MUHAMMAD SHAHID @ JAPANI S/O RIYASAT HUSSAIN (Appellant) VS THE STATE (Respondent)

Cr.V { r,..r\ 14^ \>- (31

e qlII l-c-419-9-I I tu1- ellJl' 1--l'liY"::=- SP ATJ.-J A l?3 I \q -rr..- (1".k M JtJ-,1 v' , SINDII I]IGII coultT

D,I],

ol lJan:h.

.Cornpsition Mv .1, M u-{- -* *-..i l( ct"i" u-[-'- l\nLt N4.t J Ab ("1^ Dates oI heariog:, 3c.- c,q- Dccklcd ,:ln l:l ll - s l.a!

(a)Judgrucnt aPProvcd fcrr Ycs ky/1 rcportirtg -N6

o11 tt 't IFICATIl

ti ot atulciatar n princip-lc Ccrtiliccl thal the jr:dgnrent C)r'rlcr is.basctl upon irr: prcssion / d istiogttishes /' ot. law */rlecides a qLrestiofl "i f^*" iiiri.f," ir oi liist i,i,.i:,,.,r"ii-"lri,iscs/txplains a prr:vicus tlecision lstrikc out whichevcr is not applicablc

Irlo'I'E:-(i) This slip is only to bo t,scd when some aclion is to bc tokcn' (ii) It thc slip is uscd, the llcatler must 0ttach it to the top of thc llrst page of thc )udgmerrt,

(iiil Rerdcr urttst ask tlre Judgc wrjtiltg thc Ju(lglnent whctbcr tbc Jtrdgtrlenl is approv':d ::or Icpor(in8'

(iv)l'hose rlircctions which arc not to trc used should be delctcd liG P., I( a r.--L (iii) I 459--5,000'- 6'93- -T S'S a

th) \HC \{\q\-\ RT OF Bru\r+ Ar \.4(SqHT.. ( G".'i Aq&ud* 5*nilirlio" Q.[ffi*! Agj*l t\h. o I ts\s 634

I"l^h$^*nA 8t [,] Q 5n5''..,, R,vos.* Husson, tti[, t(oAi,^, AI,[t, [".$, (onC*I in Cnt*\'(1',\0,,, \r^*ck. AtA.[*[ i,^ (rnon

\ €,(S\A

G S"fe Q.*e."&t Qrt"tq, \--rle 2or( f

fr( tn. 3;tb /10\3 \[s'.3s1-l3aq/3\ eec Rl,"r Se&on1 a€ ArA \$ P. L. : Yo.r^"..n- \6wn t<o.t^c\n .

QRrrrrrrNL Appe.AL \rN\ER Kt-c:trclN t\\0 C- Alq' S€c-trqN \A oF A t A \qq+ Bei,..r ocq(,wqtr Lv ov,,l Air-s"*"G"l tr,th t^r ,*!rr^J ! sJni*"*-"a&r zl -os - 2o\r f"r*J ky t* ^[*.*J "["a -ttr.'or1s,r Co"rL Vo.*.h, i^ sgeclol fu.oe N0. lnUT 5"Jg, \5-ttt/2-orsl- urkore\y d" &,v,tet ng6otl** wua &Jlt"* h S.^(fo- Q;qo*unr t*ptto"*"r* 6v \6t {. ttq a/kn'{ t\,\&r 8e.Io".'Bol-/tz.{/tq 9Pc tul wiV^ Seok'qn 1(t+1 of An[i Teynrisr,,r N& rtt], u,{'t * h*r..e6t .f kt{i* i32-g (x. f. c.

na A?("t!.J ns(c &C,fiy (."6-. {{ 0*oo * ,\Pe"-! err\ S."l;Jo.nA^ ,C ti" 6[!.*_ g^^-L o^L J", (r* G*CgA Ger ,€ l"t I^nh3*I J"f"-.* A"Ll'rc-or-t ir en doeqJ hu'ein.

I

Fle camt' upou and his otre l<iclncy was tlauragetl' rthtre he rtas opet atetl and hrr Marrgi has srrccrrnri.rccl to irriury' rif Lnorv trrat Abcltrr.|abbar 19' Iterl No'11' llc clainl that irr Warcl No' t,:.:tielf is trtrricr tle'rtnrent

l.r

("r,^ t.t.c c.., i Ll-t.- t 633

Il lc,,H C oliltT () IT SINDI I AT KARAC'I II No'lU3 of 20lft Special Crinrinal Atrti.f t'rrorisnr lail Appeal

l,r ('c( n 1:

\11. lt!5titt' ,\lttltLttltrturtl kttrittt h/lrtrr "\5i trr

I ,Appellatrt \.lrrlr.rrrrrrr.rti 5llallicl "rr l'l[)'ll1i llltottr"lr hlr'\ILrltarttrrtttl Itll r'l tr Nlt'o' r\'lvot'itr

liesl)r )n(ir'rr I / 5ta lc Ilrr,,rrllll \1r \litlt'rrrrttr'tLl l'll"rl '\rr''rrr Il' l'rri" l'r{ )sUL Il lr )I (,!'llL'rJl

Date of hearing: 30.04.2020.

I)ate of Anntlu ttct'rne tr t I 1.05.2020.

IU I) (; NIlrNt \,I U I] Ai\I NI AI ) l\AI{lNl KIli\\ A (i t I t\, At t t ts..'tl Nlttll.ttttttt.ttl 5lr.rhiLl ., JaPani si'L' liit,rsat llttss'ritr rras lrit"l [rv lt"rrttt"l lrrtlr;'' \rrlr 'It,r'r',,risnr ( otrrt Nrr ll l'.ar.r, hi, irr sl"r ial ( asL' Ntr /\l llt8"/llrl r 'trr\rr)r' \r'r lrr'rr -'\l'\ orrt ol ( rirrrt, No llli t,l llll1. Lr,i: 1l)1,/1lt.i 1'l I'l'( ritr t(lt)7, rt'gistctt'tl at l)S ,/,rttl.rtr lrrr'r'tt K'lt'tr lli Att''r tli'rl ritlt Irt''II"tIt' 'rI (()rl\ ir Lr''l 'rrr'l \t rrt( Lr( ' 'l {l,rl('(1 r{, ():r l(llir, tlrt',rIP1'll,11rr tt'ltrrtti 'tl"'t '' \\rl\ t() \ullcr rli),(\rrrus ltlll)ll\(rlllll( rll tt'r lil{, ittltlt't'\tr ti'rtl ' ('l) '\l \ l'r'r'

2.llt'irrg', .rgtlrir\rtl .rtrrl tliss'tticiiLLl L't tlr'' ltrLlllrrrtrrl I'.rs\(!i l'r lL,.rrrUrl Ilr(lgc, r\trli- lt'rrt'ristrt trLtrt Nr' ll' li'rr'r' Ili llrt''rl.r' ''rr'l '11'1'' " Iras [,t,crr prL'l('r'r('(l 1,1 ihr'.rp|t'll,rrrt ,r1',.ttrrt lris ((]ll\ t( trr)rl

'I I ht'briei laLts r11 lll(' IrrJsL,(lttirrtt t'tst' 'ltrortltrrr" tL' ill'l NO. l,ri,rl{ll3 is tlr,it tlr,.' Illi iras rt'i',rst,.'r.('(l lrrr ()l l() ll)11 rl -rolr lr'rrr

.rncl lltt'itttitltlll occttrtt'tl orl li't)!)'lt)lI ')i lhl! lttritr' trtt tlr(' Ir'l\l\ (rl tlrr

sl,ltent(,11t rr/s l5-l ( r l'.( ol r()llll)l.litratli Nat't'llr s'/rr I 'tz'tl '\ilrrl''tl llr'

L(lnrpl.rirt,rllt itr llis st,llt'tttt'trt Lr,/s l5t r I'( h'l.'l st'll('tl lll'rt llt i'tllir'r (1rlr1lrr' l\rrr'r1r"\ lt' ol r\btlttl laLrLrar \1arr11i \\'ll() r\ 'tll 1)llr(( l ()l l\l)/\ 'rt l Irt' lr't'1 t'rl't rl '\l"lrr th('P.lst t()ur veals' llr'ri ()rr 17(l() l(lll irr t I ' \ L' I

( I ( ' I IIII

l\1.rrrgi in Srrztrl.i ,\lt,' \"1 '\Lrli 76h ttotlr Kot'ttr1"i \r' I 1"t llL tt'tt'r l,rLrb.rl \iitiirl r)r lr 'r llr' \\,1!,.1tivitt1l Illt t.rt rr'lrt't'',t';\htlLrl ]'rl'l"rr \l'rtlt"t r"ls s(',tl trc\t ltr titirct \('.lf (ll1 [itt'r'r''ti llt' l()lti hirrl ilrai tht'tlr(1tltt'l "l ]ir',

6zq

lJLr' ttr sr.'t'ltt'r '\s tltr'r'tt''ltll",.l 'tl \i,.tcl.ilr l,lu rs ill alltl tllal llt'lla: ttr i"rr rl(lt'ls ()rr tttrrt tIIt(r' qt()P l<or,llrgi N()l 'lt '1h()rll 114 15 Pllr t\\'() \'()tlllll (rt qtoPPt'tl tll('1r t'ir' lrt)llt ol titt'rar 'rll\l ir()tlr !\,c.1t.iltFl ht'ltlrct ''llllt'lll litt'Li rt1't'tl tllt'tlt \\'ltt'r't'ti1'trtr lrL' r"'t ilrt,rn tot,l< trttt theit Pisirrls 'rtrtl l.ri)L,.rr \laIl;,.i 11,t \tritll.tslt ltllttrr,ti l.r bltllr.L ttlllltt... itljttl.r'ti .ttltl ^l)(]Lll \\"ts t l.L"rtr'(l Il'' 'rrl''l r\l'tlLrl l'rl'l"rt' irl'rrri"L .rn(l I)\ stlch fititrl', ttrtot t'tlt u'lrt'rt' llt' u'rs {ilrlr'rtr''l rlclc l.rr,trilht to iirltr'llr Ilrrspii'll irl Jrlllrlll'llr((" llr" ' atttt' tt' l"tror't' ilr'ri '\lrtlLrl rri.r.,rt ittttl lri\ ()llc Li(lllt'\ !\'l\ \l'lllt'lJr'!l' l() rrritrr\ tli"l l ll' ( l'lilrl' ill'll 11111'11r'tr lt l.rl'L,aI Nlarrrii has *Lt'r-tttrrl't'ti 'rr'l\l r\trtlrrl lairlr'rr Nlalllii arril 'rls'r tttlLtt'''l t(,1(,risls lr,r,l rrrrrrr',rn,l lr.rtl LrllLtl Itittr I ltt'r't',titer,rt tirrtt lrt L'rl\t ]r 'r{'\irr'l ilr('rll obtaittitlii llflllllc\!('rr L r\{tr,t c()nlllJ(.i11)n rrl Ltstlal itrr t'stit"atiott 'ltt''1 I'L lt'r i' tlrt' ( r 'rr( \'rrr( LI I )rrr'1 I.rr'srllrr'lrilte(l cha lla rl ar"'iitr''l tll'" 'tt ' rrst 'i r("trl r)\'t'l l1r llrt 'r(!rrs'rl !r. lht'rcattt't-tot tlr'tl ' lt'tl'1'.t'rr''tt ll''ltllr.'''l 'rlrtl It, rlltitlr ht'1'lt'.rclt''l lr()t litrilt\ nrr(l (llirrr('(l l" l)('tl.i'(l (,\.lll]1lr( ll ()(l ll!().'!L lil .], (l ]rl p1llr,'t, ris tast' llrt, l)|\l:.('(Lltllrl] Jllrl ()tllt'l ll( rlr\ 'lrr' rvitnt'sst's attcl t'rllil'itt'tl lltllrl('l'i\l\ tl r tttlr"trts lltt,r't,altt't t]rcsirlt'rrl ilrt'1'tttstt Lltllrll \\"1\L Jrrsr"l Sl'rtt'tll|tlt 'rl llir 'tLL ir*r'tl

\\,.r\ r'c(()l(l('(l tl,/s ill (r l'(' ilr tr'lriell ltt ,.lt'tltt'tl 'tll tlrL' 'IIItr1'rIrlrI'

It'r'r'lctl .r1'.rlirtst lrtttr,rrr''l l'lr''t'llrl l'rlst i I I I t r t '

I

r

t I I I lt' 'rl"r 1l(r\ ((\ r(1r'rr\

r r

\t|}rl)t\Il rrl lris.lL,lr,rlr L'..1',.

tlllll('I lr.lIh htlt tli.l ,r.,1 r.lll .lttt rr,t(tlt,s: lj] ( K'rt't' lrt' 'rl1( r l)( ']rrlr!'

7.l-e(lrlr('(l Jll(lii('' '\lrtl Ierlotistll trLrrt NL' ll' (rl t \ l(l('ll(l"lr 'ltL'r['L' tltt' lcartletl tr-ltlt'tsi'l ft'r tllt' 11'llllt's 'ltttl 'tsscsstttt'trt ()' f(lll'' ("rr\ rt l' Ll rrr'i ,,f r,t,,l'.1, r'i,'lCtht' I I I ) \ I I l : I \ t ( I itr(lllrrrt'rrl 'l'r tct I lt' st'trtt'ttct'tl tlrt'a1'pL'll,rrri,1'" 'L'rtt'Ll 'tl'or''' ltt'tttL llris '11'1't"11 lrrs l'r''r' t '

l)\ tIIr'.II)t)' II.IIILIp..rIlr\l l';\ \ "llvlr llulr E IhL'f.rcts ('t tllr "l''("r' r'r't'll 'ts t r itlt'tt'L' f'lorltt'1"'l b|l0tL llr' trr'Ll tltt'rt lor'' ' llL' coLrlt lirttl .ttr clrl'ot,ltt'rllt'rltl()ll irr tll' illlPtrt"ll('Ll i tI :t 'trt

L t

r L

(rs tr: avortl tlttPrlic'rtiotr 'rtltl uIll)L'(('\\'ll'\ Srlttr. .tf (. t-tot tr'irt'otl Lt,.'.'tl hclu s(r rc P('t iti( rl r

(). I,....1t-tleti t.trrttrst.I 1(]I tllL,,iIP!'Il.llii l].1\ ((jlltt,l](lt.(l ill.lt ll(, l\ |r1,,,!. rl] ((rll'(r(t( (l ('r\( \ Lr ,rncl has bt'ett tnls,'l\ illll'litJlt'tl irt illic eolltPl'"tt'lr t.

lrL')r .l((r)Ltlrt ()t llis irolitieal 'itiiIi'ttiotr' tllat Ilrt'r't' is tt0 t'r'ttlt rrr(' 'l)i'rlLr\I s Il ('lr Lt1'trtl llitlt irr 'l t'rst'ttrltlr't irl),rrl ir()lll lllc PistLrl r!llitlr tr''t' loistt'rl \\ iil aftcr tllt' itrtitlt'trl rllrttlr rll'rl(lrr'(i rrl thc ,,\t'ttrs ()rtiilr,lllar.' lN Itlotlllts llri 'rf i't'llarrl sltolrltl IrL"lit!Llrll\'rl 'rl t,rrrfrttes tt'crrvt'tr.'.1 itotlt tllt \'r'll('nlrLl ('\tt,ll(lilril to llitrr tllt'lrclrt'lit ol llrt' tllLtlrt ltr tlre clr.lr'1ic ht: this trrLrrt (llrLrl'rrrt r'('lirrlr'('rrl) lllt r'ts''' "l sLIirl(rrt t)l lris cr''rrtL'tr(totts ll' l'l'r't'Ll .l-lrc Stalt' (r'()i)l' q( N jli l()hl)' Ali Sht'r 'ttrtl otlrt'rs Al<l..lr ,lnd .1n()thct vs atif Unar 'rtrtl 'rnothet Vs lht' !s. lhe St.lte (21)()8 s( \1li ''()'i) Ab(lul t State (l{)lli I'. Cr I l. \ltrlt' l()) Svctl I(iffat Iltrssaitr 'rtrrl otlrt't's rs lhe r' ( r'(Ji"r l* !}9 'il lrllE irrrr' r" i

5t.,t" {ir1','.1,,, ('t'. '\trti lt'r't"rt'rrl l\l)|{"rl\ 'i! rlalerl t)1.(l().2()l 9)

('L trlr'tl lr'l' lrlll' 10 ()tt tllc ollrt't ll,lll(l l(,llll((l l)('lrlll\' l)frrst\tltot' lr'r' (()I1IlII''Ii'ri lll'rl ll" srrpprrltr'r1 tlte itltptrlltrt'Ll llr(lgrrr{'rrt llt ils ('lsr'a!',lrltlst tlrt' apptll'lrrl br'rotlel 't tr"r'"rr'rl'l'' l)l'()s('auti(rl1 llas prorttl ('n(lr t'lllt't itr all trr'rlt'r' '1 tloulrt;ts lhe pr()st'( triirrll \\'illll's5('s !llPfr()ft tll('lll 'ltrtl 'ts stlt ll llt' Lt rt'sPt\ ts.lnLI Ilo cttltlitr ll't' L''''t tr sLt;11"t'stetl '1)l'lill\t !t)rrl('\\r'(l lrit ' rrrr,L r'\ irlt'lr((' t.rtl bt' s.tlt'l! r't'lit'tl ttpotr' llrat a1'pt'l{irrrt tlrr' irlti'lt rll "rl l''- bt'lt,rL' {ltt' policc .rtt.i lt'r'l lllt'tll to tlll pl'rtL' "l ( i l t ,l t i r r l , llltrt tllt i'tltplir't tt''trl (r l t't'r'tl lr()lll tllt' \(('lr\' \)l llrt trrL rtlt rrl f) trtl ltis.rtt, sl ,lrt.i r.

{ ll].]t(ll{'(I v,,ith tht, l)isi(,1 r(.(1,\(,11,(l ltr,ttl tltr,.rlt ttst,tl crrt lr lri' , rrttYtL Iirrll .rtlLl \(,,r1\'n(( slr,,trlLI l't' Lrplr'"ltl 'rrr''l llrt rl'1'r '1i rli' rr issltl.

r

t()r llrL'l"ttltt'' . \'!e lrtrr,,-'ht'attl tlll ,rrlitll)r('l1t\ r't tlrr' lt'altrL'Ll '(rtrrrs('l Stlltt' thr'(,ul,,h th(, r,ntitc t't'ttlt'tlrc rlhitll ll't' Lrr('ll lt"l(l 'rrrl lrr llrr aP1,r'll.rnt, tilt' itlll''Lt1ltlcL1 iLl(lllllrelrt rvith tlreir 'll)l(' 'l\si\t'1lr(t' art''l lr'ri '' 1111' [r'tt' t,rnsttlt'tt',1 tllc rel(l\,ll)t larr itrt lLrtlittr', tlral ' rLltl 't1 l ' ( ( r'l llr( Altet <lttl rl'ilssr'\clll('lll ('l tllt'('\'i(l.,ll(('b'ts..'ti i'tt t l t ' t' i' l i L l

I']\,\",- c\Pt'ci.rll\r l)!\' I Nat't'tlr r"'l1tr "r'ls sllol 'rrrtl illilrr('Ll 'rt tht' st t'rrr' ' rl tlr' ()- Ir(\st lrr()rlt'rll l('lr('r l l'\\ inciclcnt irlotrri rvith tlrt' (l('!(''rs('(1, I'!\ N1l ('l ('llli)tit't ()ll lll{' \11(rt 'ltlrl 1'r''ittr' Polire r'r,itlrt'sst's ,ttlt1 l() tirr'r('l\ lr't' Il()\ ' (l lrr'\ 1' "l clt,-'ttrital l('P()rt \\'('art s'tli*litLl tlt"t tl"'l'"'"'t rttioll l

(l() lt)ll,tt air'rtrt I-15|rl P('l\{)lrs ll'l(l tlrrl('{iir rq.t\()n,rlrl!,rlLrLtlrl tlrat orl lr lir,t'Ll .rt.r (.]l- \\l1l] ttlr,trltL,ikt, .1t [)tI5 \t(.}l Kl,r.rttllt Nt.2 atrtl Ir.rtl \()('('rrr (rrr(l [1lli'Lrf' r('llis(l.,ttiolr N() '/\ltil-/5{) r|llt''h liIr"irrll sllt'ts irllttlt'rl a

lo:>b

rvllrrrtt rvt'r't'sittittli lll lill'('ll atltl llrr tr'i'r Alrtlrtl ]abl'al i\'1;rrr;1i l"rtlr ot ()i ''\rlhtrl llrl'bat-Nlalll"i' lllrs Prrsitlltr is atlrlrltlr'ri l'r c.lrrs.'rl tht'lllLlr(1('r Ir..r I ut(i c( )tr lrsel f trr tlrt''r ppel l'r rrt (rtll \rt\\' l('ll l'tl'rl( tts ir rllltllltlll;L' ti Illc r.rtllY issitt' tltt'l'r'ltrr'" lll 11'111r shtri tllt' tlr:ct'rtt'el r\l'Litrl l'rlrl"rr a1.pt'llallt !\'ils olrL) ()l tlrr' irt'l\()lrs \1anp1i irr litt'itrnl iltltl tht'r t'l'i ' t'tlltllittt'r'l his Itlttttlt'l'

{)l ilrr't i 1(lr'1]rt'\1't' Iill'l lll'11 ll'' II lll \)r.ll-\/ll\\'Jlt( l (llll f|J\\!'\\llt( lrI rlL'rrl't tlr'rt irt't'rl 'tl'll t() fllr!\r't't'i'r'lltl a f('115{)lr(li1lL 1,rost'r'ttlitrlr has N()t \\llr) llrLlf({LIt(l tlttt"lsILl \l"lrrl llrt',rirpt'llarrt \\'.ls ()t)t ol llrr' ptltorlr sli asitlt' tltL' itlll'Lt!"ttt'..l III(I!"!I\t III lai,bar \1arl1ii Lry lit't''rltlr 'lrt''l Ilt'tt'br .ur(l .tll()h llrc appt'al l!rl tllL. l(rll()!\ iltll rr'itstttls;

(n)l-ht'rc rrits atr Lrtrcrl'l'rirrr (l tl( l'rlrl I rl rrs rrr. l"tl11irrrl tlrL' I l{i r'r'hich ctltll''l It'tr't'lt'ltl t tlrt ("lrrt\tltrlr I'l '1 Lrl\('('i\("r)"llrr'l the actLtst'tl ('f 'lll\ r'ill('l- P{'r((rll lll tlrt' lrttitt'' lllt"ltr rl'''Ll rr''' l't tlor'r llt't( 'lt'l t' " lr()t Ir.lllrt'(l ilr llrl Illi lt i* u'L'll st'ttlt'Ll ]rltl'a'lu "tr tl" lilirlli arr llli \\ illl('rri ' r['latr'tii.tl '1''111't''r'lt l)r(ls('Itlti()l] ('lst'

(tr)l)rl' solt' t'\r.' tr ittlt" tt' lhr'irlr'itlL'rli l'\\' I N'tt'L'trr 'tLlrrttllL'Ll "r ' tlrr''trll'trl' rrtr" lri. evi.l.'rr.,'tlt,ll ltt Lrrttltl ttot rt'tol',trizr"1111'r'l llr' lir('(1 ,tl llll)r .rtt.l tllr' ''ltr'"'t"'tl' lllrs It Lrll(lt'l\t'rlltl'lL)i(' 'r' ,.11li)rits \\'r.'r( \\('.\rlrlll llr\)tol 'lrlt' llt'ltllt'ts 'rl lltL'lrtrrr'"1 tl'' rvitrlt''st's to llrr' irrL rtlt rrl ittcielt'tlt Sirlcc tllr"tt' art' ttrr otllIl' r't't' thr.'itlt'rrtilit.rtt,'r1 1'1 111'' 'r1-;"'ilarrl n\ ()rr| Lrl llrt' [tr\trrr\ \\lrrr \'rL't'trr t rrrr'r rrrLrL lit't'el trl'ort tirt'Llr'" 'tst'tl 'ltttl l{lt ittltttt..l l'\'\'I rltl('sti()l)

(( ) Nr) ()lrc \\'Js ,ll lt'ctl'(l lr()lll th('sptrt atttl l)o rt'( rr\ t'r\ Lri 'ttlt lrt't"l n'.rs tlarl,.'(rll il)(' \1']( )L

rllrrr lr lrL appt'llant's allt'11c'tl trrtrl'':s:it'tt lrr.'lorc lllr' poliLl ' llre irl) ru r'' llr(' latc, tl"trn, tL'Ll is itratltltisrihlt' itt r''r'itlt'ttt-'" l \'('lr ()Llrt u llilsl lr''' rr't' ltt ,rpPall,lnt aliL'1'.t'Lll1 (olrt('rsr'Ll lo a rtlrtttlt't 1,,,ii.r.' .,.,.t,,,'lt itr ,r r 'ls'" trtlLlt'r' S ll (tl) Lrl tlre sirr(llr '\r.rrr' i-r,,1i,-,.,,,,,' ;11111 .1s 'ttrIl it rlocs trot 'tP1r1"tl l(r l'("lsoll' 1r'tltL .t cr)l'11111()lls('ll5(' thal llL' trottlLl ((rlll('ss t() '1 t f i I r ' \ \ I r I "rrtr"l t I I I I

t' irr llt'rl tht'dt.rtlr Pt'll.lllI lrllltl illt'rt'tr'tsatrsolttlt'lr tto t" vicit'trt rrr /\" ( l'l\\ a,,a" o11ui,r't hitlr r{lrit lr lta,.l l'ce tr rlispt'sr'tl {)lr rr ll t t t' i l t'

(e)tlre appt llarrt lt',rtlirrg, ilrL' 1'trltLt' l''' tht' 1'l'rtt t t trtr '

' r,.t. a..,,,,,,,i1t..',.1 is ilr',.'lL'i''rril lll(' l'oli((' alri'rtll I'tt'.'rr I' lr' r' tltt' critllt' \\ (li ( ()llllllittL'(l -.

l

(t)rt.rliP('1r\ trr'rt trr'l' 'r rr l'l:i",lli:1,''rl;ll:,:"li'ill"l'i;, ':i,:'i];l:l: i- llr(' I'r''lrr\" |-l rrl'"rt tt']''" rr'tl' ''1,,.':,, t] ' L t'l' r''rl'I .I l'LL r\\'('l'r'\l Irr'll\ ll'' \" "' ' r'rlrll' '1 lcc()vL'1.('(l Ilrrtll i t ' ' I ()ll his 'rr lt'\t 18 ntotrth* 'rftLr:]les rL ' I I rrr

e!i''lctlt'r' \'\rllt'l I lll('\r' ('llllltl( I r r

' 1 I '

,^a,,r"rU ,a,*'"tct lltt't't' is tti' i,t're ktl]i ()\'('r rll'1t ls '""''th t', .rl':1.:l],']l:],1::,il,il]:,:

^l r " - \ -'r' l' \\'' 'r " rr, ri lll'i '''r" ' "'l'"'t ' t'l '- h't l' lr'rLl lrt' rr ilrttl ll"r rllr('irisl"l that tllr\r t t'tt' tlrt' t''ltl'i "'"' l8 ttli'tltlls l'ltr'l lll lr.'5lr(\ t rttovt.rorl tl(,lrl tll(' ,lIpcll'rrlt g11'11'5 c'rse (sLrPta).llli\ ,,,it,",''. plat'.'tl trtr nt"t't t'otif ('rrtrilt tl ltr tlrt' I't'tttltt t'l t ' r I ' I ' I I L I r L I t IIL

" Ihe ;1'pt'llarlt r\

(g)'

,]]i:,lli:],::i,,JiJ' ',;ll,.l:,

u1,p.n,. rr,,rt, rr,,. L " ",.llil,.::li,l;,1, ,l rr lll rr,t' tlrl |L t*''tl tr lt l1i\ r'rl ,fi,.tt,l l,,t'l'.rr' \larr1ir l'r' lilt attl r'r'lrilsi srltirr!" rrr \'!t' lilrtl tlr'll lll(' lrr"s(\ llll('1r l!r. lhus, ['ilst'tl ()ll tl]t' (ll)(r\'(' tlrstttssit'tt Iras Iailctl t(r plt)\'(' iis ('rs(' 'rl','rilrrt tht''r1rpt'll'lrlt lrt't'trtltl 't rt"lsott'tl'lL tlr("rlrPr'llarrl "l rlotrl.i .r.rtl rvt' st't.tsitlt' tllt'itrr1'trlirtc'l itl(lllrlr('nt''(tl!rit atltl as sttt h tlrt '11'1r'll'rlrl 'lr'rl l" tlrL. chat ge atrtl all'r"r' his 'r1'pt"rl trtrlt'ss lrt'is r'r'trtltt"'l itl 'ltrr trillt'r cttslotlt' '''tsc'' lt'lt'.rsertl

It. t ht'ap1'1"11 is tli"prrsctl r)l rrr ilr(''rl'()\'('t('rrrr\' 1. ll I..tl,./ tLtt )\;/

I

(I)

I ,\\}1.,

/\.t- >o, r