ZAHOOR KHAN S/O KHAN BADSHAH (Appellant) VS THE STATE (Respondent)

IN THlr HIGII (l()U RT oT,SINI) TI AT KARA(]III lr( 1'n":

\1r.IusIi..,\1ohdt trtdLt Kt!ti t Kllittt 1\lhi llr. Iusti.:. Kh,,lli,tt IIus'ni't litttio, s!!-( l!. A.l. IAIL APPIT,\l- No.?44 ()lr 2([e ApPclldttt ,u lrr.,r .lr.irr -, l li,iri.h.,l lr r',r ,ilr \lr t .l ,\ 1,:rt rl r.rrL. ,r'1voc.r tt

licsp(nr.l(--rrt: Ih('Statr lhrough t'I1 Abr'.r ALi Khichi ,\tld1 l'r'trsccutor' (;i'n' r''rl 5ll(i11

( irmf.Lrinant Ihrorlth N1/\ Sird!:l rl L ,rr"' . LrrL AbLlrrl Ilrl(r',.. rl\'('.rl' ' sPL. (li. .\. l.J \ll \l'l'lr \t \().1l: I l{)19 A pprll.rnt ,z.rlrtLr \'1rrzr sot' ,'i Nln1. J r.r h.Lrnr- Ll rL'Lrillr \1r IrtillL,rr \l ,rf(l 5l-.'i,. ,,11 (\r11

tlcspon(lrnt IIri sr.rl( llrL)LLllr\ Nlr' \l'.r \ I lil:ttlri :\clLll l'r'r)\ '.t it'f ( '|L rL r'r .ri ,,ll-

Complniflanti

L. CI<. A L UI'II'AI .\ I'PI] A I N().251 ( )l: :01(r At,pPll.rnt: ,,1.r l.'ir.,r -'rr "t iL. N I.,.1,, f.lr |: ltrr,,ri,ll \: ' I l.r\.rl .r rLl ,\[ L, tl.rt,r /.

J [<csp(tn(lenls: l)Noor Muh,rnrrnrtt Slr'r lr '"' \luhanrnlnJ Ilrrssiiil' llr,rr;r'l l(h.\.raiit NlLrh.lmrrra,l '\z' i trr l) laiar Ali \1)r ol A(li sl)'rr tlIn.u:Ih N'I, A atr ]\lL r Rlr'rt

12r 2-9

CRINITNAI- \ tsr AI'I'I-ICA 'l roN NO.155 () llrll9

A[)plicant l .rlr Khdn \orr ut l l.' NIJ\lr.

Klr.rr:. tlr,,Lr;ih \1, : "lr.tr ',rL I lr\ rl J tl '\l\ltr ll.rlrL';

.)rl\ ((.rtL'\

I{espUrrlenls /sLrtr l)Ziiheer N4irza son oI N'lat{nra Kharr through Mr. l1likh.1r Ahnlcd Shah, ad\'(x.rl(' ?) lahoor Kh.-rn son o[ Kharr lla(lslrah tlrrough lvlr Khali!l Ahrnod Khan,.dv()cnt('.

Date of l{earirrg:. .).1 0l 202?

I ).1tc of Announccnrer)tl 'tl :-

lL. D(; \II]\ I

Moh.rormnd K:rrim Khntr Agh'r, I A|1rt:llarrts/'ft'sl)Irr'lt rrrs N("

I

N4,,tLtnl,na(1 Sh.rh riorl ('l Nl'harrrrn'rJ llLr\s'rirr' Z'rh(er \1:rzr -'tr " NI.r!t'ara Kh.rn, /nho()r iil',xn sorr ')l Kll'1rr lli!isll'rh ')rLJ /'rl'rr '\li si'r "r ( n\' N'ir;"1 .,\rtil Shah \\'r'rt ch.rrl3 \h(ctcll tf ilt('ilklr lrr'tl ir:'l'c'i'rl 2{11lf) ,ltisintl out (, llli No.f: r'l l(lil'r Lrrlrl!r s"li('n li)l/r1l l'l'( r1l

:n.t()n 7 i.rf A tA t().)7 r,rgrstcr.ri .rl I's la,ro,,..rbn(1, R,llir( hr APffLL.r I \\', r. rour'rrt(rri r rJt' irrrl'r11n'rl "r(1'r 'iJl"l (li ilS l(rl!' I)r\s" h\ rlr

l{'i,, rurl Judfai', Arrir lrff,'ris:rr(('uLr N" lll l'rrr'l1i 'rh'r'1" 'lr'' r"rr" I

KIr,rrr rt:r'(r'r1\r't l rr'5lr'' lli-r I I'r :

,z.rlrr-r \'lirza.rr'(1 ,/.rh(\,r clirrre Nc'.12 oi 2()0!' h)r otlerlit' rr,": \i)l l'l)( 'rrr(l \(rlttri'(\l lo tr r( r'rr"

li.l. tur lift' f{rl tirtrs rrl', Ihe (lL'ilth (rl Z'iiLitrLldirl' N1'rh:rrrrrLr'r'1 i'rltt tll,rilr-rll.rh ( l'V.1h.c(l ullah) arrtl N1'rh'rrlrrrir'l Iirral-rrm rrr'l ,lir,rt<l ti, lli\ i(,tlr-r(n\.ltirrrr rr' ' rli '\ (r l'( lL' tl1( lr! f' '' 1l' ,.lLLtrrs,:tl lhr' ,r.trr:,(l s,tIr' .rl'r, rirrLrlrJ t.r fr\ Ii' l,tl(1.(rL\1" "''lr ' ' .omPrrnsation to rl1( lLt rc (rl th..11''('rs((l Accu't't1 /'rlr'" ' \lirz'r 'rrr'1 T,rhoorKhnnv!rr!.rlsorLrrr!i.lt'(l rr,/:;lh5 ll(l) Cf l'( l()f oilrrr(r tr/\) ' l I i|l ;\ anrl st'nttrrtttl tI LrrrLlcrllr Ii l t''r lit'"rnrl to P'i\ lrrrr o i\ llll)rllr( ' ,rrrlr,rrrLl in (l{l,rL,1t (ri I'r\rlcrrltotr r\ir''''r\l rrr'11 ':l!r:' rrr ,rl :i.'ctitr:r lsl l] rrln',rls'.\l1rrrr1'Ll "l' "'rrtqt rri'1\'ri\ :' i1rL 4,,.r\,.1 \,",r Nl,,l .,r')r'r.,,1 \lrdl .' r' '/rl''r '\l {r'r" 'r"lr'rr'"" l'' r'r r ' ,'

I

>q

(lurge of Lr/'s.265 ll(l) ( r"l'( .ls l)n'\c'uti()ll r(rrrld not [rrtn)l it! ( r:i' df,.1mst them.

vi(lL

2.At this PLrint h\r r\',1\r (\l l',r'l'l11)Lrrl!l it i:j \{orth nlt'ntrt)rrirril 'rr' lhrlit' rrIlrcr Juclgnlerrt rrt thtr A I (l lr(ilh Lllr '1lrP"ll'rfiq in(l resfrrn(lrtrls irl dlfcirls werc tricti arrtl irll ,r thcnr irrcltr'lrrrll tll('rrrsPi)ndtni\ \{Lr( lIir(] lorrrrrrlLlt'r'r.rnilerSll)ll'l'(-lil\AIA'rn(l 'rl ol lhcr\1 \\'('rr''r'1r! iih\l IrLr

s1t 'r'itl\' sr,tllen.cll i,) Llt'ath. lhi.,orrrl h('\v(\'r'r 'rtr lhrir cirlrrr '1P|('Ll llr.t JudqDreni ntrtl rt'nrarrLlILi tlrL ('r"t. hr'k l'r lhec.,rr(FrrrL(l tl( torllrr Irrrlil(1l pulfo\e oi r,r 0r'Jrrr1'..rll ll( 5 ll: ( r I'( rtntcrnrrrls ol llrr'r" Lrt"i I lr'\ll .llrrsh.r1\1 ih.reiilt'r.rllrr hrrliirrl rrllrrIn('lrL\ Irl lhc Partic'r!n(l'I jrrtlgment on rrlelrts Ih('lrrslt iullsurrrrl ns r11(]i'dt'rl 'lt1o\'e' r'hirh :::r'r\\

lhe l,l,t{a:t oi tht.t 'rflc'rl' rr''l r''v:rr"rr 'rlLrlL!'rtiorr' d(( lLrrttlnll I lr,' s.nl.n,:cri th. nFPC.rls I' Lrl\' Irrrl'r '('rrnrtnt !il-Llst l. the trIiet laL:l: trl tlr( pr(1:j({rrtit'rr('r:n"rro tl!'rl con\Plarrr'rrrt l .'ii L

I L'!lr( r:

KlLrn r|1 the T:llt 1?,'10()() rL.rt('(i llr.rl his tL'rr /airruLl'lrn 'rrrLl nnrr \ \'loham litll 'l.rhir,l-l"rirlll'rlr nrr!l N{('lr'rDrn1'rl lLr'hLnrl(ltIII !!'ir LlrLf'rr l" Qu.tt.r (,n 27.12.2t10! ilr 1lr vehr'l( 'rr /rrrrLI(1!lirr '\'hiih ,/ainuLldin. an(l reach$l K.rr',rchr rn ihr ( t ( nrF!l tinre !!'hcrr il oq| r:t liri I laii l:sra 'ilu'rl{ J ' I r Ihiclc hacl st.rve(l (,n th. i).r.L'rrl' (n shdlrro(irlr 'ri Khalitl llin \\tlet'(l Il(lrtl, Lrr'*rrr 'r' larr''rlai \lorors lllii '\l"1rrl Iiir'' \1 i' !!ns !!drLinS.rs ( l-,rrtr'(iLhI Lrl rc:irl('Ir{'' ('' II'rji I;'ra nn(i \'rl'rr l'rrr ivolking ds c,roL. IIL Irrrlh('r' \t'rtt(l ll)'rl his \''lr l'linutl'L]1 L 'ri rL'

rr':iid'llctot IIaji l:s!'r '1ti i))f nr L'r] ''ll l l(lOii intl t,rld r\Lr'lLrl lirrt-'t r I

N.r7,rrlanthattlrrynrcl:(rir1gt('(-)rLLlt'rtlll'l(ilLLrwrrlti(l'rr rntl 'r'rlLr' tLr: I

lo ldwakal rrlrit)rs naLt'f lr.rvi rll LlLnnt'r As P(rr Nltri'((l 'rLrtl Nrrl'r ir1(i trl rL'r\ N'lohanrrnatl, u'ho rverr.lls() cL1\'ilrLl Ilr( rr 'rs liLr|sts' lairlutltlir k,hrrneclirrlhuir|chi.1e.rl1{'r.lr|rrrr'r'irr(l r!r\( lrorrlal ihcrlnl"ri l'ir"Ll 'rl trlr l" nt about Ll()30 ht'ur's rr),l .rs r' lhc tlr"rlkirl'rr !t'lrir ht'il()t Jlr{,lors 1'L

r ,,1,..rr the gat..ill r i a sLr.ltli ll lir'])rll:;t.rr'1Lr.l, !-'h'n 'rl Ilrn' Lir'-r' IrlllrtiI lrr'

(nr.rI1(l indi.ators r^t r"tn arr'l 'r1't'll'i nroL'ilt s"rs seen Ltirin'l tl:'rr''rr lhcv further Jis.ii)c&i tll'11 tlr'\'w(nt LrI'slnrr( rrltl !nu t'il(ile'\ lrLtrrl t

thr,.ar and then }\rlir_L lcrs(rrlrIr' ,rllllhtlnil trorl lhe Ptil''r lno_'r].' "

I

TainuclLlrn, N4oh.rnrrnntl l.rhrr.!!t': iU0hrrrrnr'rrI Ibrnl'Ln] lo1i(('l"rvtr "tr

I

lr I

the(.ilr. Z:ri,rr,.l{li11 alil:httt tr"rrr ih"'rr "\'irlr lris han'ls Lr1' I I I ! iIII I I r II

L L

siitirii, bl'hrrlJ Z.tir:irtl.iirr ,rlsL' rlrqlltlr(i ir(rrrr llt( \'tI rrrd tlr'n th''r( !1'r\ rtr' tilir,il .l\.r,r'.rl r'; rtri, lr /'rr rrr{lJir l'rl t L'nr"rrr!i LL"rr'lrl"Lr ('rrrri 'rr)(l ri1('( hirrself lr! l,rl.rrlg shrlt(rr tl'lrirltl t\'(r ''rri lrrrl lhL lr)licc str.riglrl .rn(1 Lrlleel thcrrr, rr{)5tlv liIin1: liLL lh(' llr'' pLrlrcl tl e r 'Jr r,:,gisl.).d [.1Lsc.ir1!l l.thri.,rl,\l llll's ]lsl llil' ll5iaLl 'ril(\rSirrrt'Pr'r lhr" ot the !.nr( rn.rdL'l1t in t)nirI lL) 'i)\er rrlJ thr''l':r)rl (l\5(rrli'1ll\ .Liinledlh.rtlrr',lcr:c.rsetlh.r.ltirrrlotttir'nrLltrrLrlli'r'ar(lr'r\"rn(llh( !v.re.ornlcltILl io lrlt'r'rr llre rlur"rs"tl i:r i''r](t wlri( lr LrrJ tL 'tlt '1i l)oli(c ,1,,,..r,. I I hl (lr.\'r. r .. | '.,.|UI r'l' 1'l'u!''' : rr 'l " ' 'r'' nn(i trlR I.l,/:)01[.] \\..r:; regisiIr|Ll nrt.rirrst lh. l,,Li.. tr' !' l1'l Pl1 n rtIr " rlrl rrLrl l'r 'r

(b)iler h'lnU ntl!leJ It' llrrlhrr rt'rlrll I I'rl lhtrr'rli'r hc rtLrt: Iunrrrl rilLr ls lnr ll) (lJ\,. rrrl nlLrr' L() tl.rrs ht r"chr!l \'!r'r(lr h' with ( ('rrri t.alln- t(, tno\( thrt h. x'1: ('rilrll h\ 1[irr('trr'11jlt' SLrPr(-rn' 'rl lslanal.arl ll('lhcnr{'enrt,rll,rrt'ur;bleStrIrIrrx L')Lrrt l!l'!rir'rL"rrl \!hilr t1' th' ; ha,l tdkrf \u() nroto noh.r ('l llris in(iderrt nlrr( l) inrtrrll\ 'r({'i:'lrnil *'"tt Pdlire !r'rsiorr v\':rs thir )('srrli r)l 'rLr encourrlt r lih(robv the 'h'"'r:'"1 killeLll,vtht PLilice insrll (1{'l.n:n', (hrrr lr( wn:j t(11(l tlr;rl hi.i ''l!' i"r'1Ll'l

rv ' ll' bc;,rrrc|t'tlcrl irr tllr A l( n::Jrnst th! l'(r L'( l('r Irltlr'li'r ol lll!'(lc.. rrll)'r .r1 j'': l\'LJ/'iL'r(l r"irr'1t the k:,rli,,rrl hir Ill{ ll,'11){l{.r,,]l ll lll "- (.rntrnrt irr tl)t' ()riil,irr.r l lli l'rl1it'tl t'v llrt folr((''rrr Ll '' 'l'r'' r'l lLlr ir ' 'l( I L rlr' wlrr.lr in csscn.c !latc(l llr.|l tlrr l'oli'r lr'r(l lLr'rl tr1'orr rrrr'l I'r:lL"l Alk r .onlflctlnli tir(' rir\It\tr8'r(r('rr' Llr' iril r_'trq'r1r' ! 1)l:r" l

'I

t(1 Ld!! lhl :!rrbmitt('(1 (hxllilrl .1P,.1irrst il1(' 'rtrrrrctl lol trinl r((orclirlil (hnlitc rv.rs r!.rl 0trl to 111. ;111ps{l 1(' !\hi(h thov f1('a(-l'd 11r't t:tr lt\ r! r(l ,l.rinrc!i l(,r tIr.rl

f). lt' Pr'ovc lts cas!" llr{' frrosecLltiorr i'\'rlrrtrr('11 ll iritrr' "1' :n'l ('l llrt exhibitl,(l vnri,'rrs docul1lrllts rlrrl olher fc'('vfri(s Lhr' stat|'nltrrt\ nc(t]scL1 Lr,/\ 112 Cr l'( wcre l|cortlttl wh'rei11 thr'Y h'tr'r' Jr'nrr'ul llrt I N0rrr t'l LIL allcitdtil'trs (,1 (lrtr Prosc.utiorr drr'i Ir1rl(^!('(l ill\'ir irnr)'!r1'r L-'rc' us"J \'i':lik .1..usc!l g.1\c rviLlertrP Lrn(l( r (htll crr!rrl lL'r 'i"ee'l'eil ' llshar I vr lrr r alsrr L:.rlled 3 l)W's in suPPort oi his rlt'lt'nc'' case ,

t:t o Cb

i)Altcr ass(l.i\rrlfl thr,lv.rilalrle cvitlcrrcI rrrr rl.c'rrLl thr'l('lrn((l tri'rl (Zaher,r' N'1ir-"r Jrrtl iLrtlge.(,n!i.ti'(l .rrr(l sent{'rr'{11 t\ri' rtl lhr''icL-Lr:;'rl lalrtUr Rlr.r ) hlri,sl n.tlLlillrnil tr!'() r)llrL'r 'tc'rrsc!i (NrUI Nll'hnrrlrrrnL' (rrrl t'xr'licr iI Shah ar.l Zafar i\lrl .1s PL'r'tll('ilnftrqrr.(l it(lSnri rl '1-( s't thi! lLrLlPIn(ttt htrrLr lhi.i' .rp]c.rl' rrr': rr'r'srIn 'r:rfllr"ttrLrl rr' |rhrrri( Irrrt (,1 \i rter(. h,tr. t'Ltrr lrl'd 'rrl'rirL'L '('rrr (li'rr' ( ar1h.rll.r'mcnt (,1 'r('nt('lr(r' .rrrJ , rl,rirrsl ll'( 'r'(luill'rl (rl t'\{' acttrsr'ri,,' ttsP'rrr,l,'rr1'

7.lhc facts \rl tlrt' cast .rs rvell as ' r'i'it rrre l'r(xlu'c(l l,ll()r(' lhe tri'rl rorrrt lirrrl 'rrr elaborrle m'itrr)rr in lht' rlnIlrrltlr'l jrrrllimort pas'cd l-r'tht hi.rl c()urt and. ll,clofore, tlrt s.rrrre rlr'v Irt'l bc trlprotiucerl h''rt' 5(r 'rs l(' . rr , rir I r rrrl'1,. arir, | ,rr,,l r.rlr\1 , s',lfv l\'l\'l.li"l1 (trrr\ (ii('I E. l-canreLl c{)urrst'l ioI tlrt.rl.r],cll;rrt* irl lhc.rfrl'r"rl '1!,nir15t (oril{'rrrl(\l th.rt llx (i1\r't,,]lierne.l .r g,'rrrrirrr 1r' '{ 'rrrt'rrLlt(r '"\LiL llr' clc.(?sr.l xltrrr tl)c Li.ccas,rl lr,r'l lirc(1 'rl thL |()li'e H lr(' her( r " Lrlr'LI tl t" iire nt the (le.e.r.c.l rnst'lftlch'rr,r'wlriLlrlt'rtl t('th'J('rtl'"irl" rl'r r 'rr ' lh.ri lh rrrr,l,ilr \\as hrt.iurlrr:l lh. ('r]LirtrIlIr 'r\ a' pr"r'':r 1'' lr)li.€ Itositivelrsl-reFL!rtrllratallIrilrt''nroLrrrt!r\'{rthth('(lcce'rsL'tlrrLr:11err)Lrs items rv.r(' rr-c,tcrt'cl [r't'nr thcm inclrr'1in;i trvL) Pi!tols rrlrich slrcr .or1rl)nr{al \tith r'nlfli(:-!,rt thr'i'cetle r'r'r' l')urr(l l l"r\! I'r'r'r :rn"l lr"rr' rht' r(1()\,Lred l,islols rvhiLlt srrpporlt't1 thc irt'I'rllirrrLs "rs' "l '1 l't'nrrrrr( irn(r,tlIrl,'r I)ct!\i'( rr ll[ lr.lrlr(s.rnJ th( ir('lr!(] f\'r:t i\Lrr]', llLfLr rL"11t t'1 tl (lelcrn,', lll.rl lh( llli hnLl L)lLrr l.LigtJ n[icr ir !i!]' r (rl l(i 'l'r\:i JLrrri!' $.hi(lr tirrrr thc r!r !vitrr\n\ arr,i llrr "'nrl-'l':rnarrt "r'ho rtr'r 'rl r" Lr clr.rrl.rn,,r,r[crl up.r rals. .r- ri!rr{ tl]r r.,r,'(Ll LhnllltL\'\"'IIII''' wrrr plnrrtLt rvirnL's\( 5 arr(l .rt h.rt cotrl'l l't re13r'1" '!\ 'lL'rLr'( \t,rtrl\'s'(' nn(l .rs \rr(lr tltlr ,'r'i,leniL't rlnr:'t Lt'r'rl.'l" rt'li'''l LLlrrrr llr'rL Iv'rr Li l'L onL\ (r'rrlrrrrr " L'\'c !vitnrssc\ ('\'irlrlr.e !\'.i' I)(lif\P(l 'ri lh' L'c:rt ri r

'('LIIJ

c .ountor 1\rith Lr,ri(nown I\rlicc olli(( s h,hiclr Lirrl rrrrl irrtlLlrle tlr'' .rccusi..i rvho hn(t l,c,:11 m.r(lL' ra!rPr'] t(r.lt! !luf 1(' lhe lrtrl'l ' \Jtlt 'r' lollorvirrrl tht'incit]l']rlr th.li tlrr t t,tllt'(l ('\L wrlilr5\'r g'rrL L lu I Lhc arLrrs.rl w,lro llrrv torrIl Lr(]( iririlLl\ r11l tv.r\r.r\rl hrn\ \r' (l rr'\'i r'l

thdt ih('('\'e !\'rtn(5i:r a\orrlt(l .itt.rrilrrril irr i(lt ]. ilrr'rlirir' 'r'\r'r'ri '1:r': r' surli tlL('idcnt l\,(,1 thc P\ilr.( !1't-(! \.11'ir!olvr\l I I tl( r!r\''rrLrrLr Ll .

t

l(, I - <'l

tlx,.ld.cr!i,.1 h.trl n,l I,t!r1 l,rt'!, r', ll,! lLr, 1'.\1' rllriir(i ('\I xril r{ 'st rr'r\( llr. r - l, l \ l\ '", ' r, (- ' 'r' "1'.rr'i'r r' r'r r"" '' rr' ,rl(l(nL('r,n:.oiLr(,lL!1nl \rllL''r lh'rttlr' '('''r'(rr!al hntl i)Lt r) tr"lt ilt( l 0 r i tll! :mDl('s(1 r\l (\i(i.rl.r.rrrLI r:'Lr' Illrr 'r"u'(\i !'rrt L'rrtill(\1 rt ll .r.(luitt('(l crIeci.1lL! .is th(' cl,il' h' rl nIl tilt'cl 'rrrr 'rp1'LrLl n:,,,rLrsl thi LI ,i,,ruitt.l, thnt lht ,'lh( r h!(' rllrgrtl r\ "r it r''*r'' \l'rlL'r'tl 'rrrtl /a"rr l rrr

1r.rrl becr; lilrrr rrlr L'1 lh' l)L1rse'rLL(rlr 'rrlll 'r\ \rrr r 'rrr 'r(l\'rr:i('rlll(rr'll(r' sr'rlrLl'ri i0ulJ h .llaLvn 'r11.rin.L tlrrrrr LrnLl'r '\r'tr'1.' lli)tqi Qrr'r rrrrrr' ()r!lrnnnf( l!,ti-l (h,rt lh€! s,,Lrl(l llol li,\( trrfrrL'i-tot1 th' l)i)'L\rrr i'!L ('5' ,rrrrl lr:vrl .rLI or lh. rt\'\'r :'"'rs"rB lir"r" rrr'rl ';lr"rr 'l t" n(!lritir\i [)\ c\tr]LrLriS tlrL rr 1l' \''r.t I "1 ili! (io rtll ll ' ' r' I l- rv.ri|t.l rr,ticr t(, llri crrlr,rrr(( nrcrl .r11t'i (nlio I rrrrl r rl 'tl th'r1 Irr tlr' .rli.rn.rt,\( il thl'r..,1:r't rrrs t'r rrpl"'l' ll'( LLrr\ !lrL\r' 1rl ' i\"rIl\ 'rrl' I !v,r( not,r rds. \1:hr.h nrcrit,\l .rrr |rrlr' rtrLrrrLrrt .l srrrtrrrr(' rolrr ilr' irrrfris(rrrrlrrnL lo (i( 1th.r5 rr::l1tl1't\rLrrrrl l)\ llr( lrr'11 'oLll-t lL)l' illi rrrr\t'rr' s,r oLrt irr llrt irrrl,rrilrrlal l,r(1,'nxt1t lrr sLIi)ft)rt r'1 lht ir' "'nlrntr{ rr5 ll'! place.l rtli.rrrcc on tlrr..r\.s r'1 Allah lvaLlhayo r"l he Sl'rtr (llll r Yl'l(: ll S!.d,rA,slt.rnvSverllarukhr\lirJ'l l):rllli-rrr(ih'Ilrl Nltrh'rnrnrr(l \'if (21)17 sL Nlli -ls(rl Noor lvlrh'rmmr(l ! The Sl'ttc il() li) \t N'l i v'fhe Shte llll(rj, i\lulri'nnid(l lih,rn \ !l.rt'l.r It:rkhrh lrr'rs\( \1li r'1rl' \luh'rrrrrnrJ L(r' I(lt,rl v lhd Sl.rlt il()81 :'( [l]i qlLl). Atrdul Iih;liq \ lhr Slnt( ( :n \llt Iilrl. l\{.rjtcrl .rlias Nlijtedi v thc St;tlc (llrl9 S( \lli 11rl)' /\r:1h'rl

Ali rlias Snbah \ Ihc Sl.ll. il9'll:-(\'ilt lrlll) Ashjq llLrssarn 'rli'r'' l\'ltrhanrnrail r\51'r.tf t lhcst.rtc(Pl 1) l(r(rlr'( s7(ll Sh.][i)'rzl I]rcstnt' (llllri !'( Nlli 17tr11 i\'tst. Sullh'n lrrtunr U Qisier l'trrc'/ f-lill-':ll"lli llll), Nrsl. t{ukhs.rrla llt,lunr v S.lii'r(l rI'd othcrs {:(ll7 5('\1li 'iLi'i Ashiq Flusrain ! The stat('(l('(rl s( \1i( 1l;r. i\lr)hJnrrn'rd shnlq'i lhr strte (lr)71) SCN{lt Tljl !\.rq.rr AlrrnrLl r' hc St'rtc (-'r lir s( \l i lli('l 'l

Al(ht.rr ..\li v l'h. 5lntc i: )rS 'i( \lli '.1 AI,(itrl Khiliq \' l ht SlrlI Llr' ' \( NIR l-;;f), .\sf.rrrtlvrr ! I(nmrnn .lrlcl othcrs lrl lr' \( \lli -rlrlr N{uhtrnrnrr.l Asil r'lhe sl'ttr il0Lr'!( \1li lrir')' vulli"rrnrd I'..'\c/ ! \t lhc Slntr il'l.l) ri)ltr 'rt i'rr). AllJf lluqsnin \ lhe St'rte 1l'i :rLrl'' (]irLr r'rl '/r 'rrr'l Nin' {( r.C) l5i'i). Sotr.r Iitr.rn v lhc Stnl('1Nl li :lll':

l\luhanrnr.rd alids \irzi t' l'hcStrte(|('qh Jr( ' I l1q'l)

a {s ()r thc !)tl(f l-trrn!1. lrnr...d \.lLlilr'rr'rl l'r1''nrtrtrrf ('('rri'r-i1l qrntll ,r,ii Io.rInerl counsel l,rr thr (ornplainrrrl ha!'(' Irrll)' sLri'PL)rtL-(l rlr( I th'rt llx [-rLril ilI

inrptiglr('il $ rlll lh.'."rnllrinnrrl iu(L',trllrrt

i I t

II! i i Ir)

lhecrilIr( itrstiiit'lt l1*-L1rlr.r rt(rrlrrrl r':tlrr:'L'ntrtnIL'ithca1'ptllrrrlr rr Lr

lrfc irrrprrrtrumt rrL (' th'' ri"rrh fcrl'riti lr;'rrrliLLrlnr tlrc"'lr'rr' 'r'rrl'rr'r'tl th.rt [,.rs, rl i,rr ttre prr ii, trL.rr t.lLl\ 'rnt{ 'rrn!t'ln"s "i tlr' ' 'rr tltL ']' l" ' 'ir\ ilL l'rr : rr"t irlo,111rr11 th('l'lli h.rs I),,'r ullr crl"rrr:t'Ll 'rnrl as 'LrIh lhis 1r ll1 l.rlal t,' llre l-ro:n'cu"i(,rr (.rsrl lir.rt llrr (,\r nrtnes\\ r\r'rr l)r''tnl lirre(]l th. Lrr! i,1.'rrl Jrrll t)rl lh(irl'vi(l('Lrr('rsltusl\1'('rth!iir)Ll'rtlrlirlt r(( Irrspuirrli an.1 cilrl l)c s.tlol\ reticd trp'rn' tllrt'l l1(rur 'rrttl fl)nrirrtrl(s ril''f I ()L1ft 'rl I r' llre i rri!l('rrt tln tolice I'rrL! in or(lt r kr hi'l( lheir llrrilt orr irt \''r iol.l l,l,x,tiect Irlrrr,kr or tlre Jt.",rs'rl ["l13rl 'r l'rlsi' lllt I'c'rr irrl: li5l,/21)0S.11 lll Ii|Lrzat'.rLl ,rl',.irrsl ilr(' 'lr'ras(tl rr/s l5\'/lll"11 i'11 uhcrci.r'tlrt.rPfcilanr\.rr. .irrri(l .r'lnrl"i th'f'r'lr'! |.rrl1 \\lri'l]' llr rlt!:\ l n(llrlittcll llr('rr lr('."rr.. nt illsr L:rtr"rrr'l the\ 'rirneri t'r l 'rr i ( i' l"r tht' .1,.r',rr.rl irr s. il .lt llrre. LlLrI r 11 'rrr ' rr':oLrrrtr: I l:'' lr i r ' - :l

sLrLrsr:r1lrr:ntly .lrrposetl ,'l :n '( " r L'rss Lrr''' lln:' r''ls rr() Lr'r(1'r'r ' i(

slll.lx)rl lhL'P(rlitt \fr:J(rrrr'1 e',.rrts, tlril th' cridrrr'cLrr(l(:'i)rtlr'rL rir 1)f it.(usr(l NlaLrL lIsh,r,1 (rr'rr\ t(' tlte l)i('sLL\i' o rlr' 'l'"'aseLll '(irrliti€(l .trl-.clLrrrt\ at llr. lirlr(-,rl llr('e11(()rr rtr'r-$rrlr lhc (lctrrrs("1 rrlrir h r'rs rtr clralirnll'rl tr ,r,rl ,,1 llrr nLrfrl rrrls; tll'.rt irl '11'ss tr'rrrrirr'rLrorr :l ' .ri,peLt.rrls nt'v, r rk rricrl llr,'ir prt'rt'n.'"rt thc \'L!1(' ol lhr n)t r!i{'s; t r'rt

hoih ll,( .rtftlli,,,ls witlr(lre!\' \\l(l; frr.r :o thr I'riLl rr:'l r trrl,t " rc.ovcro,i .it tht'*-L'Lr,' nratL'herl Llrr :i\'l( ' \'hi'lr wr'r'c allr'llrrl i' lt rrr' ilr.rl .r ( l) L.ro,l!.('\l .rt lrr.rl shf i\(11 llrt.\l)|1 ll'r:]t T ilr'tl Nlir/ ' lli' I

:I

uter\,1,'$'.:riter llrr so t.rllrrl trr.oLrrrt|r 'r'hL'lr '(iLllrrrrr((l hr' lrL'nrtr' !rr

the ti,r( (,i ttlr iiri,1.11t. lh,rt thr l'(':r.ri'rrr,'l'rlr 1r'r'i ltr:1 rirtl t:f"L Ll1'I

the in(i(lrnL t1\r th(' l)t'Lr.r t.) srrlf(1rr llrt rr ';rsr thJl it N !\ n S( rtr r'\ |n.ount.r; thnt th. reroi L'k'tl Pi\ltrish'r(l l\ r r- i()i:l' rl t)nt!r' tlL\!'n""1'rr'l Is su.h the al,l,1!\l:i ngni,rst .orr!'r t Urr sLrorrl'l t't'rlr'rnlss('!l lrrrLrllr":1r their,Urrt.rrtio)rf tlrr'\ h.1vr rl:rJ ('r' llt' r'rsr\ "1 Anwrt Shinrirri rn'l nnothcr v. The Shtc (:i{ll\) H Nlli l'9li trlr'rhamnrad iUl'shta(l \' lhr' State (l'l I) 2tr(ll:;trP,('nr! L-('Lrrl l0;'l Glrula llussnin v Ihe Slnt' il'l l

20lll -\( (rl), Nlirz.r SharrLat ll.1i(l v Shrhi(l J'lnril L l(ll)' i) lr 1s(' I l rlrr

N,tchrnm Aliv l,cdcrntio of Pnkisr.ul (l'i ll l(,98S( 1115) AbLlul li.h.rlitl

v Th{- Stite i])r)',5( Nlli llisbj Shihid Zrirt v th( Stalc i:'l ll l'(

8l tj

i)'$), shir('kh I.ltoi !' lhe Slntc (l(rl() 5ll ll \rr!llr 1']15) NlL'lrnrrrnr'r(l l(.rfiq \ ln.rvrt,\li Ill!l''l'!r I f'1-) 1r ri ('hLrlJrrr l'rti'l \ lllr St'r1' i 1t).):;( \ll{ ()1,)

l() Ih('51,rl..lid Itl)t lilc anv appc'rl igaiost the n'!luittirl rrI tlrI ts. llrr,orrlfinirlrr1t hor'r'r'cI rrr"vc'l 'rrr appL'al '1!i'rlrtst llrt r'( .rPon( lr'rr llrL .1r(lLritt.ll oi llrt r!'sporr(1.:rrts r!lro 'rr'c"r'rlirri' l(' lrlol hn'l l)l'r!e(1 '\'xl saure tolL .rs th('rr)rr! r( l'(1 a1'1'L Llant' irr tht rrrrrrLlt'r''rrrtl L"rtc'i rrp''| 'L ' I ('\'i(ien.r the\ lllcir.r!(lrritt.rl sitIrrl'l l't 0r''r lLrrrr''Ll 'rntl llrtr :lNrrlLl t'i' 'rs llr| (r.n\,i, l,rl ,rn(l crrrh'F.(\l lirr th. !nrrr' rx ("i nl'1f( ll rnt:r 'rrrrl 'rL:' ''il' sr,nten..ri to(l'.rlh.()n theotll.'r hnr\l Itarn"l t'run'L'i it'r llx'rr'l,'rnJ' rl' Irrr.c.r,rrlrnrl\l Lh.rl lhc.rs, (,i th!' ri sprrntllrrlr rs rrrr a tlrt'r'fcnt l(r(rtinllltl LoJl(i Irrrl [a tlrai oI thc aIptllanls $'h,r !1('rL'('rr1!i( tc!l '1\ lhtir i)r('\t-n!c h'rrLn1; l'r' esiahlislrcrl nl lhe tirrr( o[ tlrI irf itlo[l dn'l e!cn otllerwrsc r

.1c(luill,\l by tlrt lrinL(otrrt th. rcs|(1t1(1('nrs 'rriovc(l a Jorrl'l' t'rt'trrr'1t)lrol ri inn(rt,rr.c rn!l n\ sul:lr lhe 'rl'f'al riilrllst lhc r((lrrrll'rL .l rl_r r(spondcnts sh()uld I)r' (llslnissr(L

Il l!('ha\rl1('.lr.l tlrc nrt,'Lrtrrc rt:i ('l tl r r''rILrtLi 'r'rr:rs' l :":' tlr' i'rrLr'' lr':' L--trrl rca'i "Lrr hr l'"rrrL'l ltoni'tlrr(,ugh lh! .nlrrt' e\ rJcntd r'lrr;h t.urlsel t! th! .PP, llnrlts..irr(l thc irrrfullLrc( iuJrlrrtr'Llt \'!'itlr Llf 'rl)' ir .rssrstan.r r (l h.r\'t' ,.rrsitl, r'r'Ll tht r'l'\n111 l;\!'Irr'irrJrrrg th' l'L'

rllrd at thc Lar

l:l llirsc(l ()rr oul r'(lrssessrrrerlt oi llrc ('ri!lcn'c oi tlre l'!Y's' r'sl].'l'rll\

l,\\r.\,,.triinr\<,<,tlrr,,thL'r(ilrri't:i('r'rrr{lLrrlrnlinrrJr'al r''foli\ rfi(r\'r\ ol hrlrlrrr blooLt arr(1 (rrrPtj('s nl thc sr Lnc lh' in(i{L€rni \"e lin!l tlti]r :lrL 'rt rL'r'"r:rL'll, (l'rrtirt lhrt /'irrirrl :rl tJi(,s!.ul.ioir lr,r Pr\)\((l L't',r'rLi 'r Nlrrharrln.'tl l.,hir, l l,.ridull.rlr (W'h'!(lrrll'rh) 'rn'1 \'1ulr'rDrrTrIrl lt'r'alrir ' (the dcc('.1sr(1), ()rt 3l I ll'21)tlll rt t)ltitl hLnrr'; 'ri hlr'rlr'l ltirr !\'rLitl li'rar' L'"t

lrNalnl \'1,)t,,r. rl1'r',' rrlLr)-Jrrcil l'i Iir'' 'rInr L'1 l1rlir .r'lltr i'rl- thr' position dor-s Jr( )1 scctl lo tre tlisl)ult rl t'v tl(' n lPr l'tnis I ui'rint to thc nPP.'.rl ngnitl\t (on!i(li0n t'v the 'rppelhtrls' lll lhc (Lrrrlliorls Ilt hilorr'(]:r 'rt' llrtrtloL(' (') \\(rr tirt rl"t'r'' i rrrt;r,i,rtJ irr 'r t',,lrr, r,, ur lrr 'i\ r!\ir L ' I rlrr lr' l:ir' "l ' 'rl i'r " tk't'rr" lt irrrl lrr!tl up(.rr Lr'r LlrL''iit' r';.'t1 a' rllt1"trl l'r. 1lr" r''r \rill 'riter

trt 7 lr0

L'n anJ ir llr' ol ir t,rlrl lrlrrorl l\ lh('f,rlir'' ar allL'r:rrl L'i llrr i)r():rt\ul irr lht r:ltrrJ'r I'l 1l ' lallt'r' (b) \^'lr,r \\'rr(' tlr'' folic' "lir\('rs irr!(':vr(l (aill lirrrr' tirtr"rrr(l io(r1ii ' rl tlcr-casctl I,v lircnrrrr '11 lhe

\.'' l r'rll'r'l'r"l'r"''r i"' ll \l'.r 't '1" 'rrr"' lr;s plr,r'.'rl lrr,,rr.l .r rc rs' rrrrL-l1'"1' iu l 'L lh"lr'rL1r"rr!r jrr\t t;x 'lflrLlrrrL' ir rt' l1'rn'r]\- lor whirlt 1h('! \r('r. ( i'rr\ r(tri1 I'ir I h( l.i[tr^ (rl r\Jnri!tr(ll\ lhcre $'n' n l{) Lirr rlL l'tr rrr 'riqrnil I lli \f il"'r11 L' l\ llt, .,'rrllr r'rr ' a;ir'r' lr' l''l.i'' '',' ' ' . ' rr''r

'' I ' .' . . ,

r'(r' ' .1

,,.,,,'*'.' f''''l\'' 'r" trr'l rl .- l"r* 'l "r rl ' 11.'rl''

I I

n'r!l 'i*r1( ir cir'. trn,"t,',u oi tlri\ 'nsc tlx'tlr ln\ lr'rs lrttn L'' Ilarnt'tl "t ,t nol I.rlnl to the pLrisir'trtiorr '-'r:;1" Ilris rvas Lr:c;Lrrc Lh ' ii ".1",,," .'., i' 'l o'rr\ ' r-r ' l"'r 'r r rl" l'"'r l'''rr -i'"i -'r

I

'",,llr' rrr"lr"t' l' ' 1'"t"''"1 'rrr I Il I l'r 'r\"'rl " Lr'' l,.r 1"'ir i'r' t'r tt ,",r1., ,,.,.. t""' r' i\l 'r!')r "rr' l'r'rl I r' r rrl 'l ' '"1" 't" Lr.r"r l;.,: ,, r,''. 1., L'", r' r" " r'r' t.r ' "rrrlirrlrl|s 'rl tlr'' i1(rrllrrl' llli l(, lhrs cll(,Ll 'L'i,', r\'1thin or)' lri'(rr''rhI l(l

$1.r, lr.,tll, '.,ir..1'r,'l"r .'' r" I 1'rl' ' i,'." ,.. , r,r(''r' I t r' 't' L "'

' I

lhL f\'lirt''rr'L"l trrrr trptctc'i l('ri'r:1t linit:fJ t'r 'o rlr'tLlL't i,,,",,,p t''rr lh( nxrrr rrrltriLrli'rl LlL'r'rs(l t'L'tn1: ;ltr rr ' I "..nt,. ('rrl\ whcrl 'r lr!r! nrr'1 ( L, .1,*,,,, t,t' tfL" l','Li., Lt'Loru hr! r"r\ lr lr'r:'

1\'.1s rlis'\l r11 thr lritlrnc( ol ll'rlLr'hist'trr whcrl thc tlt'Lc'r'r"l 1,.,i[,] lr,.r)r i, rl( , r'rr.r'' ,rrr'' 'rr'i llr"' ' ''' ]' ll I " "rr' tlr' \'r''r"rrr'' ( r'rrL \'Lr'r "" r\frli..r l.rlrrli" ,I'I'I',,.ILL1I 'r l'' 'r r": l'rrt I llrr t"rt' 'Lrrl ':' r'' thr l"ll'('l'lli ,r..i"',,,,' Lr'111t' lr is ou rr I:lliIN whrth tirr!' J(IrLLrlitrl i1 Ltrr r'r" 'l' .,"1U','.t'," "'l'ulinr h'r'l lt''rr r0Lrrr'l l'1 trc r'n( rrr) ''r'LL't t't whrtlr in 'tr"L Li \\:is lilcr Ll''rl'trr''i 'r" ilr('l'( a hr1:lt Lrr'l frrLr(t rntlLrrr\ rrrr(' tl\i irlL (11 I ,,,ff,,"i ,, ,,'lf,*i"i jt:til,,'n,lLu"'""' J1J Ilttt rr'rrrlr 11" i'"'111""''s irr lrr- I Ii'llrr'r ht w,rrrlLl lr.rrr'llrrrrilrt\!'1\'rr""l'rrl rr" '-t't: l'' 'n" 'r ' r'L' *11,,, lh.r *.,' lh(rs urr'l('r tlrL\! i \'ct)lion'rl tircunrslJr'('s " ' l:llr I " ti' r' ' iirr.l th.ri rlr, J(l.rv irr thr t' 'n1'l'" ' rnr 'rLll Lr" .llrr ir" r' 'rl,-, 1,.'.rr"r \\ll f-\l ' 1"'rrr' 'l"'r'"1 l 't r'tt'L\l L" ( I l( r',,r "'.r',, ..rl l'' lrr' 1"" ( rl'' r '" 'r' l 'r'' I ' I Nad*nr v Ihc Stal.r illlll ,,'". ,,, s'fui,n*-"cl 'rlins'l)ccnri { Nll{ 87ll .rrr,l 14.{st'q Ahnlcd (srrt'rnl llrt"rppr:ll'r rl: tlr'rl llrr ti'cr''rs'rl nt'r'' "il Il r'

(Lr)IlLrl tl('('rr'r't'l h'r 'l , ,,, ,,,,-,,. , .', r. rl.'.,'.\l! t llt. l''1"''rl'L'l llt' l"ll(' I'rl tl,, ,1,.'.r''*l 'r rl rt'r" ''rt": Lr' ' 'r' '' ' rn tlt:s tLtl rtLr r .,,,,'f i,,r' .ii'l'itrrv"d' r\q r-r'rrirorrrrl L'rrlLrl ',,.,,r1", .,"' 'l'' rr'\r'l"r'''l' '' !'l'1,'l:."1] trl.rlik ll\l'."t irnr\\' (1"'n'.Ll)l'rir1'l llli \'r lrrl l:.- lll'.h '\l rrIrr . ' ]r' ,

h(,ul .rrr,l lt) niinui's ol tlrr lrr( Ll( r\l 1r'/\-\ )l-/l:li'il l'l (

lhi\ I lli \.-.rs iJtn r:'llc(l I I ' ( ("' r'11'rL \1''r' tlr( l{lr(r .,,'1',1,.,rt,fl"..,,,,, 1{nth('rdr 'rllrcrIll(r"rsI({ll}\l 'ilnrrltL 1,.,ii,. ,rr.f,, \ rlt) I)l)( vllrrrlr lrl{ f L)r1 l"r:'111 ()n tht ()rL1L r! ('1 I r''

ttrt x. ,\

.l r \ ' , \ " : ' " ' ' r r ' I"r\! ("rr"" 'rrir r r i r r r

,r,r llli l{ l,rlrirr r. t ('j 'l r r tl" '\''r" '''fr r"r r r ",''rr'' rrrrr..k.r ol the,l,.cL,.rrtl N,ruI r,t llrr'.rrLrrsttl er',r .-ha! , rilL',1 ilr' (lrr(lllti,,rr oi tlr{ llli rrr'(''1l'ic NoLrl'l\ n lr:'ilr por"rtLl I\rur ,'rrlrrr r"r Il| I .'t.r,l t rr" Ilk l" Lt r'rl\" t r' rr rilrr't ' "t th,'r'n1,,rr. (,rr''tnllL'" \1.1\ lr'\Ll'\""lellr: \l Ir 'r rl 'rlll'r"lt.' r'r" ,,| .ti1,l rt illL' ti t rrrnrt t'|l thr 'rl'Icl!'rrrt' r\ r]' t "rnlrl i.irr'( "ut'fo," tlrdl tllc rrr\lnnl ltii i)(rirrll rrl*Liilrl''l 'rr1'rirr't 'h''rrlt'r' r" l"' l,.rs,:J .rrr.r iair ir:r.rtr'-.rt,.'rr Irr ln'i i:rrr !rci'r\i(ri1 Nlrrr- t!r' l'r'Lr1' irvesti!',al!' thlrrrselrL's ')r (itlrlr\ irr {r rnllcLl (rnLrr'rntrr ('\(:' lLrt' rn!esri;ntr(,r' r: olt, r l!\\ llrrn :'rrr 'rs rr'rs lr'lLr r:r tlrI L FL ' 7&'shrnol Sh.rni V Stntc ill)ll:'r'llvlli llii ri I' lll) irr llrr lolIrr"iLtr ' t)n ''t'tnlLn t,,t 7tt':' r,, r/,i '!''/r'! l!tt't'\'t' it' 'rrr\ir' "' i,.tt ))\ttttl l,' tilt\ ttliitt t'rtt'ttitl rrrr;" d'1xrr rr'ririli'r! /{r li' ,.,,, ", ', ''rr "" I' ,1..,,,.t.t.- ..r' t1 t " "- ' Li, ,nnt, a;r,, r,rlr( 7' li'l{( rrr llrl t'rn- 'iri"/ 'r('r;nr\ l""r ,ir,r''f,r,,f,,.t,'i l/r,'rr oi|ri trrrr'' srr(/r i"1r'rl'!rrl("r rilrr(r/ I r' l

' , 1:',, , ;,,. t.

' "1 .',":' ir':'\"tt '' ., ,i, ,,. ,' ,,,,; 'rr"' "" "' (

f! rrrrrr''rl " ri: 'n-l \''t """' " l"'' "' ,i, 't , tt tt. 'lr"rlr" '.."'' "'l ' " ' ' i I itt ,r'ionl ol rt'lt n,lt!ltttt:!t tltittt t:i ttb!lt| I ttt;t1!t)tt: r ;r rr'rr(l'rr " r.,,r,i. lx:,i ,r,,,1 ,.",t, ,,,,' ,,' tl, '4;1t ii,ttt 'tt lli" "' tirt rr1,1,,1!,tttt ,ri llr, tinrrllr'' In t\' 5') ti't t"t'tt1't'1)' ' ri,,/r',r',I,,i ,r/r/,,lrL , , r! '

Iellr.,r , rl' ,''r,::'r.rr :ll: 'r "rr: '' I l'rr'r'"' ' r'"1 'l " ' l I r'I i,,i',,',r,',,.lg ' -l ILrl rrl.r'i \''rl(l t(' "ri rrr:rriil"t l'1ir " 1'r' ir.rJ r,oL ilrt s',1,Ir'rrr'( irLrrt irtt('r' crr{ 'nsur'r' 'r in ()rder tL) (lei.:rnrir( th(' ntllr'rl 'riJ ln'tu'rl (lr''rrr1rst"r1'r ' surr,,unJIng ihr ltri i(ic t

Ilorrtrcr l,rrs(rl on lhc cti(l(n(c htlirr( rrs *c {hxll conritler Nhtllr(r ii" prn.""uli,,,, has prrrvr'rl it\ rrrtion ol thc in(irllnr' Nnrrrel\' i il *l'",i,"r ,u. 1,,ti.. 1,,r,rr Iit'ctl oa rhr rtr(e:r'(rl i ("11i hllrrrl mur-derc(l lhctrr rt itho rrl Iro1ocnliofl'

ril IIr,Llrvir's rll,'r'r'*!\r.r"..\'.r- il'' rr'l'r': r'1 11"'rl'' ''' ,,,,' r...1 t,. .1..,,'.., r, Ll l'.""t "t ^l' lcr '' l l'" r trrt'tl ,rn tirr: tirrt'.t{r |rrLt'rlri rr'r r:r"l uir('rr ir" r': 'I ' l

.i.i.1,,.,' r"rll.rt rPsl\ or\ tlr( '1'i11' n('" "t thr ( v( wrl:rt'sses r() tlr( ,rr,,,.lnr,,r ii',.'.l"..rrecl s'host er'rtltrrc'' lve \hnll 'r)nsrricr ir: J't'rr

(i)Eyc lvitlr':ss PW 4 ItJshir' FIt $ns th( rrrIllt tlr)11 c1,,,*jl<i.lu, (rl thc ,nl r'h('* r(r'n1 \'\:11' r' tlru Jtt';s"l r"' r' lris L'r'lrL'r t stnrrnil ,rr tir. tinn'ol llr( in( rLI'nt A'-coltliill to

L

.,,, :;.i::ux rh. dr'.ta'e'l harl arr:irt11 lr'rt11 Qtr''r 'L 'rrr'l .t,rr',.1 ,'t tlr, ,. 'rrrcrrlr')l lr' fl(:t "i llii -'r' 1' ' rr I l'

tltt + (,

|, r:l,l '\'(\^'(1'lr \) I ll\'r 'r:r'i it Ilr'xrh 'r11'l rr l"'*"r

,hrn) .,r1Lt ,r'.l i .r. tr,. lr, s.,- r., 1" "l "r ' 'r lr' I -r'l"r ' L'.rrl ,.1 ll,,'.h,'tr,.'r',slrerr, l"ftl rl' lr':rr"t r" r't'r , rr,' lt. 1.,.r , Ll ri''r. '.r ,.1 ''rr' tlt 'l 'L 'r'r'l ' l\ rr ' I lr'' .'r rtu ,'.,t. .'r'l . r'.r.' rr"l:l'' 1"rr'''l tr lrrr 'l rrr"'I *t,,.t, itr, 1,,,,,' .,rl.'rl :" r'': ''r: rl'' l"i'r'' l ' lrr'l' c,,rrfirnrc.l th. Pr!s.ni( !)l I'\\ I \itt r \lrrhrrlrrrr( " l r rl L

l,.rl,,,,r .:l llr.t.rnrL rrtrt \t1'r'tlr( t'rL r' \t('t'ir(''L rrrr'r11 Lr' \,r\\: thc folr(t' Ilct L)LLt trl llr' P('li(,. rlr{)l'rl'' 'rn'l "r'l' rrrl '/ rrr' to,:ci,,it ,rt liis vchrclt: lnrrr rl()L oLrt or lhr'''r:' $illr hr\ r,.,,ilr',.,,*.r llesdwUL1.ri.lrtll.1h!'l1t)r"rssittLnlilnllrr{l rlr(' L,l,|\'rns s,,l .llj. r,L.t 'rrrl ot rh'' ' r llt'\"R lrrr' 1"'l " I

ll' \'r'r r'l"r 'l tl I "rl ,,,, ,,:, /.,rr, *1,, r.ll ,1. r'rr i r.rr"l' i,, r,,.f. i,"r,;*t somc lt'hi.lci irr rh('sh1)w rrrrn' Lll)Ltr'itr 'rll v!as in ulr,tl aLul trL' sa,,r crnL PolitL rrl't1l Ilrr' 'rL("rr" hr lr Nlulr.rtrtrrt:(l lbtahLm ,rrtl N'ltrlurrrrnr(1 lalrir tli(l n()l olrt {)t thc vchirl,j. llc nlon! wilh I'W N4trh']nlnlr'l \r(l'r thrrr (1)rIlr'rLrr('r]s tl ' \.-cnt (iolvrr shirs an(l sd!'/ (h'r1 /nl r 'rrrL1 hrs nr)t lr.rvr' .rlr\r !r't'al(rns l\-ith tltr Lr1 Zrrirr u"rc 'rl|c'rr 'lta' irrl hr's.ru, ir.',,,;'-,i,re.1 lti rll l'rkrrr t(r h')sfrt rl lLlrLlr' rlL\ ihr' in,:j,lent lo the (t)nlllri]1J )l in for\(']rr n r[]rl' '(r(lr/ rvhorr lrt._atlle Li' K.rnchi l Ir Ltlt IltLiLr(l lhL 'rccust 'l itL"!ltr'l .)r\l |,,rr",1 .'|.rr.llrP(''ar'r \1r'l1r'rrIr"r '/"l r'r'' '' i"1 'r ,., 1,.. , t\ '1..,,,'1, ..1," rt'.r' lr"'l r'1' -' r' "r I in.i(lert.

(' t\ it r's\ 'ls lrr \\ 'r\ I l. \rn. .1 Irnlrrral NitnP!r nIr(l nr '! 'r 'h']lr( , nrL,r,,r r'l .r. rrrclrr ,lr. s 'rJ.,r 'rr'l'rr' rI'' I'''r:''Il lr rt,.lr vchr.l, r.rLrrrlrr\'r .rrrrr llr'ri"rrl"'''rn' tlr. l"r" ll"' lrL.rrt tt'i.r t rir' -)r,'.'rrr1 rl'"f"l r'''l'"'tr :' -' "r"r'rl" rrl,.i'1 ,..\t il'i,.rtr' \\.1- I l' ' t\\ ll' l'rrrl)"'l rl'r "t r" lh. .lccr.iir(I. ili. 1''""'''tt" L'rrrrli'1 tt tl'rLrFi''rl r ' rL- ,,' -, , ",' 1r,.,'rtrrrr..lr'\ l'\\ a\r("' \lrr r''r'rrr'''l i,,lr'. .'. *,t,'"-t l'tr '"Lr '''rr'r' ''I l-- ' 'l ,'\1,r{'r()l tl',tslLit\'roimal\(r(irlli:rllr((i tI)'It 'I'Ii:' IILrr'rll' L'r' llt'' r' :il hrs.l10\\ki(1dr b(ri B rlris c'.( rvilLrrss Lnlir(l lrjIr

L

(1ct'ril\ t)t llx I r.L rrl L,l tht rnr:iL1, nt anel g.\t h:LI thr ltrll i'rv i rr.t, t"tut u-,*,tL Salrir whorrl(lr((l th's(r'r'('"lr"rllr dii('t thc in.i(lclrt alsLr s.ty thrs olt 'dltncs\ rr(rrni rl llri \(enP()l the inci(lerlt lhiser' I'rtnesswasn('l n'l r!'rl lt)nr\\ ol the (lu'e.rsc(1 .1ncl nu rnituriil Ius cotrc otr r"'rlrl trr s t"Lt if,"i f,., ft*f nrr)r r:c.rson tL' l'r1:r'lv irrrIlic'1ic llrr':rtcrr:cr AJ!nitl('ttl! i1 Lt.rs a rrii,ht l'rnr lLrr'itlcnt lrow' r" r'rt lr'r' " 't'' ,,n n'c,rrtl ilrat lhcrc wns lilhl ilonl tlr( strcct 'Lrr(l l'(' lrr rI

th('rchnler inclutlinil llrc p"licr rrr"l'i1"trtLl lrt r"rr or Lrt''" rlri,rl (lirt.rtlcr nua\, Iiom tlri inertlent rihLLh he 1!'rsIr"l Ll()\"rr uI)()rr llom thc b.iIorrt's.' lrL rrrrLrlel lr'r"'r'r':t "'' t' its i'r)lrr( l\ lr.rrl lr\ 1,..r.r, aL,i., l,:, s.c tllr'in(i(l.11t Lrrrt"L'l Ln t.r.' llc 1;rr c hr Lri'lrnc' irL I \llrrillrt l. \i'1r'L ,I.!rrnrr ,rnLl rlirs n'jt .l.rrt|rl Jrrririll r LrrrlllLrlr'"'' "1."1.,i,.t t;t' r'\.rrrrnntiln ( )rrlrn.trilr *L nriiilrt lr'rvr' (11'r"rl r" t"li1'tr'' (nr hi\ r\irlcn.r' e' hr g.rrr lri\ 5l{'l t l'( '\' $ sr.rl, m.nt . \\e.'ks .1[tcr th" rrxid('l]i lr'J\\'('\ fr lr'1't\i ( lr llr' (lrrr {rr c\.cPLiundL .rt1.l l',tIliiLrl'rr i'ril5 n11(l .'rr\ uirtst'rn!c'

III 1,9

have lttrr case as alreaLly riiscusseLl alrovc hc couLcl har:tll-v lleirrt n lnwl) clr"'lkrrl'1r t" Irr\'t''orn( l"r\^'''r'l 'rt\ilc(1 .ro'n,,t., ,t,,' ,.,,.', *'on ll! l'otrce lrdrl "lrcaJl rlrl'l'r'Lrl " .ii.r.r., , u"rtinn ri tlrr: cviritr N'1n'cl\" rlr"l llr{ (lucHrr\c'L lire(, on thc L,(,1:. c nnJ thP I$li''c Lrlle'l ltrern ir1 'rl l 'li"\J' llal hc tUuie l',)r\vJrJ hi'lli miglI hr!e lterr n pr'tv'' .lno", 11,,r' tlrc pclr.c wl" c.,rrietl "rr' thc artnr L on 1Ltr'' J.cease,ln'.1 a< s.rcl- urr'l' r' tllcse e\'t'Ptrona' r'ir''Jnlsrall' we clo not filrd lhe late re.ording of his Sl61 Cr'l'( th( st.rtcment k) be o[ any signitic'1n(e in so [ar'as it c()lrcerns truth ol the cvents whiril he narraled As slrch wc iirrd th' ,^,;,1"n.",)f this PYe wihless n:' tr('lcliabl!' irust !''rrltl)! anrl contielence insplriirg:rItJ $'c believc thc sarlre with rcspe't tr) the cvcnls r+4rii h urrIrLrle.l

Wilh resarll lo idenlilication of the '1'cused as ltirlg ih(' ..,irticrl.r' r,nlicerlrer t'r''srrrl .lt lln'<'( lr'' \tillr l'' erceptiorr .,,-rellant Vrr',anrnr,.l Zi tr'cr \\rrr're r"r'tretl o I Llr' tetr' nit"l rt,,,,,.'.t.uton,. ga!c.rn rlrP'vreu roCL() r cu'' er rl' ",t of tf,. i,..ia.r'rt jult aftel it had hal:Pcned antl arlmitled fuirls al llrc \ccn ve 1', " c llLtle it dnv weiShl lo his evi(lPrrr,'' i. iii. *gr"r .r- rroq.Jcniiri*rl"n para'le w s irh'''l rr''l lr" ,,ou" ,r., ti,,ti,, in hi. Ii,l f .l-C 'l,1lcm. nt d.1tl r^ 'r' l"tt' ' ii*i ,lil i.ull ro ('r'rc'tl\ irl rrirv tlr' 'rt' r'r' "n,firrtlivicluallv who hacl lell thc scrne ilnLl '1lth(rrBlr oii.",r.,t i" i,tentiiicLl all lhc accusetl in court ihe SuPreflc (i'uri hnr .lePIer iirreJ --) (ourl |'II IIIIiI('_rt:IiL a5 'r mea.l_ l" iolr\ '' ' I

a(cused in a cal,ital case.

-fhus, for the reasons rnenlioneLl nlrov. we tintl thc $'idenr! of llle eycwilncss 1o bLl Iellable, 1tll51"\''Jlthy ar'ld conJi(lL:n'r) nrspiring arrd wc believe thc sa re with legard ttt the (ase Namelv' lhc incileniunfolcling as Per tire Proscculhon ,r"fr." *'i,f',,r, provr-r.ati',r .ir'rng "r' and nru''lerrrrg lh' lr*",...,. rlotn.u"t we find lhnl he hd\ only corre(tly ij..riricd appcll,.t Muh.rtrrmed Znhcer rs l'rkinE P:rrl irr ttr" inciaeni who rcmaineJ bchind after llrc in'idenl 'inJ save an intcrview lo (;hO n('ws dt the 5(tsrrc *h'lr r" * ,_1,..u,"* *n. al'o exl il-,te'l 'tt Llirl whcrcr'1 Ix " r'11 1""1 I orr iirilrg i:luring the $,.dlte.l eR'ounlcr r11cl we 'au cr)llvi( thc c"vidente ol this eyc $'itncss alone Irrovided i'r rerP'rl oj appellant N{Llllanlllrcil l.rheel tl'e'": is solrc'()rl ollrofilli!€'" orr lh( ,'i,i,1r,rrtive cri,le,,,,c. In this rrsltcl reliarrc is Plxcetl cases t,f Muhammad Ehsan v Thc state (2006 SCMit lil57) As also founll irr lhc cases o[ Farooq Khan v l he Stats (?l)l]tl SC\,11< 917) .lrd Niaz-ud-Ifin and nnother v The State and lhc .r,ottrnr lZilll SCIMI{ 725). ihat whai is of siSnili(ancc is quality i the evit{cnce and rrot its quarrtily and in this c'rse qualitv we firirl rhc cvi.lence o[ this eYelv]tncss lo Lre ot good

(ii)liye witness l'W 5 Nida Muhammed l [e was a lrusiross i.1,,'nuh,, *us aitt' in the rPsidenlial llarl ol thc shr )r "tai'ing r'r roorrr ltrving col e lloln llalo'hislan wilh Maieetl ,6.12.2008.A.: ording t() his cvrde (-t, or 27 12 200t1 rh(

dere.rscrj arrivcd in a'fovota car ll1rm Quctta and stave{l irl

the resitlential Parl of tlrc shou' room Thal t'lr tll(' lrrllht ol 3{)1221)0lt anil 31-12 200{i he u'a: slirvinll In lhe resi(lerrti'rl r)rrt of the sll('\^r(r'rrr wlrPrr .rt J['out I2'1{) r"iilrrirllrl ten^ee,t (ttl'\U,rrrtl tlrtrl5 h,'u|s he Irc'rrJ ir lr'n11 lronr i)ulsrri( the roarl antl therr hearrl sr!'.rdsountl ol tirinll' [lt'cantt out of his loom atrrl snlv lhal /nlnu!1din'!' car lvas lyinil PnrkeJ in Ir(nrt ol th(: tFtc nn(l Poli(c wert' lirirrt', on th'11 c'1r' I le inJ Maic.:tl thcn v{rnt u1:-t" llre I'atconr anti sau tlr' |)"1i" severely I_rrrg,,l'lrlr's c.rr. llr.lt tlre l:rirrl' 14rl- \o c(\ur( that it liit diff;rent cars in thc show room and broke the gloss ol some ot thosr.ars. Flc saw 5 pcrlice [ren alight fiom theil' mobil(:4 ol whom weft in urrilorm and duly arr)e(l with weao.rrrr arr,l rc,rchrnf nenr the ( dr "l '/airr who tol'l / t'n tr' pct lur of the c.rr'. 7alt ,,',t'. out oi the (ar wilh lri- lr')rr.lt 'r',ri.".t ,nA orre 1,r,lire rltnrr Iir1'd on hirn arkl /drn ll]cn lcll down. Utraidull;h in ordcr to savr hinrsclf wcnt tou'ir(l: th1

pdte u[ ll'e sh(tla room wh'r llre l'clrcc frrc(l trp' rr arr'l lrr t ll iorvn' [ht'reattt'r' rrrarrv lr)ll(r' l"rsttnlrr,l 'rrr(l rrrt rnhr'r'r "l rhe Irrl,l ar.r rvr'ri in(l he.\l!, t!t'lrl ,iIwn <Lrrrs wh'r" 1" s.rw th.lrZrrrr ha'l .lrc.l,rrr'l Ut-'rr'lull'rh ni'' rr'1rle'i llr s'r'r' tlrc r1,lir, r,1k(' lB'(' rrritrr.\l Irer\(!rrs lo h't(Pir'rl M'1li r .,.".it. nt*, n,r'""4 nnrl th(\ lo.'k llrf rrrlcn rc\^' ol aPltll tr'l ivttf,o.,,,r.'t Znlrt er \^ tN h(' Puintc(l orrl rrr t |rrrl Hp h.is (orrot,oralcd I)!\' I clc !villres\ B'rshlr ln dll lll.rtclirl rcsDccts. The same corrsitli raliorl:' aPPlv to hirn rs I(rr l'\\' lla;hir ir thdl wr'r'clicv,'his evi'len'e 'n rcsP( (t oi rlL incidenl and his corre(t identification ol appellarrt Muhammed Zahet'r at lhe sccrlc of the inciderrt'

Thal lhe appellant's/pt'lice proJrrc' no r:vi'ilrrt' (4ratsoever tliat tlre-v actccl rn self delt'n'e u'hich 1^'1! initiillly there case in the l:llt ll'hich they loclge'l i'r( lrour .rrrri lw,'rrlv ln,llutes ailIr the nr irl' rrr

lve h.r!e littlc cloubt that thc.t\()v"rcd PisK's were l('iste\l on the deceasetl .lrd w(rra osl likely use(l [)Y thc Polr'c rl. firint, aL thc dc(eased iTence the rcttve'-.y of thcir emPties al the sccne especiallv as lhe eYc lvitnesses llave specilic'rllr no stated tlrat nrr Iirc camt' from the deceascd side 'lnd wcilDon lvns with th('rrr. llri\ howcvel is 'n'rrc Il 't i,,1.i",.. on (,ur D.rrt rniher thrrr l:eirr1', bascJ on l\Jr'i evidence whillit tak;rg th(' P.rrti.uLtr iacts an(l circurrrqlnn'cs ol the c.rse inlo aacount.

Thus, we find lh,rt a Policc Palty fired on dnd murdcrcd a the deceased in cold blood.

Turning, tcr thl: ncxl issuc of whcthcr lhe apPellants wcrc at thc s(enc and firetl on the deceased without Provoaation'

lr.] .L

(d)()rrr starting Poinl is lhe rlelerrco casc r.1rsecl by the aPPcllants as revcaled by thc'rr cross examinatiolr (n I'\t's an(l irl thcir s:142 Ci.PC statements lvhillr ilr efle(t is not that ihc incident LliJ rr()t takc place [)et*'een lhr Policc .1nd thc cleceasetl by rvar ril encr'rurrter/sell defenc. lrut rathcr thcY Playell no Part in the en.r,urrter helweerr th('l)olicc,lnJ the decensecl ds thu) wrr! rrtti frescnt at thc time. So it apPoars that their detence lasl' rrr(r!rr'( ironr ofie of s.'lf clefense to one ()l lr()t l)cir11l PrPselrt 'lt tlt(! trrrl('ol thr irlriderrt

(e),\s nlenti(rtrc(l e.lrl:tr irrrrrr"tli.rti lv 'rll' r llrrr rn'r(l{ nt th(' h('r!l irl rlrr |,rli!r Iwi\ ll,e Lr,,r J,iLast.l \lalrL lr': ha'l il'r\ IsliIt ' irr'

:,L.ltLnr!nt wlrL'h l')rrrr''-l th'' I'.r'r, r'i tlr'' rro\\' 'lsl\r{r: r' I 1151,/li,{)N l1' (oLrtrrrl 11lri( I : st L (rrrl l'cl')v\' 1'l rl('' t'h. u"r: fr, s, 11l al tl1. trrnc i)i tlr('.h('()t ('ul r^.'ith Llr' tle'i 'rrrrlr 9l A rl,!M,J'l u/s.1:4 (lr.l'.C. ol s l. UI!I.!L!!{5II !.l llLl!!I]N' iirrr/. / SilIl.'Srl'] ,\l,rIl, irslrir,l /1rr5l]ri,r l'trsl"1/ ,// ?1( i ( f''1r/r/" d.( o,ttlt ti l tt ilh st,il nnu'lv : ttL: /9e;i \oor Mt!htt'11tnnl \hnh lC/lll'i9b T hoor Klitt, 17tt0s /.r.lteet' llirzn, boanlal in tfliti'tl N().llL7o2t, dt l,n ro'tn'l bs St, lot iaarchltt:j ol.rnr "!hi.l.

Ir,.-,1t/ -6:)(', i\Idktt lttVoln t'orcll!, b!r'k 'olut. l'("4 I'u\v tti 01).r(/ /,15.. r,,r,in,l ,ri i,rrr,r i l(r.r'rir)r{, ilt"l 'tL ttt' \1")nli'r!l rr" Ii

!rtllt !n)r tint ,l,tttlttltt !r)t)t lrlntltt)'n!\tt i lxri0rrl,il'j r'/rr ;'r. i'ili rlr)l) ,\l,rk'r- I I irir,, /' ,,'l,rrrrl rr'' 'r';rr,rnri l il()rr' rrl'Lrir illtt')' t')tt ,'i'rr'r,. 1,,.,;r',i,,, rri ,,,i !i,rrli',i rIr,ii rrlirrr ll'' l\r1l'r' r/i' 1r' rr 'i "il ' l,,,rr' ,rt t t! l/J1tl,t,rtln,rltraitlti,t,titltit.'r,,,ti:lttt I l;,,,i r-,rr,i;,. .r,,r i,l,ir,(11 llri\tJt nili' irrr,il'i/, !rr. llr, rrriil rrrr rrrrs \lirrrrlri 1rll r;,,r,;rrr.,;,rt Lrar,,1 l;rrr t!irl,rri liri,i rlirr.':irl( i'r \lrr/l'i"\l'i"^ il/rr I'i r,i.. L,,,,,1,, ttto1, tl1' n.. sttl 11rt5o'tt tt':di't 'lnlt ['rtn! nt polirr pfittq, ttt,ott t,hitlt, ;n tlu 'tU nllna', nult l'inn;i 'nconpaniil th. brthl'd i tltt'lut' iL,ith stdl1., Po,1 'hi(tt, frso s ltrrane hixrd, .l'ii r('ssc.l l,l/ So S tl?at lhttl Itt'o rr' rrrs''l 1" rsr'rt' ,li.l.t', ; :Dnt nhit( ttt'o 11..'*,1 l,?rn'* !t'tr rr rt t h ittitfftn cattliliotl, t11 lit ltitkit ol tlit,t,rLLu:nl ttAtttts, n&it\t1 1t1tl)i' t:tt! nt a,rr,lr. oar' rr',r' arlrtr,rrl rrrrrrrl,'lt,] ii) l'.r,' rr'rrl n'itnin! l\\i ti I rttrt tt i'i.(' -l2Ji n,',1' n.lriii rir/ rr;:r i,i rr',rrs.'l tnt ttttrtitri 'r'' i"'' ' rr'' turtt, ,t: l1l,t:,lttti,l, rr'/rrrr n,'rlsr/,'trl /ii. rrrrrlr,'r t']l rilt1l rr| t'i'iri r" 'r"l 'L'ltir 1l 7tin tl t\'i'itltl tt tlt'1 lis'tt'''1 t)n ttttttt..:!.trttttrt!tt'"';;'i it"'' (;rr'\rr' rr l/l'r i\ ilnltttii. l'1:tr lll,' "ii.,i /i[l;r]'r i,ir rrrrri'rl' rrI rr, ' 'I r' ' I 'l li,/ir,rl.lii lr:,'i,l,rrrr,,1,r'iir,tiil,'1 t': :iti\it."'i)ti tttttt't t: r'';):i) . /rr, ,/1 s tlt t11, tt'tt \ ')l l, liittt iltt ,tr,l /tttt tti /\/rl)rlr('r''lr rt,.'fr trtL',, r',1. 1 \l /i f l/'!rrl ittt'tt;trt, t,r' t':, t) ttt\II'lI\ III iIIriIIl /II 'rIIiIIl ,J:', .,.\lj "'".,' "r i' i ';

r,(',({'x' .it'11' ', Dl !n lttttnll 1io1'!lnl !itto rtlt 1"ilr1t rttrttli inl1t 't': i1r'r,rrr..l 11.!istrrtr,j,/ itnlilll)-00') ,\lirAl'r /r,v,riri (i,/.llllr,.\ll. i'llr,1' rr,l,r.l !,.rng,,,r:i,1, r,1/ i,' sr/r1(i, t tlh'tt t)t,'it 't.t.rrtr rril''rr rrrrr'/ ':r'i I -i'l'\.tLtti 'i','..;.,,.,cr /'(-, l/rr.'r(1,,/ rI, ( rrj.,l l','rs( ,Is ,r/rt ;r'r ;,u-..,,.,',,,,r lij':'J'il la1) At lst)rltttntttt.,,.tltsltnl'tt ::tttl l" th!lV ' !':'

atit "llt" tlt!'ttt!r "ttt ') itto dttri itt ,,lirr/',,/r rlr/ L,rsi'. i/ i' 1t\4'tt .' , 1 'r., .,;,' .i,: r", " . i. if i, , i'r S,l,/ ll/']7Siit r,\Ii,, ir ,i,,,,i

lt5

Ihr:r S.l5l Cr.t'( sLrtrrrr('nL nllh(rugh inlsr irr t'rrrr' t'l r\lr'rl rr-llrsr,lr,'.'. t t:, ir r" lllr"'l " lrl'):c llrr r '\r"_r" \rr ' r''l " ' 'i., i'; .,,'t,1,.' ,r . .,,r.r ,,' l"'rr.l' rtr Ilr \''"r \h l'I'rrr' -lrrh wrr( t'r(!,rrt .rrl ,t.i',,'l lr," . . t ' r ' I rrr'r'l t'r""rl I , I . ' . I .t. ,'"'r l, . "1 I , l, .. rl,.ll \.lrr' (r "l ' r' li r" "" "-,'.. rlr h'' r"lit'l rrl"rrt Ii'\ I ol srrbsl.lrllr\ !' t_, )J{'r\'c 'rrr'l r':rrlir'' thr! r\'slttl r'LI! 'r'r' c,,rr,rirL:rirtrr.,/,rri,'Lrlrst.r:rlr r\irlr'rr'r ' pl.r,,rl ,,, rlr. r,rsL ol l\tuhanrnrcd Akrrrr V Sl.'te (11r0(r St N'lli 1r,. )

rll ll'L r'\\l l' , I ''i'l"rr" r" 1 ''t' rl'' l''*, -' ": I ,r . ' ' t. t l', *"r, . lhr' lrr}r' ' ' tlrr' \l rr"rrrrr' r' llrt t\ Lr"rl'L' l l . rr r , r

\\'r' rrr" l 'i' r

,1,ir.,, ..,,r , .l , r'.,r .r'' 'rs'11 i\lr' k lr'lr"l r'h" (,i the P( )li!c p.trt\ 1r'1.1r'lhL lrrnl .oLrrt'"\'hi(h is\r't ''trLrr\ lrrrrl('r'l F\AMINA I I(-)N lN ( !lllil: OI S.l. !'L\l-ll( IRsl l l) I I LSSAI\' '1.1. 't.,.. 't': t,,tttt ' " ""r "' ' '' At tl lltr!il,'t'V l,ltttlri;rl. ,il rri'(rr'l )il)l) lttt i!rtiLl t't1it"l tni"t t!t"\t rrr,,,r rr.ir,./r'rr i\rrttnt !,1 irilt'(l ,ri Irr ttt,"ltttl "l tti ) \ti1i!l"t! lr.1,,,. .,,' "\";' ' '.,,,'i\ " '.'j ,

1.,"'r''"" r;' t.. .'u "'i''r' ' {'" "''rr.'. ""1 " """ t't ltt r,,'ir,,'{(rrir.i il'ltt\i'lti} lttlltt)tttt'l ! ilul r 1t''R;'\'t'ttt)t'tti"l rtL 'ntht1.l t t ilittl,.r)l',til,,lrr,ll' l'r'r l"r ri''r 'r'l"i;;l/ sirr"("1 'r'rr ' r'rl /r'r'rlrr'rr 'ir;'l r"'r' I1' l/ rl tit{ srtltttLl ttt llttlt ttilr,.t\l rrrr' r/s l''r (ci' ''1( I Lrrrri i'r,,1,li1. t;,,r.1,,,,, t !,11,t'l t )t,tL rti1,ri''"i i''l"r'I"rr'' /,1r'ri t ' t' /'\ i { i , lit.lt '!)t'.. t"\i nr !tt t}t )tI r'l i/rt lrr,]'ri.'ii 'rl11 t : t } t t t 1 t'ttt' ': t'! j t !11

t) )t lt:J"t l llt ttLllt ,,tt. lirrr,l ,ttlctt,t,:tttt!'rtttl'ntnlit t t t : tl t

tt

t t t t

I to sli!ttlt'l i ilitl ldtlu rt"ttptirts ulntt Q lt( s.Zd-htrit l\liittt, /.nhr.r \litzri nnl II( Norrr Shrh' ih-nrt li" Ilt itt t;,,,,t,rtt|r,,:rtt tttol'ilt tiilisltnthtt t\'o'St'-7020' ltoc lcl tott'lttlr in l"tt ,t-,-t qttnt. ,,, ilu' ,,,r. ) ;tttt,tttt'l ,ri/r "r'rrri i l'r 1""'r" ,'i, ' ''' '''r'I;'' r;'''''

.,r ',t.r,,t, .,r,, 'i "','' 'r" 'r"' " " i'i:' i''/

I

ir',,,,'lii,!!' l.,rr rrr,1r II,Ir,IIirII,LI l"' lirinr'rr1i ltt' 't!'il'tti: t!\ )rti , ,l,, iu', , ,,,,1r,,, I atii ,t'1,,, rr (l::rl"'ir'/ i'l" i '''''r ' 't,"t''l !,)l\t|rttit,t litl llr' ,,14't,' t,rl, i! l"rrrli t"tt\tlils !t'll1nttttttl\"t nt it'ttll tttt.rt,o:l;rlt,'tt 'i1i,iir',i,il l1t, ]t! .l n'ni i lrlttrrr'r'/ rrrri "/rrrlisri \lilirr ,',t,1 n,tttttl ttth tttltltott l/r,']1 'rti)rr'(l irrr i! rrrrlrlri rrrir)r'rr' llh ril\"' tt\1tlia)1, tt!ini1 ih'. r tuLilltrt tnt lrvntn tt'h'[lti t't'ttt ir'r)t l"t'ltlltttit\it (rI .:ij,,, ir,,.,r ir'.,/r,ai gil', rr (r{,r,Il l(' ,li'I' l/!.' 1''flix :rrlli'rS II ilrir r rt ' , . l't",t,ttt ,'i ttt 't''t '1tt I' I'/ 'r"r \r' I !t 'it'"'.

',.,.,,1 lrrirIr'l :,r, Ll,t,r'l' rr;r',r ,'rr,'rr,'i'rl' l1l!"'r i/rr'5r'ri/ r'tr tt;L'1t''Li t 'r"rr u1'L'tt t'' ,unl, \.. t. ....r I ,,,1. , ,:r.. l\,,, ., t,-.' lhtu ttlnt)t ti\tl t'tlttlnttir ttt'nPtt,t'tiqI'i-/t't'tt')''t'rl/ttltrrrlti''ttrtt"rr- t',,p,ir i'].r, i tttr';tntatrrt.tit ol-ttu rdil ttt, i 'tll Lltltllit- lir ir r

i rtitt,tLtrrPts,tt:,r,rr'Iriirrrlirrrl. lrrrrlr',r'rrS'/ lhtrt '1t;'l i 1ir' :"i ttttl:tt'l ,rrr r,rijlirLrili.{ litt trttt; it'tttttt: ril1r'Ir'ri'' /ri' t"r11 r'ttri:trt\lt r,; r', rr,l. irll,i . I r, , , , . I i;,i - .','rr li l ir t //r "r"r''l' l J t r r , I I i , ; I I ,

J

)rr"' /,ril(,ls irl tr|ttdtlrt,'i', llrrrrr'!'irr,'i"r:i'!lr'lrlltr!rr' '1;'r tti"| li lttt ttli i!,")';!l t' Lr,'n! t" 1 'ltt\'l\'tt 1!!"ttt !l,') ' tit'it 't,tttt i,,,/, ,rr ri,r ;'l,rr ,'/ r/r 1r;L'ir,'rri 'r'|('r'IIi'I:L 'r; Ilit "l rr' i"rr rrr'/1 ' \rI'r ,,,,,,,'l tlu','l,,ir'tr,1 l'L',,'tr'' ti|tt'h\t'ttthttt /i' /lrrrrrr/r /jt)tirrl'rl irr ri'tlttoI ti',t,itt. Ihtulit itt\l'ttvl Ct t'C slntItlullt rtttl s(ltt lh? st1

I r{, I b'r

ttr,,., hul l'tlt,t \ttt!t,'tt'i', rrtts/rrri rr"r ": ttt' i'ttttt th' ll^ \r,. / J,iPlrlri, tl,!.'tt't: ,rt',1 I t--'-t/-'ttlt\ tt'th rt\t't'tt'l ru tlt' tttll ltilt" I ttt i,,rsi. ,, ,r,v ,l1',r'c sl ttttt'tnl i !h 'ttitlr) ' t t'tttrr l''al' tt il"iii 'rl I iirlj lr'1r' -il;l-1,/).i li,./',lnr' ''rti;'l ';r:'l i'r:sr|r"l'l;:' It'u, .l :t\- r, 1,.. ',,r'- ttt'tt ''t:'rl o.!t't"l ,ltl'tl' t'''rr"u' i'rrttt'l l\t ,t,tt l\tltt-t-l\trtu ttt lllc lttl nt i'ttt t\tl 'tql ti1" n1r!i':\1 'tt' : " .,,',,i;,,,t'ti "f i.l'lJr;jri'i rri rrr rr'r:rr,irri t' ,,r,',.,/,, r,."' '"" ",,'' ,'.'r 'r I ;''r'!r 't,, "t r."t ""''" t '' '"tt '1 "' . ",:t. r.,r:,,, ':ttt "tt|t -. "',',l r r"" "'' '1"'':""'"' '""' 1'.t,,tt tlh rir,' t ""': t;,tt ',ii'''l ';"r)rl lir,' r';r't'!lrf'rrl ri,, I ii/lfjal.\ /,r l jl i./')illl,r. i ir rtt'l ittt)trrliti ,rr'!i'"/r/ir 'r n"/' rr"l , ' r, j:ri, rrlli'r"'r ' tir r ' ir':r'l"r''r 'r "l/ '' ri ,,,;i,l,r, , / ; , , r 1 , r i 1 r r r ilri

i/r,'\r,',1 /l'r,r'lilir. rrrrlr' r|/r rrl " '1'L 'i: 'r 'rrr';"'ri 'i,,',,r,,r,' ,,'ii,1/r'rS irlrl ))rttt!-ii) ittil"rr ttitrttttt tt't)'l''tt' t 'titt'ttt't ,, ,.,,, r I , Ii , , l, , , ,',, ' ,'i,' ,li, ii ' '//r'i"\t'tttt iir' /rrrr Lill i'l 'r ir t"tt )1t:!"t'

,r l. .'it[rr,'. rr.r.'' t' r.'t]r' Nlr Llr :rr'r''('rr\ " ' - lj'rl' 1,.,r,. r"rr,r'i"'l r"rr\ ('rr'r'f lli ' li "' r''nl ir' rr 'i'.1',t*l.,,tt ,",f irrin,rt.s.rlt.'r thL rncirlrrrl eonsislt'd of thc aPt'('ll'r'1ts ,"*p""a"n, LIC N('or Shnh lt 'rlso clrnrly sl'rt('s thit thc "tr.:i fircd upon thc (1"'nscd Orl(c r13in this evitl.'ncc "pp.ii.r,l," sh"rr' rht' l"'\'rrrr oi lh' rP1'll.l rrrt\ 'tr rl'' "l'i,'' ",,,r,.lcarl1 r" sc.ne,,lthc.rirrre.,,r(i'rrdLrtr)-l'r rrnlheJ|r'''rstd' I'l s.rrrr"r,-,1'.,1 ,'i'',.' ..II'! ' II' '': '" Id r'"1"r'r." ', ' \l'rrl'..'\ r'r , . . r L ' r " ' ' " ''r'"'l " i''rr ' 'l' ': ' r r

rretJs sl;-orrll \()frolrrrntiorr L('r 'rrr\ r1'liJLr(( lo tr IL't'Ltl Lr| 'r i .l'ho first l'ie(c ol l!1J,r, .rn rLnrmpr .t' lr'rl'l'' '"';'"

con lrrr.rt;vr/sLrpportive cirrLrrrlstrrtlinl c\i(tr"rc(' i\ tht Ithu ll{ rvlTich has t'L:"n rrljro(lltco(l .rbovr rvhi(h sh('wtJ "l'"'i'ty f ir irrt on the cjecrnt{'d' 1""r".* .f ,fl" ..pp"llrnls nl Lh('scerle '1lrd S{' what othel rorloborativVsuIPortive ot'idcncr is tlre'! ngninst thu .rpt'rlldnt\.'pa.t frt,,n thc I llt?

(h)lLr.tr SNI( lr nn(l nrrlrr.lurl trlrrr t& i'trr"l t" lite 'rt)l' llilrl. l' '"r \'( rr' Il1'rlt Ir(' t,, lh. in.rJcrrt .rrrtl III'' ('I)IIIII( t rLe'^ct'''l llirrr lhc th.'SNlC,s\\.lrl.hh.l!l[.ecl15.']/.ijtr{rlntl,!'ilrf.Ll.lIlI '1 ft'sitive |ll' rei'](r:i whi'l) lLrs iil( 'rl)i'ell'r rl'r t(' llrL'rr'rr-L '' L * .,','.t rt,,'nt t,,in11 ai lhr rr('{r:I I rL rltcL"rs*l 'rirlr'5r( ,:j .11. I I \\ { li r,"/r. l'lr"r I' I" :r ' ili.Lr ,)rr:]1 l,'l(Xis lrr \\'ns !lLrrr I'iri((' ' rl5 l'rlr7'1hr' 'rrrLl s r!t)I Irrtht (l\rt\ ',ilr!rr.ri I I "rr:r lr'tLr tr' rpptll'!nls r'rLrrL ' 'Li- t I\' L ii Llr.(l.sLtl tlLrl lhe" \rr! 1'rr fJtro' \!rrli lr'ir "l l() N1'rl i' l:\ r'r(l L

\\,lr,,l li,r.rtl \vhr'11 lll!\ lr'r'l 'r rrrrr('triltcr 'rrrri s'rrrrr tlatL'tl: rL'LrL' kill(11 ,rn,1 {'m( \!'rr( rr1l-rlrr!i Nritik I ('l tll( 'rprell'rrrt' ' lraLL' rri'ri tIrr-,'It{,rr,' "r 'l ' r''1rr'l'r"l"'l:" \ 'nlrr-'nll rrr' *''r' l"'''t'"':' 't: L ' l" "'' u:.1, l:, .r1'1','lar'.' nl''l' 'rlJr r ''il' \lLootLrril 'rl thL 'lrrc'strl 'rrr'i i 't'r I ;'"..,ri ",t.i t'i('k l\r:" irr ilr' tel,cs th"rr (lrirn rrr LiL'"r s lll i I l'i :i'Ll I r( r'i\ thrt llr( ' ':l ilLrst'1ll dt tlrI lir|. ()l llrc rn'i(lrLIt (rl\ 'rt ll r

(i)llrnt nl'ln ll,rnt \ltrlramnr(l /alr" r $''r; sirrr( rr 'rI. i 'l r'r','rr'\ 'r I'r'l 'r'"1' rrrl\1rirr""l'r r''!

'., ,. . i i.,. ',,l'1.',

,b I t7l b

lrrrn,:Jr.r1' rl.. '.,r.1''r " r"'Lrrrt'' nhi'r " r'rllPt' l'Lr'' 'r ,t ,1,..",f.r., f, n.r..r.'t t ,srr,t . ll,'*,,'r', "t rtr' rr . 'Lr 'i' .r1,1,, llant ,li,l r:Lrt ch.rll, nile llr;' i l) r'YlJ(rr'r 'rl lri r' ll( I\'" r,i.irrtitie.l hiL.,,thlh,'c"'chilnt"r\'rsthel'rLL"(ri:i.'r)"r\irrll'rL intL'r!iew t(r lhr rrc!lr,r itrsL 'ilcr tlrr iirirJ('rrl 'rrrrl it ilr' ('''rr('"r llr' ir, i(lcnt.

r(\tr 'l' \Ll ll', t.Lr ll...r:.rrrLr:r:.:,,.'t\.rr:lrIi.ri ('rrtlr' 'p|'e1 ''1"' ltr .(, ,,' t, 'r .l ' ). -'ll 'r ',.,,.,,'. ,,. .' .r 'l: ". 'r ' I " r'' rr"r" r' : l' '' rl 't "' rolirrd a\ n .L.rr dllr r th()LIT lrl

rlr Il, t r rl rr,.li. r, , r..l' r"' r"l\ ""r"1\'f'tl \ thr '\ rr "r ''' "'r 'l .'r 11,.,t, ".rr'cs.'.trI:'I rrr'l "rl "llr'r''lL 'l r'tlrl'r' rr'l ''t l,,r nur,.,,,,,, trnl,r\ ('rr \ rtil t'.1f| ')l lh(' t-r\lv b\ ti11 Lrr)r sh')lt rrlriih rs.r,l..rr LJl(:i..tlil' I ri ih' rrL'nttf iill th"'le'trrs''l I r-r' l " .l tI r ,\l-l ,,r'.1 lrr, .'r,'"''rIit' ' ll '- l" r",'"':"t' r,.,'r.,rL'.. .1,'.r 'r r'. r,r' .'l " " '' ' 'l' l ll' '" l r" 'r'' '\ r'l;

r..itilr(1 hi tll.(l(irrtr('(.r\r llri' '!,' rl' lr( 'r tr"rrr-' lJtl' r"r t."r "l ,,,li f'"inr, l,r,'c('rrt .11 rh(' iirtrr ol tlrt' LnrLJirrt It'i!!r'!"r rlr' - r ,rrrr.,,t .'., r,r,,, I' \ 'r' ",' rr -r'r r{' r' "'' ' '..i,:' ',. r1'. f'L\' 11 rl'L:' q '|r'.', 'l"iln" r"' 'rr' l' tlr ' 'r"t ' " tfl... . r,, l' ,i,,-.1", tt,,,' r,t.,r'j l lli r','r'. ':s"lrr"l "r''r'r'rr ':'rl l. ii,,i'.i1., .,,r',,'.,,rr.':' 'r"r Ir' r"''r\rt "-l NI'r,'k l: l'r'l t ,,,',.r.i.'rr ,'r 1,..r.'.rl'' ll "' rrri r\"1''''r rr" '' "r '\'l ,r,.i., ,,,.r $.r' rr 1".r. lr \"rrllIr ' " 'rr'''t ' \^1" rrr t() 'r'' 1"' r r" ,,',,.i",-.,,,., ,,, tht .lr.r\r'L1ui tl' ' i'ri-5 thr'qLIr'\liorr 'r\ 1'h\ lrr

r.,.1 I',.',t ,',i '...i,. f,, ! ,k rrl r' rlrP' r" 'ri rrrrr 'il 'rrli'I r(. i ,.,111(rLl.. r,lr.,! rr .l " rr "llfr f"li" 'lr""r $'l r'- 'r"Lr'r'' ,1,; ,'",,..,,,'iil 1,,l.rk( L'!LI IIc 'itrs rl(jt rrrLrltiorr lhi\ 'r\Lr\I'r Llrr ..,,..'i,, f,'. ,,fa.,,., rlr(1 rr!rt ( nll 'r' 'r l)l\;:hr l'('r!or1 :ri'rrr rlr' rr'r' '( .,'rrrr'.rrr', .r1", l', ',, ..' 'r"'l' ! lrr t,,rir.,",',,,' .l ,li'\.r,( r1',''rl ""' It 'I'I'I1 i|\'' '| '' Lrll ''"' th.rt ill thL nritltllc ot .r lr rlh spt'trl .h'r\c 1^rhflf h' l!'r' t 'r'L ' t.rrh.'r',r,rrl,l l.'l ilrr!{,rrtel .rr"r 'rnJ t rrrr l1r' 'rlllniilrrr l" 'rr_\'llr' ,.,, b..nLrr(, 1l( !l|,l\ri L(n,!'tt]:rr\l)r!r.us t!h\r tllrn lrr(s \lilhtlrrr , n,ri\iLr.'' .lr l'. -l ,l rrr'l' ''rr 'rl lr l' l" 'r'')t " r .l'l"tt'' i.,.,.',, ,rlr lrr" l1 'r'r 'r'"1 rr "r l' 'rl'llrlr''I "r'''l cl()o\rrd ltcrrrr torLr.L trP siihnrl'rrr(()uiltL'i lhcPr)li(( 'lrscharll'l (irncs ()rr !it'ri P'rrl' rrlnrl\'t.liurkl\, l.ler,'.r...1 *er,'.'a.h lril tci'cr'rl ,'i',li"it L,*f',. thc v(rlrr(I( irrwlli(lr lhr (l'''nseli \{Fr((\lriL'ri'(l tr'r!rlliLrrl irr l'sl .,,.oi*'".f ,,1,i,u,2i) lir( shot5 's e!jrltn'cLl I'!'rlLriv rrl.,,rt.rn(l lhL drrr'rtiorr,'n llri'lr tir" Lrtrll('l\ hil :lrt ir:'rlr Lr"t *.,nr t.r 'rr1,1,ort illt'{l.lrl1.. L.rs(' (r: r' 'oul tir lltlllt't' lrl r'rt' tlrt.hor{ r'(;i,r11 nrl(l fLso hil 'r v'all arr'l nrr !'lr'rrr(r1\' |r'l' 'r' .,r irlence.l 1,v a tlLr v , rhibilL'.l !Ltr irsltitit'Ll It t'rl t)\." jtrLl'(ir L lrrltl 5in1l''\ h'r\ t ,' li' Irt'rlrrrL,l ir' :Lril lr i I ,,l iicer l lr,,l,r,:.r.,,1 rrt rrr.rJc tLr \urr,lnJrr lr. l'irlLrl rrr'rrL\ L'rr rlr. mLrhi:'' rrL't' r:'r' s ()r(lcr l(' rr lal rlr' i a,lu ,.,f1, ,, ,, l.! l,r, ltli.r rll rrr';"1r ' rLl

,,irlrcu',,1'upp,,ir thr I lJk' l:ll( Js irrt('r''rtlirrlilY thc I il rrr()L)i1r s"r' ,"; ;,l,,p".t,,i nt thr s(.rrr irrrl il 1r's r('t nrrrtri('nr\l irr lh' llr I .,"..r'.,, , l','.r' ,r',r tr''' 'l' 'r'irr' r' ' r'"' lrrL :'r' r'lr'r : " '' ,i,, l' ,tr" Irrlrtt''r'l'\( ' r'r.L'' r"'\'r''1"'rl' ' 'r' I't

I$I )11

s.rrn' \'lr(, i!\'!'(\'rLi! !rr . r' ,r l)\! tlirl rrL)t n{)tirl nrlv htrll' I rr ' rL " r an\ 1!,1r.(' rrro.'iL lh' Jrrlr 'rhrt'rietl lsl rrPort ')n il'L irrr i" ,',,,h,], ,1,*t llsn rr1 trrrrr\ \rl dire.ti.rr irtrllet rr'1ri'J'n' rl'L "l suPP(rrt ilr. Poli't ('r\t'(ri '1Il e11({rrrnt('r' No ftrlice 'rllLr(t '\'rr thcilight,"t rel.rll',,1 lh('\'!h(rlrrIi(['cc'tc'L]()e not rlnrl ';.r.rk'h trrrL' .1ml r(:Lks oi n l.1Lt N(rrlf rrl lh' '1f'f'r'll'irrls ll'r\' ''r1'(runl{'f ('\ i(i!'n.( ('n,).rlh.rLr(l tr0Lrr (\f thcrrr lr'(\lLr(ul 'r sirllllL \\rlr)("c l(' f](,\( lhnt th(\'!,('rL ,l5L \lrtrr il llrr tirlr' L'l lht'irrtirl.r:r' tllLr\. li)r lh('ri'.rs\)ns rln'rltrrrI!(i .rb,)\. \i'lirr'l lhai the pr'rs'r'trli" ' Lr"' (llt , r''''r'r" rt 1' t )'ll'r 'l\ "r l' l,rr..crt.\'r,'rr. ' rr'-'lr..lrl(' r,'rr''t riri" 'r I I :Ler,., Llr| rr.,i,l. r.'rr. :l r l\' rrrri" 'r ''r'r'l' {lr.rns((l \'1illr rnL, nlrorr t(i .rll rvhich lr':'l t(' tlr( lrri nr'dii'rl( rl Lrrtr\l'r trr

thr (lr\.nr,r.l an<l as strth lhrir irPPorl\ 'rfc disnrisscd in(1 thc;r .on\;.:tir)ns.uc mrintai'red.

Lnhanccnl{,nt of Sente'r.c h.rn(lcd down t(' lhc ;PPell'rnts tronr l-ife Inrprisonnrcnt lo the dcdth Pcn.rllY.

(nl I hi' (,'mllainnrrt lr'rs vrirn-()rIsLf (l ihat tlrL' \rrrtrrr' c i )l itr".rpp"ll,,,iLs L',: e,,rra,''..1 lroll Iil' rnrlrr'( ' rrrlerrl tr' 1l' LlLnll' '{)nt('rr(l( ()l th' b rl.ll L)I"tried nlur.lrr \'l l"ti Perralt! r'n n.c(rtrrrt 'r'lLl t,',.',,,i ,r", rrlro ha.l n'r t'ri'ri"rlr 'r'ir:ri r'rl histi'rL i'r tht lr'1 ' srr.l1 L'nll.rnrirn1.rrl h'r' l'rtn vclrenr''Lrtl" '1'p'rr''i rr l'rrlrrt'l coLrrrscl l,,r' iht'.t'l(ll.rnts rvho Ir'rvL'Lorrlt rrLir'tl thrl 111( lr-rrl 'r'Lr '

lrrs ri1lhtl1' rctlrrir',1 LIrtir \( rtcrrrr'\ lLr r,rrr' Lrl liiL'ir)rIris.rrrrr('rl l.r*,lIr lL. rrrrlr r'.r.'"f "'l r' rr'l'l '"!r'' r'rl"' 'Il' 'l' l. .h. l|L.i '1, 1.,r., tl ".' r,'r'l L "l l" 1" 'l' r'r 'r tli',rrr.r'rl arrri thrl rr" rI'rlr!" Ln(l l'rrrr 'r"trt'-'J t)r fr\" \:r l'r LIL Pr,)sc!rrtLt)r, rt 'r thr Irrlrr'1':'r' is t rr' rll \'l I \i,l I r' lrrrt rlt rl rl rrr''ll rt l( r"_\rl'r I : "' I,r It't,"tt ",rt ri trl lh, r' r''l 'lr"ls "l lr I lh'' :r'rril't \'l Ll "r'l learl n rrlrl'ri ( ' rl., L'.rs,',i an.1 in sr,th .lrctrrIl\1')n'ei tlri\ r)ril"lrt 'r 'r:\ 1,,.r ri\lLr(lion rn:n'rrtrrr(i'ir(rir Jr'tlh t(' liJr'lrnPr:sorrrir' rl lrL\ 1r'i(r' il n() nr(rti\ e \ Pr()\'cJ .r5 in ihr\ ! r\r \ntelri'nll h(rr!r\( I r\ \tlthirr llrc disctetii'rr ()l thc (orrLl 'rr1\l rlrcrc is rrL' tLI r!(rsl IrirrLiplL'1;overrrini', th. s.rirr ds en' lr "rs' nlu\l tr' 1Lr'[""] "tr Lt' i",, 1i.,.,ii],f.r. i',.i. ,rrr,l .rrtlnrttnn'rs lrr lln ''lsc ol l\lrrhanrnrc'l ,uman V Stitc (l0ls s( lVli I lill il s '1s lr! l'l n\ trrlll'r 'rL l' i-l'l

"sc le citts is oN n.f th. tfinsl i ll'orta11l ttt l n titate tisk, u'hithn cti,ttit,tl ( o rl his to l'Ltlorttt tltila hanling tlol!:fi tt cL,ttt)i.tilt't a[trt 'o'11'ht5it)l1 o.l a critnirul iitL lnlltt]-ittg to lti'tiott i i intqori't( sotterrc? is o ttt(th i.rtl exr is( btt il is o'tcrotts n\Donsibilitv It' t,tfliet, fair tr,tsnn tlc nnl ttlt4nalt 'tot .*tnuc. coirnt"usuralc u'ith gtof ilV utd ot se"trtlu of crint, loo|in{ at tht ,ttolil\" dttotdittg t1'1tl ot trritigat,rg circutistn es thdt Yol!ok(il L'r itstigttI?Il ,,,rrilittiit ol' cti t? ini it ilt?oh'es cL'nst'ious rc l'l ! 'lt,scribtl ot it't ttttl siundu.,l ur ,1afi1 'til, lo ittllict coirt'ilion inll se tatk?, surh faclots t'arlt

lrel tL ac

g such ctertisP fror cas? to cdse attl tt'hile u'ulertaki Coufi tsl k,?l i si+ht yrottisions ronlttinetl itt clnptcr.-Ill urit tv ,'1 th" t'l'C Llttortunnlclv tto sentctrcittg g:,idelire ii tornt ,,l.""n in ltakistan' thotgh Clrurls haur'sPl !tut ct'ttait luratltctcrs itt l'lq'tV cIJsl's as to tohat is niti+nli tl a Li or Ltli{ruotLtitlli ci'?ullts!Ltr|e! thal 't'!tV l)arra'tl altctaliotl atti ot t'ut1li,ts itt co'tttictiott a i it s'tttcttct tt'ithifl t11' puiort,'et"ts of ptot'itlttl ttt,icr lhe thurSin1 or Pt'lal Prrtrisioz (Lrold addecl).

l\rhilst dilating uporr whether a cleoth s.ntence should be |etluccrl tu iil" i,rtprririn*",-tl on account o[ '-r l'rck ol rnolive dlld the latc sen, ng oi errtpti., l()r l:SL the SuPrenle Court in the reccnt brutal ,r,,,..1"i.^r" in CriD-Iinal Appt'al )'Jr:46 rtt 2{)17 Noor Zaman V State ilatcd 22.02.2020 (utrrcP(,rte.l) held as under in matcdal Par'l at para 3;

"thui, it ts ttnl o?? to thc de[r"'c that thP |tctili.ottct tlitl nol ktltn.) as to ttil| fu tt'as iti tlrc iock lt is high ti'ttc lo let out ol thr.luae tir' oI htlttrt lt(hniitl f/ttl \" tts lt' 'tdottt a tnoft r* islit-nttl lVnant al'pro cl' Io ('tsttft ttn elleirtiae dlministratio ol oit"i al Nsli'c' d sin( qun tto't ii rr,aiztan Pcnc1ul cquitibiu' i thP roiiPtv; tdl 't iiruns"qu"rtini lapse or iailu'e lo oltteroe a ptoced formaliitl -irh t tutr:hy yrelulre ot htlttl'ca!1 .lo n,tt 'arusrd in his dtence tdnflot bc alloued to d?'ty iustic' to Lt[ gLnrtotct'uts ts tle t)i.-titn ol critne siniiarltl' rr(stttttllltotl altat hed ttt tti o{lkt acls hoth tt tl/ nrlrl' 'l2L) (!) n[ L]t' Qtttuttt' i-shrhnrlnl Ortiir, 19$4 'is t15 titur /\ttiLh 150 ol tht' 'rrl/ Consl']]ultlln o! lht Islmfi ll'l)r/l'/i'' o/ /'lrlislrrn' 1973' stqttr.n.tt Lu! t l lt. n,n,i ,nt,l. tlttt'. tfi lh( .,bs'tt.? o-[ a posrttt'c ptoo[ ltt th? t:ontrarv, l,lt'adrd slttcil;1allu, a l.lltu?d disPatrl, ltq "fhrce ilsel.l cafittot bc r:icuttd tt'ith susl],i:it'tl' iturc.?ttl i(s;trN inlt i ! !11'o u'Lttn?'t in lh?n ptimt tttul\ lttt'c 'b"",, ,trn" lo ,t(';tlt shols' ht'o t lht 'ilh rcPfitlcl .[tra tt d btult' srlctv oI th?tt horrtc, h a nt'ttorcr ' t'sl 'illous thus, tie uay stttlc.l is cottstif iablc itt rircut sta 'cs;

stules a|c itt'inlarrc?. No ttlt'tfi'n t] l' is lit\l lot Prltlttttl fflils. Ir,1ft dtLi ti." \lx'lil a'l'lett)

( r-cLr;Al'drrl \l'rlil \fi1lrr,tl.rrrtt(,thecnlrnnecrncntr)las''rltn'crL-rl'r v stitc il'l l)"lr()oS( l"i1 ir'.r.rr hL'l.i : ; Lr;r,1.r.rt I'ir'l:

, '' ,,j,,1,,, ,r/s.rr'lir,rl l,r 1' I ,'r"''r' rrr ll1 ri''i 'rr'ii" ' l'' lir rrr'i ' rl 7ht' L'ottrl Lt.t-tltP4l tltt \r tt tt tl-flfi 5ntt .t\ I 'ttltdktt 'dtt t't tlttt i't ltt itu"l'1utt' imltt'ii |t*nl tt 'tL'oll 'rith rrr //rt' 1'titt,ttttt' trtl lttr 'i t"' "!'r"/'.Iik "7"""'('""rr' tntt't ' "''lr'rl 'rr'' 'nl r "t\1I 't i1 ttilJtl'. l"tttttt'ut't rrntc'i.:nik ro htt a 1)r"tt il'lt ol ,lt t rnl nllltiLtttott' t,.t,'t.tt,,,,ti.-,i,,.,,.-,,,,',,,.rJ., 1 ".,r'.", -'i 't 'tu'l ' ultt'ttr r lltr' '''rl"r'r r" ' t

I 2r) I 12\

i)It r., r' //r.' s.rIll'rr,1' .r \t' ttol iusliiid br ldlt' ,11.1r, r',r 1,, rsr,rr ((rrs si',rii',r(r1/ rIr'./r x i|rirrrll.//rr ti) lrrrl/ i)rr'1!

iii)i\:)ttl!tt\ t' pt.t,])t')II iilrl t)i!o I t)r\ttlo'tt! trtt ')t ilt')) nllctt lo l)t lt)^ltt tttlnn,.t)ttttl- r' i''ij r,,. s., r.,,, '4,":i,',illr"''1..\".' ''r iir"'j.

Thesc rtrt tt're guitlclitt.js drkl thcir ! icatio" tooull ,lenatl on carh cist. Ih! (dis entail\tg tafilal t hrr{ nt1' 1o l,? dtddcd u'ith utfltnsl carr. l1hfi lutt' rerls d'sfftti)tt in Courls to ruarl scrttcrc? nf dl'ulll or life it'ryriso mnl' il ta s t h?a!\ tlltttl'lh?s? to bula c? thc 'ttious 'otts id?l u l iot'r u)hiclt ttttdcrlil scnle rittt lroitisiotts litr' itt.ttt).-l tt..|.hrt-ittttdlrt t;r lktt,,- t;n it ilt t nt tt"t'' \' lht l1nfii4'lc ol ynlxtrltrnit!rlt1,)/st',rl'ri..'. 'l lln ::tttt\lV t' 1l!' ,.I'irr,r ,/rrr*,,r thc ttsidr ltnt.. t'f ya'?fitio't 'ot ttl ,tlrtcrrtuLt uu I :,rl b:ltt,th - nU l\tt t At I't t't rtt i.t'tltr cir.urnst fices ol' thc .r.r..! u d thc law ttPllicnbk' sr

(p)Orrlin.rrity tlte lesser .llternali!e Punishmeni oi.r' lil'' imtlfis,,nrtrcnt might hn\(' lxa rr JPfroFriatc how' vcr l"*rl Llt' paititular fair..:,,,, r'ir\'unrrtllnc({ r1l rlri-'as*'rr'l L'Lrr llnllln}l'' r'r' irc,.f thc !,icw thdt this (i1sc is such .r .asc whi.lr ,ustrfrr:r eldlancenrelrl in sentencc l'his ir [tcarrse thc aPPellants i'ere nol orrlinary citizcns l)Lrt *ere insk'ad Polr'P ollirers oPon \!'hom I higher ltanrlard of condutt is erl'](( te(l bv elicrcisirrB their oilici'rl drii"" "i,,." thev arr..ntruste(l b,, tlrl'St.1lc to uPlrtrltl the law aLr'1 protect th..itiiens frcnl hnrrr rathPr than k) mur(l(rr llr(rn ilr .lr,trious/lakc crl.r)rlotets. Citizl:ns musl havr' tlre coniitlcncL arr'l tLust lo llave rclian.c on tht. Lr{,li.e to Prot'{ t '1nd serve thenr' lrr this casc lhe al)Pcltants .olrrPlclel! abusccl that trLlst irrllrrr thr ('i evi.lence they cirisrr,.l d .ar tvith I l'oung mcn irlside. irr-the Prinre their life; thev sul,jectell them to n Prrnrc(litatccl hail of gun ii( I Lr(' attcmpt was made to arrest them; each ol th{':t (le(eascd receiv'(l nurnerous l:ullet *'ounds on vitdl p,rrts of their bodics, thP vthi'lc th.1t th.ry nere tr.-1vr:llirrP, irr rPceive'l uP to 2() bullet holes; the r:"r shoh'room rvhi.h llrel were Parkcd in lr('rrt ol an(l the cars thcrc irr rvere clanragrrl h!'t)Llllets; evcn the halls an(l an elcctric Polt wds hii in this feroci()us llsc ol lor.e whidh ev€'n thc cye witrrtsses tla!(' evirlelce was sevcre. This incident was more '1kin t(' n prcmcditated target killing of inno'ent citizens with exressive isc of fo.." to eisurc thai there were no sut_t'ivors' Two of tht' deceased (Zair, and Ubaidullah) were ordercd to 8et out of tht'ir car and w;re thcn mcrcilcssly exrcuted bv the Policc whilsi bcing unarmed and Poqing no threat lo arry ()nc Norrc ol lhc + dc( \11'p(l ha.l arry previous,:rinrirral lect'r.l arlel thcr' wen'nrrrnlele'l rn.tl,'' rnust l'ruial arr.l Laltrar'ous nrannur.lltr P('licl vclsioll ils Ptr tl( ir originat irlR lve hnve dlread!' iound to be cornPletelv LrntrLli' and B,as a deliber.rtr attemPt to .ovcr uP their illegal act l hc SuPrfrrro Courl llas tilne xnd ng,airr eurphasizut that in brulal rnllrders ol on(' person let alonr'41,ersons thc dc.)tl1 l)enaltv is the aPProPri'il" scntence In this rcsic.t reliance is placcd on the cases of Khalid l\tehmoocl v State i2017 5( MI{ 201), Zahid lqbal v state (l()17 i.( N4l.' lsli).tn.1 Tnriq Lthrl alirs lnriq V Stdle {:017S( MIi :q l}

lr I 7a i.ll liegrctt.rhl,'' lhIr,' ,rri rrrrDrr r(rrri 'rll'i}tiorls (rl ar 'i r\l L ,lli,i,,Lrs,'raL,'prrlrtr'. rLurrnlrrrirLl"'rr'rr'lri 'rl'l 'r:'u(rh\\'l rrrLrr\ pr"vIrr"rlltl ihai (n1('['rir li 'L r|"'l l)rr]l'r 'rr'l rir'r'il'-' "ir( '' L ' ihi.,,rs,,thL'.,rtrrtrr,rblig.rii'ri inIhL'r'rrl'l ' irrli'rr'\t 1{r lr'rrrJ 'l"vt I ir delerrcnt sonl('nco to (letr'l slr!h ((rntlu(t D\, th. |')lrt' lr lL" lritnr(' .rrr(l 11rvr' .r h)lr.l .n(l ,l'1tr rrr(\\ril' tt' th( l)Lrirlr' iiNt '' lrr qrIllr r'.r'Lr nrL lr,"'.rr rrr ',rLrl tlr{ '"Lrrlt r' il trr)t sh\ 'r\\'r" li' l th.ir r.sl!'rsuiirl\ '1 lrirrl.lirrli(LL'r'rr(l!'l('rrrrrLs( rl(rr'r\ rrl'lr t'rr' \\l\lli(:lirl' l)n)t(1t tlrc prrbl,, .::rLl tl'lIr '1rLIr 'rL:r"r'I'r 'r:ti n:,;rr\,,rlsir .r!llrr'r-rt! \'r\'thrr"\:" r. ll1s"'Lrrrrrr 'ilr'!trr"({ l' tlrc Itrlc o[ ]n\\ ,rrr(1 rrol lrl.' (rl! ('t rrr'rl) lhe l)(rirlr' nrusl l1'r\' lLrl l.rrth ,1rr(l .()rrli!lrn.( rr1 thc .rllrrrrfi lrr(lir' '\str rlnrhiilr sh"trl'l rlsn (r,rr.rr1( r llr, \ i(lirrr' .rrrll lh|ir lrtnilics nhLr ltarc htt t' ,,r'rll,'sslr arrLl rllnrllo'sl'.' irr rrro\t i rsr\ il'privuJ .'l thr'ir llr'tl strrh lh('.cntencL ()l Irle Irnl'rrs rrrrrIrrt i'r tr''l\'(t tn I dt lr ',r ts A- oi thc aPt'clt.rnts is cnh rnccd to r sirlglc dc'tth sertcn(c for thr ntu,.t".,'i thc dccelse.{.'lhc (onrp('nsdtio!r' filr{'s cl( s('t ')r't in tl'c itrrpugne(l fuLignrcnl shallro'r"tirr irr l.''l'

With rctinr(l k) thc nPPe.ll a8,.ti sl r(qL'ill'rl of thr rospon'l(rrts No('r l\tuharrned anrl Z.lfar lq11.rl.

I'I\ rrrr'r"r rl l'lr.,1"1 ...rr''l ". lill'1" rtr'r' I'r'l,'r r"h,, . " ' , , 1 '., r"\'L ir".'r1.a' '''' rl 'r'':

, . r 1 i , ,

(le.rrle(l nrrri rrrur,l, rr rll llrrlrr '1\ ]r1('lrtr(rrrt'(l c'\rlr' r ir tL i' trdtl nelrl .Lrr rpP..rL 'rg'1rLrs1 'r'(lrirlr)l is n n1'rltrr of l'rw lr'rs 'r " \ n!rIr(,\r:rolt a rLl IlrL aLrurrJ 'r'(l!)ires 'r J"trl'lt p|rsurtrptr' L' ..,.,r,, l,lfir\r'.1',r rrl' "'r -'1'r"r" ("'t " Nluh:rnlrDPd Sh.r(i V Stntc (:l)lr) l(IlJl rl !\''1s lr'l'l it L' rL:' "aNll{ ,rl I) ll)'17;

"!l r, l-11 tlla rt'r' l t!tl'ri t titt !t t) 'rtt ' ti)!t! tn'itiitl!11 tit'fir!

1,r,..:;/rrx)tn,)r,rr,,r,i,,L',rII 1. ri;'5r',l.rrIir/irl;.r:r'irrriliir 'ir-'ii ' ir,,",', "'ri,,'t' ttvon h.ilt!t'. ol i'ttPo.;sibilitq 'ntl trultit'; iltlo ntistttltid$ nI if,ti" lt t i\tt! 1)t \ti t]\tti' !r)! tr!tt tit' r t)il /r'r' ri i ','lri 'r lr*tri:rirlri,'i,r LL',il,r; i,r I ii' ilrii; L rtrrr'' s,'itl,ri;'rrrrrrl'1," t'! ht tttttl !tt!t' ti't)trttin rl(rl trL'/ rrrrrrrlr//r' tttr)! rr,ttr ttt:t;tit',rl (l'rrl'l r'r'lc'1r

(s)We hav*.rlr('ady foun.l tlmt lt was a fakc police encourrter arJ ihat the appeltants'took Part in the Pr( rnc(litated - murder. of lhe .l.cease.l 'ihc quesliun bel()re Lrs lherefole is whcther lh( re is sufli.ipnl c!rtlen.e igarnst cilix r |L'sJrrrtrlrrrt t(r meel thr lr)1" apteal ag.rinst arrlrrrtial stantlarrl to Prove thL' Prcs'nc( r)l "'lls'l ,""po"A"nt at the sccnc of the irrLideltt an(l that they t(xrk fari ilr the killing ol the (le(easeci by dtrcct iiIIn,l or b1' \li'rv 0t c{nrrrrlorl I intention.

(l)Irr otrr vr('w tllr ..1s(' ni!ri11\l th| rlrspon'icnlr r\ N!il\( I ll"r L .ri.)rrrcl rl'c "rr'\r'l"l ''l l)cllrrrl' rr'r rl'' r"r'"rr' 'r'l "rr: i' ,' n1,,a nst eich reslron(lfnt;

Respondents Noor llohnmnred ind Znl'ar lqb'rl'

I

l-- I l-

(u)r\ltlrr,uglr rc'ition.lent Nrrrrr N4uhrrnnrt'd ' rr'LrrI' (l :rr \i'lri' lrshacl ,l:lli. rJinhrseri.lL.n., Lr r,irr.).rth hi lt'rt llr, lrr'r 'r'rr 1'r- t.cin!tt'utr,i thcr.riJirrill,rrl!rnr1('ith('r'tr'lrll{ort\i!lLnLr i\ lr' llrvcir th. r(,. r,l r|aLiir1l .rnr iirirrg rhith t"""t t" 1'" thc "rrir .j. i.lcnc" at',.,,,rs1 hinr. lh,'r'ri.r1,,,,,rLI,rIr'tlr.llrt'!\'asissLrc.l .rr1\ (,tli(inl wcaP(rt1 nlr!l rs su.11 l1r, (nlPilt's bc lra'rrl l)'kk l(' '(ttll(l hilr; n,,,.'c,,t,,,rr l'a. r.:r'r,rtt'r'rl lr()r:l irim tn1 hls rrl'('ri' 11( \'llr'' I'\'v unlrke I'\\ S Ii.ro /rrllitlLr'rr, rrlrLr (lir{\llv irrrl'li(ai((l llr' ipln'llnfl\ t,r'irrg p|t'st'rrl irt llro :i!\'nL :rtnt'd lh'1t thc rril"in'l( q''s r L

t!as .1t ihc \'(n( .rilrl hn.i l,rLr Ir ll'rrt ir1 thi rlr(11uIrl'r; lt t"'r slln\\rr (,11 rrlr Cll li)ot.r)lc,1i thr' c"rr(-; th'll thr' l() l)i\ sriii' n(lnriLlL]'l in irrs tviLl,lr,t th.rt ()rr Ih!' !f i ('l th( Irr'rJ('r t lrL resf!,n!l(rri$.rilr.rioir,rrrii rlrr.rr(1 !lLrl! 'ritl1''l'San\l tlr( r'ritl (1111\ is frrl()11r1r(l .1t thc I^i onl\ wh'h rr"rs tlrt lt':1(r ralsrrl l'r tt Ltsponrl,rrtrrr lrirslll( Ili)( rt'rL(nrrril:Lhriorrr('ilh( re'\'\('rr'' rrscrl l'i rirrr l'1rt llti' l r\ I('r ltr Lt L' ttvt tr 1,isi,.ls might h.rt'c -..rn L*f ,,t lrasrrl on tht'in\!'govcrnrng nlP''r]s 'rf'rjrl:iL nttlLrrl1'rl "".i, .r1,1,r, .rsilrrtu-+11 1g'ri:ls1 t'(l1L:ti'rl 'ir'lrL'ri'l'r,lisrrrrs'lri"rirl)''rl ()r1'r better [r'(]trnil (r ) I lr.'' JSr oi respondent Z.far lqbil rs cr.Llr ih;n th.li ,,t ,,'1',,,,4"nr \ir)r N1(rlLrnrrrrt\l in ltral 1h{ 'a'rrr' .ofs i( lL'r .rtLorN .r1,p1v to IlLnl il:i lor N(x)r NlLlhrnrrn'(l L'ul in nddition h, ',',,i ,,.,,,',.r irr \l.lil: lr\lt rrl's Illi 'rs L" inl t"rlt "i tlr' rri(li:rl l,.rrl1 nrrLl lLr \l,rl l. lll:.r'l'' ' r1\llrr(' rrldr' 'rllri I r'rl ll( l(f in hLs .\ i(l.rr, (' sl,rlr (L lr'rl lru w'rs Lrrr'rbrt h)'r'lL'rt:rrr\ !! rrr( rn .rgai[st il]is rtsPonll( ,1t l l. .rl'\' !('lur tnr'rl\ sLrl ri:nrl'rr(l l'r'l'rre I

I

g,',tlct. tr upyti,,. tlr.rt lrir' so r r{rlL !v r: to 'lrlrver' \1'rlik Irslr'r'l :r

S l5.t ( r.l,( srnl(,nrlirl , Lh. r,rrr|rrr|Ll I\ l\r rc|r.lr.ili,'rr ,'a lll:

,,r .,.'-.r.I ''.,.i ,ll rlr. l.r'..r',r'.,r . ..1'.'.',1 .''.r1'r 'i'"ri r' astlis.rrssf.i .rL,r,r'e,,r. hereh!Jrsrrr$s rrs 'r1r1t 'rl 'r11 irr5l 'r'(lrrrll'r Summar),.

1 Ih,,rp1r'rlsag.,',t!tt,r11\'r.titii\.tr'':r'rnrsse'l : lir, str,tenc.'r h.rrrtletl d,*r'lr t,' lhr nfl'rll'r11ts '1rr 'nl\'rrlc\ai I I' I hI rn1:r'is0rrrtlt'rrt li) t]lt] J(\tth f(n'1lt\'\\itj1 rll ()ti1rr t:rr('' n:1'1 airrl[rr)r]\ntrL,Lr ( rn.rLrrrn]l rn ll r\ t l. lhL nPlr rrl rrt',ninsi r!(luitLtl is (lrcrrr r"\l

w trfff, 'tl"l z'z

A