Peshawar High Court

Tikka Khan Vs Muhammad Iqbal etc

Case
Cr.A No. 151-A of 2016
Type
Criminal
Length
10 pages

Summary from the court's website

Accused, after acquittal, earned double presumption of innocence in his favour. To disturb such findings, strong and cogent evidence was required. Court act slowly in interfering with an order of acquittal, unless grounds for acquittal were perverse, wholly illogical or unreasonable. Accused is presumed to be innocent in law and if after regular trial he is acquitted he earns a double presumption of innocence and heavy onus lies on the prosecution to rebut such presumption.

Full judgment

Official copy

Judgment Sheet

* I

V' lat,,:,r{$tyte)bCt* ar.

,v)r|ltf-i*

151-At2016 /,-8, ,J4/

t,r,Fr.f"UY(taDlvfr ll+i

24.03.2021 0ttlOtV

J- " it g t; a t 1, 4 ( g ri $ ) * tl-,r t

, ( 4 -Q), l8 t,€-(t) p gr;(i"1fir gtt* )., -i.?l Lrr-t.-r, n s1/),2 L rb 1 W. gv-l /A,fru rr- rh"d t _(r,), $ C _(r) t ,ltitt-(D dd?L -,1" A d,fs,.t I tt ?t-?{t!tt, -:ut i v L gdt eu i r, r rrr t t u,t t t t i ) y ; fg ; -(t),,f a -(r), ( 2t -(r ) -71'/t!l-gx7t!6,i

,);6rl.s-v.-7,tbt/L*j.ULo,4rjw.to6uFLodon -r [u.Qri 7, . *r'0.*!,n -t,-r47sry14, ot!.t g{tt:}) PjU,tt t Vd fi Z.- rl, i/.- -:),{ ttt,*, 6-:ntgt g|/;t )tt:} S, u gt ;r gC,-c ,., n

tt g, ;, 1f r gf /,,./t,.fi f Dty, 6 fi, Jti gtd/€- J)0,t i4 t, rat, r

f,,t, 6 {' /cti L o ri". z z-, Q z-(t o6- {,y' r1,, tjrl v t r, t

,fJ ;u, j- ol, l(/r rl,,t I tl ry, 6 t.tt, /i, J$ L€c)0_,,J,,rg f-fia ; utt L ctt ) - d ? tt lv€ et ctA <, I L tt fl -(rl 6 L) 0 r/n,S;

V

a V

!,J tea 4 +,? toi,u lr r - (rtl t, ) ett<.-,>t stt t Lb L x Le glf1l t t

=b, - { Jv *v'Jav,v a $ $ {y' t L p g,, t - +,!,.1. a,.t; -l J t - g t tL o

-t y (t r vt y';: 6 tl t g d tf t D4L /, t o -: -, ;t t! t e*

,- P,.Pr-E'; pl - L rr .,i)l{,2 t -, o -r.b gtr ? t :t ( tat, lt) -€ gt t t ) -r - r)* * /,fr it ;V d r* e: p 2t.4 / -. -r. n st y n t c) t) b j p L,tt ) ;J.,ra t-qv n a (C) ): I ; Jt t,(/u {*9,:,1'*.qo Jry od_h =,r{ut, L o rrt.- or{ 6 &!i v (2, ).: $L ot iln-, Lr, 6j)/-{J u,l,f t ?r L :q- -{L! *,>,t i (2g- t2 4+ - t! v,p t!-;,,.rt ? L n Lt6 t t |

-,*J-:errcF,!,1.-1rk*;V,rlt*c),/l{D,.fLLL,r",:v/Af, ,' I c{t t o V d k 6 /r z- L t) e, t,/J ) : ti f { D : f-,,' f t o o

{ ttVetT$,'t t!lt L/i$*-, $/.- -} b o(( e*.pw -t t t &*, ) gt d i L /1.t,/

t r .rr,1 i, ( ) i:x ( z <-( ) r ( ).p I a,.t t!* y r) q r" $tvt r'* tg./J i,tt (r)/ t/t t L /,!,t * J ;y. L t /q- f-,.,t,1 a?: ud ,eI,jF-,, r!,1. - ; v, fi/. r ex.pw t n,fp, t ) 6 - { e sa - o, e, r at rL /t,y* lA U t j,&., i +ui: LQ t t! ('t r { g|gV,fi :t 1!;rt L - i,, alL :r,, 4 Pt!* y zq g) 6r -t{*. dr:(t)/ Ly L L /q sa6t ,/,,; sa6/r:x g 4 Lt,[t,, L /{r)/t/., yrt,fd t) f! z- n - /L*, g t t,>t1t?,t)tor/)!"-{q,.fuftv{Vt-f-,rtl1t)l!rttr{,-z.rt?'ytit- - ? Q4, *v l S/' ft2 7' {r' $; r

I e{,.t d u {r + L tl (i- o c,*- U : t!- f ;' t ri I p ct b tJ t ) to

7 f ;,lt!/-t.- t)t, *6i/J$Jv.,t )g )'t aG/ t*, ;t,,€ Ju.(ir uj, { e $ v 1t'} ;, t /, I ur, f p u I ti g# } ( I u i,-,. Z n t, gr ., , t, t tt C:

g :)Jia L ctl i{tty{+, f, I Ptl t - Z t-x { j}t!4t.-2t.14 tt

r/-l ; r,'s [v.er a ;fu (/t /,,V tN f, p ut, lQ \)#e - 6,,f t s t,c.,

,,f t ut v, r,, j') t,V,,t' 7t, ty', ; cl* jv clb qt /- ultr* - -u tl ctV o, 4, - 1 J u.

- 0 r, i, ;' rr. $ - 6,,, i f; L rl l+, (, /,1. -,f,! S l';

U G

,fa. v, v a - C./:,L, !, r,,o,i, - +,!,,t r,t ! ) t* ! x L J t, gl, A o, J t 15 ) -i Od L,fJi 4 t*..,, ; v. Lry/ j v.

+t - ? (f, 6 tv tt t c) t s t, t .,,t D,

(,4ffi I e*.pw -zr t e,th' ( ifa {/fi p L 6rta.,4,r, g{,aftqa * y L -(f fz,re*.pw -zrz r,l, i i/L /,f- gJ t v

--,,urL?-

LT

!7 L{t-t U V J * :f7 7 L tf-r^tt +: (r : V f u i' ; u LJ r t ) r,

* iL o$LS g Z <- ri/L )D: I P<- f L gt;/, ;t.,: I PotV t tt o, t)L.o o

,g qr, !-1, JQ j ct# - j) t! 4t ( :,, i it- L . e:t 6 $1,.t ( Cut r

- L { I x z-6 ot/- { t t),,t,,,y' ;,,-F v t, gf / r,/t t/l| trt ., ,gqt,li,,)t)t,lct$-t! L'),-fuv o4r, qt 6 L o0 0,1, v{t - t

/=*,1 tl'/ L g 4t -rvt 7f. gq 4d r./J ;r,,,r ;u. Jiu {/t /, D,a , ; fi i, i-,y t -,fi;, * 6& s,-f t

(r ,, r, il, (.q c) t L g t ) - J q o V q' f{;'.,, [u.,, ;g lt,-(i g i,,t.,tl t, Otl t tt Lt o, - 7 (ru1 /Llt )r,t t 6,, -,/0, O ut, /,) p Ju. tlt; $ L o t o4 fi i, - ( p1,t1l, od i $1( L/ t t)1.

,(( e*.pw / -G {;. 7 0 r9 i4'6-a t!* r t!ov/,6,t 6tl -s t 1, o t r

,>V

ltrrli UiL J P,J, t!'z r t! oYS,,t ( q t4i P-,, r!,,/' -? ;b t 6,r i,- t/,tr, / 2 Z- t v lle w 4,1 ex, -z V. Ex.p A ; u,, 4 - : t) e d -1

,' -A {rz$-: j (nD), / ) ot.(J, L d4-+ q< r} e,.,,, )i?, (gaS,'(,', -1,-ttv/: t)t gl fu Pr.Q-,fi{tr ;V..,:t Jitit zr tr

SV

17 c{,t ttt . } * $ /7 7t L Ast i?) t'-,r ?) :t;-t,{ lp L tlt,P'cu FtR{.n -t.-r. ff;D-ti ed &, 7:C/,i 1}*, H o,ui, gt t q -t{ ;. 7 Ex e e a, f ,f t ty,-., 0 r I L /^a, * f A r t tJ z - J re : t5, t

, / t u { ex.p -2, t z .t r ;r i., ( | i :,u ( z t) t d, - 6) v (t' ) e tv d r.t, ts o

i-' i cttf(Q sa6'rtr:* & L,/* vt C,/,y L//a 4 A

J P t!* r tl 0 r^[, J * ) 6 fu.7 Ex.pW 1,?p, i /, /9f' tt g t,, g t - -4 t

L ;u'jJ P(,2 y'<-o e, / g -t/(r),A-f., tt* /ti ex.p -4 & t ). ui<) tt: t L /*,/l 4, /'- u /d rcx.e -s fL z- x z-/,x., L.- a ) t) b 1!; ol { ex.pw D,fP, /-{* sa,ypv,* d L,/,t. d, t >,i,!., ! v -c

31 c) ti, * 4t I ? L -.& ei- J ? e g, y c* * er,b 6 - t t{;. 7 ;1, (* r P- 4 &P' iL 11,/ A {z * y fuo p p J uh, t, g., t i o i* t, t) z- -t! s1 / cf, rt.,, - A,4f6,.-, ) d lL .r;. 7 Ex pw i t ( r, ) t t y -3 t 1 o

,l# 6,Vli7. {c -t (;1 y- f ,fJ,it *,! t/ OJ; i t!I ?,,ui, tv | c-7o 1

ouS.7r,;rt jx ; Vl J{: r,t Lrt,-t?t t)d i: {6 0 :qV < O t/X

"L X J

,:,,ti,: el t! Ll &ter,t gt -4.rr7 Ex.ptN -4t 4 a Ex.pw -4E Gf:G, orS { tz-t,-r. r,str -j1fit te r st o / z-'r. Ex.pVtt -416 t, Ex. pW-4/5 Ex. PW-4/8 .7,t ti,t : / t 4 L tJ -{,-f J 0 L ./;. 7 Ex.ptN-4 t7 J P, I t | t

Of C y Ez-u, L,/,.f v -: j (/. ( ).,t / ),rt gl ) -: $a {n -t c-rt (J t / : t t t Ex. pW-4/9 v th I t i L q 7r) 6 -( t J /",/,t,,)?p t -( : t r r O

,.> /, t SL g :, ;r -t! or c ), r E u r. L /Lf v,: j (,t z),;,, ),> t tf F t t t | I

,fi q, t n f,P--e".pw -ct fi t &! rfJ 0,,r <-,:,)!t 4 Jru Jry gqLx,6lL ( qtJtt $ v Jv Gctlou ue. - ( suoI'tct ttgELu t, e(; -. 5-7. 5 sry 1 -{ q7 ex.eW-4l1 3 f Ex. pW -4t 11 LJ,ijli,( L c)t L e,G,t4 t q /t -t 6-tc 6 ^it/-t"r- y'{6{4 | + o}- 0x t F,yv Ltt t 61y.a i'u., t F it fudt -{t} gr v| P+ 7 Lu vt d t,nEx.Pw -4t I s ,:,t'1 P: t)l /.lgi i- t1 -( SHO)t ? O t)V i Lr, -r;4f,Pf';ul -( rr, o r

- 7 ei.r,, * er., : et fu 4 i' 7 J { t t

r -,,p! u{t t ctg 1J* 6 /7 7t LMHC -t i } G) :vt,f

j/. jz{s- 7 /- efl-t'1 J* (r a $/ f v,O,fio,n c)|a:l -l:79 d, 17 Ex.P A lz - 7 4 4 * e, t : L?: 41 t, sJ 7,5, i,! 4 r p - { O, r P &' ., t t

- fi{v,Pt t r n f, * y r ta (,1 g ;,,'t - 7 t

(, i 17 fi.t o,r. j x g /7 7L L s H o d ri*, b O) :w of t I

({i/fo ilu duoV.g/r W,l/,} t .t,,<, t.rt ep t,:,4 c,t.,,

(' i'.,'t ti&re $ { :r. :)4 -(+,1o, 4, gY $ [u. f ,; -4 ( f$1 - t 6 7 t t,,t

,:,/-u t7 - ftfirrl ex. pw-ol t -v i /. j t L,l {.1 6o., c_t el t7 t *+.p f t!{v ; rt -t |* o{t g q 4,J L,f{.-., L t f. ( v /" / t L, t

Z

, -(;. / Ex.pw p., f 9 4) ? L q s{: | v, (t a) / t -a v, O,-{ r r} t a o 0

Jb ,>rr ,-Q ,tr4., er,b tlt -y/ (rlt, Z-tt ,-tL> /,,>ub 1; t JP ,/ ex.eztf,J t) ? dt ) r.i, L LJ,,t'f';,rl - 7 0,./;7 (g (. Ex. pw-6/3 t t

o tt tg i g) -) p4 st ) u,,1, L ;r $ ) 6,A I ; p1 g) 6 t, tt -t{ C * fu t r t

t{c*,fuex.ezt

-t /* uil og I t* 6 /7 7t L LHcd ) / z) :w o{ ( | t

yr,{ r,-{t in'+t, cl., r/; -'<- ilv LF sL Lr tQ t tt (r ),(i,i,y, I r tnr cV )

f St,@),'t(t)/t f,y,ll-,tV-O;l k t -{ )vLJt L t/n rt trr.tr r/ - { l v L : t}; t5, 4, yu e & $ :.,, f r /'-t t { {',:, i {,u t Q t tt > y t

It,.Plr u{,.t Lt V. tJ b 6 f7 q t Lor c J,4 ( D : ti- to { Ir Ez:r. L,r,f v $v u,t 16 t-€, p rat gdi ut U, r),i,/ ),-!.,1 t L ij : y ty: od.f-tf ,tr, g, i,, l,Ji ( L o0,,t L E,!t - { S', L *-r,,,, t Ll u / * {#,--t t,Q, t. ct | {t'j t t w,,.fq,! 86,y, t L J - L x t t

/ *u tf g / 6 - + Ex.PW-8/6 r Ex. PW Ll,t I t tfu < 4 6,tt t | -8 t 1 t

t ilvL E'-v. tr,gdi b,: -) j nD),

^QV 7s {gud L rlt - t ( orr

Ex. PW-8/ 1 2 t Ex.PW -8 17 Lr,, t ) ( J /, cr, ( gl, t'-r,o t, d, -,! E t - tJ,,/u. 4 L n,.fo : \2 6 t L : ti- t i v L, f6 - r- t :t*t Ln Ll$ ta 17. $tta t-qVGtr))ry ; gt4 z-t L g0 -( =$tt o'q i { i : L g a 1 t -(,{p {-,i z-.t t : : t i d.4,L E i ?t {-,b L t tL t LD

Attr,f od,:,c1'. tJt{ ; pt - L x rli 4 1 : !ts.,-Aet g : r,t t!,* Ju" g t o

ee;*1" ;, + c/.-!:,/6 r <- sit 7 (1t,ii {fJ *, Iod L * v v v

- r-tft t, -)V ! * i $L clt )q,,t L OY r

,rst !, a7-7),e/ilA {r*G t$t-x+t Jtt' 5*'[ -6 a. U /t o,&,i b L x Z- : i A # o {g},lz- t., S*'/gi:lri 1!:€- L,! x t t r

{ O) L t,t, t, p A * lt *,,f, f I' ui,,,/,} t!: g- -G r { 6 t 6 t >- - o t

{&),y -,.Pct,t 4 t g ub I pt o J P t! nt rit r- {6 e,,, - t i t i v,!

t{- - q ) o L 7 Jb" L o } V c) } )l - 7 ) t .- o f , Jft- }i, $ t;- - ? t r t) t |

d t', S {g },f-,., 7 S,a LQ ( t t i t,, * ! L'4 | 0 ta'<- x t- {J tt'z- o?- t

-LV6'rf

.- t7,{, l, fl { j 6, * r r;., q,, t v + cF/J tt'L,-yf ,[ t- ( r, t Y

-t/^,tv,

(t:g- t,f ) dG $,,ae{- :t;, ( o,v tJ,4 ( : W, I ( yt t y g -L ,,t, 4., ( f$ E gt;$ + )i,- 7 {,! / vaf": t;-,,,1 >,fifu ryo(a, f ,,r t

g P Ao/lt, t $ $ $ ;"t 1Ex. PW-6/ 1,/* /t -O t'r (y ol ) i bt ta ., t 1 r

,;' t 17 jq n U V O,) 6 i'., ;,., * | 7 Ll lr \/ : 1 V 40): V t,t lc*"t- 1 t ('i,.-i ttut ti,t rti *,f: *-( 6: * r40 r 6, <- c7 ori(u,b*t i 4 lt - t! Q.,,,t,t I t! { (l L 4a y'I "i qt L Ii,,t ({t5, e u o"; .,.- v t

if-: fu uf ju.' ; a, o L4 ?t it,t t 6 $ 6t nt, t d * z- L,zr- t ) t" r

-tl)tr,t* L,,lJ; z- * 6tJ,qAlA/ L :{- ( vc-(ot/ il{a' I fu i' t r>:g-tt{P/,.f -1.+(t,ltaex:s14dr(a/Lf L,br,,{)J{,-bf ,tL 7 f rlblt t tt G: tj :t, r- +7,,, i ro;--17 0x {,, a 7 ot,, "a, fi (, y.

!., /; f!7 i9, $i o t . i'-v t{-,t v - & 4, fu V L G ) : t;- o 0., y t

q OV,,L O ;dt., L g n 1,,11.,,t f o v.

t il *.0 )r. tlr;(io*-*<- dr,.,r t qr., /;, f/7 { {;,,i e l, i tv / u {o"p I I -.-.b -. v u. t{., V t s

-,/,-. v.: t,rt u.,!* r 0 r t!, fil i tU L L : €- c-, 4 g, sf.

o, r, tt 6t t

,, $i S) 4, g o/,4,, -fii,// {- q (. g{-,' f, r l; - 7 I ( er,) t t t t t t,, c tJ

* drfl-Z *V o{/La/t:tZ L n I L Ly-o{( ;u}) 0 r t i/) 4t,(G)/ I w gt;/i*, (,, {fr>/ I v, ; }) p (D/1 V L,tpB tt t tt t., :

(r, r e@ t) k t) t/, L J P,, ) *, f d k ( -. 0 rg^a, * - f fu{,.f tt t y yy

,> t,, 1'z- g t{: : y ( o c V t L cf; l.;t 4 (a, (,,.5-,1 V., i r I j - A u r o

-7 i (o,,w tf oi v9/, rre 7 tL (e ot'flr C,, U,! 0 OU ou OV n * |rpf, I ;rtgZ 7,v { o{*' F, I P, a, f o{, e?j.w. t a+$(a' f'eir-' {/I-q <)1Ik L-7,,,{r|P,ttyI B 6{E,- 7.,q { a, f 1.,'t I Plz-v,) rf. oo 6:e-,1' - 7v/,!,fu i-( t/v{ t ,t |

Ut ),y ott & }L 7.,g96 r., r,,1,,tti,/cqq1-,li *,& 6 * ) iZ- t;

i v L J P,, +' F o {t! o }-4 v,v e 1 .- 1fs, - Z 4 LttL ! L r | u r

-6 ueEV 6,-tt 4'i, f oylDl - 7 C u <-(r t r! G) : t,(!t,-f,/',f ,{' g*

.- -71 0 r1t 76t c)1.,,!- Jf L X I /"..v"ci: $ i Q 9,J I f1dl - 76'' gi ), u it' :t L : * r 6' t

Sts 6oi,/z g'-6 o6.- {o$ J.aL,tfa, (,'t,5, I -^ *, !7 {o E 6't o t, i v.,l qt /=A $ L tt, /,,, I -,/i; - y - v r

Lltt{7-.,,01,!6,,r,!,,j\,!*vf ($).-LjJP,,t*,F,(!Ltt G) q;t tL-?,,f, LOu,L lt;- rle Z gt gt v i,b6,fL* o ot e;

L! 0 L i I -h,/',), <, ut 4 v L oi.,, Z Z: z- 6 o 6.- { lt d ) L) t;, > r t

z- : 6,iut,,-) t,' i $L oi Jv U, i4 {0) At,,,U,,fil/i 4d ?-:r f o t;

<l -? i /t/*t q, f,,Fo",,t 7 J i,)v i: L L 4 : v1,),f',{,/ S J g a V q' /v< 4 L o, A L o *' /7 $v.,tr, o' t| $ e, 1", /-- e ti- sl I t t

^u, -+U t 0r9l(;r ry,:t:t At: LL evtll I {r,tl,A i: L7 ff1 v O r

y4f/? r// i \r rr2r 9 A' r tf \o f /+a 71a17.r Q 741 c+yr r t 4 r

t? F fi \6/3V - / -/d ?r$r 4 r+j.r r'! 7 \' rf \ t t a

)-772.1ro'7€tt19t1, fln -? qff rqfiln r rt 7 v f /, a- Tf f dl.rtqrnt ,A-,t -rQd \ y zV rt qfff f f t,,' r ay{,y

sf r<4', a t' 4t rrffi 1's 2 71 yr r 1r, ipJ r fr, a rJ - - nt ? 7/rl +f r 2 c f a r 4 o 1 - z \ ay \ r -/1, +y r 116 1,s,5 r f n ? + p, g 7rr f ! - n fi il rJ,,y', -,, 7 7,/ re! A I I f l ! u f ) 6 r 7 r, r O -a<7, r +S r r

.r,i" \n r 2- ; \a I r \f +/,/ ?r? 71, ) f ! ruf fy| = .r-t-,, /! a a 7 rcp748 t r7 rl r 4gyn la f tng0 7ay 11 pr v| r a a s ,,f o l. vte p 4-Z q' ? A a- ii-7 r ?s 5c41o -? fl t eS

/agl +.t 7 it yr V -tr )t 2/ t- fi <f tr f | 46 () r^ rl 1 c :

r irc q lf 1- y jr m; {) ! 12 $ <r! t- I 2 \o 4,a 7l -/ cr

"t Q I f ?re ,c r : 4 r',<rer ! tr 7 7 f & ;/1 I fi 7 "lt r "' el A, 7 io a lf'c ap =y r/,,,.4 f {,f Lf - t.na /!4 ? o* q, rf 7"XC 1/ 2 f,t.t r : 4 j - I a p { -', e rf + - t/ r .p tz r r r.<.h A, i, a f a A

f e 1 f ! ";o i't Q: r r.!, - F \<, qa r g 17 f O O^ il, ? V I cr

f, { a 1f ! n - r4-, tf ? ) {fr5 r + 1741 +S r n f/t-/1, r t 1 tn n

{ -.<?e<,/$ fi f t ?t rr! a r rp 1 r,, io f f rn {2:f Q a r

o

i t-v g, i v j.a ( 0), 0) :€,- t,fz O z,tl /i sl, .t., !,.,, t i:,i t v :t - q

L J i (r ) : W n lt O I tJ.w. I - ? j v -(9 d e c{ t,) u{,!r t;-' ) t.d.,t !, ) t

(r ) : v i< lt - : : r r1 cP,> :V J tqtl L?& {,!,fu er,, E t

_ I

, :r L gt ) tt r t 7 t {ti\ ; v l,#x,t : w t!oi -4 c{,* l, g z }.w. L b o (t t t) oi u ; o V Lq i *. ( v7 {,,,t e, t Q, t,fu /;, v. +, f (o $ , r, : ( d, 6, yy r,g fut v (t t t) ), / ) c) L tl i, ( y /J. 6 a- g, a t u. t

,f;v Z ull ilfiJ,ut vt Lu-f{ q./:,.t,4, -E Ll u,h" '-7ti7{*v

4 ?tJt 4 r*,vr,,-, v A iryrf re L 1,'; v tj.6 Gcg L gtt tr',n v

},.t,tl t, i ;"t.,, g1 ; {- & tl q c) | fi 't, l* t{: 7 N,o. L k; Qt r 0 {O t t

t

i : i ri *-O sl r,-(P tf a 6 06!: v, i u L s # :7 -Q,,, - 7 ( o t t e

-! :,4fu +,.t ) ft L : V {g}'z- x lt r o' v t tS' i L tl r', L.t,,-0 {1.,, ct i o i 1 CI,-; u L t {7 | r $} $ t|., t :

-r7 pt d,l. 7fi!;; t

- Jrr* *,1 q* II r p - * { 6' r-i V t

f { u ! Pl i u {' !' $ 1!,1o7!7 *b t aJ! b'>7"

V

yt t

17*.r4-Lo1zbrry6fi -E-x,-i.lttWJ{,l"4t?/{4.- -'?.fr uLs+a',/,{-,f v,tu(lt/ivfi{S{4,L./iu,.r4-l -1aw)1 (,,* O{t,f ; n ; tJ z.!D@ v) n 4tv)

)t1fuo7-'*.fto1r-+rt/rdt-dUt)r{{r$d':!,)rt, - ?Qu J r w, tJ :a(jv I uita o Lgifi {€' {,)vr r';- {':f t

* 6 {&,P-, H {t M J- :,.., p L f.l, * d,,/,t'

V

ot.?g,1fo.,{14n*a ii(7 p Q'}tp" -l rr:^47r1f,:.r/(4r*r i)(/ p, Q,tllt -r

- d r O0 uj, Ll )t -3 P 01,$' :x QD I t,( J i 0 r^a, $ gt., 4, lt - r. j L :t -4 0/' g i, l,f' ) L t.r P -1, 2o/' J ? il ub, r h1$" 2 L t P r' o t

,r1,4 i- /ov,) Pt i, z- v ;, i2 6. r r 1 f d i,>. t,t, t F SL.Q r t 7,1' o ., t o

li.- U$LP - i,lt/.-3 n o ) s/,t I u i, fuA'r t/.t,* t{o,q2 g6 t,, t c r

(t!"it q *t Ji:y ( zt)+ e,',,, dr4 l!7 l,)v ('7 t, -c,,r : rit6f ! ;iv I i, fi) i lL x o.e .-,.1. 7 :, e r r- f t t I t sL v,L. J ( t <- t F r

--t!{la-,.Pi

.- p Q)17 tJ,-lL,>r, 4* tf,-t -g -a qt6 i6' L o I u A r - I I ) )Si 4li etrtJ in't i/.H L.r,.<., n7e15 ;* t!,t{+{',!,J' o, t

f, L ul,V,,/,t {:g-;Q fl w i t L 4 4 t,lt,) t*,-z 7fr vrr' ,f,,t ; t ;, !- vl. : J.V L tl r' A L cl ! s-Q I i l,,P,S ; s J /* li n ro

y

1(7 1E {t' 1 6,y {,Vt 4 tt M o L f,-1, *,1,t /r' -,/t,1,' n d', t

11r,Ptr{ff utl!, &(, p oltt/1",,t'bra^l'!* rfr"#4t'n -xrq,P

s!M If) *' L.t *,s ltl * r, *,t' (,-t i",!'s' t)l'21*t -ff t t

; ra,I t,t sl - 6o{,.v.,, t*, 6 /,{t t ;r" ( t + vt : 7{-Q t t ( u,'.

t :t o,

-1 iv'!e"asvJ'*''

$yvti

.rgttl+.,

cl

/HJ

cl

Text extracted from the court's PDF and reflowed for reading. The court's official copy is authoritative.

Closest in subject matter, from every court in the library.

Please confirm