Ghulam Kibria Khan Vs. Federation of Pakistan.

I ,L;),.---“#-J I A:t11 JtJ ?&_t a. c...J1,J---(s clts1444, .• •

elnD

L5-2,1-5 •

C't ,sto 4./ 5.> oati44.4.

at !tr.> ust....."

.6;0. to ..511 ae-Pree 47o-1c (spat; als 'zeta-T.-1 4s Zi.ukrt, s iiAr / yea; 0.24..tt 6: c)...-S rY-1

AY- &.-SL. 4.:,.ift.4.27 t er —11A r r 4.144-9 : ⁢

I 66

1 Lr--1).‘ .10.11-LA law

3.1.3 C.44 1 31.; cm: Lir:••••• 140 je (N.; C)•••• tart 4.91-77,Tht.itr• t71-1" Asia # r ,“:“:““u“. ".,),". tica:L41 )11 eg tr1 e-1J (71 # caL cs c.. A:- se4 L5se its1 at rr.

eit,C a I J--"•/ 1-2aLl j•UT

I is—Lit; 3-5)L.J I )1....1 15 " a4 cji r y :—.4 1.—es 3—t,1

a". - , jr.) ,(rA 11". .15 4.-,16 5-.4 Lott. at I rtlail.s; urs . thr-tti e4 et airs g

LS; 1:70. 4.55 +Lit el)

c-I rt cz,71 j.410.-, Ai eS eS

I:

AA* Al ;A, j rjs e; .2 5 414 .tisc. !be.; V°11 Jr-r 'cIrri . 1-7" "; Cle (Licit":7; cSaut ?LI II— at c-4 C aj rl; ler c't r1.414 L vitg us.si 01,1 1:

c4 I — 4 le Li ft-) 54-4. 15 L.41,-s c,4 1.13) 4.:Ist

.o$ eg 4 is. '4:74" )441;

Lt'a, IS JV J.14,

JIiJ eS a.. k$cS 1)-21 dt ejI4,

. • ,; 3-4 “is.. et LarJi.oçV 74

1.1 j c3. tb. cS ji I cS c2-5 e.-14 ot -1,-4(tietr; c•-1

otoricrl ç 4 wtJ cS al 'LW r4 L:

je.-4 7.412..

ft )

eS k I.:)-S c.ts ci.t -4 A1.1 -r

eztr)-s: nid), i d/ S cs" 3/ " r as ChAr cA4)

Lc°•rJ ct*:)51 0 Tri _ “rt . 0.: Liy..; c •

Y. oil; J-4 {Or° -4 cas• ;11161j. .1' ,yr. 31.)--; trr-c-; fl.-1 "t-L: I a'"? c'el pi 0 L-5 J3L-1‘ L0.1 tuts tu .Q.-J I s az a 1S4L7 . 1-45) col (e.t. tf., 0L-J eas cs s-s P CA CS ItS.c:b 5103.: lift's, 3: 3-4 uzl cri cste;. '"'. °' 3-4 cia Jt eSch.a ..1,5-5 ctUia isb1.1,5 vet; cz.;-. 3 011 Lot 'aZ7.41) 10e(e; c631 11;)') -0 I

J.Jrcy.t

J•04-1 d ci41 cS el )3,1 J-crl e4 Lc f Trj CL:

5)ri J3

cS l'a cc-14' OTJ-; Oi l-5 at tr1 AT- d-A t,-4 ot-S-' C-' 3 34.ç -A e3 Lot; csot 'Lt.- cS

Cs ten. Jra..-..:.c•j1:—.4.• )51 re crt le 1)4 LOI; ct 4- CA)-:-,..“ J r"; tilt; 0 citt cu,s cS 11;13J1 • c_S Tref11 ct,,,e1 dem % L.F.Lse4 aj 09.11 )1 T fut., Lot: P Jr: Lis-.

eL•t. es' )14 cis u3-4 Jr; Jer t; ,..e" °I J-4i 3:1.)1-6 ej Lot: --- `:"?. ts4 ; I (o 1/4 tor-4 er-Sc.)tis--:.

att. ,ScrIt chrs, AI • (03-4 eg

Azzlais) cs iLyent est:i 1-4j 11-:-;-1Lx— lots

(r

jlt.—

u5 (.05-4 (U5/3-•• es

.r4 1r4 1.01-4 4 )J-.t o 12 '

.. c1/42..40%-.4 c--(1‹ hirt z 6) j tuiE.-7, 0-1J

oel TY-5 4*-15, t-is dr. 433I cjle Lills40:• ita J31 csitf:-'>it- It., At-7c LI ti.)3:4-••• i t )31 31 .131:- ta • cs tri .‘ 47: Lsr7s;pi 7.

1..“ L,4s, out.; )5 1 Lf .14,1 j31 tg.:

a 4e. jps.i cit., c-: tt•

re 3-4 `17' Z.:113'6X. " rk trl rtii.vr-4 134 •ce-5 15.4 , “I arts all it air! a) )51 vitz 01 ;I )-4-: -Oris. ail 0 Irk) c cot -4i sr3J AO assist C'3; "Set t e- 4J:1-4 isr"5 . en" 3-4 9 kt.JI r iccr4 c-Zab0. 5 jr../1-7 /I— eibtff r. 'Jr:It 1 I tO7" 4 rt.: 111 IcLvs-tz )5 1 cite. e2lt 3-4 Los," ((.277 J kits: at- 34' )3 1 tin: Cr en, 3-4 c"3-"i pni -,.-; cz-os “Its, Jot ,01 - es -Lc--; )31,-A-...ez 3:4.)r:it 3.51 LA: SJ .3 0 -.. 1_,s.

( 44 1/1•La I I in LIP

• • Liz -4, cZL)-..; cs13 a Lt

3 4 1:tS 0SJ IS Or. 4

!arts--; oc.71

c.4 5-.g J11-4- cS - ))I

(A)

Or.-4 tn• '3 5 4 Li

" LI fr usba• e ,Jsrl Lgs.6.; y, 3-4 1,'L- ci Lsc Fri' III. J--; 374 - tut-4 cit (Ir• Lpe ÷1., 01) ‘55-...%•11 ) -4 fr-4 Art T 4•1 3 I oTral a:21: Jt.)- ir rhil 1-.17L1J 0-.J ;.3JISi! LY“,.:11" (rt(i'; wt j•

alb e,s ItS .43;1; F az...z3/4 4)P4 h)31) 5-t er41 Ova ) e, 3.4 fiCjal

c.S '43;1; oc

tur.-4 AsS'a‘e.T, &us ' tvr

‘r-tA r-4 cis, 4.- s step cI) tT I 01 oact: is at • .64 . ç Ly tt4jt 4

t: f re dt g 1/41_ c4, 01--s

0 c.

.t .1 j r&S. tie kr.le 0.1 ell cS tar) cS 0-4 Lcc c7 )15-4- 11-r , 01 ,7- n:s-- Los 'krill- g 0L-

r 3315-. cS fL" °tit 4" ts"LP 41! . jr-J•it-e."1--1 (r t )

4)--ii L./kr. tot) c:01 a.-Pee

6:4 ava: ) ct.I 3 j 44,411, L5.10 431, oz .) )51 c.-:1

cc ri-3 atilt ai tilaout 1 eSc1 Cti:Z Jr•-s: LI 41e7,3- Ars . terl )31 - /Ler"

jj I ) c4 °AL:U-2 3 Ot j r4t-si 1—• Lsar. — ksopat:

31; Cat: )51 Ir.L)--; c-: J ....sS JJl <SL° tA4! L# ": -tore; n:07- 1-4 4'11( cr'S C 11 31C-14 eS Chr j L31 )1J cr... e 21 ) le. Jr; Jr/ Oil")treell) Li-0 04 43-'. >51

(j)14 c.ie 2; Rab ,tyti I )

NI T i fru Ler:Fz.

( r ILibsw.

%Dr."' Vt"" X4:7 Az 1

rp Jr c 7'4

Li 4sJ,es ef,rert 551 °I C:Lt--; n's Jr) eLti ;cis Cra-N-a rsL Ajtazi::j iLe 1 cCj.4 ot cl",:tit" 5 ts: Is* 010 at li 3

x74`t j J oT44,6P.— 17s Likeic J teZt I ,LL: LO die) cj 47.4

et! 41 0,: .;

jtli: crtl fc TScl J 4". 5)-*:

Jit Lid! 41 kor.-4 0.1.6 ta.)1.—ce

3 3:7-is mill ci rt.« atie.s all cria, 425 l'3.1_44.1 I r t -01 6.11.1 L. -A ,k31), " 414—st,

0 e- 3.14 6.111 ALI at° Apa--,o;

J* ck:4 J 3.00-:34.

L I • %....1:;_S L5.4.1 c itiit, 03 1.1(..-1 cry.: )31 1.131.--1 It A I,

- it) .‘790; oirn o iy-; Lgnl 41.1"nst. I • 1 &.-,140 • •4.1- at.i f74 oTilj I IS-- lAto tvii.t.

" ty.1.1-J )1J-J1S-r) I 1.:-J;_Q I 3"

J 1 -4 ri-S Ti--3 f (t.) -.-• Toti

L;Le; al I J1- Jj1; j 0 T;p• qr. T

c) TiidC c-;I3 J-" I TCYA tire . a tor. ea t— eS ft.; Jr ) e tc J3 I ";)" 5 ‘-41/1"

L.: I j-4 "11 c4 y n 0 tr:

rt.., 44.

. Li J., fel Tio c-- asus )31c.?c., riJr-) c t:3-4 Fit; as:

céI Jrry ,s1 cr.-2;3: cr: 1 fir.- dr*

J40.4

cueto; d;

:A.

4.)3-1-- ' 1:71 ca -4 c_•;1.)...ro- 4.3..J I mg °L.-, ur1;-, "Since God has imposed on His Prophet the duty to obey His Cauuunications to him, and He testified to his right guidance and imposed on men the duty to obey him, and since the Arab tongue, as already explained, may give a variety of meanings for each word so that same of the communications of the Book are general and intended to be particular and others particular and intended to be

(A)

general, and some are general duties which the Apostle specified in the Sunna a function which the Sunna (fulfils if.its.relation to the -la Book, the Sunna cannot be contradictory to the Book of God, but will always follow the Book of God, in conformity with His divine commanication, and clarify oll,God'.s behalf the meaning intended by God, Thus the Sunna always follows the Book of God."

(PLD 1983 F.S.C. 255 319)

.3—.42 1. -N. eS

"From the perusal of the above quotations, it ie crystal clear that Allah himself has given the highest status and position to the Holy Prophet (PBUH) which a human being can think of or imagine and the source of such status is the Holy Qur'an itself. Similarly while ordering to obey His own commandments, Allah has equally stressed to obey the commandments of his Holy Prophet (PBUH). Same is the position about obedience and disobedience ( cnaibl 1r2s3 ) of Allah and His Holy Prophet(PBUH) and both are placed at par although the basic differnece between the creator and creature is obvious. The source for this is also the Holy Qur'an. Thus the Holy Prophet (PBUH) enjoying such a high position, can it be imagined 'that he would act contrary to the Holy Qur'an or could Allah allow His such a distinguished Prophet to commit such an error? It is not disputed that the Holy Prophet (PBUH) was guided by Allah at every step

(PLD 1983 FSC 255 (344)

-:‘vv.--t cze-3-'1t-jotAlut-.7 :

13-e rt. azis al1 0-1,0 At, c)15

lfra 3J-sit t>e.-416....11 0-4 JWt. i-tt; ti jA1441..>11,77 . 11 ji It 0 J1.204-t 0,111 re 1-4,.J 1 J-e 3L cra; -S 01 jr 1.113 43.11 jJt i iLs. .1% Le; C.) Li.

31: 0-4-, 13 A.;SL1

"-; 1 ry.ti i5 tt.

r15.-°•1--L0 . 41 0-714 " u-s-o S Jr;')

'Jr )5 1 3,71,6-Z ,c)S el& cl -ef, din tr “,, 1 .1

rt Ls-S,rl-Ittrr;

1 cc. 1 IC ire 4-4 c.sa 7.41s: 3- I-4 05.-•• Li I Ja

01 tQ5 e; k_7;C:A:: a I r J5I “vit. JI-Lt.), - 6 C.J rc- t JJI c.tc cib.r4 tsre.; tra

0.cl ze•fr" AI r: I j 53' Jr; c ro-1 rft-:1 lC 0-I 6 14,- "I 'lay's: )5 1 6 Pt1 dr 3-4 LT I ktJt 4 c":4-4CI 0...60;0 rLy•I ar.4 ). I 0 Lit 04 ys Cy I rS ø 2 5..3 cut, t orl

""" r at; • C 0 eC 31.1 Az a 1.,•-1 tut* e; € .tw .; CIF 1 4C j,ç3. jj l a 13-4 J; cia” 4tis al Sk° ins AP' c-' a;.

,1:-..1)1-;-:-1 tr-tz: cl trl

Ct) te)tip,,o'1 o praii 51$1 jr- HaiZ

cas.1 4,- 15' '47.1X6-4.

* +-13)--,- )11 rrsi-..c.L1 )31

3 °Iris ail Lsiag' '24 Ti45-: "5 . a C .3 ‘-' 1"1"7.. Cj;d3

I&$) 4.gL4! C"`" 1 V LO d jjti J;L 4.ri J-41. 3: 1:1".

1.4 ttl0 7, )56 c 2,1 Lt,r. ar:.. tz_ii ;),_.

L.r..4t. 0 I F. Tr Tri Lrni Lx: s ot:; uaie Jc•;1

c---1 " j c/1•414. i. Jil LI g ("A .- 0•1 J-41.: S os c#4 ellb1:471 cr-510"1 't."41-rt 4* cik 1 t. tss

..11.:jrA d4 iC:113 at Jr° C J-01. e•- trA j rt.- criS ,S,r,j Trik L. L ¶ si-.22.4 di...tit e4 It j1-5 c).-..).3 41"

I : 04 OS

irJr.; tu...;;;•.: • • • • r ,L,Ir)

cs en, ej J..t It Tri ,cril

(1 tLY Q.-4s..

- sl 0.3 I ,34) ras

o,;..“11.: rut ,a,:,; Trinc...14..t.z.1 t;

c-t•v•ft es fr.1 01) cS ,u;•T L.) I Os" Sc.;_C jt.; eS

( a-1..1%r urell /a/ I 1- 1 Jc.. 4S bj ()Aa r;

j yoi 0.0•)•.C.--.0 0-4,N J .10 r"4 .6r.

“Ln-4 cr." c1.1.47. ,0 c“?. 0.:25) : ,j."1.i

4J T c 411 es: jou.

Sts"

0i ) 38

Lst-1(tar.• (4,4crt-,): 4:tit) •ar. al,sex s 04-r dr. cjrt.,QI 04: 47: c Jt rci4C 6 :I. 1. 1.1" Ti441 93-43,421 Cs .P4-- y/ I r1/4 ell!' L1.. PI )11'7 LA: 1)- 4r, ¶r, i-rwr. ttnIrs ?LI s

c1,0-1 c4.4 j:3-1 V I

(ant c-nt _ 411 • P 474 tt— d'iti

:ovr #01 iortfj-, /4 1 .565 # 4 / cAS ens. cl',1" 01 e4 Ir.C. 4.3 It a 6

aritt 0 I tor.-s ççscS a.ZS; s. .Ja. cl tett .))) 3,) t)-1 kr4 c 0a LT ,Ls.ce; ci44 1r:

cN' I cS -1/297 "So l °I chfjs.cl -1/2 )-4 546- cs re- 5-

4.'x— 5-4- joint ac 44/. • j: Ira /3-?:

rstat 3-7,4 iS4 nilt" C e4 ! Usti i_01 "31.1-" irg)-4 .4 sal At -- I-, 0 C.) tiosi c 4-7- Itz 44 1..)e. cS • 4::4 if owl c.i tsom. in, )5 4A-4)-1 61=-041 a itz Ls-M) 4zit 0-1 ur.4 5a4 L.S4' cS ela

cji sal 4zit LsS ude Ls-11'A •Lviatt.aati II Tra11 SI cp: tima-.. ci

re,01); cznt,S co“, eS 1 r I

# ttrJ # on; - in; 15

4:4 •.),, 12.1".1 gtr, j I ja irt

a` 4 ST: I (ti O T . 0 t ° 4= titj 4 C "1-Z O tt"... 'Qr.

(I )

4)* c#5'. Log, )51 - -4 c5 Lis° ci

crorsc 44.." c../. jj..40 S (6:, es ts

SO 1 List c“ 1:)1d-15 OTS. ▪ e41 -0 1 - ut:^09 j ft' c.".) Pant Ls< V> I 1.31

(t.x...4 :qt.< ei Jr) jai

tr..44S S c.4," 41: elk, N-01, at-c-L-, (r9 orA or•An:t

0Li 5-3 e5 eic) I 41 ei 4, 4464 IS cy," 611 0-. he Lyn.) )1:1-4 J Lc urti 0.1 40. e.4 j)1, ttz St. I AtJ di...4145V St. , )31 )r)_4 ;or_ d-.2-'• d,3 t'33-4-7 1').1-14: 31 I-64 ci if r ; I Arl cgLth' 4-41 !I ant; 411 r1 •):: ^S C4 St.'' 34 'r r'

- es Lel. 3-4 AL- e.;_U a-7,-4 5 )5-, S \01 15 rAaLa ej

e4

Li-41 e51 Jcag-: c-5 s Lon»,,, )-4.;I orjs Lit"; LI I.;

tft en) it ,c)-1 0-16: el" - LA ;:," el N.

)542; i“pt. "I 4.4/

)5414 Le" )51 A--) ell cs; u--z1):

-ti o41

*. 6; 0ljt" 43.11 "J to,:n.

"/ 13 ts." Lc: ol I e4 11 414-, ,!St.')1-1)-(m V15 015 — 1 15 0--tr. `7,:.sal 44)-1 5 • 05-4J - 01-:fre

( r)

el 4.1.tt (L., Az-it:to-I Jt.

c.:)-.422.:,e, 43 5: jt,1 c.; 5-4 Li Ar.." or. 34!kit)! - c4 Lt 4:At c_44-: ye:* 4,?. Ok" cts 1 - ce.-4 1-?' ca.: 3-4 '3 4:

111 (01-:":9(S

!DC 5 44 c•-"k) Ots—L* - " 45 5:C T ; c-4-1 ot 4.1" 11-4

#.1 s LtS ‘113 c -3 oa 40.1J1 cerp: 4, Co ig "91.

Lver tO?",43 C:c t (11; c' 4. La.' Cr)Lb

LI I st..z. pl:sdr. I.:I. ;51 rYist t , crs c Ia J.o e2.1,0-1

ç .4 t,cUt ic (L, Lt( 4etr(f-; LItft'L1/2 at A -Cs t.15 4--dletKo-1 tic c-4 Ist-: (vr.• dit

el •Ly,i_;,J . I R“L• I c, )51 jta

4t: e- P--11 S41; Cr)--;2"- A .6 17:3 1z 1-;• c-"1Y- t (kV 1“, ditir, e; (kn.*" e4

U.0 et e.:-1:5 tij cit.: jar@ 41'

'tX 4 c4 .F44'1 1,0 tit* I Or° It:1

- _-t •JY:L4-.1 tit.».k7A--2; eS

. 777 Ciet; rs f4 iorx snot-4 Sr: C'11%."

-jj—`44-• 4

c*--nisi 4.1:3 sat. I '1/4 >31 cres. fi '0"-72 t tir..fet ‘15 el 3-4 L41 4t1 IA. or cyst !lib 40.1-4 us ciers.,

Li r

, creS dc:. I 'flj tit* 4-01.; I jt:t• t" !WI rIti C4 LW) . ; 51;; # ). 1 :1 Ot

jI3-51 csl1'l,11 AI dr.:a das ,(4 ir I J 1.)

1 74.144t J 6-1 Ls. "fp.: If) 4c,e - rS 4 :113 I.J doi jlS og 41.31 —A - :!'•S 1./". A-'t c4 t: L05 ca"-. tt.:),/ 15° Or. "Li 1.4.rtiV:"

Vij4.:tt c? LrS dJ.t tqLivi It g 4 at15 4:Lorst '• ..‘11

Ltirars. r1/4 d LC3 r;) ‘.51: c'ret r e4 1:40S 4:At

1-4 S".

. 0.1.5)T 4 13-4 rim— ca, ,c...;_ask, t cas. cat is cs Lyn jrt "—" 41 3:.1-ZcS tisS ‘..44 c-; )" I‘ 3 C tri e4 jolpt dr: SZkr er.4%

it c cr.) isr- (frt. ej—t . 4•73t e‘143 at

Ct.r.".:.t. L.- - j j Lo

J J—‘..s• A: 4 iaar.9 : ,rej,cy.14 te .j ,

e Fri-.• 0 1 items• c••••••• ,4) J-*V JeS oc4-.

kr.1 0 Tr"; 'LK C4 C";:)15 jet.; LS)14 Al 6 r cLLZiJ ,4j Le aff—v ait at. Lta15 cji cr.1 Lsek: I es. .t..)::"'" O '4,7-6 Cl/ LS:s—" a,—,' dr. t4:4 Iv) 1

3 tkJ jes Cit.^-tt t: urrL5 .4"1-1 cs-L" C415 jtØ ‘strA "j3tv't . it Al tyr-^11, _ Lrob.,

1-S •

tzS e Lis-. val as1 3:: Si

HA

LS,t; e r • J., a ‘ 4 5'46 4-1-1 C-';15 A-4e

-Jr4 J.61.1(33 LgSr51_, Ls1 Lin; c.S I L* ,I eS Is....1441_,;0c.4 t . 3) Li

cS • -- Fit 4:;11 Jr j

k sJ-scivr.rel r••• ••• tot -4 c: Li•Lr".. Stt ecY' l Usl- • I i C

ir cc:iced , cit,1 c 2 cc es 4J5---- et

(1 A Lso IS:10 A A _ArLJO 6 1 f' A Jo Ls- )4. J JI ,_! ,cJ1 & —.tI "Le rELLI))::44 sitg.• oe--•••a:

c 1 A.Ljo c c 1 1 • Lp•

111...1•A Lysi c 47r-4 13“, # • — 1 r Le rc Ti Lot; c•- • :Us

cS 043.1S.1:-.. 50 I - e4 V jr.-JI: )31 a ezrs e-113--- es ;Hi: -,-Lt 1-4 1.4 .3 J .3601.3.1.40 431 Lt

r . c•••C) I 13113 It Ja" r4 5-t• )51 l' T )5J.. 91 Cs Li c `it j 1 14

21 LV (. ..19

cl d r )11 a cl )51

. LArtC JJ,$ c50 1 0 5.11-, )56-fur. 4itt 'L.)5;9 -3

ci !Lr4 ei 15 e511.: J L-11:5 c,S ci(Orr) `II), t15 ca Sir fl1Jr" c-313CI Wr, jJ-1" J 2-11 Jut c• 01 t 113 ct-1C 4:11

c4 VI; c-1-5 I LI “I 4 cl S

s fl,

t (..r

J!J

c-55-s J5 : j air 41 4.1-'4 >1..5 c art,)31 • - a4 or. LI cico

Ira ai “1

: “jolty V,,.. 6)

ti Lt IC 4zitt 0 3.-; u5-4 Jr r 113 di at. IS c“, I

-ct : L.: jct. (71)

l&ydi fri 13 .1$ . )51 .”--e" lAir-n- 4 c.4 all )31 cl all C.9)10 c:

V 5-.4 (-4 !,

5.11.1; 1=5 c 01 cri rhs It 5-4 j--fo ci ‘ 95--", J5I c"*Tr's c"" 1 9--;- # 1)— ,urts---; el 01 ‘9. - c,s ( )11) y.; I )31

JP

( Ar. ani Si air" Al ells Si is

Lzns (AI) 0 V S urtj1,-,cr1 c c'r. 4t-ezil ,-101 ps c.4 0:4 Jr.) te - cis

L ca) 14-1' g4.1.1,

-LI or crS S'S tel ,

L.441-4

a.c.4 1:-.1; 5 -el els )51 4-2_,LA3'5 4zte 5.14L4 [Le .)I 'A;1 ej•e"-es cs r

21:iia;5,3zs. )51 J 1 t)71:41 )51 - dati:T.Liti,tai 4.1 et} 4-5"e

j ...4,LAct s: r tSt Lt 4.1t

,-e5) ' 43r.)1•:. tOr.*". T e/--1 eS tIVSIJA a. jJ

rres.

;1; 6) _It cb: .35 jr.3,041

LÀ

Jr j g en" jest'," cyjg J tati as—r-g Si, Cl/J 3 3 St1 05 ja-:41.1 .3se: i A Iv 01;1

c.J cl z.y Liatz 1 1)• ._ e.;..Z 4.-A# j At e cl6 cri Cr' cS4 Al 0 c 141 LSJ3e Jni be) 4, -i->•• SZ•z4 la- I# ya.l ( Stine) ). f.1-1/4. St' c;9tr6 4P-7- ‘I'llwr; r4 J6:-23-; t d ;26* tre. e •< cc-'6) 4.11 LI °Fit-. ill ,-4 ozerd% Jar r Lie es' 111"1":t<je-cQfl LI ntty.— es-t.1 c4JI-0 3 •--4--) 1-4 L56-:

!# eg a:3-4 )5 j:1 "I “1 031. 5 Li le el 0)26—

L15-4 3 4)L-.)-5 4.115; e-aytyA

0:•.061.: 43"-- di:tr-- 4:5—e 4$ CT -c4 tit',5-4 1Y I S Lzr:s - ve..tr• Lilite: LI l;—• 3..r1

e • j ç ciit. L.1 1 )5 1

1 >56\PN

(IA)

T vl jl t Os)! jao rrs Jr

.1 c.., 5/36,.. )51 iguul rsi )11

e La*: Lis* " 1. -asti )3I )-Ic C-i - J tas Scwl y aP :9z r cn

C.4

I r-15I kur.4c :L)

0 1 1: CS JS Cr,* J 1S 1c' 1 c4 41:e. )11 es 5 J 9.1 CS 0 1

.L

uele; ert3 cS oJ..51 $ 5 .0 LL: jl.-.25_4- L:1 14; j;

S.

X dt.. Ltera-i.s • si•

4.-1 5-41 1 T Li 0 Ti; 2'7-4 cif jt.5 t;

S din 0 ". \') 15'.: 174 Ls ci -.I I - 04, g W I

47.-1 S 1;.:.jts St 1 es 0.1

C J.".1 L. nil C-1 t rkir3 ci 0t.:0'3/4:1'C J5t, 0 11 url ' dr4 5Ss r tir‘Cr. rt-: (51 )5I eff )3 c— Si -sne z at; IA."; •Lr1 f tr----; I at Xr•••••• •!= • C$L14 ?•1111. )51 -c-1 4 br-tioCme att.-Sri c cS

cori . cs Lr0rw L4 u4 c acS

L";79 cis* cS e4

c,4 I yr-141-i )51 - cS '5.J it. 15 Lk 1 IS

e4 dt ‘L‘le kri cs4 L.5 4 ca;Le a° et' IC et) c-5 Jr,

c 4 p41 ' tit j- 1 - p3 jS t. 9ac'LL ISo<-..:

jr 1:,.. eg I r Jr)

JJ1 qU S 5,,y 0 _ 4.7,1t

SI) 04103;5 ji .e.

1-; 13."-S:,;1; clr' • er t i -"c4- JT -r-

P")

;. 3-4 C 'XiT113-;

Jt c21 c5aa

f twa.; Lrs L-452 # fel us or;

-e4 f a Lac. aS cer.J4-:

c J Lut Jr) Lcis

)14a La ufrit• ' e ç rys J Liz ei 1:3-4 t1-4.7 V.6.31.t Lo”.

)3e 4 5t:.5 tJ Ae.'.47.,& IrS ct it• trO l z-11

ett-,,,-.et k.):5 4.1:5 cre -cit..- L5.0 az C.. It C.1 # St.1 4 igst or') a.-1 3-4' C: 5 • J:s # Ist 5 4:4 4.:td- c516V.)-4:5"3-o-;- C `Lr't "I I kf.X.1%*; 3)5 -eV J31 J I.t4 r" ) ) 1 )-4 Utr• 041 r1/ 4 s effi CsaS.s• tts: al 31 411 ..Ar.T,311/4/4 czt.,_,14, ty.41 -c4 A•St- cr.; ISit)r.• c4tt Lell, °•:3; act rtg e4 ot tot, r to 13' ciT Lb, Ji 1 az tg .3 I ,15.j jo.1 j-t Jjtst -'S cjiJ;t5 c ca.c'2115 4ztt c.S j!).. LsS ct Ktri

Js1 c-; 5-4 4:Itt C59' k)7:j1.4 LC5-4 (Ut4 J Cak 1.rw 1;—", ;-1 lir

.H.J

lDS oitt LS;X°

cr J 19 tilt"4- Ad 1- ant; 1J5

-tht ce .A 45 LI oil: cx . rtcs: 0.0. c Jr..; cir.T )5 1 - 5-4C ccrif Lstit>4.17 — c4

rrs rzst- T Litt. )11 4-.1:Li LI:: 45 J-iitib 0,5 I tsrl -t51 ;13-4 ce al '1.; -331.3,11 41x 4 &.:3:J315 )3 I It1 eft) 31cyt e4

, Az T05 c.4, )--, St!

1 j.."1 c..1 — H

cist",,bw I stair e-14.?7•1 j 5lurt.: tn. J'-t p Le.t. (tf OP a N. t e4 sivrit

tre. 1;."1" Cm: rf ir ‘510e4.X4 ell est. r LI 1 3-4 Asr.J 3 A:taa 0.4:15

I es, oz:1-4c"..-02-zz tn. 0-es c Ir. TO4t p:1 J5.01 sLat lc OT/Cc T C4 U L'---$(L,4 czl.) aLt r f

e kx:-4 j mire 35-.PIrk74 0'. 41 m, tr: sr!c‘igj`;:ii sl••,•:•• LOS-: azumr.-42-4z ids Jit 1:411`• fr.C J Jae 4 ‘.5-$ vr‘ r t-ro Lgsti AI :04 (Lit 01 3...):!•(rl

a31; 't":46-1 tut-4 Ls1L4 iori Lt 45.e-ur4 I all,. 4.7-c

f -et Ls .; j c

.5( T

lQ 4 Erle-Z J3^4 I 0 I )3 I C4 LS J f An iefeS )31

" 2,5)-31 I " c4 lc can

IJIlt 5:3-4 It 1°)— L:t i & ctfea: t).:•chp:1 (51 1 4 1115;)

&a i. f - CI I 'an ç 5-% e 11

ity#1 tts 3-4 (0.1-: e""7142; ta;

- (Are; 0- it() X' •

f rif j4 cit e r (0.1 C16 'sa l ac.-4 17.5 ca: LO:;- Lzsa" , Cit-C '7•142.;

isiie j ;Lyra*: .c.5.:: Lsopf e; ,S j ac.4, c“5-- Ors . 5-, a c416Q-7—'3/4° C" Jit

1 '3_S;1__; 43.3 L.,13 LJI, c), •L3.1 - 5.) s-L /S 4:415 clwtml )”..)-4 -S (6)-4 tg tri /5 e 4-7t6: 4 ef (Sin?

s' et LS Cfirl".0 j L71 LS,:j c t) SJ -jtç J aj.-3.;) )31 -71t. a “I Jo& S.7 1 c- .fiztt 331 (r< ..r<r) ce. J dt• AA 0.4 %.3.t.14.1 I 1A . r Lk1 0-..)

Vt -4 calj uaa-ti"

)te" Clii/r e- 43)1-- c4 itt 321'

es 15 4:16 eS (cji3-1 -tolt1-1 cis= 5-3 j1:

istrt 4.1 .3.:5 147.64AS eS0 -,c4s ,c.....,1:25 ity,1 1.2r“ :lc') 4.131 427.1-4 ji5.; _IS2i fl4:!4 V 15 sl • ) I ) &a c 1 4 t us &LI I 3t 43 ja- JSiLri List j!T4 tt LI r" 63 ki; k“te-Itt c4ct"J tfeni, )11 -S vet; 0_--3 cs.-1 set 03Ms c.1

len!. J tn: diy da*A“ - d dtr-

c.t.>

.41 43 Lis:: ts) 13 Lt.', tn dill ltl.) c31 ajt-, tL)5J-54 1r- es) '5)31 S 1:71; Jrfrtz J 0 -gt"-I v:-.P Ls-Sur, éV Jr•s:s. 15:-\-) 1 1 )31 ktR

j tie °5 15--1 45 -S 41.141 es;41 ) J-0 1 4,04 cz56 Jez-z4 ,o c;r: )5Itit4" c::56 tir° -15 di., 51 1.174., ..31-at t? r1 IS 3.7 1•161.e sL>.-1 3: 11 r 1

4431k.)-!

rust c .5 s 'LA; 4Ult &t5 dte 03 s e— (jt• L)e

s ae A:Y-4re -tsz 4: zjywe

LiCae . ir )51c0.1.4-a• 5 cal."- 0.(: L.Art", s )31 it; Al 56 4 JI:j ca.? (514:14 c4 citt i:--t ett (safer.

Jr AI el 4'; L5's tz; 1::01 $ 7" (v174.3 .3:31.1 ti ciLt iLt ce

07:s c.5 3-4 a.: S1')....1, c.v..... J1. 5 - c4.1a•-• )5I

5 II

ft th;

""ellj Ja el 't cS e- JL it.);,1 trot j at ! e4 ,441 ;j5-.. # Ler I e4 Lila:. tut. I 4,i ts r.4—S riz

tsj.:1..11 4L4JILL.t JL.,1 cr-1-3 .1 it..11 ... :1 jr) 4 0.1.11“1-4:f d- tI S. jLt21 calls: JP es

ut. sic; u 2.3).-J13 jf-J I,"

( r )

" nsa 1,0 t; JIOI5 AJ2

r A : a51. )

1.93-4, 4:7-)3s 3::ci LQfl Jr°

14-4 In 5 &15 {t c54 ic)3:3 c-..1 1 3-7

c 37.4 4:(Lie Js-.1t 31 1-!-;

-s t;r1 J3-.5 ,7; (L)-1 41" rej1.4

(- c.4 tusto V 13 .3111

36 ALaLyle ))t c 53-4- t't; t.4(4t-?' jtd36.135'7--, tX411-: ?It r-; Lvt, Atitl 3: cit., tAlt c" te ";LeS 4"; c2It fs4P4t)e jjt.9esi 11 , 304; j31

al I J. Lc.; Jir Ln. o iUUj

eS 14 4s. $ Ile 16-!•°-" ("Gt. .991 s'• c-4 J-211 Qr.'

C: ksit,'-'1 ill s113,0-. ---e4 ail) 3 A- 4-4-) kr iti 4:—Cer St I (ix°

. I," t r4 c46 cre

et....4,1 11. 1.; ot a 41j1 3 J-ei; KtjyA )51 c o; 4.,44 I 1_.., I az.,i1)1 - »3 .r. 4--)unt It) Lvt-t

J tO S # kci;ti e" 4 CJI-"crt 36 4; -13-4:a" LI.ts J5I etrt jt; J J Al -

.JjL j ! J si e.1 to I. icy) I eg 1.:4) .)1/ 41-1)-^4- JSJ 1,1 e) • 1:21 L.7 1 es de, LL.411 I) )31,0..i:

1.4 ci a,1J1 — LJt 1

-Lx-1 - a ,Ls;y1Ail)cs-,-)c>rscit.

Lohs e-ne jList!`:••-•

r zWis; ej 14:7" 3r'j dlit Lfrri.j i11

IztJ 15J tstl n1 &It./ "LAP cS'Icr.-:•b, 1 6-1.ian1 1331-1- '5 es- c3-4" c-L.1 )51 aa tt)r r e4 rato-1 c 4 IZL, kr:;. d44-"wl 0 tu5S; ej113 c-4÷: triaa ac4 0 Le“.1 I all: . cl e;.31 4-41i r l jT e.1 - c-t 15j Lob")51 °sot./

ct0 5 )51 c-1° (1)1n1 /9-Ar." S V di-iv-1 4-4 4,r.- S: ,c05 ..35 az% 41S C f A I Lot!

. J Jtt att. _ciT rr,

t 75s 17-1 J3 -1---14 i..7t4 j6 cr- P:37::-* * - cia

'1 IJ

4.3.45 )3 J 1)1 4 l'-74r0 :1 . ca.:I Lo tt Jl aa- i3urs

c3.51.4.... eat tl1, j,1 0-01 Lj It lx) 4 e441t 154 ei is:: 5 Lt.?.(S )31 - JG*C.y i nt cAssa 241 cm-'

)51 I•s;') ut" cji 4..151 5 Lor; ‘:•sli, I de, cStrt - 4;1 ‘.1J1

0 J!)! 5 0...

Oc4-1 cS )51 C I ‘.71'1; t3," lc al" d..s. ceS) P; ‘ss?' Al 1)— 3 3;:s ei-1,1 clz j

j&J3-4 ii.714 S S) Ls-;'1) itç 14, - ail( ct>.I 45 ,s1 J-al; 07911 Ia..z nI Lv t., ej&I )5! L•-• LA- 5 sttl l tislit ivy) rritz cc.. dc-P1'ree 1 L..cSA$1111P1 jiv.1 (ut.4.-"a-‘. 35, C)12 n1 tit5e.J 4 J5T 4-4; c I-'tor- 4.01 citml e4 Iztt 54,‘,..I.s.n XL:4.14,1t. Al IS ° I) J-at. cS cf LP1-, )51 5 3-4 J5 '3 e"rif-:

( r •

(IA)

se4 45-1, )1"-il %rt. c 1A

1401,t 1-st-.3

PC) )3 u: J4A y J fr~ ),“ -1516-"At c5 C)1 icr. 14t. Jr.' I Y1'51; -Scs:01 C-:

ceirr-, /51 -IS cjIt 4Jtcf Lpr: `5`-'!' 5*"3 I J7 at 4 faC.: ttr. )3 dw t .c..7tt !Saul I wt.?.

oejS1 J czarce IC) J jS

17 1 WrA C:56 Cjj CS 401' ‘Lt.J, 5 - u.)56 'tit" sl$ sz e1⁄4c-4Alo-1 S Lett JJL:•-• c3-6:4 c54::11 6.c1/4 -1 ,1 5-"5 et/ Lr 1 - 5-• 4:4

LW)Ltj I a) ( _J_ 5

( Lt.)36:1( )it '14-7J)" L1461 3.:: '097,:.41S CST es List ...c4 Jr1 A l de, j L:

f51 c' le IC ist crovi c 1r

J15-: .-c4 c't:s et/ u.dt1 /51 9Y-v C.) )31 t,or:61;1-.# .c•-• Ls)", 9 ntor.k;C:. c-ns L5J coo"-, 4 C 47.

°S.2 J51 J15": 5 Jr.13, °3 et , 15 Lova. ,93-r 4-10C ts..5 )51 d-c4 cgS4't L15) 0-1s1 Lcat 1.7•“0-1 çsc4 • CotW C15)! J51 5C5-I 4.1-, jL.JI r

Jr-r: TA 1 Ljo c ) 01> Li%1 Lrial - , L.C.t4 Wt. ,J7. ...J) T“:6.4.74;;JI-J 15 jkii-113 "

"1 L4 H

c=it:

I 0 I Otis Lryt ai/01 c-1-,015 omit; at&Y0-..i

(-rA rt.:a)

... I jej5 ).01 0 I 3 3)

Lite rt. J se,) jae• Lye;1* 3

J36.1 L ytle cissL•44. e5g J3 Q10 I ;it:

tali: jthi -4 Zsra Z. ca.° el.; 6321..... )3 1 eSrt.)-1 )31 ,v3e )-4'7-15z) e5(.3-1 4 56 LrtY j .jr-I- ICZJI 4 C.4% cc'''.c1/4-ti; 1 Liji c-C' 3-4 3)11'1 15 4C tr-5 e4 J1/4 tikt C" aS Le'S

trd 141% cj:$44)-402 LS-S tr} 1.)5:tr.t43 cs.:121.; j6"-# S C-3 ). rt, er: 1/41 csji e; Lit)A '• Lon: 41 at OSti -s-c4 j15. ler LO.I. 11 '...4-1 3 tielt: nidinT

1.4 att !Jai ;owl it

t-4 .J 6 (ye:67:c -c-t .115; e5 ut1 )310e-c pe-YA ccat ,?is*tcJ ci LA dt tt Ur.° J

-,cs .1 eJui (0-1)6 ,s1k01:1-u-r I: securfe:Lizt, ,J!--7-tit-• 5g. 4)1.); cts . 1.: cit.. 41

tx- LI -415

4L,eid 4-qt Lira • it3

- 3-4 a•1S 05 *err 0-113 e-45)•.- -5 5 '4; a-5 a>3..-t (-1) LAn e LJ r1.-5 drit AJJ1 also c.),e3 J s cJ1, LSJ

u-L s e).1-4;1 c-44t55)-33 - cs-1 is4 Az ,$)” e“.4, !Si - L I dr. )3 I eg I 151 slits/4;yr.

e:-"t 4.-3t :A•r; >Lt.' '3 St I St' j.t:

.ThyS L5') tttfr: rJa

Lr l 431. 431., 56 SI! 1 c.JI3 eso Lot" kyr" Vv.1 Lwe jLit I 36 Qt. 1:4:1.1

a ig 1-6 Th atn;(0.-11' t)i; c$J3e J &Y )31 (-7 vr,d 31. eS )3 I rcpt. Avors cstrt "t ce,-; cør c4 4/1 C's ji c5001{-M1 04": )6-te: Lit) Wn7 4 7"/ LeC CLgtt i.nn-1 . ail; 04-turs-, 9-4 414.'s IC )1):,-;.0 I (-1) 1-5 e", 1 ! ,--5 es "Pi r ddtne;•:4

5-4 .13.•- •• til cS Li; c< ort

5 01 it: J51

c4 ?L51.a 4-1-: ,un.; Jl 15J I)I J LMC 4)1 r r tgkrA . -4 L.." g r .; cert....Set J31.- 5 .1.5--1 dr. 05 ve.

7,27;?4- ; • .6,4 • c (tn. &J;

st- s 4 Lt.! LI an 51 1

v j ci a Li: elo I $ 15 jj.: 4; 1,615 I0 f j:11.; c.; Lel dll I dp,...;

a- 313

It Irs L c.a.- 14, az! 01-s.6.3 i_a

NA )

fir cS fr'7" dr..4 dr. St •"A.7.: CA": 4rt-i c at 565 t) * eS 11 L5 .4 Lin eS sit.; .e4

J-Lt jr.- t .la ci ctVi 1 .3 I Mdtbk(t.nt cr- rese cs,.411"-•.; 51 -1-1 I sf-""tr I tcdr:t: 5.J 47 4S 1/41:7Li cl-zg-tvi L5-4 la /eS 4.4;)31 se4 '1/2-• List ,u;:-.4 C1'1;51 1""1 ej113 3. Jg": C V5,41: (L),: 5 a1,! Zest 5,/ dJtuej5tr c 4 I eS Cr ur.4 c-: It 9-4 aL. C.) y r.l" ILoi e)--.--0-1-Learn' ç)S utn-1 se4 ,,x‘dri ,s4-: (Az's')J rlrtL4 - tr4 ,ILYA . Sy,.c-'; 4;;Pftec,*-

-S

tr.-4 c.,S eau.- ,&..“)

-e4 J ley C•jr4a.: L L.- 'cS L,) Jr", eCti c03-41 r 0-113 e4t..4

ct.J r!Ir S cS J.L.,5;1 3).0 cS IL

Jig cr) CL: 'a jid '444 I 4/ ...ciTclWntt/ 5:7 Jar- Itts. J e'S eiL eS 4. at “rrcr.

J u .)3)1.7.41 1 4:43 "67 4,:ti LS it. air, c,4 s

tons:j. icr 1 C-6513 ei 13 etz.

tilie •••• Ur3 cZT Ur• k‘tg. csle 5 Lesne Afici; S 1;-r4 J c—Lent- set asti-7-, et elj":

I 4'.

19.'45j L: 5: It et": e”er4 Jr.". e I) J ant isi,-tx.4 c:irtot.

Alec?

eS J r° e- lar J cid 1 4i4 Lvrt °S • e4 °I;

(Ti)5-6

— Lrs iiitte..; L07, Jr • rift- cr5J A - -4 T" tilt 5. -4 e- e-; 45. 4:It P ea- c-tfitc LSJ kr I 4-J 5.:kr ;(Ji 5-6 1; 5-4"."

!Jr Lt.o. at. 4 s ccatoS Lit c, 4:rtt $1.:,36 c•-'L, d j n. CA-j. e`e4 Jr. 47: L: IV; A e4 ir-T Atte • or.. 4--7,e- LI

I 34: Los (ut: )51 r T .,t cJt ot

*Jr:, 4 5 Ur3 I•OSs g CIL° K.e.:1 3 or* Ils-r1,7, ccjitat acit f 5-')1 c fr di ter 0 5.4 e43---- ity." oe5I )-1 e&u:-.11:0 )11 ae4 ,c 4- jr-' Ica",1

45 41 e4 Itt:j 47: cr/ eS01 at. /5I e4 r. - J )11- izt4_$a. c.:61,- JL

4.)::" twig ..ist cy. -;;;\41 cleelieell; ar..; c). 0 —a, Li)=, -Josl c;101 c4 LC- 5-6 j14°J; b SU'

4 c- turi Lis cta)-1 Qrs . cl"J I cJ I-4j1sj.).1- Jra. ea)

. 0 ri; M-)51 141`rIC-4dil e4Lrl cst-,, )7: La: or' 3)-1

t)1-•--; I -çç4S aS e4 '1 :91'- '257:1 et ill 1%7.-4 arr ts6-: <1-3 c crok terS-T,IS “ ant S L54-:0 " .43 4 l`r•-! Jr) e•°•? -

“Qv., J el•L1/4-..3-- e.orlSzj I jr47.It s ( kg t y C.a re ,c)a:

. °CI co:4 va; J rz 4-5It; LIS c-v-I .41:4 14.7 T . “4-: di; awl 4 (v"; Izr. Ctti- Lis° cr-ri c4 JUSLyE., tfi I 43 r

: cYheiG1.1.- eS

(r•

c4, ea:6)2 St1 d.1,,z 1.35 cS

LI &L)t; Pa; °5 5:LSC.1 5: a LI fr.- c kr! di.. "41 LLP: 32- 0.1 (tmer .3 .) 0.1 c4t1 0 5 cr - et;

cN-0 1 J

34 c-:J/-11•1 c/ tits 40,iJi.."1 C LO--e arie

C3,11-4'1 i/ elt4 1e tj45 .,4 04.1 C.11 Lit c5 TJJ L15 c..4 56i-it° 4,6,5 c....AeT - 5-4 ,,ce. Arty: cS o.15:

LsC' 1 j j 1 ft r:i0T) as dsl

;r /C h l7;' L$) SkAts. 1 j''c ci jrrai: 3 -1;:i.31.>-1 f r.;

I )3Lit-i.ern .J-L' 5 zit ut-,Cst tst.4 strAJ J rim

11_1 Lsto 4 '-15, cluri 44.-1 15 Lyn dkr, c.S 0 fr.Sr:11,A CS 'AA TJ 01.1 5 L.s.”-

je Lirres:0 dt,. °S C. c-- - c- c ."tfl°c4J Lon S (vs. " 4.5 e;

1e-.1 63"79- ),1 sel)-6,4 )11 aSr.)-1 Or::

.3 1S_a 5 c- 4 ct5 ) I fr-S3

.4t din ,s1-0

)31 - 51 ‘ .-LE Jflsj4Jldt e-

vi‘ LE S-.1 &HA:slit aitir, keS estri 0/1))1

(r )

,u5-4 1:)4 4.15: )5 1 co5-0, 1:-‘1-e all Le-• # IsJ e: 41 ..6 al j.1.40

r Li r; 1/:4 114; ails; LI e l (r •r:r•T cep c J5-04- 1 J.4 cr s,

—et c,t1i) Lot. e-; ‘01- nt esr 0.1 (kr t: T t,.4 c. ofrf

61-; LI

-c6 a r :

e4 ..5"- 15) e- "16 --)..5)1.-S rim! • (1) 4Z vr• sin Li j Cri .1t, A

-IS I-.15

(T : Ls)

Ce&e. e4

04)1,3 # ft.--; 0 J51.3,1 1 jj t;.:11-0"1 )5 44 efi 61'7: 15) 14 )5 1 0 3-4r: #

c4

(1.Joe a.1_, r‘,14i.111,1)

14)e)1-: `14:. CLS

); I

';j4I'lai C; )4;A. 4:r J31 it Cr a flh O. 41/4 - 15J e"" •

ctost-l;. 1 J A•51);.• 011' dar.thre ekt.n. "t,r. 15/,•.•. 1 j cle-a (r) L5L14;ta- I cLtta 5J,i 5:LI wr 4.1 67,. c-t1 5Ut qLs, 1s JJ t

j , 4S es«, 4O)43ss. La nr,,t a>

1 55-1 cr- t:ICI,/ )51 It .1 56 c1,J—4) . )31 Is cz1,05u— )51 el,: j1s• irc.r1 1:51 -".)1 k.14 tor.. 0 c254 dt:z 6pN,

)4t) — an; j-"- ityl ty" jt ft La L./ fal UI F 4-714 DLY' l Or° . "11,9 Lvt•

43-j'il cfr,c-et,),Ii t: 1.1" 1-1-3 az-6 d-ul fr. J51 LS' tirc..ird . cs I-I— drls al-dd art,

f q,-1 1-1-3 dt-i-d dill Lsi-dw-.0-- sc.6L J 6-;:-%:".=*);ci-- )31 (4,1/4 - cif rims. )

Jr, 41 c m4j c,t i,“—lis 0.; Alit+.s t s, Lctr 4z14 jjr,J JI6 IS St! r1..- a --tls di I Lgio oil (cr • 11 LeS-114 )

Lette,..m, c f Irjltij. jcr, AJ )31 St ( Q)5!!',.“ b1/41 ,) dx;i ‘r)l j )51- i _ ej-cr-, frl (s-5 tit L$51: ..Lt'41/4° ), 15;-•° 5: 56 45 5:Li 4)5 - C'irI 4 c c5 Pi I-, ail at° 1-.4 )1;1 le) 1 1-, el-tts. itt: ill So 051-0 ro-t 0Y-0 ejço 4-tt: r-v-T ckarit dris tr: c-± 4-714 citarl V,1 4, - eg

J.) I al.z, 43J I J crais6-1--LQ Lst.— e; 4; Jsy x10,1

.14-7 L I ciain (r • AA5S.n. t65.)

° _Si ctr C ,rs aa-0 (-1 .1

em: Ce°"") f's Ai 61 L.5):* It)! c):4

c'mt-t's tn. rrm / ttt4.

(rr)

err: - Q., a

. .0 41)1 aisho 4r1 0.1.: 4,),A ••••

rs e—Lri )51 — -4:

1Euts. ,pn- >1;t: 4 it LA e

e4i Jr )1.:.r. dic.:,e7 )51 cc; r _4 J .) J I trep.; ;Lir.

ikze7c,ril--I L,v3—e I ),---"Ht.;1 -14: IP-Sicefr; 4-Itt tC0'A qjt-'• eti+041 ( AA :A j1/2,1)

St1 °tit aft sio A-a-- 41 04. k

r just 01,13 St. tis .s; Ls)

(j5 lj 0 It5e Lc‘:

SI at° j c-...istri 0. Its 0434ill .4..s -A a rl j )1.4f StA ttLif..-0;41.4 C:141 (1 N.< :1 ) cot°. Lo,t.

- 4;24 cz/ cla it L4/.4-Ic -1 ..ribq citioup ' 'ors 0.:43).3-2s

eS in CS cL) t r.'s din 0-1-0

tIce .lir I it-tr (Qt. — 11: Ltit e sisa Ara- 31-;

en, J.,--93 e-L7A-c,•10.--; J,i J J-6-4P-1 c4 J0-1 5: 3-4 yly 14:-"• •••••7.5 oc,1 ),1 ;, It. l)t e• CU'14" 4.3;t1:

JrciAsts s:s3-3 c r-s e j jIt ts ;101 - tYe t js.

Es . t.s41 c>1.41.-7-S ter-. ol

"I çL42 j Aris ii ,31-0 ),--22..- (9 (1 • ) C— stdP--141z11 -;')Us i a c-raa )11 eij-S tic

11/ kr4 e4 C." f3-3 41/1 gJ .O 25-1"" azret)--11 L05-er )31 # 4•11Tef (kr ! crS Lon- - fc 4.;i11- 4

N4\1*1

er r) 61

_az is' IS 4zit, 0.63;

440 - Sç 21 eZJ. aly... tfict Ls ...1 3 I Lrfrt d< .1-4 eS ..vt4 c..41J , Lt•,1 di ..ar:0.1: dais 0,e.:1.:47

Tiii) II t t;J•lio I ri-s) jyt.

(°-6-!" "•'. !gm I L I-4 j'e—je: 131 SILI obi el- grls 413 u-?-I I It r4 -.1 V ., Zinc 43,:i

. .."^t Ciri C;fi .° Lt ,1/4 )51

,r1-.3 arts oin 01,0 “I 0.11; til I J•ti J^Or: c-nt 5-4 .c-

( 1, al JV i el j ,sc

Ots• Oft: d•C) Lt )1 I IL< ) ) nos

16L_ I 0-:,) (Li:AA I'LL,. ct..11 J c.5 0 'Ili ji.4ril clasi ( 1Ar - I iti5 )1) diari 15 ist r; d e )5 I 4 di C eftl-r i Jr" ...I lie 3".

C4 t; 5"4 L:14 I Ca' LS,!; 05"rj 1lMtl*;

- SJ-01- {yr .0501 3-srd t-9 .- 01 rt) ,51

S

. rsi C.) T r Qrs rj III•40 rr A 4111 ecr 3 ( ) 03; Ujr 0 e4, c.,;05 r 'fl: ) Lt.> . ki jkryt:Joe

t r t.; Is O. ;) “it, 6,i t; 0.,LA 01. ) LJ J. 5 ( 54:4 ei)r)

-vett% a.,5).-s. cal 1-4. Lot, 41Se i crS S:, eloti Jrkt LIS> (LI 1:4 It . itro- S.,,-11 ç>t 4,,,;

“Qr.-4 c:1 4k,j9 t Lord Ellenbrough, C.J.

" Lord Ellenborough, C.J.said in Isherwood V.Oldknow, It is truer to say 'Communis opinion is evidence of what the law is'. It would be unfortune if doubt had to be thrown on a statement which has appeared in a well know text book for a great number of years without being judicially doubted and after it had been acted on by justices and their clerks for many years".(1815)3M&S382).

LoSti C31111. Oi 5 4°1. fla ° J 5t, 5-4 S dt: (.01 0.1:1910.1 51 S., 1 1 1 r 1"

r4,J4.:10 Lcrtts. 514 Li,. i:Ot 4 cA4 e`•• e4 1 44 S-'54.x. j1" “my) eil." 5-.4ja 514 eLgte 3,1 ri y

1.ciat;-= c-L) ( ctry3 c i5c..jZ•11 ) Jj C.1 ()VI r 5r ..-s:Ust jt' 5' 1:57:: r4 Vet" a'75 di trl 'el V> r.i 1 )51 LOSJ T cs:3-41 catti3 tLet )11c4;,— kirD . cji ,trz-z1 4.)4 St- Liz; CC5 Ctr t: J

tor:- 4 c:.1.1 rtAi

slsorsH.J1..tLis •I is... "

L

)1 I 1 1 311 r ..e.v

01-i rst1-...,tos .0 I °St 3.3

fr1-- 4.1 tn. -4 at

vz-lb tLet u-sr-t >51 -420-4

eL-el 03 ds ot cri . es ts cit.- 5-4

LP ,4344Sc'e l 4111 c-U ,out ci till 3-4 vectj 611,

r4 c.:1.)-; 4.NX

H 0.a; als-,s ositil 1 34.1J-11 rU 0.-;,1 7111 i-S, tr.“6"; 4111

r.4.5 sti Jtotil 5 1.5.1

0 1,11 Ltra s1_,1-1J1“; ro.1.....,1,S; 1 irrit'l

4.1.; s;a2,

scla U 6.1,2,7;Li 0_1U LelI

S1 :

jhta is IS 5-4 lIted; al& di 5:•,4.x.-is 4:31V 'War; I,or.• J2L.,5-47:

1-Z ci6 --c4

IS is :..nat-; ft e,

-1114 tg) 4-elf; C); 1,st5-; e-142.1 °Lag. 3-6 LI 'War.; 43 5-4 j11_51 sit el.“)

nit c4 C-4211 ti.at ci-t3)

C'1 J cS,L)-1 ce:

dt.)L: c-1J Ly.1 )11 'se& 0S--t 4..15-42:j 0-t "Y" -c4 I 1-4 x (obi 3$1, 1 0.)-,as tLas3L.!

(r<

' 44,0 a e Ca s I.:5-4; Zeo..: SSUp I IS. icy, L.A.: tr.

Le,.11 JJ I. 4—s 0.1 1,21)-2 ass: Jut-. 01:4 lt ;Iht.' —1.:T iutre; oti; es.:315 5'0101 u.L...s ors j31 j%>I go“I ct.t.

_ c4 31,41

c)1_.; “eft.; le I/ cer.— st4— A

cb"441Af vitr.ati%1/4) r!”, y,

fr /4-4

A

atiraal

1 • -r iAr

Summary from the court's website

Full judgment

Please confirm

Summary from the court's website

Full judgment

Similar judgments