Mohammad Yousuf Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

279.C.P No.D-1516 of 2018 [Rahib Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

280.C.P No.D-1517 of 2018 [Ameer Shah v. Province of Sindh & others]

281.C.P No.D-1518 of 2018 [Noman Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

282.C.P No.D-1519 of 2018 [Muhammad Idrees v. Province of Sindh & others]

283.C.P No.D-1520 of 2018 [Imtiaz Ali & another v. Province of Sindh & others]

284.C.P No.D-1521 of 2018 [Ali Akbar v. Province of Sindh & others]

285.C.P No.D-1522 of 2018 [Hakim Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

286.C.P No.D-1523 of 2018 [Ramzan Chohan v. Province of Sindh & others]

287.C.P No.D-1524 of 2018 [Muhammad Sarwar v. Province of Sindh & others]

288.C.P No.D-1527 of 2018 [Gul Hassan v. Province of Sindh & others]

289.C.P No.D-1528 of 2018 [Noor Muhammad v. Province of Sindh & others]

290.C.P No.D-1529 of 2018 [Muhammad Ramzan v. Province of Sindh & others]

291.C.P No.D-1530 of 2018 [Bachawas Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

292.C.P No.D-1531 of 2018 [Muhammad Akbar v. Province of Sindh & others]

293.C.P No.D-1536 of 2018 [Muhammad Paryal v. Province of Sindh & others]

294.C.P No.D-1540 of 2018 [Mumtaz Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

295.C.P No.D-1541 of 2018 [Abdul Ghaffar Uner v. Province of Sindh & others]

296.C.P No.D-1542 of 2018 [Ali Gohar v. Province of Sindh & others]

297.C.P No.D-1543 of 2018 [Nawab Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

298.C.P No.D-1544 of 2018 [Bachal v. Province of Sindh & others]

299.C.P No.D-1545 of 2018 [Subhan v. Province of Sindh & others]

300.C.P No.D-1546 of 2018 [Abdul Rauf v. Province of Sindh & others]

301.C.P No.D-1547 of 2018 [Abbas Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

302.C.P No.D-1548 of 2018 [Aman Kumar v. Province of Sindh & others]

303.C.P No.D-1549 of 2018 [Muhammad Ramzan v. Province of Sindh & others]

304.C.P No.D-1550 of 2018 [Punhal Khan v. Province of Sindh & others]

305.C.P No.D-1551 of 2018 [Shahid Hussain v. Province of Sindh & others]

306.C.P No.D-1553 of 2018 [Muhammad Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

307.C.P No.D-1554 of 2018 [Attaullah v. Province of Sindh & others]

308.C.P No.D-1555 of 2018 [Ali Muhammad v. Province of Sindh & others]

309.C.P No.D-1581 of 2018 [Fayyaz Hussain v. Province of Sindh & others]

310.C.P No.D-1585 of 2018 [Muhammad Akram v. Province of Sindh & others]

311.C.P No.D-1610 of 2018 [Manthar Ali v. Province of Sindh & others]

DATE ORDER WITH SIGNATURE OF JUDGE

Present:

Mr. Justice Aziz-ur-Rehman, Mr. Justice Fahim Ahmed Siddiqui.

Mr. Imtiaz Ali Channa, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1065, 1156, 1371 & 1372 of 2018.

Mr. Mazhar Ali Leghari, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1075, 1288, 1487, 1488 & 1550 of 2018.

Mrs. Razia Ali Zaman, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1091 & 1273 of 2018.

Miss. Najma Lakho, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1097 & 1098 of 2018.

Mian Taj Muhammad Keerio, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1113, 1206 & 1462 of 2018.

Mr. Waqar Ali Laghari, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1121 of Mr. Aijaz Bhutto, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1124, 1174, 1186, 1271 & 1272 of 2018.

Mr. Fakhuruddin Dahraj, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1130, 1205, 1403, 1408 & 1520 of 2018.

Mr. Santosh Kumar J.Kalal, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1139 of 2018.

Mr. Faisal Nadeem Abro, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1142 & 1501 of 2018.

Syed Shahzad Ali Shah, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1145 & 1384 of 2018.

Mr. Altaf Hussain Chandio, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1154 of Mr. Bheemchand Kolhi, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1161 & 1405 of 2018.

Mr. Hemandas S.Sanghani, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1162, 1163, 1165, 1169, 1382 & 1416 of 2018.

Mr. Moula Bux Narejo, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1167 of Mr. Rizwan Ahmed, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1168 of 2018.

Mr. Jehangir Khyber, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1175 of Mr. Mashooque Ali Mahar, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1179, 1213 & 1277 of 2018.

Mr. Muhammad Hassan Chandio, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D- 1417, 1471, 1493, 1507, 1508, 1527 & 1551 of 2018.

Mr. Ashique Ali Laghari, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1184 of Mr. Abdul Majeed Malak, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1185, 1187, 1189 & 1191 of 2018.

Mr. Shaukat Ali Kaka, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1190, 1282, 1283 & 1383 of 2018.

Mr. Abid Ali Thebo, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1194 of 2018.

Mr. Noor Muhammad Rind, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1199 of 2018.

Mr. Muhammad Azhar Arain, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1200 of 2018.

Mr. Mumtaz Ahmed Lashari, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1203, 1211, 1262 & 1490 of 2018.

Mr. Muhammad Sachal R. Awan, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D- 1208, 1275 & 1543 of 2018.

Mr. Mohsin Raza Gopang, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1212 & 1346 of 2018.

Mr. Poonjo Ruplani, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1214, 1235, 1268, 1281, 1284, 1337, 1413, 1414 & 1521 of 2018.

Mr. Muhammad Zainuddin Baloch advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D- 1216 of 2018.

Mr. Ashfaque Ali Khaskheli, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1217 of 2018.

Mr. Shahzad Ahmed Narejo, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1218 of 2018.

Mr. Aijaz Ahmed Chandio, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1220, 1221, 1279, 1409, 1431, 1432, 1433 & 1447 of 2018.

Mr. Ghulamullah Chang, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1219 of Mr. Abdul Khalique Leghari, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1228 & 1229 of 2018.

Syed Imdad Ali Shah, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1230, 1231 & 1441 of 2018.

Mr. Shahid Ahmed Ansari, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1233 of Mr. Ahmed Nawaz Chang, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1234 of Syed Tarique Ahmed Shah, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1236, 1237, 1238 & 1239 of 2018.

Mr. Kanji Mal Meghwar, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1243, 1244, 1299 & 1316 of 2018.

Mr. Waheed Murad Khaskheli, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D- 1245 of 2018.

Mr. Zafar Ali Chandio, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1246 & 1249 of 2018.

Mr. Adnan Ahmed Siddiqui, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1247, 1248, 1257, 1500 & 1522 of 2018.

Mr. Suhail Shahzad Khokhar, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D- of 2018.

Mr. Ghulam Nabi Meo, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1258 of Mr. Zubair Mirbahar, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1261 of 2018.

Mr. Khalid Hussain Channa, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1265 of 2018.

Mr. Muntazir Mehdi Laghari, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1266, 1473 & 1516 of 2018.

Mr. Kashif Ali Lakho, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1267, 1426 & 1497 of 2018.

Mr. Junaid Soomro, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1269 & 1377 of 2018.

Mr. Willayat Ali Khan Magsi, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1276 of 2018.

Mr. Mumtaz Ali Soomro, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1280 of Mr. Zaheeruddin Nohri, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1285, 1286, 1368 & 1369 of 2018.

Mr. Zulfiqar Ali Samo, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1289, 1291, 1292, 1294, 1453, 1455, 1456, 1474, 1475 & 1477 of 2018.

Mr. Ghulam Mustafa Hingorjo, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D- 1545, 1546, 1547, 1548, 1549 & 1554 of 2018.

Mr. Ghulam Sarwar Khaskheli, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D- 1311 of 2018.

Mr. Badar Rajpar, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1312 of 2018.

Mr. Azizullah Ghambhir, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1314 of Mr. Abdul Majeed Lashari, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1315 & 1523 of 2018.

Mr. Hitesh Kumar Maheshwari, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D- 1317 of 2018.

Mr. Sartar Iqbal Panhwar, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1318 & 1319 of 2018.

Mr. Waseem Ahmed Ghahoti, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D- 1324 of 2018.

Mr. Muhammad Jameel Khan advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1325 of 2018.

Mr. Karim Bux Rind advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1326, 1327, 1331,1332, 1334, 1335, 1363,1364, 1365, 1366 & 1367 of 2018.

Mr. Om Parkash H.Karmani, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1328, 1330, 1340 & 1341 of 2018.

Mr. Waqar Ali G. Zaur, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1336, 1352 & 1494 of 2018.

Mr. Bisharat Ali Memon, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1343 of Mr. Imdad Hussain A.Shahani, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D- 1359 of 2018.

Syed Shafique Ahmed Shah, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1362 & 1466 of 2018.

Mir Asif Ali Talpur, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1370 & 1460 of Mr. Muhammad Ahmed Khan Pathan, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1385, 1386, 1387, 1388, 1389, 1390, 1391, 1392 & 1394 of Mr. Ayaz Hussain Chandio, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1395 of 2018.

Mr. Bhagwandas Bheel, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1396 of Mr. Aghis-u-Salam Tahirzada, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D- 1397, 1398 & 1410 of 2018.

Mr. Sheeraz Bhatti, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1402, 1427, 1449, 1450, 1452, 1482 & 1483 of 2018.

Mr. Imdad Ali Dahri, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1411 of 2018.

Mr. Mushtaque Ali Tagar, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1412 of Mr. Javed Ali Buriro, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1415 of 2018.

Mr. Saeed Ahmed Waggan, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1424 of 2018.

Mr. Anwar Ali Solangi advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1425 of Mr. Ghulam Sarwar Baloch, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1428 & 1524 of 2018.

Mr. Amjad Hussain Rajput, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1429 of Mr. Ghulam Murtaza Shaikh, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1430 of 2018.

Mr. Satram, Sonani Bheel, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1434 of Mr. Aslam Baig Leghari Baloch advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D- 1435, 1436, 1437, 1438, 1439, 1440, 1445, 1446 & 1457 of 2018.

Mr. Nouman Sahito, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1442, 1443, 1444 & 1489 of 2018.

Mr. Shaukat Ali Pathan advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1448 of Mr. Parkash Lal advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1451 of 2018.

Mr. Nasrullah Khaskheli, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1454 & 1458 of 2018.

Mr. Mushtaque Husain Khaskheli, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D- 1459 of 2018.

Rao Faisal Ali, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1461 of 2018.

Mr. Ali Khan Laghari, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1463 of Mr. Zahid Mallah, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1472 & 1514 of Mr. Akash Ali Rind advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1476 of 2018.

Mr. Ahmed Ali Jarwar, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1478 & 1479 of 2018.

Mr. Mirza Naeem Baig, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1484 of Mr. Ghulam Shabbir Daudani, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D- 1485 of 2018.

Mr. Saeed Ahmed Mirjat, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1491 & 1492 of 2018.

Mr. Zeeshan Ali Malik, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1495 & 1553 of 2018.

Mr. Naseer A.Narejo, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1498 of

Mr. Faisal Ali Raza Bhatti, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1499 & 1519 of 2018.

Mr. Abdul Mueed Shaikh, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1502, 1503, 1529 & 1530 of 2018.

Mr. Subhan Ali Panhwar, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1504 of Mr. Niaz Hussain Laghari, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1505 of Mr. Mansoor Ali Jamali, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1506, 1509 & 1531 of 2018.

Mr. Wali Muhammad Buledi, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1510 of 2018.

Mr. Velji Rathore, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1512 of 2018.

Mr. Ashok Kumar, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1513 of 2018.

Mr. Taj Muhammad Qaimkhani, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D- 1511 & 1515 of 2018.

Mr. Kanjee Mal Rano Bheel, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1517 of 2018.

Mr. Altaf Hussain Junejo, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1518 of Mr. Abdul Hameed Bajwa, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1528 of Mr. Shahid Sahito, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1536 of 2018.

Mr. Ahsan Gul Dahri, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1540, 1541 of 2018.

Miss. Rizwana, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1555 of 2018.

Mr. Wishan Das Kolhi, advocate for petitioner in C.P No.D-1585 & 1610 of 2018.

Petitioner[s] in person in C.P No.D-1264, 1404, 1421, 1581 of 2018 Mr. Allah Bachayo Soomro Additional Advocate General Sindh for respondents.

Aziz-ur-Rehman, J. - Per averments made in the above / listed petitions, the petitioners are proprietors / owners of the hotels, restaurants or canteen, who are carrying on their business within the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court of Sindh, Circuit Court Hyderabad. According to the petitioner’s version, their business activity is protected, as claimed, under ‘Exemptions’ provided under section 5 of

the Ehtram-e-Ramazan Ordinance, 1981. According to the petitioners, since holy month of Ramazan is likely to start from 17th May, 2018 [subject to appearance of moon], as such, they apprehend that the official respondents will cause severe impediment, in the way of doing/carrying on the business of the petitioners within the parameters of exemptions, as provided under section 5 of the Ehtram-e-Ramazan Ordinance, 1981 [Ordinance XXIII of 1981]. The official Respondents, as apprehended by petitioners, beside creating obstacles in the way of the petitioners will not accord permission to the petitioner[s] to run/operate their business in accordance with exemptions as per section 5 of the Ehtram-e-Ramazan Ordinance, 1981 [Ordinance XXIII of 1981] during the holy month of Ramazan. Moreover, the official Respondents, as alleged, by the petitioners in this regard, have already issued verbal ‘warnings / threats’ to the petitioners.

2.In all the above petitions, since a similar and identical question, is involved, the learned A.A.G., as such, opted to waive notice[s] in all these petitions, in which either notices have not been issued and/or otherwise, the same remained un-served on the official Respondents and A.A.G. Nevertheless, learned A.A.G. upon receiving copies of the petitions and annexures therewith if any, besides, waiving notice, concedes that all the above petitions be taken-up together and ‘disposed of’ by a ‘common order’ to which all the learned counsel for petitioners, present in Court, extended their no objection. In this regard reference was made to the case of Arshad Muhammad & others v. Province of Sindh & others [SBLR 2016 DB Sindh 1751].

3.Heard.

4.Before proceeding further, at this juncture, we would like to reproduce herein, Section 5 of the Ehtram-e-Ramazan Ordinance, 1981 [Ordinance XXIII of 1981], which reads as follow:-

5.Exemptions. - Nothing contained in section 4 shall apply in respect of-

(a)A canteen or kitchen maintained in a hospital for serving food to patients;

(b)A restaurant or canteen within the premises of a railway station, airport, or seaport or bus stand or in a train or aircraft;

(c)A kitchen or dining-car of a train; or

(d)A kitchen or canteen meant for children within the premises of a primary school.

5.It is significant to note, that the aforesaid clause (b) of section 5 of Ehtram-e-Ramazan Ordinance, 1981, has subsequently been substituted/amended by Ehtram-e-Ramazan [Amendment] Ordinance, 1981. The subsequently amended / substituted clause (b) of Section 5 of the Ehtram-e-Ramazan Ordinance, 1981 now reads as follows:- “(b) a restaurant, canteen, stall or wheel barrow, or the holder of a vending contract, within the premises of a railway station or in a train or a restaurant or canteen within the premises of an airport, seaport, or bus stand or in an aircraft;”

6.No doubt, a number of the ‘exemptions’ under section 5 of the Ehtram-e-Ramazan Ordinance, 1981 [Ordinance XXIII of 1981] regarding operation of restaurants and canteen etc. as above, have been provided in the holy month of Ramazan but, in our view, at the same time, it is obligatory for the proprietors / owners of the restaurants, canteen etc., as above, to do such activity strictly in terms of the

‘exemptions’ as mentioned / provided under section 5 of the Ehtram-e- Ramazan Ordinance, 1981.

7.The ‘business activity’ permitted in terms of ‘exemptions’, of course, shall needs to be done with utmost respect to the holy ‘Month of Ramazan’ and that too, subject to the necessary ‘pre-cautions’ and permission to be obtained from the concerned official Respondents / Magistrates interalia for ensuring that no any, such activity is conducted/carried out at the restaurants and other places which must needs to fall within the ambit of ‘exemptions’ as provided under Section 5 of the Ehtram-e-Ramazan Ordinance, 1981. Moreover, such an activity at the places shall fall under the ‘exemption’ and in no manner should be allowed, to be exposed to the public view or access. Rather such an activity, keeping in view the tenets of Islam, is to be done/carried with proper restricted arrangements of curtain and screen, otherwise, the petitioners would expose themselves for punishment, who do any such an activity of running restaurant, canteen etc. in contravention of the Ehtram-e-Ramazan Ordinance, 1981 [Ordinance XXIII of 1981] as provided under the provisions of the Ehtram-e-Ramazan Ordinance, 1981 [Ordinance XXIII of 1981].

8.For and in view of the above, all the listed / above petitions stand ‘disposed of’ in the following terms:-

a. The petitioners may continue the business activity, which as asserted by the petitioners, would be properly protected from public view by means of a curtain or screen and further such an activity of running restaurant, canteen etc. duly falls within the scope of clauses (a), (b), (c) or (d) of Section 5 of the Ehtram-e-Ramazan Ordinance, 1981 [Ordinance XXIII of 1981].

b. Further, the petitioners will not conduct their business activity beyond the parameters of the ‘exemptions’, as provided under Section 5 of the Ehtram-e-Ramazan Ordinance, 1981 [Ordinance XXIII of 1981], in a canteen, restaurant or dining car referred to and mentioned in clauses (a), (b), (c) or (d) of Section 5 of the Ehtram-e- Ramazan Ordinance, 1981 [Ordinance XXIII of 1981]. Besides, such activity shall also be duly protected from public view by means a curtain or screen or otherwise. Moreover, such an activity shall be subject to proper ‘verification’ and vigilant checking by the concerned Magistrates / official Respondents, as and when the concerned Magistrates / official Respondents deem it necessary and proper with a view to ensure the Ehtram-e- Ramazan.

c In case of any sort of violation or contravention of the Ehtram-e-Ramazan Ordinance, 1981, by the petitioners or any one of them the concerned Magistrates/the competent authority/official Respondent[s] is/are free to initiate legal action, as provided under the Ehtram-e-Ramazan Ordinance, 1981 [Ordinance XXIII of 1981].

9.Office is directed to transmit copy of this order to the learned A.A.G. Sindh Hyderabad and all the concerned Sessions Judges, Deputy Commissioners/Magistrates/Official Respondents of Hyderabad, Shaheed Benazirabad and Mirpurkhas Divisions, for information and strict necessary compliance.

10.All the above petitions stand ‘disposed of’ accordingly along with all pending application[s], if any.

JUDGE

JUDGE

*Abdullah Channa/PS*