The State/ ANF.. (Applicant) VS Jahanzeb & 03 Others. (Respondent)

N a.r c-[.cJ C- Rivlr'i, ^ Afft. Alb*./

I

CEI{'t'll:lC'A l'lr O F Iltlr Ilt(;ll (lo l.-ll('t oI slNl)tl t(r\lir\( ltl Cr. Appeal No. 270 of 20'12 aiw Others

Jahanzeb Khan & others Vs' The Statc

IIICTT(- otit{'t'01: slNljll

( t)Dl l'llatttlt D.R.

Mr. Justice Muhammad Karim Khan Agha Mr. Justice Zulfiqar Ali Sangi

Dates ol hearing: t9-05-2020 ,l )0-u5-]u

Decided on : )9-t)5-)0:0

(a)Ju(lgmcot ltpltrovr'd lbr I{e poi ting l'r,' t/, a cut{l-l Irl('A't I:.

Certilied tl.rat the -ltrdgment */Ordel is bascd upon or enllnciates a principle ol lall +/decicles a tluestion 6f laiv which is o1'llrst impressiolr/dislingLrishes/. Ovcr-rltles'' leverscs/explains a prcr ioLts dccisit-rn.

* Strilie oLrl rvhiclte'r'ct is lltrt al)l)licilble.

lr'' l:r]itrl' NO l t : - (i) I his sliP is otlil' to lre Ltsc'.l ri'ltc'tt s()llle ilcti()rl is 1r)

(ii)Itlhc sliP is ttse,'1, tltc licrt''lcI llltlsl attilcl) il to llie to;' ()l ihe lirji pagc ol' the i Lrdgnlcnt.

(iii)l(cll!lcr trlttst ask tlte Jtttlgc rvriting the Itttlgttl'"ttt rrlretltrr tltc .lLrilgnlcnt is approvcd lirt t'cpoltinu

(ir ) Iirosc tiitcctiolts u'ltielt ate Ilot l() be tLsctl sltorrlrl be tl':ltt'.'''l'

r2\

IN TFIE HIGH COUR'I'OF SINDTI AI I(AITACIII

r\,

9pecia.l Appeal No. l?-012.

', 'r ,.. I i , t\r r"1 \ Jahanzeb Kl-urn S/o Zaliir Slrah, t Nluslittr, Ar]ult, lt/o C.ti.l1. \ I lor-rsc No, 188, ChareeL,-Alrat[, I lydc'ralrad.... , .. .. Applicant/Acctrsed

Vt'r'stts

'l lre St,rtt llesp ontletr t

l;ll( No. 04 & 05/20t)l;

Llls 6lL)-C, (lNIi Act ltx)7 ['.1i: AN |, (itrlslr.rrt-t'-lt;Lral

ApI',EAt- U/S 4rJ Otr (C()N',l liOL oI NAI(tlOI'l(ls

SUUS; !'ANCI,S) AC'I' 1997

l3L'ing a.:p,r'itt'.'J anJ rli:';.rtisli.,1 rr itlr tlr.' torrs,rlitl,rlt'tl lir.lgtrt.'trt (ll ttvt' tr,rl r(r\r5 p.r.'L'.1 l,\ tltt i,lrt'ei:rl L \rrllt N,r' l- .l,rittl .r rr^r lg.r rrr.r

lS-()7-l()l-l ((l()nlr(,1 (,1 \ir.,,1i.,:,u[]rt,r1((!l l...rr.rehi, (l,rlrarrz,'l,.rrrtl l)tlr.'r: V/s tlru tt.rt,') br Nlr. l.rl'ir llLr".rir lLr.1,1,"rl i,1rt'.r'rl ('L,Lrrt Nt'. I t', lrrr.'[rt tllL'lri.rl ('()Lrrt !\'.r: plt',ts.,l t,, .otti i.t,r,.l tlr.' ,r1,1r,'ll,rrrl Ui. l-t .rrr..l '('rrt('rr!('!l trrr(l(l s,-,ction l5 rc.rci ivith :t'.lirttt () (. ,.rl llr.' .r\al tor tll(' lt'lrrl ol li l. .rlrt',1(ly Lul(lcrgr)rrc.r: Ll tl', rr'ith b('rt('lrl ()l 'r-'rtiotl .i5l-11, Cr'.1'(,.rlt,rrg,r,r'itll otlrt't';ttttl tlrr'apptllrrrl thLrs f,r,-'ictt',',i ilri:,rI)P..rl trtr tlrt ftrllrrrvitt"', i.tct:-.rrr.i gtrruttrl.is:

IIACTS

lhat lhr';rppr:ll'lrrt il(rrl!,\\'itlr tlrtL'.'trtllcr> u.ts ittt'trlr''''l irr I lli N''r' t)'jit)'l U/s 619-L, CNS.Aci lte7, l'5 LlLrlslr.rrr l.1l'.rl K,rr"rihi"l'lr'rt tlrt'L'r'i'"1 leils i''lJl ttt"t ;ts ptr tltc ,rltrr.t':ai11 |ll{ th.rt -'iNI tlt,'\l)l:l' Ii\ lN5l'l:t lt)li .l'rlr'rniilI ot l'l'' ,.\rri-1, Krr.rchi, or1 iPy irllt) rnl.rtir )lr, .r PP rt'lr('rr(ltrl thc.rPpt'llrtrt 'rltrtt;iiritlr lrr rr 'ttt ..\tltin s/ir .\nrinLr.lin .rDLi (,irrrl.rrri r\li S,ro ,'\,lrrncti l]arrr'.tni, rVlrilc tlreY rr'trL' t,rgetltet br.'irru trtl tlruit lr'ar itl iltlr.'tt [r.',rlirrp rcgistr'ltiotl No r\( 'X L)lll' 'lrrr'l 'rs -, rr,srrlt ol the sc;tIch tllerL,()1, 5...Lltr..l !rLrt ()l ils tllrnl' tIrr,,,,tt1'IoIt lr,rgs lilll ()t: a0

-I'i'l'

I !\

I\T FIE I{IGH COUII T Otr slN DH AT I(AITA(]III $pecial Appeal No.

l'// 12012 ,/' :. .. .:' I,.N'l W&.

. il . . -: I ..1 ^t '.t- ,-r.rrrzeb Khan S/o Zahir Shalr, ( trir' "r n, .,\v \ ll l \"\\ '.i.,',lim, Adult, R/o C.U.H.

' u" X"-.! tl"r' -. . rlse No. 1Sti, Cllrar.tcLr-Abltl, ,)

. . Jerabacl... Applicant/Accusctl

Vr't:;tt';

. r',c Sti-rte. . ..1{t':;potrtlertt

trill No. 0-l/20()5 Uls:619-C, ClNli Act t9c)7

l'.S: ANIr, Cr,rlslrlrr-e lt1[ral

Al'l'EAL U/l; 'tB Oli (('()N I lt()l Olr NAI(('()'l l(':l SUliSlt AN(.ltrl,) A(.| 11rt)7 ()l l\\'() [3r.'itrg .rg;li it'r't'tl .rtrt] tli's'rti'liL"l \ritll tlrt'(()trrtllitlJIL(l lrrd!'rrrt'rrl (lrst\ llrL' 'il"',.'i'rl L()tllt \t' l' tl'rLt'rl .rni.rlg,itttratt rl 1,.rss,',1 ['r I: t)7-21)ll (('rrrttlol ol N.rrttrtit; iiLtlr't'rrrL'':'1 l'''rr'rLlri' (J'rlr'rrrz''1"'rr'l t )Llrt rr Vi' rlr, statt,) trr,'l\'1r../aLir Iltrs'.rirr lutl11'lrl ''l)t't r'rl tlL)trrt N() l rrlrr'l'l')' tlr' 1ri'rl { ,,Lllt !\.r\ plt'.1'.'rl t.r rrrttvit lt'tl llr"r1'1't'll'rrrt Ll/s l'l 'rrr'l ltr'rrttlr(('(l ttrr(l( r -,.tior.r l5 rc.r(l witlr stttitrtr tr-( ,rl tlrt r\Lt lr)r llrt tt'll)l Lrl l( l 'rlrt"r'l1 'rl1111('rlj()rlL'.r, Ll ll', rr itll berr.,lit ()l r{'r'tli)rr rs'll' Cr'l)'( 'rl()rr}r'!\ illr rrtllL'r: 'rrrtl tllL'appcll'lrlt tllLls lrrr'lr'r'r't'tl tlris '11r1't"rl orr llrL'I..'ll'rtr'itl11 l'l(ts nlr!l rittrtrtttl'r Ij ,\ (l'l s 'l lr.lttllc.r[)]]('ll'rrli'rltrtrliirillrtlirt'r't'tltr'r'rvastttr''''ir"l irr I lli Nt' l)rltl" U/s 6/9-C, (lNS r\,.1 lt/e7, l':i (ltrlsh'rrr lt1[r'rl I(ar'iLhi' llr'rt tlrc t'r'i''l ln( tsl*hig tlr'r t

I

as pcr tlrc .rlort's.titl Irlli lhat ''\Nlr lllri\l)lrl) lJ\ lN:''tre lL)lt J'rliarrl"ir ol l"i' l tht'a1'P''ll;rrrt ;ltrril"rvith ItlrIarr -\nl-1, Kilr.l!lli, trn sPy irtlot'trrnti()rl' 'rPPrr'll('lltlt\l II'ttrr''rtIt' r!lril'' tlr.'i' lr''r''

I

l\rtrirr S/tl Atl.litlLrtlitt .rtlt1 ('lrlrl'lrn Ali :''lt' ''\lirrr..'d j ttrlit'thr.'r'[r.'itrP, oli tlr.'ir \\',tv in t]rr'('ll Lrt"rt'rtrg rr'gistt'ttitrrl N'r '\('\ (]-ll' 'ttttl 'ts

.r lt,sult ol tht's,.'.trclt tltt'rr.'ol, st'cr'tt"l oLlll t ll5 ltrttlk tltrcr" rtr'l'''rt ["11"' lLrli rrl :'t)

\:t \

i fiFtJrl -5ttN # It.. ( I lil} i 1(

I

I

I Ho No IR ,,\ lt I 0r, L ll l't 1)

I

i t.il t,r It 1- ( r(Jr I

ot,' ,stN t)il A1' t

I

lr-r-r-r-t lcru (

I

t (l{ ]] \,'l.Sl( )NAi. \( J UfUSDICTION) I ( t'. Itrr iriorr I .\o. ol'2012 t 'l he

I

I 91x1s7,,,1,, ti r., rtics l.or ( 1r-/

,_\ L./

throLrglt its . .Nlrt e ,,

I

I

\ sstsLinl I)ir_cctor t I .rrr. cot.r,rL rrtler I t

I

ol l)lri, i:tarr, )

AntiNtrr.e otiu 'ot.i sl (i-I.l. IJlr,t./, l(haylibln_r,- i.r t;

tnr. ( lrJion I(arach i

.,\ 1r1 r/ica I r

I

_ i. Jahanz.,b s ,() Zllrir. .Slrrrir Vl.kst /s ' Muslinr, i\ rlrr l t.

lt t ) llrrrsc I lyder.ahrrrl N,, I I l,a thair

I

Colony

I

* ,l \ri \ r r\rrrr,,,,rr< , ,. rr, f

,;l.,ll:11 ,ii:;l;lll,,';ll;11,,i1,,,1.,;,,, .,,,,i i:,,,.,,.\,,.ii,r t F' -i. lVltrltirrnrtrr,i I r,

R4

Fi r,,,,,,;;;."'i.',','ii.',1";; t( ,( r,,,, , iI- !, ur,,.r_i,, i,,,i;l,ll l l,l;l;";1, ,;,l.ll,: ,,, r r , \1r r .111.. . J. ltrrr.ll .,\rrr,ur)

\i,r,.., tr,...1., .:i,,', r \ irrrrr.,rr,,t,, j,rr $ r''c trs('(l"ll (^sl)( )r I (1'r I I s

Llt-l I t tlr. r-l-rJ-( \-l.l!l]-lr-c,-.1 (, ffi rr cirrrr a-r! r it r ".,,..,'-'l'lrtl tlir:trtislr,,,ti tiith t j,,,rr,,g,,".1 .t i

.r.rtcrr rN.,tt,, 1.. .],agrrrt,rrt r._rissctl ir ffi ts tirc Ir.rr..r,-, .,1," iits \S I(ariiriri. iir ..c.iril ,r,,,., ,, .#;. trse \r,.i(r.!.;7.._100-s j't0-5/20()5' li lsllr! ::.. :,:.," oul 0l:l lrllis

Srr'''' 1'.' \ No. I 'l 111'111.2q'lr .\ ,trrer s. c.rrr.ir,tirrg llre licr.trsr-tl -.1 \olts [/,.\; ]-lol-i.9 ( ( l\\ .\ei /()rr7 .,,,,1 :ic,lctlLr.(l

# it [c],, ()/. ir,(lr.l-.(),, ':'rrrt cri,rir.r rurir-r.' r'r'l ,r,r.i.tl, tir.. .,\lltlicrrrrr to s,lii,l. l.

,et.el1, Iile llrc rr.li\ llrrrt tlri.- r'rr,.rc l :.\e(i to c.ll f1.1 1r c,aLrrl ,*r),bt .l.rir(,1,j.1i r.it\e \lr). i6&.);r./10,j Stirrr, .r- :.r: li..rrr \,,is.ltrlrlrz.,h.! tlit, l.,l,..cri \l).,!l.rt !(),rl ( \S i l.,ltrlrclti, -- ,tt:ibl_t, arrtl ltlicr. ,,..r.Lrs.rl crtlti,t,-...., llt,, r,!,Jr\;\l r,l .!.lilr.,cc Itl t]tc I.csl)iit)(l(./tL

N .

^y.-trcs lW, Cri-. ?*, , Ct+l^. AU^*-,{

l't t

HICFI COUR,I- OF SINDI] A1- I(AITACI II

Y

Clirrrin.rl Al)pcnl N().?70 o1' 20I l, C'r'inrinal Appe al No.J7l ul ?01..1.

l)r t'scr r i:

,\lt. ItrsliLr.' ,\lolnurutrrltl lirtrittr li,lt u l\S!lt!

!It'. ItlsI iIt: / Ui!l/rr..llr:sr/,rsr

r\ppcllant j,rltarrzr'1, l..lr,tn (,,;/r). ,/,tlty ',lr.rlr lltr,rtiillr \'li \lLrlr.rrrril].r.l \.r.(' r),,\./,r(1.,;\tlIoL.rit'.

Ilt'sprrrnrlen t; llr., Iit.rtc tIrr,rrr1,,Ir \Il I l.rLril, ,,\lrrrrctl.

'.1rlt i.rI I'rLrsrr Lrl,,r '\Nl

( r'1. l{cvisiort i\p1rli,..rtiort No.25Ll o[ 2012

,\1,1r1r..1,,1,'',1.,,, I I r r t , r r i I r i\ I r ll.Ll,il, \lrrrrr'.1 ''1,,'. i.rl l'r,,',., Lrtttr \\l

I

L

IiL's pt r11111'1, it l,rlr,rirztl, l..lr.rrr .rrr,i (ilrLrl.rur ,'\lr llrrrrtrlilr \lr' NI Lrlr.trrrrrr.r,l \'.r.,('('n,'\1.r(1,,\rl r rr..rtL'

l)att,of hcaling: I 9.05.2020 anrl 2t).05.2020.

l)att,rrf Ar rnorr rrcr,nrr,nt 2 e.05.2020.

I U l) (; N'l l, N'l

NI()llAN'lN'IAI) l(r\ltli\l l(ll,\\ .'\(;l I ,\, l:- ,f., r.L'tl l.rl,. rr,, l, l,li.rtr ''. L, Zahir Slr.rlr r.r'.rs ttir.'rl [r1' lr'.rrrrctl luLlr', ',1,LLi.rl ('r)trrt-l (( r)]1tr()l \,1 \l.riLotit 5rtLrst,tttcr-,s), i(,tr.rrlri irr Spr'ti.tl (.rst' \r,. lt, rrl l{)(}'i ,rLrstrrl' r,tti ,)f L rllrLt' No.t),1/20t)5 ,urrl 5p('ci.rl L.tst Nrr 5)',/ -lL)0 r .rlisirrll ottt rri L lirttt' No.(l:7'-'i)05 Lr,/;

b/!)G) t)i ( rrtttt,.rl ot N.tteolitr L,trl)\t.rrr(r' r\at, l()(ii lr'l',i:tt'tttl .rt l''' r\Nl-Gulsltirn-L'-lt;b.rl, Kara,.lri. 1\ll('r tri.rl viilt: jr-r,.lritrrt'rtt r.latt',.] lfi 0;'l{)l-r tlr(' appcllattf IalraL-rzt'[, l(lt,trt li,/Lr. ZalLil filr.rlr \\.1-\ (()]1\'itlr'(j ,tlltl 5('rrt!'li( L'(i t() sllll('l tltL, it,lnt ol Il.l. Irc lr.tr1 alrr'.rtjt ulr!i!tr,,on(, .r' 1,11'] llL'rrr'lit ,,1 ',t't-ti,rrt it-r-li ol (lr'.['.(. rr,.rs als., Irrl,rr t,rlr'r]tlt'Ll ttr ll1L .1|1,1 11.1111

? Ilcirri,, Jlll,,ri('\'('(1 ,rrrrl tlr:saiisliL'.1 I't' l l , ' . r t 1,.r',.t'.1 ['r lL'Jrri('(l lir!ll'!' r jLt 1 r

ttr t 'r

S|iri.rl (rrrrrt-1, ( \!S, l'.,rr.t, lli tltr'.rl()r('-\.rirl .rl)l)r'ill ll.r\ i,,'L'rr l,t,-'1,'rlL'.i L't' tlrt' .rppt'liant, ivlril,.' tlrr' r\.N.l lras Iilr'.1 tlrL' ( tirltttr.il I(,.'i t',t,rtr .'\pplrt.rtit'ir No.25.l/2()12 i()r eItll:Itt(.r'lrlr'rIt rrf sL'ltt!'ll.t'nll;ljll5t tllc oltit't tti tlr(' lri(lfi( :;[\'t i.rl

t2l

(OLrIt-1, ( NS, l(. .aL'hi ri,rtt.i l,\.(li.l()l-l in r.. sPrr.l ()l lir,\Pr) (1r,nl\ l,rlr. r./(,1, l..lr,rll ,ttttl (,ltulattt ,,\li l,rrtlr ol rlltor rr Ir.rr c l,r,t,rr :t r.i ci1 rroti.,., !)t t lrr, \.r rr(, .1. Ihe lrticl fatts ol t]rc Irrost,trrtit)n ((r.,r, !u'(, tlrirt tlit, r\Nl Io]J1.., Ir,,atlcLl 1,1 Itrspr.rl'1s1 lth.tn1,,ir ol l'li ;\Nlr-1, K,ir.rtlri 1rr \lr\' ill()r1L.itir)p, .i l) l)r.r,lrg1(l(,rl tl1, decustrl frt'tsrrns rrarl]r-,lt Jehanzeb I(lran :,,/,,,/.rltir' 'ilt.rlr, ltllr.irl ,,\l)tr,r,lt :,,/'(,. ,\trtt't'ttutirlin, Cltrrl;rnr Ali !,,i o. ,'\lirlt.l ll.rrrr,.rrri r,,'lrilc tlrLt, u'(,r(, !iri\ illl,, folir:th('r iLl tll(,(.lr L,t,.rrinii I.I,i1t. l.!r'..\(,\.ll[-' .rrr.l .r.,r tL,:rr]r ll lltt, sL,,rrrlr lltt'tt,oi,strult.el ()ut()l it\ tr urrL tlrr.r.,r, l\l',rLl).r1\ irrllrrl ,0 i,.r( 1..,t.,,1 lr,,o.,l.rt,., L,r .lt.tts o1 I liti. t,.rtlr, tltrrs trrt.tllrr,, ll() l..rt l1t,',.rtlsi,(l tlr( rIrIIrit'.rrL,I sr,1.,,..1 tltt'ttitrcttlir's.rtt,.1 tltr,.ar nl()l1,t,li(l LtIl(1(,r'.1 ll!,1]l(, l)lr,],.r1(,rl ti sirtlr ('llr,rt,rrr ilr(' sl)r)t thcrr,()l ()n 2b.(15.1()()';,rl ()r)'15 lr()!u\, lr|lLrrt,ilr( olliri,rl rrr.rslrir' rr.rrrrL'lr lli Jaiial NaLlinr.rntl I'(l I)irrr.t.z !ih.rh. llrL.,l.rslrt,,,.rr.l t,i ilrt,.,rr rr,rs loLrnel i,, lr,rr',., Lr.rtit.liller,l .t tltlcLtnrL,n1 slitru.irrll tltt' :,rrrri'.r: l,,. irri,, ()n r'('1li ir lrr\ L)uf {)l rrnI l(r.'lt.rrr r\tttr'r,tt s0tt ()l ,\lltL'L,rtLlLlllilt. s() r,,i\ r,rt [,\ it' ,,\"\'ttr,r' rr.rtrrr.lt I(.rslri.l ,.\li :,.,rr, I Nlttlr,trnttratl Yt:us.rl tr,lro lr,itl oL'l.rirrLLl IIr( .,.iLrr,,()rr It,.rsirrl lrt,nr tlr,'1,,.,,1 lt'.rsttn,, litrtt lltt'r\NI olliri.rls \)n \(lu(lr,,l tlrl l,LrslrL,,l llrr LLrll'ijls,il()1,'.rr(l \i(ur('(l tltt'it tr.'s|t'tlirr'lr('l(|llllirl,,\ rrnritr tlr, \(rllrl ll\rt!,.rtr.l l(it tLr, lr i,l.r.,'l{)i lllrrl p0lirt,st.ttiLrtr.ll()r('sJi(l trlr.'t,.'tlrr'.Ltzirtr,,,r11irr.'t rl.rllcLl .ilJ()\('lr1,l\tr't((l tllt lIl( No.() r/ 2()():r lr)r tll(' ()llerl( L' ()l \e( ti!)rr D I ., ' tlll(lr'l r('! lir)rl ')(. ) t,i tlrt' ( N', rLI t r t I r,rI rIt

/\rl, lt)97.rr..rir1st tlrr' errlplitr I in rrlrtlr. r ir.. lLr.lirt;,, tlrr' .t1:;rrt Ir,'tr11t'cI p,'r',,rt. .il()r!':j,li(1 ,rnLl tlttir assrrt i.rtc rrattr,.'lr liclr,rr .\rnt,. rt .rn,.l llt!'lr l)('!,.ln t(, il\'('\l !,.1t.' tltr.'s,tutr'. l)rrIirtg tltt,!ouIS('r)l ittv(stit,.rti0r t ,,tL lltt's.ttltt' .l.lr ott .lt', l(rstll('Il tll\' itccr.rst,tt pr.r'sotts, lrc lut ntcil .r r.lirlilrf,, l).u t\ ,lll(t lc',tL Itt.i t]r.' llrLtsr' [,t'.rtitt11 \,r l ) Il:till, situ.rtr'ri in ll.rrrgilr,rlitt (,oili, Iilorl. ij. I ll ;\r'r'.r, i'..rt.rtlti ,,tr I ( i i t . i ( t I ()l rl,,' , ) r r i )

.tar'rtsl'tl t!lr,, ,.trtscri iltt' rl(r()l ilrr'r\''rl L', l,r' Itt,i.lr' ()l)L'lr ll(rlrl tti't.1,' Irr lllt tt ,tssrrr'i.rtc n,rnrclr \lLrlr.rrrtlt.rtl Il.t.,il '.i,' ( lr.rl..)r, l.tltt ittst'rt.',.1 .ts.t,., Lr..'tl itrtltu llt.litL'r i|t ltanri. llr.'r ('lliL'r('(l l l t ' l ( tLrLrl :(rlrl'('Ll ,)Llt ',1 tlrt lrL'.r1' \rl ill( \Irl . L ' .rtlL

l lrir.'r L' r.lotlts, rt.rr(()li(5 (,i lil\( ri.rtrrrl lrLirri' I't'IL itt Lr.rr]. -'l ii, rtLtrtt['.t ,.,. lt r'.rrryinll Jl.) |.111iq,1' c\L(,1,I r,r)c rvlri,.lr r..rrli.',.1 ,ti ],,r,.Lt't'.,',r, lr trli)'lritrt', r,tit'1".', l,L'inli sla[,s trvo itr rrrirrrlrt,r', irrialinl:, fi:-,(l l',11 llrt ()tii(!'l .llli]st('rl llLe .lt.it:.'.{ ptrs(,lls in tlrt illst,lnt rriill('.llId s('i1c(l s({l{rr'(t tltt' ttattrrtt,5 tlrlLlt'r tL'.ll L()\t'l' Iltrl(l the n)r'n]() Pr('P.rr('(l t() stt(h cli('al !)ll \ti(ll sP()t. lllt't r'.ttlt,-'to tlLt' Pt'li,'.' st.ttiorr r'vht'tr' thc oifiit'r' .rlttt'trititl l('gist(r'r-'(1 .r11otl]('r Illi ['t'.rIirr1', \t'()-l;'](){)r .lll.lill5t all tll,.' atcttsr''rl pL'ls()ll5 nt()r('!nitl lLrt tlrL't'illle oll('ll(("lntl l't'11'ttt tt' irrvt,sligatr., llt,., s.rrrr,., t(r(). Il(, lL'a()r(i('.1 tll!' \ t . I I . ' I I ( 'j ) t s rrl tltL' \\'itll('\s('5 .lrltl

I

tiisP.lig[1gi.1 tlrt ir.inrt, l)t()l)(,lt\ irr ttrto !t lr,rllr tlrL . t]t(,\.i!(,1 !\rll(1. l() tll('( \l)('1 t

t3

for tt'st antl Ieptrlt I It, crrnrPlr,tt,el tii( irtr'r'stiri.ttirrn.tt](l ]LlLrrlIItl('(i tt!| r'lr.ttr',t' sll(\'ts alininsi lh,.'L rrlIr'its ,llr)r!,s.tirl .lrorlinll lrrl rrl llrt'rrr ri,urt{ l\ Ii,'lr.ln ,\lr('r'l

Y

S/o. Atttgt'r tu ritl in JlrsrL!rtlirrri tor tti,tl l,r tlLr' (()ltll ,l(((,1 t{llll',1\ llrt t,,LttI Ir.rvirrrl rl,.',-l,tli,Ll ih(,.tb5L()lt(lillp, ()lrl l)llral,rirn(,!i ()ll('n(l(,r .ur.l l r , r 1 . r I I r, . t r r 1 . r t .

( I [\)llr tlrL'c,ists, lr.urti'ii ,. lt.tti,,r,r,l lrrrtlt tltr,rrinlr'\ l(,ii! Lll('r .rll.llnsi llr('.rr( u\r'(l l)('r'\(,lrr on tlrt,factr,tfot,s.rlrl l,r tlltli'lt tlrL,t';,1,,.r.1.r1 rrtrt littiltt .rrrLl ,l,rirrr,',.1 tri.rl.

,1. Tir prLrvc its r'itst' tltc Iros,.'tLtlir.rtt t'ratltittlr.l ()j IttrrL't tttiott rr ittl,.'ssr.'s .ttrrl t'xhibiterl vari()rrs elottllrrt'rrt5 i:lr](l ()tlrer it(,llrs antl tlrr.'t,.',t .'t tlr(, sirlt' L,l tliL Prost'ctttiottrvasr'lttsctl.'llrt'slrttt'tttt'tttrrl [1iL'.tt,.tnt'rl i]('l'tr)ll \v.ls t,'rot,.1..1 it,/s 34? ( r.P.C iri whitlr ltt rli'ttiL'il tltt'.illr:1i.rtit,rr',.rr',.tirrst ltittt ll.'.li.i rr,,t ( \.irrrirrt' Ititttself on rr.ttlr ot c.tll ,ttt1 tr'itrtr'',' itt 't11,1,.,r1 ,,1 lrrs ({('l\'rr\('(.rs!'

l. Lt,.rt.rrt,tl Sl,t'Li.rl t ()Lrrt'l (( \',)l\.)r.r, ltt .,tt,'r'h..ttitrtl llri'1,.'.tt'rtL'tl .,,tttr'. 1 Iot tlrt' paltits .ttttl .tsst'ssrttcttt ol t'viLlLrr,t .rr,ril,tLll. t,tt ttlot-rl, r'Lt1t' jrrti;',rrr. rrt I (l.tt('(l 18.()7.201?.tttl\ittr'rl .rrLl s!rri('rr(('(l I ' 1 .rs.l,ttr.',.1 .rlr.rr L', lt,'tt, t' I rt .r

I I r,' I I , I ; 1

this appeal lt.rs Lrt't'n li1c,.l lrr, tlre,t;tpr:ll.tttt,lil,lrllst llis ( ()llv i( ti()rr -l-lrt'l'ltts oi tltt'(J5t"rs \\'('ll {r' 't: t'r i..l''tt''t' l)torlttrr'LI Irt'l'rrt'tltt tti'rl '"'trt litttl atl tl,rIrotat('l]l('llti()rl itt tllL' jttti1'.rrtltIt tl.rtt'.1 l8l). illll1r.r:".'Ll lrt tlr,.' Lri'rl rorttl ,tttrl, ilit'rllotr', Ilrr' :,rtttl ttt.l\ llol 1,,' l,'1rr',,.11r,,',.1 lt,'t,' t,r.t: to .tt'ot'.i r I Lr

I

rI r r .rt ir rr r . rI )r I Lllrr\ r'\\,rt\ r\ Jrr'lilt,, I

;:. Lr,.iln!,(l .ottttst'l lLrt tIIt .r1r1rL'II.rIrI lr.i: L , t t t ' t I t i r. t I llr.rt rr'i(lr lr'r',.rr(l t(' tlr(' r r.

(Lll .lsl)('ti ul tltr.'r-.tsr.'tliL't, is ttt, L'i jLl.'tlrL Ilr.lt lr,' rl'.i' tlL,',,r'rr, r rri llt,'L,rr .rlrtl tltcrr.:lort, Ir()tlrirli,, t() lirtl' ltirir tLr titt' l.tr,,r'r lt'tl1it ot tltL tl,ttrrrlitr !vlrr!lr \\\'rt' seizrrl fr()t)r Ilrr.'c.tt ,rntl t]t.tl tltctt'1'1',r\.t \ i\rl.rti()rlr)l 5. 101( I l'( \\'itlr ('i',,trLI t'' the seizurL: ()l tt.tra()tic:i Jt tlte ]lr)tls(' tltr'ti' ir,rs ll() ('\ itl('ll(r' tll.rt llir'.rPprt'll.rrrt orvtL'tl th,.'hoLtsc, llt.rt ()llrr'.rtiilill tllt'ir tr',ts.r ri()[ilti()ll ol 'i.l(].i ('r I'(, tlr'it ilrt' .tIr.ival e'ntty tor thr policc r(,.lChiltC llrt,hottsr,\\,ils llot Lrl()(itla(rel, tll.tt tllt';roiitt' h1,.1 no leg.rl authorit)'ttr sr'atrlt tllt lirrlrs,.', tll.it tltL'tlalrtrtii: l'('('()\irll'(l ItL'tlt tltL hottst'hltl ttotltittri lrr,-lrr rvirlr tllt'.r[1rtll.rrrl, tlr.rl tllt' t.tItIII.titt,tttt tr'.i: 'li'. tlit' l(),.rrrcl tlr.rl. tht't't' ltatl L)t('Ll !',1()5s itt',.'g,itl,tttiir's l11 tl11' P1rl11.' ill ((rlr!iL{\'tilrf', tll( ittvt'sligatiotr .ttt,.i tllLts llri' 4p1,1'11.1111 .lr,.,Lrl,l Lrt' attltLttlL'LI oi tlr' tll'trll'' l'\ ('\t('rtrlintl lrirtr tltr' bt'tli'lil r)l tll(' (l()tll)t,rllrl lll lll('.tllt'r'tr.tiir'' il tIrt' 'i1I111 'rI I' rtisrrrisst'rl b! thi: ctturt tlrt,rc i: Io r,t irlr,ttr-t' l,r jLr'tLll tlr( L I I . I I . r ' I I t I I (tl I I I I L s('lltrlrce ilr rcsp!'ct ()l eitht'r l('sp()lld(lIts lt'll;ittz,.'[' ot Cltttl,ttn A]i atttl ar 5tlch illu

I '.,, i I.rl

criurirlal r(,vision Iile(l Lrv thc ANlr slroLrltl Irl elisrrrissctl. ln sul][)(rrt ot Iriii contcntions hr: placetl Ieliancc on l{hurshet,rl l(h,rn v.'lhe St.ite (3t)l) l' Cr l.l 1"151), Zafar Iqbal v.'fhe State ancl others (2011 YLI< 59li) Mst. l(azi.r llult.rrra v.

The State and another (2019:iCI\41( 1300) l(izwan Ahnecl (lrrrt,shi aurl others v. The State and others (Pt.l) 2(,17 Sirdh t;'.,'1.1, IVIrrhanrruatl Alshad llrrssain alias Gtrl l(han v. l'hc Statr' (?(n2 YI-t< l(r.1()), Anrc€r' Zeb v. 'l he !itate (l'l.l) ?0lJ Suprt'nre L'oLr|t fll30), 'I hc Statc tlrr()uy,lr l)eputv At t(,r'lrr.y -(-ierrer.rl v. Muh.rrnllr.rrl Sicltliilrre (ltt()tr 5(lvlli Ilr,), 'l lr(, (it.rte th|otrglr l{cg,iorral l)ileetor' AN!- v. lDr;rm llakhsh.rnd others (l()18 !('\'lli lt)l'.)) .rnrl Bonif.rcio A. llr.rlayag v,'f l.rt, St;rte ( I'l-l ) I 99 I Su [rLt'urt' ('or: r't')85).

()rr tlte Lrtltr't hart.l 1,.'.rln.'.1 'ip.ri.rl l'rr,',,', tttot \trl,l)\,r {,\l

6.'\NI lt.rr lrtllt' tltL' intprurlr,.'Ll jtr,.1y,,rrrt,nt in t(nl\ (,i ils lirt,iitri', tr, i',trtlt Il\' l1{r\\(\r'r lr,l', r'rrtttertr.lt-r.l llrlt tlrc tri.rl (()rrrt lr.ls t'r'r',,rrcoLr'1\ l\rt r'()n\ i. li'tl tlrr' .i1r1rt'll.rrrt .rrr.1 Ilr(' r(':ip()rr(l('rtt (]lttrl,itrt l\li iLtltlL't ',.(ri ') ", ( N',.'\(t l9'),".r: tltt' Ptoslt tttit,tr Ir.t: I Pl(,\'('al it5 (.i\('L)('\\)D(l .l |t'.ls()tt.ltrl(''l',Ltl,t rtL lr':l]('(t {rl tlris trllt'rr,r'.11'.lill\t tll(' aPPt'll.rrtt .tntl tlti' tt'sPort.lt'itl. lt'll.itt,,t'lr ,tirti (,lrttl.ttlt ,\lt .ilt.{ .r', :Lt, lr i't'tlL tll'. tr s('nl(naL's sltl,ttlrl Lrr' ('ltl),lltaL (l ttr.itli.'t .l,.rtlr,rr lilL i t t I r ', , I t t t r t I l'Lll''tl.llll li r r i r t ' t

9', ( N!,.\Ll l()tl,'.t\ llr(,ri,\\)\(,r\'()i r.t|\\,li(\ !\,r5 L,.t,,rr.l l(t l\r' .rli(l r!lil, lr i' tltt't,ttly s.ttlr"trtL'.rv,ril.rlrl.'rlrr\lt r tlr\'l.trr lrrl'.trt,. ttl.tt Irt L'rrIIIIII(ir(I|rI tll'lt llr( ,rppr'll.rnt rr.,ts tht rllivct ot tltc r t'ltir l,'.rrr.l tll, l\'liirt'lr.r.l ,rr.ltt.tl l.rtLrrllt'tli't ,rl llLr' llJr'('r,lic5, tlr.rt tht'rr.tt,.,rtit", (tlr.rr',rs) w(r!'r\'\\,\'('r((l orr ilrt :1rrrl IrLrrrr (lr.'tliLl.i ,,r tll('(,ll \\,lti(lt rt',.'t't's.'alt',,1 ()lt Il]('\l)!,t .rlr(1 !\\'i]llr!'(l l:t() l'.(, '.rlltl ilr('rl '.lt'.'tltit.rl ttst I)rov('(l Ptrsitit'r-'rvltcrt',ts lt':'l)olr!l('lrt (,lrLri,itrt Ali u.rs.r |.1s5('ril),1'r irt LltL "rr' \\/ith L't,!lar(l t() tho t('(\)\'r'r)'trl lltt'ttattoti.s.t[ [l]t'li()Ll5( .,1 lt'lr.lrrzL'L's lrit'rltl tlll\ \!.1\ lll(l!i('otl tlit' r i t t ' t I r 'rl tlrr''r||r'li'lrri 'rll(l r ('s l)i il ({('ll t ( 'lltll'irtl ''\li it'lr|r'' I r r r i

r )

fi-r(t l..1is ol ,. lt.tr'.t: \\.ls l'(.r'o\(r|Ll irltt, lt tr, t,''rrlrlr'rt i'r \l l)\)\ltt\'(' tlrL'rlri.,rl l,'.t .ttt,.l .ts srtrli tltL, Irrr,'r'. tltr()ll ll.lrl |1,,r,'rl rl' r,ls!' L)!'\ \rLl!l .r l(.r',,'rt.rl'l( rlILtlrt r.rn(itr S.b,/9 (a) (-NS r\rt l!)'l7,tttti ,t'.tttlt Lrotll tltL' \,ltIrr(t'\ l,rr rr ltt, lt tlrL' ,rpp.'ll.rni,lll(l r('\Jr()llrltlll L,ilttl.lrrr i\lr \\r'l'L't t'l)\ i!t('rl rltuttl't ir,.' (ll'illg('tl tt) tlr'lt rurttlL't S.(r,/ (.) (() ( NS ,'\r'l l9(ll .rtlcl llrit'r r( rrl|,rr\( ! i tllt.ttr|.i'.1 i't'rrLIiitIiIt ti) t'itlr('r Iiit' itlprisottlnt'll f ()l (lcath as tltt'st !\'('r(' ill(' ,rtrlt sL'tltt'trtcs 'ii"ril'tlrll.' lt't 'r .()ltVictioll Ltrrtltr fi.ir/9 (c) uN5,'\ct l(l()','- Lttlrlr.'t tltt'larr' .iLlLi \rr((' tlr\'i)r()-c('t trti!)rr it.trl 1,rov.'tl its cas,.'bcr',.rtr,'l .l rL',t5oll,tl)lr'Ll,'ttl't tliltli't :' lr,/(l it ) I N" \'t l()'t': tlrt' .r1-rPr:.rl sh,rLrltl Lrr, ,.lisnrissL,tl ,lti!l tlt!, s(,ntL,ll((,\ rrl Lrollt tlrc tLrIrrtttlt'ttt" Ir.'

!,11ll.ulcc(l lo citlrt,r. litt,ir.1,rist)r.rrIt,llt (,i rl\,,ltlt. lrt:uP1r,rIt r,t lti', t()tttt'ttttott., lit plat,r:rl rt lianct, 0 Nazif she hzad .rnd othe rs v.

'Ihe statr-' (1u09 sc lvlli l+-li)1,

l's \-

Mir Muhanrrnacl v.'l'he State (1995 !;(,Nlli {,ll), State tlrrough l)irector ANlr Peshawar v, l'-akhar Zaman (2019 SCMI( tl?l), State throttgh l{egit-rnal Ifilector ANIr Pesh;rw.rr v. Sohail l(han (2()1(./ 5( \'ll( l166), St;rte througll Dilectol ANli Pesh.rwar v. Muhatntrrarl llatnz,rtr atltl tttht'rs (1019 !( Nll( l -)()ll) .rrle l l'astree ttt .f ;rl.rl v. Deputy Director ANF;rnd othtrs (l()lt) ';t N'lli l5l).

(j W'r'harc Itr'.tILl tll('.trilLInl('rt1-{ rri tlrr lt'.rttl|tl (()Llll:(l l\)r'tlr('}'.irli.s, il'rtr\' tl 'orrglr tlrt, r,ntirr, ,.'r,itlt,rr,.t, lr'lri. lt lr,is l,t','it tr'.t,.i irLrt lrt tlr,' , r I i r t , tlrt'.r I ' .rr

itrpLulnt'ri jtttlr,,trt'rtt rYith tlrt'ir ,tbl.'assjst.ttl,t'Jlt!l ll.l\ ('corr:i,lt't.'tl tlr(' IIl!'\.llrl lar,r' incltrrlirrg,, th.rt (-ih,rl at ilr., b.Lt.

l() !\'t' .rt t]tt' ()ut',r'l liri(l tlr.it tlr. ( tttrtltr,rl lit'i irrtrr, lrl,'Ll l'l tlrr' .\ti'l is trtaittl,ritt.tlrle PUrsil,lll to tlri' r.r:r.' L,i 'l lrr' (,tatt' \' lllst l'au t't'l.rt lritri (l'l lJ 'Lll j lit' lrrl), tlr,rt tlris LrrLrtl lr,rs tlr( l)r)\\'r r trr,It.rrIr', rrIIr'ItrL': I.'r irlri, l i r l l l .rr .r ) )( ' l . rr rt is Ltrtrt.j,,it'.I l()l Lrlr(l('t ', -l-) I ( I l't Ir,,rr.l,il lr,'lr.rtl rrt,ti,. L,l llr. s.rtrrr'llLlrrtrl',lr tlrt'Llrar';,,r'tvlrirlr lr,.'tli.l irr tlrrs L.t:{', llr.rt t,,)tl' tlr| lilli'r..rrr trt lritrl t''r'.'llr.'r ,r'' LltL'5' lrtrttr.r l).1)t ()i tltt's.ttlrr tt.tlrs.tttltrtt ,)lL Ill('\'llll('tl.rr .it 1'.'t '' )]l ( t l't 'irrLl llr.rt tlris rrrtttt itl its r-listtt'lirrtt lt.ls tllt'lrtrtrt't t(,('1lil.llr(t'\r'rLl('rr\('\it tlr''r 'rt' tt''t itt acr.'ortl.ttrt,.'tYitlt larr' ,15 l,t'r llr('..r\r' (,1 A[]drrl lVlalili !' llrc !'talt'1l't l) -'t){)tr s( t(r5)

ll Altt'r (rllf 11'|Lls!('s\l)l!'lll \)l rll\' (\l(1!li.( \\(' .rl'r' ,jl tlL,' rt''iv tlr'it tlr'' I)l-o:,e( uti(rll ll.t. lrt,,r ('(l ils !,rs( l'.'r,,rt.l .r t,..,','rL'rL'1.'.lt'ttl't ,rl','rirl't t I ' ' r I r r'

I 1

' I I ' 11 1I

l()r' tll(' ()ft('tis(' tt,/ \ (),i'!) ,1, ( \:, .\, t l(l(),' lL )1 tlr\' l\ rll\)w llllr, lt'.r\(|rr\ (.rl llrr' Iill('' \\'r'n' l(r(li',('rl \\ itl, I I , i I I I i i t ( ! ' )',r\ irr|', rr( '} lirrr!'

I

r I I

I()t,.irtirtreti tt .rll(l ill('',.ll,l \t.ll\'ltrL'llt5 (rl tll( l'\\'5 \\('l(' rt'rrtttitrl [)f(rtll[)liY tr'ltit-lr lr.'tt rrrrl 'ii'riiiit.riltlt llrll)r\r\r'(l r-rP(,n Lrl, irny I'\\i,rt tlr! tirrrr',,1 ilrr irlii Ir'i.lt'ir,t' lr tlrt','\\l pt,licL' lrari \\irltt('(l t() l,rlr.:lf irrrlrli,.rtt' iltt ,rl'1't ll.rrrt lltL'ri tltt,tt,r.r,its I.l{r lt(,(,(1 l() 9l.ll\(,.1 se(()Ll(1 f!,1'()\'(,1 \'.tt a litrLtrr' as tlrr-, Prrlitt' lt ci ,tlrt'.iilt s('( tllt'(i .r \t'r\ I'lri',(' l('r()\'('l\ r'l t);u.Cl)ti(5lrorrr tltt,(nt \\,ltiall IIrr,.rP1,LII.tIIt rt,ts tltir ittl', ,rlt,l tlrrrr lr'rrrrlrl lr()t ll.i!(' irt,tltlt.'Ll it itlr t.ll.irrri tlt, tLttr'' .ttt''l t'ilo|t trr 'la1iL' .t I,llrt' ,'r.',,,t. 11 ,,1 ,1 llL'tl'r.'

(lr1 It is s|ttlt'.I lr\ tlt,tr (lr.tl tlr('L\' 5 rl() t''':lttt trrrtt r'tt lllt' (()lllPlail).lllt lrt'ittrl tllt' l() I'r"' i'l'''l Ilr'lt rr() 'rliirrr()\it\ ()r ('rrrlit\ is.rl),'1ir'J.rri.iirrst lttrlr l'r llt,'.r(\tl:'('!l 'rri'l Il!'riL' lr'r\ bt't'tt.tllc!it'ti itt tltis,.a>t' ltr tlri: r'r':'1'L'1 1 tt'li'itltt ir l)l'rtt''l 'rtL Zafar'\/ St.rtt'(l()()N S( \lli l:) ' 1)

(a)lll.lt th('rll 1('sl dllti IL'ttr\('l\ \\.lt lll.l(lt rrtl tlt'.' s|'rl 'ltlti

l'('I i6l

tlre apgrr'll;1111 \\'rr5 (.rtrllllt li'rl Ir.trrtlL,.l iiitlr tlr.,rr.rrtt,iit: lri lltt' polict, w'lrilrl tllivirrli tlrl r L,lrrt l(,,rrr11 (,\!,tl tlir,,rl t,r llt,,. tltt'scent, \\'lt()sr,(,\,i(1r,1la('trrilv c,rlr,,lr,,r'.rtr,r r.trlr otlrr,r' rn .rlj Itl.ttefiill lr'sl)('(t\ (l\ r'r,t'll .rs tlr,,Irrrsr,tutiort i,rst,. lt is ,,r.,ll scttlt,tl b1,n()!v tll.lt tlre rrielL,rrt,.,ol .t Plrljr;g lvitnt,r> i:.rs leliaLrle .rs rtrrv other !\'itn(,ss Prr)\'i(lr,.l th.rt tro rnllljl\,, (,\ist5 Lrttrvet'tt tltcttt.ttr,,l Ilrt atr'Lrsr',.1 .rrirl irr this (.i\(' lr() (,]lnlit\ It.rs [rt'etr stll]llr'sit'Ll .tijain\t ,ur\ r,l tlrL' polii.r' l'lV .. .rnrl ,r' :ttr.lt tltr, Irolitl lt.rri ll(r I . \ ( I r t \ , I I I I I , \ . I t (, llrr, .r1,1,r,11.1111 11,.'

(, I ) L I

l.tlst' r,rsL'. lltir. ri., lrr,lrlr t llrL |rrl111' r.'1 iLlL'rt, rr lrrr Ir r: rottobrrt.r(ii,., irL ,rll rrr,riLri.rL rcsl',,.ts rr'lr,tlr irLr lrrtlL.r Ilrt, .iP;rt'll.irrt Irt'inrr, llrr' .lrir'.'r r,1 tlrr' ,.,r' trlrr, ,rttL rrr1't.'ri ll r':t.tPr.' ltUItt tlr(, s(\,n(, r!lr,,tr ilr, \.rr \\'.l stoyr1r1,sl Ir1 11q,, l)()ll..(,.lllrl tlri r,.,,r,t t,r t rrl tltt l.Lt\,,t1\\ Itrrrrr tltL,.lill,i ,,1 tlr., t,rt I(r'lr.tnr! ir1 (ll|\ I(,\l)(1 lr., t,l.rLLtt 0r Nlrr.,lrt.r,,l r\lrrrrc,.l \/ 'llrr,'5tatc (10-10:,( \ll{-1,'11 rrlrlrL.rl rr.rr lr,,l.l lr in.1l(,l.rl P(rrt.l5 u nLl(,r nt Pt11,i.l;

" I)ntstr ttlttttt ( r/5r' l5 /t///!r'i/ ui\)u lltt 5lttlt'tlit!l\ t'l Attlltlt !\1tt5L)L)!1, /';1 ii']l\' .') tut,l \l't,l lltts:;,rtt,. ).;L ,.

l1')l'V ir; l,,,llrr Ltlli, itl.; rtl li. !iL 1'111,11,. tlkv tltr r\tl \t(rt lo ltttt, tttt ri.\(, /{, S/t/111 tt,,,Ittt.'l lltL' lt,ltl!ttth,l I itrltrLc'yltl ttl tr ptrl'lic l)lar 'lttntt:l rottltttL' 5t'ttIt11. ( ottlntlttttrl, tt /\ilJttl)lt' Ii ,tltit ll[]1, tutttLttl bt' ltrt',ltltl lL,r:!Ltl !it lrrbt i' ttlL ti .ttti,, t ii,r''i,'. lltttl lt)\t. tt:tlltt)ll tut I t!l)lttu'rl 1t'11"\ttt ,' lttl, littttt,liIt,1 t'tjlttlltt' l',,llt tit, rli/rr,.'r" ttttt,!ltttti 1111,t71,'.'l1t11l i |ttsir/r'tt1 ,0tl 't,t!litl"1t., rt,l)!t!1it.t tlrtl ,6 \utlt ttttt lt tt iir'l tltt'tt tt,tllkt!tl i tit'ultt

(tl)llr,rl tlrr.' :1,1 ltt1111 111.lli(,1 .rl,(,ttt tlrl t,tt itr, ltt.ltrttl lt' t'r'1,,irlrirti,rtt ul [\'r, ilrL l.r,i tlr,rt iirr ,rl}[r'll,rrt tr',,Ltl,l 1,,.' .ilirirti', Ll .rttrl t l , r , t l t . i t rrt,ir/,1 t.rl.t t ir llv rr)1 t\,1)(,r,rt('5 tlrc t ,. r t

[)r()s(\'llfl()ll ('.ltr,silr((' tlris i: llrL'(.ll lli \\rlli( ll tllt ,rP1,t']1.1111 lv.t: tlt'iVinr,,, s{()PI)('(i ,Urrl ,rtt'r':,t(,ri iYlrilst l)r{)(r('(lilli',,ll tli', tltt irtitlt rrtt'tl tottit' ,tnrl tl)e rl.lt!\)li!J .li.r't,r'.'te,.l rvltit'lt tr',r: |e(()\'('r'L]tl .rlortr, r!itlt tlt,' ,.rr .lrrtl r'('ttlrllr'(l to iis .rt tLr,rl i )\\'l l('l'

(r') llrat ilre lt'.ue Irrr rlJl()r \')rt1.r(lr( ti.)lrs itr tlr( r'\ lLlr'lrr( L,l tlrL, I'\\''s .rntl il is iYr'll sr'l111'.1 l)\ ll(r\\ tir.rt rrtitt,rr' (r)ntr|ldiLfr\!1\ !\:lli(11 !l() Ir()t ( llr', I tlr| tIt.tt(,ti.tIiI\ ()l tlr(' ('\'i(i('l)(('(.rn Ir('li,,n()rcJ. ltt tlttr tcslrL', I t,. li,ttt,t ls f)l.laL'(i (rll Z.rhir l(h.rn V Slt.rte (l(l9r'( \lli l;tri)

(l)]\'lost significantly lllt'tt,|tiLrtits \\'r'r(']r'(()\'('rr'(l lr()rll Ill! cliLl<i ot tlrr-'cat'itr rvhich the nPl)('llnrrt rvas tltivittli attd as suclr tlrcrc is no doubl tlttt tltL n..us(tl lttttl nrttttl Ltrutulrlge (rl tlrc li.ir(()ti(5 tllrirlt trL'i.' Irt'ittti tt'lrrtspt,r tt'.1 llie e,tt tr,.ts r('a()\'('l'r'(1 .llotit', rr illt tltL' tt.rr.'trtit', ltr lltr: r(')i),.,.t iir lltt srrttilar ..it(' \rl N,t(lir [(h.rrr \' !itate (lr)'th 5L\'1ii 1899) it \r.r\ h.,l.l .rs urr(1('r', "i!i ir,i,,,'!(,/ri llil()r/.,1i/ li/i rl rri r,,, rtlti \tttl ltttt! tttti! lltrtl lltt 1tr'ltliL,tttt' lttt,i tlt, , /rr i',i r',' , 'irl{ r, i,'/ ,r lrr,r! pllrtlU \llltll)ll lt,'itt fi,)t't'tt t :ititl I I t t t t I t I I t t \', ltl t ) t

t?l

KiLntLlti. llty lul llr ln,i,it /1,( /i\('\ ri1sr, 'ls lrllit.{ pe rsott ittt'lurqL' ul tlt( tttltit lt lor sut lt tt lott,\ Y jourttrrl, tlt4 tttttst Itt srrrlllrl tt illt thr tttt:t'\5ttt't/ l',tttttoltl.gt .t'illt rt':{tnl to lltr r,rltitlt ,rttrl ils fottlt"tls. l lt,' ltt rtLt,tl t lt'',t ll li ltt t'\r tttl)l tt)ri\ rrrr' rllJ LIL'l\'l1tlL'ul\ r,ri ii tr', iir titlt\lttti,, . ,,t ,1,/1 11rs1' ttttrl ttt 1iI lttt'\1'|1 ttt't' lllt tit )ti\!'t)t,t trrllti,'1,r1'lt.lt tlt,'tt /'iii,,r'1,',/11,' i,,,1! rr'r''rtL'tt, 'r (,r iir, ,,,,/1,'/ri- tilt,l lltt'tl t\l)lttltttlt\'1t \l/(,rr'lll.! lttt I.i,i\,i,rrii( :,, lt,'tll 1 r/rr'tt1l/1,'trr lltrtl tttttL ltt\tttlt tttll t I 1/rilrr ri i,i/1r /lrli.rl tl"(brrlLl arielL',.1).

ln this rcg.rrtl lcliill.lcc is.tlsLr pl.tL't',.l ()n lltrss.rirt !ihah arrrl others V The State (PLD 2020 SC 132).

Fultlrt,r'nrttrt,, Uitrlt,r 5.f9 (-\:j ,,\, t lrl97 rrri,.r. tlrt' rr,tlrr,rv lrJs l)r'r'lr I)r.()\,on irs irr this ea'., rlr,. rrrrLrs 'lrilt., tLr tlt.' .tr, rr,.'rl t\r >llrr\\' lli- itlrt()r('lt((' ilr tll.lt ,tt lL'.rst lrt' lr.rtl Lrr l.ll()!\ lr'.lr1t' ol llrt ll.ll(i)ti(\ Ill\' ,tl)|('llrrlrl lt.t: ttol [,t','rr .rl,lr r,,.1,, -,,r irr tlri',.trt' lrr tlr( ,.,',1' \)l lVl oh bootr- U r'-l(t,l r r rr,t rr \/!,t.rtl t'(lllJ \ll.l) lbl)il ir.,: lr. l.l ,r' ttti,lt t tt, tltis tcsptt t at l'lli , l'.rr.r ll

I

"Lltttltr tlr /,/1,(!/!/r)l! ()/ \{'r l/r)/r .") ,rl //ir' r .\r" ,r\r / r'rrtr' //1,' t(roi|l-V t)l tolllnlbttlltl\ (Ltt\ tlttttit' ltLtttt ,r lttt,ttlr tttt lt)ltttlt tpii bV lltr itr ttrttlrol t),t llL' li)tt iPl)\'llLitll\. lln'bttr,lrtt ltt (\l)ltti llr l,dssl.t)td,l rt:lrlltt't tt, ltttrl or,tttts!ttt< lii'r' ti'rt' rrrt llu' tltlrllrtr!s to Lli',lttt;.i, 1'tl tt(ttltrl llu'y lttrt lt,l rrtttl rtrrk'ttrt rtt ,lrli'tttL tLr,t 1tt ., ,t1,1't'rtn rl tt1 tlt\l)ttl tl ol llk .u,1t,'1 )|)tt) \ tl'j\ tltrr: tlt, l)ttt,,t't l l tt)1 t,t,llttttt l1LltI ,ltrtrn'ltttrl tl\tl lltt'it ltr\ tt titttttt 'l rrttrtl,trllt,l

(li)llr,rt it rvirtrlLl l,L \'\lr('rJr( l\ ,lLllr, trlt to t,'r:t :Li, lr ., l.rr1't' .tlIt()Llll( r)l r lt.it.t', itt llt. '.rt 1,.'tt1|' r rl,,t.r] l'() l'.(, '.Ltltl rtt tlit lr,,Lrs,' l,,,irr1i ln t(,t.rl S-itl [(, s ,is ] I ( I t i ( I ( r I itl Nltrsl,lt; r ' I i I '

r\hrttetl's rnse (5Lrl)r.r) .trtLl l'ltr' :rt,rtc V Abdali l;lr,rlr (-l(J(l'/ s( NlIilel).

(li)'llr.rt lltr'tt' ir'.ts l1() tlt'l.r\ lll :(lrrlilrrl tItL ,IIltIriL.rI t,'1r.'rt Irrt ittr.tl\ sis tr Itir'it Itrrlr('Ll (,lll t(r 1,,' lr!,5ili\'('

(i)llrai th(- l('r()\r'rt'!i ll'lrri)li(' \!('r'' l\rl)l ir1 5'Ll(' ' lrst()(l\ IILrnr llte tirtri'oi tltt'ir r,.'r\rr('r\ t(r lll(' tilllL' \\'ll('li tll\'\ \\\'l(' taLr.'tl [rtr al]clllia.il ,lllnlvsls .illtl ll() sillr,gcsli()ll ()i inllll)('l ill!', !vitlr tll.' s,ttlti' li.ts ('\'('11 L,L't'11 tlt.tLlL'. Illt' tt.tttt'ti$ tr".'tt' s('.llr'(l ()rt tltc s1rol, rr'l1l'lill('rl st',llL tl Lrt tll.' tltalkli.rti,i [r..'llt' ir,.,in11 trartspot l.'Li t,r tlrL'.lrL'ttti.,tl r\.lll]ill('l ,rtl,.l rt'.ttlt.".i iltL' rh,.'tric.tl e\.ultilttr itt .t sr',tlt'LI (\)ll!iitit)ll .l5 l)('l III\' !II('IIIt'..II t(P(rrt llt tltis ri'sPtrl tt'li.rtt,,' i' l'l.t.tel irtr llr{.' t!'r('l1t :ruIr'(,urr' ( ()Lo.i (.1s( .rl Zalrirl ,rrtrl l(iaz r\li V St.lte .l.rt.'.1 t)( ().1'102() (unlc|()r te\l) irr l.rii \1'1','.,1 Nrr l,'-' ,rl llll5 Altlroul,,li tltis r-,tsL'L()ll(..'lll('(t l.rl)(' >ill((' it (()11(('lllt'(l tlt(' s.ilc (Ll5t()r1\ Lrf rr.'t t.titt s',v,tt's lr,-'ttt:l 5('llt l() tllt' (llL'll)l((tl c\anlirlel we r'()ttsi!lcl its liir,.lirt;is ttr ['.'ctlttallr .1])l)lit'llJl('tr), i

tlic salr' ( usl()(l\' ()t nill(()li(\ lr.,tnp, r1,111 to tliL, .lrr,trrir,rl ('\,tlltilltr r.vlrirlt lrrltl .15u1r(l('l Jl 1,,11., ,in iri.rt( ri.il l),Lrt, " llu' ,,lu'nttLrtl (.ttulutL,t''' 11'lrrl ltuluL(Ll L,V llrL !rtLll tlo,l,,t sllt.s lltltt lltL'sctls ol sptLttlt'l\ \t'tl lor r'llL'ltl,rtl ,'vttttlL,'lL,,rt 11t1'1'1' 1.p'1'f i1t11l ittlttt Ltttl il LL,its llt tlh,'Iti lL'\tuitinL't (t,ltt) llii ltrolirtt ttyL'tt tltL' srals, llt(ttlt)t'(. lltt tt)tlli,uttnu t)l lli lrliliont:rs' ltttt.ttttl LLuttt..,1 ri'.!r//'r/i//( lltt st!,' lt'tut;t ttsttott ol lltt sptcit ttts rs tlistotrttlerl l,ollr ltv tlris.ltttt nr ttt,ll ,t5 l)V lih, .lrtcl llttl nr tllt(\llan ( r l/l// ri'{iilr/i/t{ !itttt1tvv1111 L'l lln' 'trLl U) llt,rt tltt' ,rppt'll,rnt r\ illrrr I li,.,Lrr', 'rl ltr.. .rr t,.'',1 .rl,,rirl rr i(1t otll(,1 \()-r1(au5(,Ll lL'.rrl tlr| l\\l' I,r;lrLt, r,rr lrr. IrLrrrIt.LIrrrrr lr, ., Iltrttst'lVItt,t,.,(o-.i(rus(,rl i.r'.rs r!sirltrrri \\ll(,r(,r,r lris Iriritrt.rtrrrrr ll!r0li11'r trf rlt,tt,ts tr'.ts l-t'Lr)\'(,li'rl. llrL'Ir,11.,.' riiil rrot l.rtLrri !l Llrt' Ittc.ttirttt ol tltis lt,rLtsc tvlr.,rt, I.rt1,,t, .un(,rlnt! ()l lrlli\)llr\ \\(-r'(, kt'pi lrf ilvl'.' tltt, ,rppt.ll.rrrl .rnr1 lrir o-.rr r rrs..,tl l.,,rLl tllcrr t(, rt ,ln(1 r.

tls sLl(ll tlris lLiltltt'r lLrltiIit,s tlr(. l.r. I llr.rt tlrr, .i1,pcll,rrrt ri.rs ittvolvt,tl irt Ilrt, nalcotit's [rtrsirrlss. llrr, ,rp;rlllarrl .r1i.-r (nrr, l.irr;r, at)n tlle (l()()r'ol thc Irotrri. r'rr,rr r.rllr'Ll lL,r tll(' r)(-rti)n irr:;irl.: L,t trittttt'i.c ll.isil Lialrxli tr,1i,,..,1,.'rr.'.i llrL tlir.,r .rttrl .ti:rr I,,.'..rrrr. .rrr .l( aus\,(l irt tltis t.t't,.

(li)I lrirt aitlrrrttlilr no irlri('l)L'nr1('nt nt.r'lrtl tras .l',5(r( l.rt('!1 !! irir tlrt'atrt'st.llrLl li,L!r\!'r\ ,rl t . ' ; , I I I 1 I lris (.u il lr,l\ ({rl]('llr I r .r

, 1 ' |. 1 .r

evi(lr'lr(r'itt ti's|(tir! lrrs arrr st .llirl Lr'! (,\ ,'r \ \\ llii\1 rlriiirrri llrL CJr llt,tt ll\) l)li\',lt(' |('rs()rt !\.r\ !,ti'l).t|r.'tI lrr Lrt,Ll,ttl,.' .trt itrclr'1,r'rt,.lr. nt ttt.tsltir' ,it tliL, titrrc ll .tttr.t.rlt(l l!r('\\'lt tl.'.1,111 Lrlirtli asLcLl. lr\('r ()tll('r\\'i\r' ', 1()l ( r l'L r: L'r, lLr.l.',1 tur ()ft('D5r'5 f.rllrrtg Lrrrrlr'r tltr' ( ()rrtrol rrl l\'l.LitotiL ' t t I ', I . I ( ' \t t

, , I I L '

19()7 lrv iiltLr.,rr] \1, ol tlr.rt .'\!l .rrtl ,t":tt.lr tlLl l.rtl.,,i .rrl ititlePt'tttlcttt nlu5liir .rt tlrc lr,,tll t,lrrri llrr r.lrr\!lri. \\'('r'!' r('(()\ ('r('(l ()n p()int.rti()lr is rrl rrrr titr',r'tItl('lI((' l1l llri. r',':1r.',t lt,liarrt't, is [rl.]rr,ti ort tlrr-,,.ast'trl \'lultatttttt.rtl Harri[ \/'l'lre !,t.rtc (2()0r s('\41( l-r1')

(l)l'liat irt rlr'.tlinil rvitlt ll,lt(\,ll(\ r.rsr'" tllt'(()Ll]l\.rr'(' !lIl),)\, rl t() .l\l(,[)t .l (l\ll.i ]r( ,iP1rr,r.rLlr .rir1 l,Lil .((ltlrt lllr' .i!, tr\r'!1 lrrr tt'tltrriL'alitit's lrt tltis t,.':lr,.r t tr lt.rLt,r' i. pl.irL',1 t,tt (,ltlt.rltrr Qarlir' \' 'l'lte ljt.rtr (l)l l) -lt)()i, ',( 1,lr\\lri, lr lrlltl .r\ rrrr(1('r .rL I).lrJ li [).(r().

"\ry( in, ttr)l ttetl'fltbL' r'tllt llu' titth'ttltt,lt ol llh l(ittt(tl tol lsd brLtntst' lrrtl rt'ttt,tttts llnl "Poyptl liott't't.t" rr','tt fotrnd lytttg ttu llt rt,.)l o.l ll ' (\'l!irl( llPreft)ft, ll ' trclmicnlily, trlticlt is fuing poitttetl ottl bV tlk' l(nrtrcl couns|I, t]ot d tlot be stll'i(u'ttt ttt tt'Lluil hittt. l,t tliitiott to it itr sueh-likt'cosps Corrts trt sultpttstl to disltttsc of tlrc nttu toith ilq nt it' LtlrPro tlt, itrslerul oJ' acquitting tlv drrrg piiileN ott tt'rlttti.\tlitit's, tts it lms been hell in ('1993.s('Atr( 785) itttl (P1.1) 199(, l;(' 305"). (boltl atldcd) ,

I

' t\o iel

(r.r.r) No tloubt it is for thc plost'cutiott to Pto\'('its c.lsc.rg.rillst the accusecl beyonrl a reasonabl.. tlotrbt (rvhich n'r' titttl tlrat tt hatl .lor-re, in this ctrst') but wc hirve rlstr consit{erotl th(' !i('1l'ttat casc n,l.tich wc tlistrtlie ve. I his is [ri,t'.tttst' tlrc aPprtllarrt silrtply rais('(l th(' dcl('nc(' that I)r.' tvas intr,rt'r'rtl Ilre ,rppt'llattt riirl rlot exrturine, himscll on o.rth antl ,.licl rtot trtll ltrtY l'\! irt sul)l)ol t ()1 his clcfense cast'.

12.'Ihus, for tltt'rt'asotts rt)elltI()rtc(l .tlrrr',.', tvt'firltl tlltrt tltt'Irtosl'ttttiott lt,ts ploverl its cast lreyotrtl a lc.rs()llablc tlotrt:l ttlltinst tltt'appell.ttrt lot oflt'tttt's urtclel S.6/9() CNS Act 1997 atrct lry cxt'r'.isirrg rtrtr ttiscrt'lirrrt.tty pttwr.'ts tttltl,.'t 5.423 Cr.PC horcby vary the cotrvictiott of the .rppt'llattt k) (h.rt trtl(ler 5.b/9(r) CNS r\ct 1997 antl clisnriss thr,appt.tl.

13.With lcg.rlri t() tllr.'r't ttttittal r('vi'ji(rlr,l[)[)lic.]ti()rrs irl tll(' (il5(' ot At,(ltll Malil< (Supla) it was Irt'lcl ,ts tttrrlcr rtt l'. \li'l p,tr.r's l9 .rrrtl 2() as ttrt,.1t'r;

" 19, trt Il. i,. ful,i1151r1111, trr lirtrrrrtir, (19)'0 (20) Q.ll. ,'I l), lltr Ll.k Cottrl ol Aplttrl ltirl rlo , tt fttrt bttt,l ltttttr'iplts/1trtrl,'ltttts itt lltts ragrtnl u,ltorr' tln' llottrl (\tlltl ittlrtf(r( tttltl (ttll ttt' lltt stttltttrr:. 'I ltttsc trt rts ttttrfur:

O Wlrcrc tlrc srtrlcttrt'trts ttot jttstiJitl b4 lfiro.

(ii)lNltrL t l)t)l'sntt (rtt\ stttlcttrtrl ttl)ott Lt (t'tttttg firtltrrtl lttsts

(iii),\ltllLrs itttlttolt'rlq I'tl'rtt ittln t[]tt5ttl(t'ttll\)tt o1' ln'5lt tttltrt'lo I't ltl','tt ittl! tt(tottttl

\ttt) /7Ir' .,/lh'//(, 'tr,r,,tl,.ll,t ,// t'\.{"r,1 ,'/ ,i',r'l.! I't'tt tt tltlt

'fhase tre nt're !tidclittcs rttul tlteir tpplitrrtitttt tlLttrlrl 'Jlt,' ,irs,'s r:ttlttlitLg rttPttttl tlnt depend on c.,clt ctse. st' trc lo b?

decidai ruitlt ttttost L\rr l'Nln'tt lrttI tl'sls rr t/tsr'r?lltrrt Itt ('Ltttl'l to itpnrd setttt'tttt ol lcatlr or lilL' tltlristtttttttttl, it ctsls tr lrurpl tltrltl to ltr nttta tlrL' r'triLttts Lrttlsldt'nrtitttts tpltttlt ttttfurlt': llt:st scttt(,ti S prorisiotts. lltt tititttrts/rtrlr't's sttl.tL)tt littl tln'olkttrr:, tln,qtustittrt ol nt( s rH, tln' prirttiltk ol yrolnrliotnltl t1 5?ttltttt(, o.[ tlN Br T,itV rtl tln' ollrtrL' ,lnrrgLr{, llu' t LtttsitlL'rutiott ol ltruu'ttliotr or ol d(ft'rr(ttar ttttrl L'l n'lutltililttLotr ttttty so lr l;L'pl ttt t,ie('il llt r tr t it t.s lr tr tr t's ol lltt' rtr't.',rttrl llt,' I't,t ttl)l)liLttblt: 50 r I

20.|'lrcre is no rtlt' ol ym'ntl typlitltitttt llnt tltt strpinl o f of scrttct 'e iurinu tltt' yandt'tr't1 ttJ'rtpyttrl or rtttisitttt, btl itsell, utould constittttt t lttr Jbr P lt ,etttL'ttt o.l st'ttt(lu or tlurt nury tttercis? to tlnrt L.fllct rt,ttuli bc t'iolttit'e o/ Artit:lt: 13 ol the Constitrttiott.'lhis rttull be otrt'Jnctor tolriclt lltt

\ i\ \

I 10 l

Court ntrry tottsilt,r, tlotp tpitlt otlu:r Jit'tot.s rtt lln, Pri ciPles rtferrul to itt lttnt l8 t,ot)t,, .t,ltil{' tlcciiitt.y llrr, 4uestiott of tttlutttt'utrttl" llrrrlrI .rtltleLl)

l-1. ['his coult citrr orrlY lr.rrrtl riorr.rr \L,lll(.lt((,s l]l.ln\l.tt(,(l bt. Ltlr .trL.t .t: slt li tir .t t'ortr,'ictiolt urtrler' 5.(r/ 9(r) ('NS i\rt l(.r(),'llrL,r)nlt, !1ii(.r.eti()rr rr.lrirjr tlrc r,riirt: ltaVc is ulr,.,thtr t() lt.ltri ,.lOrvrr tlrL, (1(,.ttll J(.nt(,ltr(, (,1 a sr,rih,itr(, {,1 lil(, ittt prt iso111111,111. lrr tJris lt-sPttt r.r,li.rrr..,i' Pl.r.,,,l on !_ltate tlrr.ou.lilr l)irer.tor ,,\Nl l'eslt.trvar v. li.rl<lrar Z.uu.ur (ltlli) r,( i,lll 1i.,.,) rllri. lr lrrlLt Lr: Llr\l!.r .rr l, ll-, I .rr l',r r'.r l.

"llu' itlltrrutrttl i)NiL, lLt rltl tt)l ,,)))t11tt')ttl Li't'll rr tllt llt itirr,. tttulttll)tgrt\t:ilV 1'routrl tt, tt \t'ilrt1tt,. rtol ltss lltttt t I t t t t tII t I t )t ' ,; t t ttt

lir !ilL' rt: tull i. ltttt' itt ttr';,, 'ttt rllt'utlrt t\ ltltl ,yrrllq Ltl lr055as5l//1, totttttlbtfiLl tttLttr:,, Ltf lLtt l,tlo,:rtttts tt\ t5 llt( tlt5t ('ttll llu rtsyttrtrlL,ttt trttrl llu,ttl,ttt ll)|,.;itrt! t)t(it,tttl,()! ltq lltt llt:lt etltrl ts LtltL,tt !o ttr'L'ltltLttt. |\|'ttitltr\:, i tt't'lt'tttjt( bl tltt., \ t'ttt'l: Lottst'tllt(ttllV ll ' ttlllt,tl t: ,tll,t,rt,l Itt1ttr,;tt,'i tuLlt) t,1tl t!t!(tl lS.5.l0l-j is s,'/ ri,rrl,, uul !lr \ruit tl\ t tttt tu Llt tl l))/ tlr i.,tt itL ri n ttrl Lottrl i5 n'5lat',r1, /to,r','r,, r l,tll! lt, lt,lt! r)/ \r,(l/r,/t ;S-')ii rr/ //ii tirr/,, rl,i,1. l'trttL'ltrrrl tttiuttiul\t'i :ltttLl 1,, t\5tr,,rl t\)Lt1.1itl lltt 'ttt,:,t t't\Ptttttl(tll s(, .t /rr /(r !r,r, t' tttil iiti Ilt,ILt, ltlt tlL,Ll tlLttt t! lttt litl lrttni(tl llt,llt t olti".

15.Lil(('!!,is(,irr the r'trscs rrl !itate llrlrrLrglt lleg,ional lJilr,rtul ANlrl'esharv.rl v. Sohail l(han (?()19 S(lN4l( 1288) .ltrl (;t.rtc throLrgh [)irert()r'ANI l'eslr,rrv.rl v. Muh;rnrmad llamzan atr(l otllers (20I(r';( l\ll( l,)9:j)

l(r. Sir.(, wc lravr, corrvjetr',.1 tlrt, .r1rpL'll,rrrt J.,lr.ltzcL, rrnLlr:r'!.i tr/9(t) ( N', r\r t I()()7 lor havittg over l0l((,'s ol r'lrar'.is irr liis l,,rsstsrion tltr ()ltl\. l.rrr,lrrl st,rrt,.,rr..t is t'ithtr tl,.,.rth or lilt, irrrIr isrrnrncrrl rr,. lrlr,,lrt, .rllrrrr tlrr- .,\Nl's ( rlrrrr.rl lit'vision r\pplication irr Lt,sPt,,.1 Lrl tlrt, .rP1,r,ll.111t Jt,lr.uiz.,l,.rrrl i,nlr.ir((' llr(' s('llt('llCL'ol .tPPL'll.titt.lell.tttzr'[r to lil,,irrr[,tir,,trrrt,. ttt.rttrl .t lirtr,(]l lis ()n\'lllillr{,n llt slr,rll lt.rr.,tht,trt'ttt,lil rri ', lSlll( rl'L ,rrrL1 ,lr\ I . \ tr,r \ r,.l rr 1,ril I iIIr(

,II r r .t. 1

iltt Ptr'st'nt r.l5(r \\,r' ,ils,r orritr llr, l),r,,1, r ,\\l t,, i i t i L lr .rtt,''l llLr' rr i rr. ' Ii. t

irPpt')l.rrlt lr:ltirrzcLr .lnLl reiLr'l lrirn 1,, 1.ril , rrst,rtlr irr rrrr-lti lL, \('r\r' ()ul (li(' rcrrr.rintlt,r' Lrl his :t,rrtcrrcc.

17.WJtlr rt'g,artl ttr th,.',.'nlt,rnrr-,nr('ri ()l llr(' \('ilt( rt(('()l r ('sl)()nr1('itt t,ltttl,rttt Aii u,r Iinrl th.rt lrr lvirs ()1rly.r pissellp,(,r'lr] llli'aJr .rl tllc tiLir( iri llis.lr'('$t ,rtrrl Illr'r('(()v('r'y ()l tir('lrarc()tics.intl tlr.rt Ir('(Jlrl\ olr ltririf prtittlatiort tll\)!\L'(l llr( Polirc to tltt'house wh!,1(,()tller l].]l(()li(s \!('r('l\!'l)t.lr'l(l tlrU\ \\r(' fill(l ll() 1r',1:()lr

I '1 1',

to cnh.r'tct' his s('ntcr'lr(. .lrtl ,rs srrr'lt .\N l 's r't irrrinal li,r,isior.i applicatiorr irt lr'spr'ct ol rr,sporrtlcnt (,hLrl.rnr ..\Ii rs lrt,rt,Lrt rlisnris.r,,.l tu. The appcal antl crinrinal rt'r,isiorr ,rpplicaIions .lrr,(]isp()s(,rl ol iu the at.rovt t('1 nrs

,l ,',t7 I Lll)(; I

,JII..,

l\ rr ^ ',- *.,.1 t 7.'1 .- o S

i! I 7

,i, l!,, I. I l.- i l(l il ) \ I I ',.1 1 .t /'r0- .I